© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

Terms Privacy Legal Notice

arXiv:2510.13086 · Physical Review A

From elastic to inelastic deformation of a dipolar supersolid

Qiaomei Zhao, Xing-Dong Zhao, Jieli Qin

Published Sep 19, 2025• 2 citations

Abstract

Due to its peculiar superfluid-crystal duality feature, the supersolid has received great research interest. Recently, researchers have paid much attention to its elastic response properties; however, the inelastic deformation has barely been explored. In this work, we study the transition from elastic to inelastic deformation of a dipolar supersolid Bose-Einstein condensate trapped in a box potential (i.e., a dipolar supersolid with finite size). We obtain the stationary supersolid states (both ground and excited) of the system and examine the relation between the supersolid size and the number of unit cells it can accommodate, which can essentially help us to understand the dynamical responses of the supersolid during a dilation or compression process. We found that within a certain dilation or compression extent, the supersolid can retain its original crystal structure, that is, it endures an elastic deformation; however, when the extent exceeds a critical threshold, the original crystal structure of the supersolid will be disrupted, which signifies an inelastic deformation. Furthermore, we both analytically and numerically determine the critical point of the transition from elastic to inelastic deformation and map out a phase diagram. These results open up new territory in the research of supersolid mechanical properties and may find applications in quantum material science and quantum-based technologies.

DOI: 10.1103/2vyl-dg7c

Related papers

The Excitation Spectra of a Supersolid

Lily Platt

This thesis explores the excitation spectra of supersolids - materials that remarkably manifest both lattice structure and superfluidity. We focus on an ultracold dilute gas exhibiting one-dimensional crystal structure with two gapless excitation branches. Two distinct supersolid systems are examined: a one dimensional Bose-Einstein condensate with softcore interactions, and a three dimensional dipolar Bose Einstein condensate confined within an infinitely long tube-shape potential. We investigate the crystal-like excitations of the supersolid through the use of the linear chain model and by introducing an elastic constant derived from ground-state calculations. Subsequently, we adopt a hydrodynamic approach based on an effective Lagrangian, which depends upon three fields, corresponding to lattice deformations, defect density current, the global phase fluctuations and four elastic parameters. This description of the supersolid allows for the determination of low-energy excitations, as well as the behaviour of the associated density and phase fluctuations of the two gapless branches. We validate our predictions for the low energy excitations by comparison to results from directly solving the Bogoliubov-de-Gennes equations, finding excellent agreement. This thesis provides a deeper understanding of the different types of supersolid systems, and how their low-energy behaviour depends upon their characteristic elastic energy scales.

•Sep 20, 2024•0 citations

Excitation Spectrum of a Trapped Dipolar Supersolid and Its Experimental Evidence

G. Natale, Rick van Bijnen, A. Patscheider +4 more

We study the spectrum of elementary excitations of a dipolar Bose gas in a three-dimensional anisotropic trap across the superfluid-supersolid phase transition. Theoretically, we show that, when entering the supersolid phase, two distinct excitation branches appear, respectively associated with dominantly crystal and superfluid excitations. These results confirm infinite-system predictions, showing that finite-size effects play only a small qualitative role, and connect the two branches to the simultaneous occurrence of crystal and superfluid orders. Experimentally, we probe compressional excitations in an Er quantum gas across the phase diagram. While in the Bose-Einstein condensate regime the system exhibits an ordinary quadrupole oscillation, in the supersolid regime we observe a striking two-frequency response of the system, related to the two spontaneously broken symmetries.

arXiv:1907.01986•Physical Review Letters•Aug 1, 2019•237 citations

Rotating a Supersolid Dipolar Gas

S. M. Roccuzzo, Albert Gallemí, Alessio Recati +1 more

Distinctive features of supersolids show up in their rotational properties. We calculate the moment of inertia of a harmonically trapped dipolar Bose-Einstein condensed gas as a function of the tunable scattering length parameter, providing the transition from the (fully) superfluid to the supersolid phase and eventually to an incoherent crystal of self-bound droplets. The transition from the superfluid to the supersolid phase is characterized by a jump in the moment of inertia, revealing its first order nature. In the case of elongated trapping in the plane of rotation, we show that the moment of inertia determines the value of the frequency of the scissors mode, which is significantly affected by the reduction of superfluidity in the supersolid phase. The case of an in-plane isotropic trapping is instead well suited to study the formation of quantized vortices, which are shown to be characterized, in the supersolid phase, by a sizeable deformed core, caused by the presence of the surrounding density peaks.

arXiv:1910.08513•Physical Review Letters•Jan 31, 2020•92 citations

Supersolidity around a Critical Point in Dipolar Bose-Einstein Condensates

Yong-Chang Zhang, Fabian Maucher, Thomas Pohl

We explore spatial symmetry breaking of a dipolar Bose-Einstein condensate in the thermodynamic limit and reveal a critical point in the phase diagram at which crystallization occurs via a second-order phase transition. This behavior is traced back to the significant effects of quantum fluctuations in dipolar condensates, which moreover stabilize a new supersolid phase, namely a regular honeycomb pattern with high modulational contrast and near-perfect superfluidity.

arXiv:1903.06161•Physical Review Letters•Jul 2, 2019•118 citations

Compressibility and speeds of sound across the superfluid-to-supersolid phase transition of an elongated dipolar gas

P. B. Blakie, Lauriane Chomaz, D. Baillie +1 more

We investigate the excitation spectrum and compressibility of a dipolar Bose-Einstein condensate in an infinite tube potential in the parameter regime where the transition between superfluid and supersolid phases occurs. Our study focuses on the density range in which crystalline order develops continuously across the transition. Above the transition the superfluid shows a single gapless excitation band, phononic at small momenta and with a roton at a finite momentum. Below the transition, two gapless excitations branches (three at the transition point) emerge in the supersolid. We examine the two gapless excitation bands and their associated speeds of sound in the supersolid phase. Our results show that the speeds of sound and the compressibility are discontinuous at the transition, indicating a second-order phase transition. These results provide valuable insights into the identification of supersolid phenomena in dipolar quantum gases and the relationship to supersolidity in spin-orbit coupled gases.

arXiv:2306.04794•Physical Review Research•Sep 6, 2023•20 citations

Dynamical signatures of superfluidity and shear rigidity in different phases of a dipolar Bose-Einstein condensate

Soumyadeep Halder, H. Ghosh, Axel Pelster +1 more

We show that a sudden change in the polarization direction of the magnetic dipole moments of the atoms in a dipolar Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC) can serve as a useful dynamical probe to sense its superfluid and solid-like properties. We find that for small angular deviation of the polarization direction, actuated for instance by modifying an external magnetic field, the superfluid state undergoes an undamped scissors mode oscillation, a characteristic signature of superfluidity. In contrast, both the droplet and supersolid states exhibit a scissors-mode oscillation, which is effectively damped due to multiple closely spaced frequency components. Notably, we find that this damping rate provides a qualitative measure for the rigidity of different phases of a dipolar BEC. Furthermore, there exists a maximum angular deviation of the polarization direction, beyond which the droplet and the supersolid states undergo a permanent deformation i.e., we find an analog of the usual elastic to plastic phase transition of solids. We characterize this transition numerically using the fidelity of the condensate wavefunction with the ground state as well as the droplet width and periodicity of the supersolid density of the condensate which are experimentally accessible. Thus, the dynamical protocol introduced here can be an important experimental benchmark to identify and characterize the superfluid and solid properties of different phases of dipolar BECs.

arXiv:2512.24108•Physical Review A•Jul 1, 2026•0 citations

Due to its peculiar superfluid-crystal duality feature, the supersolid has received great research interest. Recently, researchers have paid much attention to its elastic response properties; however, the inelastic deformation has barely been explored. In this work, we study the transition from elastic to inelastic deformation of a dipolar supersolid Bose-Einstein condensate trapped in a box potential (i.e., a dipolar supersolid with finite size). We obtain the stationary supersolid states (both ground and excited) of the system and examine the relation between the supersolid size and the number of unit cells it can accommodate, which can essentially help us to understand the dynamical responses of the supersolid during a dilation or compression process. We found that within a certain dilation or compression extent, the supersolid can retain its original crystal structure, that is, it endures an elastic deformation; however, when the extent exceeds a critical threshold, the original crystal structure of the supersolid will be disrupted, which signifies an inelastic deformation. Furthermore, we both analytically and numerically determine the critical point of the transition from elastic to inelastic deformation and map out a phase diagram. These results open up new territory in the research of supersolid mechanical properties and may find applications in quantum material science and quantum-based technologies.

This thesis explores the excitation spectra of supersolids - materials that remarkably manifest both lattice structure and superfluidity. We focus on an ultracold dilute gas exhibiting one-dimensional crystal structure with two gapless excitation branches. Two distinct supersolid systems are examined: a one dimensional Bose-Einstein condensate with softcore interactions, and a three dimensional dipolar Bose Einstein condensate confined within an infinitely long tube-shape potential. We investigate the crystal-like excitations of the supersolid through the use of the linear chain model and by introducing an elastic constant derived from ground-state calculations. Subsequently, we adopt a hydrodynamic approach based on an effective Lagrangian, which depends upon three fields, corresponding to lattice deformations, defect density current, the global phase fluctuations and four elastic parameters. This description of the supersolid allows for the determination of low-energy excitations, as well as the behaviour of the associated density and phase fluctuations of the two gapless branches. We validate our predictions for the low energy excitations by comparison to results from directly solving the Bogoliubov-de-Gennes equations, finding excellent agreement. This thesis provides a deeper understanding of the different types of supersolid systems, and how their low-energy behaviour depends upon their characteristic elastic energy scales.

We study the spectrum of elementary excitations of a dipolar Bose gas in a three-dimensional anisotropic trap across the superfluid-supersolid phase transition. Theoretically, we show that, when entering the supersolid phase, two distinct excitation branches appear, respectively associated with dominantly crystal and superfluid excitations. These results confirm infinite-system predictions, showing that finite-size effects play only a small qualitative role, and connect the two branches to the simultaneous occurrence of crystal and superfluid orders. Experimentally, we probe compressional excitations in an Er quantum gas across the phase diagram. While in the Bose-Einstein condensate regime the system exhibits an ordinary quadrupole oscillation, in the supersolid regime we observe a striking two-frequency response of the system, related to the two spontaneously broken symmetries.

Distinctive features of supersolids show up in their rotational properties. We calculate the moment of inertia of a harmonically trapped dipolar Bose-Einstein condensed gas as a function of the tunable scattering length parameter, providing the transition from the (fully) superfluid to the supersolid phase and eventually to an incoherent crystal of self-bound droplets. The transition from the superfluid to the supersolid phase is characterized by a jump in the moment of inertia, revealing its first order nature. In the case of elongated trapping in the plane of rotation, we show that the moment of inertia determines the value of the frequency of the scissors mode, which is significantly affected by the reduction of superfluidity in the supersolid phase. The case of an in-plane isotropic trapping is instead well suited to study the formation of quantized vortices, which are shown to be characterized, in the supersolid phase, by a sizeable deformed core, caused by the presence of the surrounding density peaks.

We investigate the excitation spectrum and compressibility of a dipolar Bose-Einstein condensate in an infinite tube potential in the parameter regime where the transition between superfluid and supersolid phases occurs. Our study focuses on the density range in which crystalline order develops continuously across the transition. Above the transition the superfluid shows a single gapless excitation band, phononic at small momenta and with a roton at a finite momentum. Below the transition, two gapless excitations branches (three at the transition point) emerge in the supersolid. We examine the two gapless excitation bands and their associated speeds of sound in the supersolid phase. Our results show that the speeds of sound and the compressibility are discontinuous at the transition, indicating a second-order phase transition. These results provide valuable insights into the identification of supersolid phenomena in dipolar quantum gases and the relationship to supersolidity in spin-orbit coupled gases.

We show that a sudden change in the polarization direction of the magnetic dipole moments of the atoms in a dipolar Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC) can serve as a useful dynamical probe to sense its superfluid and solid-like properties. We find that for small angular deviation of the polarization direction, actuated for instance by modifying an external magnetic field, the superfluid state undergoes an undamped scissors mode oscillation, a characteristic signature of superfluidity. In contrast, both the droplet and supersolid states exhibit a scissors-mode oscillation, which is effectively damped due to multiple closely spaced frequency components. Notably, we find that this damping rate provides a qualitative measure for the rigidity of different phases of a dipolar BEC. Furthermore, there exists a maximum angular deviation of the polarization direction, beyond which the droplet and the supersolid states undergo a permanent deformation i.e., we find an analog of the usual elastic to plastic phase transition of solids. We characterize this transition numerically using the fidelity of the condensate wavefunction with the ground state as well as the droplet width and periodicity of the supersolid density of the condensate which are experimentally accessible. Thus, the dynamical protocol introduced here can be an important experimental benchmark to identify and characterize the superfluid and solid properties of different phases of dipolar BECs.