Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2509.22774 · SciPost Physics Core

Entanglement and apparent thermality in simulated black holes

Iason A. Sofos, Andrew Hallam, Jiannis K. Pachos

Published Oct 14, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We investigate the apparent thermality of Hawking radiation in the semi-classical limit of quantum black holes using the mean-field limit of a chiral spin-chain simulator, which models fermions propagating on a black hole space-time in the continuum. In this free-theory regime, no genuine thermalisation occurs. Nevertheless, we show that a bipartition across the event horizon yields a reduced density matrix whose mode occupations follow an apparent thermal Fermi-Dirac distribution. In contrast, partitions away from the horizon do not exhibit such thermal distributions, reflecting the absence of thermal behaviour. Our results demonstrate that Hawking radiation appears thermal only with respect to horizon bipartitions in free theories, with genuine thermal behaviour expected to emerge only in the presence of strong interactions deep in the black hole interior, a study of which we leave for future work.

DOI
10.21468/scipostphyscore.9.4.067

Related papers

Simulating Black Hole Thermality and Interior Scrambling on a Superconducting Quantum Processor

Ryan Smith, Ewan Forbes, Iason A. Sofos +2 more

We implement a chiral spin-chain black hole simulator on IBM superconducting quantum hardware and probe, within a common microscopic framework, both semiclassical horizon physics and interacting quantum scrambling. We first measure the dispersion relation across the exterior, horizon and over-tilted interior regimes, reproducing the predicted evolution of the effective light-cone structure. To probe Hawking thermality, we prepare a localised excitation inside the horizon and monitor its density response at an exterior site, observing the predicted inverse relation between the peak arrival time and the surface gravity, thereby establishing a calibrated dynamical estimator of the Hawking temperature. Beyond the semiclassical regime, we continuously tune the interactions and distinguish non-exponential operator spreading in the free-fermion limit from Lyapunov-like OTOC decay in the strongly interacting chiral regime. These measurements use observable-specific Floquet circuits derived from the same parent chiral model, including its mean-field and coordinate-equivalent XY descriptions, to reduce circuit depth while preserving the physics relevant to each probe. Our results provide a unified programmable platform for studying horizon geometry, Hawking thermality and interacting scrambling on quantum hardware.

quant-pharXiv:2608.19318•Aug 21, 2026•0 citations

Emergent Hawking radiation and quantum sensing in a quenched chiral spin chain

Nitesh Jaiswal, S. Shankaranarayanan

We investigate the emergence and detection of Hawking radiation (HR) in a 1D chiral spin chain model, where the gravitational collapse is simulated by a sudden quantum quench that triggers a horizon-inducing phase transition. While our previous work [33] established that this model mimics black hole (BH) formation conditions even when the Hoop conjecture is seemingly violated, we here focus on the resulting stationary radiation spectrum and its detectability. By mapping the spin chain dynamics to a Dirac fermion in a curved ( 1 + 1 ) -dimensional spacetime, we analyze the radiation using two complementary approaches: field-theoretic modes and operational quantum sensors. First, using localized Gaussian wave packets to model realistic detectors, we find that the radiation spectrum exhibits deviations from the ideal Planckian form, while retaining robust Poissonian statistics that signal the loss of formation-scale information. Second, we introduce a qubit coupled globally to the chiral spin chain. Rather than acting as a localized point detector (which would break translational invariance), the qubit couples to the collective chiral excitations of the analogue spacetime, functioning as a global quantum sensor. We demonstrate that the decoherence dynamics of this macroscopic probe faithfully encode the thermal nature of the HR in the weak-coupling limit, while strong-coupling dynamics reveal non-Markovian memory effects driven by the horizon. These results provide a clear operational protocol for distinguishing genuine analog HR from environmental noise in quantum simulation platforms.

arXiv:2602.04593•Physics Letters B•Apr 17, 2026•0 citations

Gaussian quantum entanglement in curved spacetime

Madalin Calamanciuc, Аурелиан Исар

The influence of Hawking radiation on quantum entanglement for bimodal Gaussian states near a Schwarzschild black hole is investigated. It is shown that for a thermal squeezed state of a bimodal bosonic system the Hawking radiation reduces and even can destroy the entanglement between the mode of a Kruskal observer Alice and the mode of Bob, who is an accelerated observer hovering outside the event horizon of black hole. By contrary, the Hawking radiation increases and even can generate quantum entanglement between Bob and anti-Bob, who is a hypothetical observer inside event horizon. We show that in both these scenarios the competition between the contrary influences produced by Hawking temperature, squeezing and field frequency, may favour the preservation of the quantum entanglement. We investigate also the influence of the thermal environment on the behaviour in time of the entanglement between the considered observers and show that the entanglement is destroyed in a finite time for both considered bipartite scenarios of observers Alice and Bob, and respectively Bob and anti-Bob, for non-zero values of the temperature of the thermal environment, i.e. the phenomenon of entanglement sudden death takes place. For a zero temperature of the thermal bath the initial existing entanglement is decreasing over time, but it keeps for all finite times a non-zero value and the logarithmic negativity tends to zero only in the limit of infinite time.

Results in Physics•Nov 10, 2023•3 citations

Chiral Spin-Chain Interfaces Exhibiting Event-Horizon Physics

Matthew D. Horner, Andrew Hallam, Jiannis K. Pachos

The interface between different quantum phases of matter can give rise to novel physics, such as exotic topological phases or nonunitary conformal field theories. Here we investigate the interface between two spin chains in different chiral phases. Surprisingly, the mean field theory approximation of this interacting composite system is given in terms of Dirac fermions in a curved space-time geometry. In particular, the interface between the two phases represents a black hole horizon. We demonstrate that this representation is faithful both analytically, by employing bosonization to obtain a Luttinger liquid model, and numerically, by employing matrix product state methods. A striking prediction from the black hole equivalence emerges when a quench, at one side of the interface between two opposite chiralities, causes the other side to thermalize with the Hawking temperature for a wide range of parameters and initial conditions.

arXiv:2207.08840•Physical Review Letters•Jan 3, 2023•10 citations

Effect of Hawking radiation on quantum resources in Dirac black hole model

De-Feng Liu, Su-Wan Tu, Cheng‐Cheng Liu +3 more

Abstract The black hole information paradox arises from the tension between the thermal spectral properties of Hawking radiation and the unitarity principle in quantum mechanics. To explore the dynamical evolution characteristics of quantum fields in this context, we employ the standard quantization formalism for Dirac fields in Schwarzschild spacetime and investigate the coupling structure of particle and antiparticle modes within a framework that transcends the single-mode approximation. By calculating the states of externally observable subsystems, we systematically derive the evolution of concurrence and first-order coherence as functions of the Hawking temperature. Additionally, we assess the impact of varying initial parameters on these quantities. We further contrast the quantum entanglement differences between the observable exterior region and the black hole interior across diverse temperature regimes. These results provide valuable insights into the evolution of entanglement and coherence in curved spacetime.

Laser Physics Letters•May 1, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Entanglement in the Dirac Field Quantization around Charged Black Holes

Abdessamie Chhieb, Chaimae Banouni, Saliha Abdessamie +1 more

We investigate the quantum entanglement properties of the Dirac field near a charged Reissner--Nordström black hole, incorporating the effects of Hawking radiation within the framework of quantum field theory in curved spacetime. Using concurrence \( C \) and Bures distance \( B \) as measures of entanglement, we analyze how quantum correlations evolve with respect to the electric charge \( Q \) of the black hole, the frequency \( ω\) of fermionic modes, and the initial entanglement angle \( θ\). Our results show that the electric charge \( Q \) enhances decoherence inside the event horizon while, counterintuitively, temporarily increasing accessible entanglement outside. The Hawking effect induces an apparent loss of entanglement for an external observer, due to correlation transfer to inaccessible regions. High-frequency modes \( ω\) exhibit greater resilience to gravitational effects, maintaining robust correlations near the horizon. These findings highlight the redistribution of entanglement in a multipartite system in curved spacetime, with significant implications for quantum information in relativistic and gravitational contexts.

arXiv:2605.05143•May 6, 2026•0 citations
We investigate the apparent thermality of Hawking radiation in the semi-classical limit of quantum black holes using the mean-field limit of a chiral spin-chain simulator, which models fermions propagating on a black hole space-time in the continuum. In this free-theory regime, no genuine thermalisation occurs. Nevertheless, we show that a bipartition across the event horizon yields a reduced density matrix whose mode occupations follow an apparent thermal Fermi-Dirac distribution. In contrast, partitions away from the horizon do not exhibit such thermal distributions, reflecting the absence of thermal behaviour. Our results demonstrate that Hawking radiation appears thermal only with respect to horizon bipartitions in free theories, with genuine thermal behaviour expected to emerge only in the presence of strong interactions deep in the black hole interior, a study of which we leave for future work.
We implement a chiral spin-chain black hole simulator on IBM superconducting quantum hardware and probe, within a common microscopic framework, both semiclassical horizon physics and interacting quantum scrambling. We first measure the dispersion relation across the exterior, horizon and over-tilted interior regimes, reproducing the predicted evolution of the effective light-cone structure. To probe Hawking thermality, we prepare a localised excitation inside the horizon and monitor its density response at an exterior site, observing the predicted inverse relation between the peak arrival time and the surface gravity, thereby establishing a calibrated dynamical estimator of the Hawking temperature. Beyond the semiclassical regime, we continuously tune the interactions and distinguish non-exponential operator spreading in the free-fermion limit from Lyapunov-like OTOC decay in the strongly interacting chiral regime. These measurements use observable-specific Floquet circuits derived from the same parent chiral model, including its mean-field and coordinate-equivalent XY descriptions, to reduce circuit depth while preserving the physics relevant to each probe. Our results provide a unified programmable platform for studying horizon geometry, Hawking thermality and interacting scrambling on quantum hardware.
We investigate the emergence and detection of Hawking radiation (HR) in a 1D chiral spin chain model, where the gravitational collapse is simulated by a sudden quantum quench that triggers a horizon-inducing phase transition. While our previous work [33] established that this model mimics black hole (BH) formation conditions even when the Hoop conjecture is seemingly violated, we here focus on the resulting stationary radiation spectrum and its detectability. By mapping the spin chain dynamics to a Dirac fermion in a curved ( 1 + 1 ) -dimensional spacetime, we analyze the radiation using two complementary approaches: field-theoretic modes and operational quantum sensors. First, using localized Gaussian wave packets to model realistic detectors, we find that the radiation spectrum exhibits deviations from the ideal Planckian form, while retaining robust Poissonian statistics that signal the loss of formation-scale information. Second, we introduce a qubit coupled globally to the chiral spin chain. Rather than acting as a localized point detector (which would break translational invariance), the qubit couples to the collective chiral excitations of the analogue spacetime, functioning as a global quantum sensor. We demonstrate that the decoherence dynamics of this macroscopic probe faithfully encode the thermal nature of the HR in the weak-coupling limit, while strong-coupling dynamics reveal non-Markovian memory effects driven by the horizon. These results provide a clear operational protocol for distinguishing genuine analog HR from environmental noise in quantum simulation platforms.
The influence of Hawking radiation on quantum entanglement for bimodal Gaussian states near a Schwarzschild black hole is investigated. It is shown that for a thermal squeezed state of a bimodal bosonic system the Hawking radiation reduces and even can destroy the entanglement between the mode of a Kruskal observer Alice and the mode of Bob, who is an accelerated observer hovering outside the event horizon of black hole. By contrary, the Hawking radiation increases and even can generate quantum entanglement between Bob and anti-Bob, who is a hypothetical observer inside event horizon. We show that in both these scenarios the competition between the contrary influences produced by Hawking temperature, squeezing and field frequency, may favour the preservation of the quantum entanglement. We investigate also the influence of the thermal environment on the behaviour in time of the entanglement between the considered observers and show that the entanglement is destroyed in a finite time for both considered bipartite scenarios of observers Alice and Bob, and respectively Bob and anti-Bob, for non-zero values of the temperature of the thermal environment, i.e. the phenomenon of entanglement sudden death takes place. For a zero temperature of the thermal bath the initial existing entanglement is decreasing over time, but it keeps for all finite times a non-zero value and the logarithmic negativity tends to zero only in the limit of infinite time.
The interface between different quantum phases of matter can give rise to novel physics, such as exotic topological phases or nonunitary conformal field theories. Here we investigate the interface between two spin chains in different chiral phases. Surprisingly, the mean field theory approximation of this interacting composite system is given in terms of Dirac fermions in a curved space-time geometry. In particular, the interface between the two phases represents a black hole horizon. We demonstrate that this representation is faithful both analytically, by employing bosonization to obtain a Luttinger liquid model, and numerically, by employing matrix product state methods. A striking prediction from the black hole equivalence emerges when a quench, at one side of the interface between two opposite chiralities, causes the other side to thermalize with the Hawking temperature for a wide range of parameters and initial conditions.
Abstract The black hole information paradox arises from the tension between the thermal spectral properties of Hawking radiation and the unitarity principle in quantum mechanics. To explore the dynamical evolution characteristics of quantum fields in this context, we employ the standard quantization formalism for Dirac fields in Schwarzschild spacetime and investigate the coupling structure of particle and antiparticle modes within a framework that transcends the single-mode approximation. By calculating the states of externally observable subsystems, we systematically derive the evolution of concurrence and first-order coherence as functions of the Hawking temperature. Additionally, we assess the impact of varying initial parameters on these quantities. We further contrast the quantum entanglement differences between the observable exterior region and the black hole interior across diverse temperature regimes. These results provide valuable insights into the evolution of entanglement and coherence in curved spacetime.
We investigate the quantum entanglement properties of the Dirac field near a charged Reissner--Nordström black hole, incorporating the effects of Hawking radiation within the framework of quantum field theory in curved spacetime. Using concurrence C C C and Bures distance B B B as measures of entanglement, we analyze how quantum correlations evolve with respect to the electric charge Q Q Q of the black hole, the frequency ω ωω of fermionic modes, and the initial entanglement angle θ θθ. Our results show that the electric charge Q Q Q enhances decoherence inside the event horizon while, counterintuitively, temporarily increasing accessible entanglement outside. The Hawking effect induces an apparent loss of entanglement for an external observer, due to correlation transfer to inaccessible regions. High-frequency modes ω ωω exhibit greater resilience to gravitational effects, maintaining robust correlations near the horizon. These findings highlight the redistribution of entanglement in a multipartite system in curved spacetime, with significant implications for quantum information in relativistic and gravitational contexts.