Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2508.19592 · Journal of Physics Condensed Matter

One Rudolf Peierls’ surprise: the quantum-to-classical transition in the context of solid-state physics

Navinder Singh

Published Nov 12, 2025• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In solid state physics, it is an unsaid (tacit) assumption that the Bloch theorem is applicable to a crystal lattice even if it is of the macroscopic dimensions, provided periodicity is maintained. However, in a realistic situation, electrons in a periodic potential of ions constitute an open quantum system and are subjected to decoherence and dissipation. A natural question arises: up to what distances electrons in a periodic potential can be considered as constituting an effective closed quantum system? And what is the cause of decoherence? To answer some of these questions, the seminal theory of Ovchinnikov and Erikhman of decoherence due to ionic motion is revisited and an oversight of the authors is corrected. Correct conditions for decoherence to occur are worked out. Length scale up to which the motion of ions remains coherent is also calculated. Finally, a realistic physical picture is discussed.

DOI
10.1088/1361-648x/ae1eda

Related papers

Chaotic Interference and Quantum-Classical Correspondence: Mechanisms of Decoherence and State Mixing

Valentin V. Sokolov, O. V. Zhirov

The famous Nils Bohr's quantum-classical correspondence principle states that the classical mechanics is a limiting case of the more general quantum mechanics. This implies that ``under certain conditions" quantum laws of motion become equivalent to classical laws. One of the conditions is fairly obvious: the corresponding classical action should be very large as compared with the Planck's constant. But this condition is not sufficient. Suppression of effects of quantum interference ("decoherence") is the phenomenon of primary importance for understanding of the Bohr's principle. Being, in essence, of quite general nature, this problem takes on special significance in the case of non-linear classically chaotic quantum systems. Whereas the rapid decay of phase correlations is an underlying feature of the classical dynamical chaos, the "quantum chaos" by itself is not capable of destroying the quantum phase coherence. Strictly speaking, any initially pure quantum state remains pure during an arbitrary long unitary evolution. Basically, formation of incoherent mixed states (decoherence) results only from the process of preparation of a mixed initial state or interaction with a noisy environment. Just the decoherence brigdes the quantum and classical worlds. Peculiarities of the time behavior of Peres fidelity, state purity, Shanon and von Neumann entropies are analyzed in detail. We demonstrate the ways the decoherence shows up in periodically driven systems that can be associated with Ramsey-type interferomentry experiments with ion traps. Finally, decoherence in ballistic electron quantum transport caused by interaction with a disordered environment is considered.

arXiv:1311.1953•Jan 1, 2013•2 citations

Classicality with(out) decoherence: Concepts, relation to Markovianity, and a random matrix theory approach

Philipp Strasberg

Answers to the question how a classical world emerges from underlying quantum physics are revisited, connected and extended as follows. First, three distinct concepts are compared: decoherence in open quantum systems, consistent/decoherent histories and Kolmogorov consistency. Second, the crucial role of quantum Markovianity (defined rigorously) to connect these concepts is established. Third, using a random matrix theory model, quantum effects are shown to be exponentially suppressed in the measurement statistics of slow and coarse observables despite the presence of large amount of coherences. This is also numerically exemplified, and it highlights the potential and importance of non-integrability and chaos for the emergence of classicality.

arXiv:2301.02563•SciPost Physics•Jul 24, 2023•27 citations

Breakdown of the periodic potential ansatz in correlated electron systems

Wouter Montfrooij

Our electronic structure theory for crystalline solids is commonly built on the periodic potential assumption $V(\mathbf r)=V(\mathbf r+\mathbf R)$ for every lattice translation $\mathbf R$, enabling Bloch eigenstates, crystal momentum as a good quantum number, and the standard quasiparticle-based description of the behavior of metals. Because the zero-point motion of the ions, however, in correlated electron systems the electronic environment experienced by an itinerant electron is neither static nor self-averaging at the single-particle level, even in perfectly stoichiometric crystals, leading to a distribution of local Kondo scales that spans two orders of magnitude in temperature. We discuss, through a comparison between uniform scenarios and one that breaks with perfect lattice translational symmetry, how incorporating this distribution yields a unified description for all heavy-fermion systems at the quantum critical point.

cond-mat.str-elCross-listedarXiv:2603.24347•Mar 26, 2026

Decoherence of solid-state qubits

Pieter Kok, Brendon W. Lovett

Solid-state systems, by their very nature, have a vast number of different possible quantum degrees of freedom. In Chapter 11, we saw that some of these degrees of freedom make good qubits. However, there are plenty more which are less suitable, since they cannot easily be localized and externally controlled. Once the qubit has been chosen, it is important to think about how it interacts with the other, uncontrolled quantum excitations in its environment. Such an interaction leads to unpredictable behaviour and can cause decoherence – the irretrievable loss of quantum information from the qubit – and this will be the topic of this chapter. The most obvious decoherence mechanism for any optical manipulation scheme is the spontaneous emission of photons. The theory behind this follows analogously from the theory we discussed in Chapter 7, with a suitable definition of a transition dipole for the relevant transitions. However, solid-state systems bring with them lattice vibrations, or phonons, which have no direct atomic analogue. We will therefore focus on phonons in this chapter, first discussing how we model them, and second how they interact with the electron-based qubit that we discussed in the last chapter. Later, we will see how this leads to a loss of coherence, and how optical methods can be used to slow the rate of coherence loss. Phonon interactions are complex and not easy to model exactly, but we will show that with certain approximations very successful theories can be developed.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Apr 22, 2010•0 citations

The quantum mechanics of particles in a periodic potential: Bloch’s theorem

John Singleton

Abstract In this chapter we shall set up the formalism for dealing with a periodic potential; this is known as Bloch’s theorem. The next three chapters are going to appear to be hard work from a conceptual point of view. However, although the algebra looks complicated, the underlying ideas are really quite simple; after some reflection, you should be able to reproduce the various derivations yourself.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Aug 30, 2001•0 citations

Non-perturbative breakdown of Bloch’s theorem in bosonic BdG systems

Yuxuan Luo, Zhesen Yang

Bloch’s theorem, which is one of the cornerstones of condensed matter physics, has played a fundamental role in the development of many theories, such as the band theory, Fermi liquid theory, and BCS theory. It states that when the system has discrete translational symmetry, the corresponding eigenstate can be labeled by a conserved quantity, or a good quantum number — Crystal momentum. Based on Bloch’s theorem, many important physical quantities can be expressed as the integral over the entire Brillouin zone or the Fermi surface. In realistic macroscopic materials, the translational symmetry is explicitly broken down due to the existence of boundaries. It is natural to ask why we can still use Bloch’s theorem to understand the physical properties of real materials? In traditional textbooks of solid-state physics, a thermodynamic limit argument is used to explain the above question. Since the lattice size of the macroscopic material is very large, e.g. N≈1023 , its asymptotic behaviors can be described by the thermodynamic limit N→∞ . Therefore, if we fix the lattice constant, i.e., a, the system length will extend to infinity, i.e. L=aN→∞ . Since wave functions, e.g. ψ(x)∝eikx , should be bounded at the infinity, e.g. |ψ(x→±∞)|<∞ , the corresponding momentum is restricted to be real numbers. This revives Bloch’s theorem. Physically, for a finite-size system with open boundary conditions, the boundary only acts the role of scattering potential and can be regarded as a perturbation to the Bloch Hamiltonian. Therefore, the eigenstate of the OBC Hamiltonian is a superposition of all the scattered Bloch waves with the same energy. In this sense, one can say that, although the existence of boundary definitely breaks the translational symmetry, Bloch’s theorem is perturbatively broken down, and one can still use Bloch’s theorem to understand the physical properties in real materials. Even for interacting systems, Bloch’s theorem is also approximately preserved. Indeed, in a many-body system, the elementary excitations (or quasiparticles) are referred to the eigenmodes with well-defined energy, momentum, and dispersion relation. This means the excitations of the system are extended Bloch-like states in the bulk, which is consistent with the physical intuition in a disorder-free system. In this paper, we show that all the above arguments are challenged in some Hermitian bosonic systems, in which all the eigenstates, or quasiparticles are localized at the boundary, indicating that Bloch’s theorem is nonperturbatively broken down. This phenomenon generalizes the concept of the non-Hermitian skin effect from dissipative systems to non-dissipative systems, and can be understood as the Hermitian skin effect in general. Here the physical origin of the Hermitian skin effect is that although the bosonic Hamiltonian is Hermitian, its elementary excitations are determined by a non-Hermitian matrix. In order to understand the quasiparticles in such systems, the so-called generalized Brillouin zone theory is necessary. Finally, based on the Bogoliubov theory, the quench dynamic is also studied to illustrate the non-perturbative breakdown of Bloch’s theorem.

Chinese Science Bulletin (Chinese Version)•Jul 1, 2024•0 citations
In solid state physics, it is an unsaid (tacit) assumption that the Bloch theorem is applicable to a crystal lattice even if it is of the macroscopic dimensions, provided periodicity is maintained. However, in a realistic situation, electrons in a periodic potential of ions constitute an open quantum system and are subjected to decoherence and dissipation. A natural question arises: up to what distances electrons in a periodic potential can be considered as constituting an effective closed quantum system? And what is the cause of decoherence? To answer some of these questions, the seminal theory of Ovchinnikov and Erikhman of decoherence due to ionic motion is revisited and an oversight of the authors is corrected. Correct conditions for decoherence to occur are worked out. Length scale up to which the motion of ions remains coherent is also calculated. Finally, a realistic physical picture is discussed.
The famous Nils Bohr's quantum-classical correspondence principle states that the classical mechanics is a limiting case of the more general quantum mechanics. This implies that ``under certain conditions" quantum laws of motion become equivalent to classical laws. One of the conditions is fairly obvious: the corresponding classical action should be very large as compared with the Planck's constant. But this condition is not sufficient. Suppression of effects of quantum interference ("decoherence") is the phenomenon of primary importance for understanding of the Bohr's principle. Being, in essence, of quite general nature, this problem takes on special significance in the case of non-linear classically chaotic quantum systems. Whereas the rapid decay of phase correlations is an underlying feature of the classical dynamical chaos, the "quantum chaos" by itself is not capable of destroying the quantum phase coherence. Strictly speaking, any initially pure quantum state remains pure during an arbitrary long unitary evolution. Basically, formation of incoherent mixed states (decoherence) results only from the process of preparation of a mixed initial state or interaction with a noisy environment. Just the decoherence brigdes the quantum and classical worlds. Peculiarities of the time behavior of Peres fidelity, state purity, Shanon and von Neumann entropies are analyzed in detail. We demonstrate the ways the decoherence shows up in periodically driven systems that can be associated with Ramsey-type interferomentry experiments with ion traps. Finally, decoherence in ballistic electron quantum transport caused by interaction with a disordered environment is considered.
Answers to the question how a classical world emerges from underlying quantum physics are revisited, connected and extended as follows. First, three distinct concepts are compared: decoherence in open quantum systems, consistent/decoherent histories and Kolmogorov consistency. Second, the crucial role of quantum Markovianity (defined rigorously) to connect these concepts is established. Third, using a random matrix theory model, quantum effects are shown to be exponentially suppressed in the measurement statistics of slow and coarse observables despite the presence of large amount of coherences. This is also numerically exemplified, and it highlights the potential and importance of non-integrability and chaos for the emergence of classicality.
Our electronic structure theory for crystalline solids is commonly built on the periodic potential assumption V(r)=V(r+R)V(\mathbf r)=V(\mathbf r+\mathbf R)V(r)=V(r+R) for every lattice translation R\mathbf RR, enabling Bloch eigenstates, crystal momentum as a good quantum number, and the standard quasiparticle-based description of the behavior of metals. Because the zero-point motion of the ions, however, in correlated electron systems the electronic environment experienced by an itinerant electron is neither static nor self-averaging at the single-particle level, even in perfectly stoichiometric crystals, leading to a distribution of local Kondo scales that spans two orders of magnitude in temperature. We discuss, through a comparison between uniform scenarios and one that breaks with perfect lattice translational symmetry, how incorporating this distribution yields a unified description for all heavy-fermion systems at the quantum critical point.
Solid-state systems, by their very nature, have a vast number of different possible quantum degrees of freedom. In Chapter 11, we saw that some of these degrees of freedom make good qubits. However, there are plenty more which are less suitable, since they cannot easily be localized and externally controlled. Once the qubit has been chosen, it is important to think about how it interacts with the other, uncontrolled quantum excitations in its environment. Such an interaction leads to unpredictable behaviour and can cause decoherence – the irretrievable loss of quantum information from the qubit – and this will be the topic of this chapter. The most obvious decoherence mechanism for any optical manipulation scheme is the spontaneous emission of photons. The theory behind this follows analogously from the theory we discussed in Chapter 7, with a suitable definition of a transition dipole for the relevant transitions. However, solid-state systems bring with them lattice vibrations, or phonons, which have no direct atomic analogue. We will therefore focus on phonons in this chapter, first discussing how we model them, and second how they interact with the electron-based qubit that we discussed in the last chapter. Later, we will see how this leads to a loss of coherence, and how optical methods can be used to slow the rate of coherence loss. Phonon interactions are complex and not easy to model exactly, but we will show that with certain approximations very successful theories can be developed.
Bloch’s theorem, which is one of the cornerstones of condensed matter physics, has played a fundamental role in the development of many theories, such as the band theory, Fermi liquid theory, and BCS theory. It states that when the system has discrete translational symmetry, the corresponding eigenstate can be labeled by a conserved quantity, or a good quantum number — Crystal momentum. Based on Bloch’s theorem, many important physical quantities can be expressed as the integral over the entire Brillouin zone or the Fermi surface. In realistic macroscopic materials, the translational symmetry is explicitly broken down due to the existence of boundaries. It is natural to ask why we can still use Bloch’s theorem to understand the physical properties of real materials? In traditional textbooks of solid-state physics, a thermodynamic limit argument is used to explain the above question. Since the lattice size of the macroscopic material is very large, e.g. N≈1023 , its asymptotic behaviors can be described by the thermodynamic limit N→∞ . Therefore, if we fix the lattice constant, i.e., a, the system length will extend to infinity, i.e. L=aN→∞ . Since wave functions, e.g. ψ(x)∝eikx , should be bounded at the infinity, e.g. |ψ(x→±∞)|<∞ , the corresponding momentum is restricted to be real numbers. This revives Bloch’s theorem. Physically, for a finite-size system with open boundary conditions, the boundary only acts the role of scattering potential and can be regarded as a perturbation to the Bloch Hamiltonian. Therefore, the eigenstate of the OBC Hamiltonian is a superposition of all the scattered Bloch waves with the same energy. In this sense, one can say that, although the existence of boundary definitely breaks the translational symmetry, Bloch’s theorem is perturbatively broken down, and one can still use Bloch’s theorem to understand the physical properties in real materials. Even for interacting systems, Bloch’s theorem is also approximately preserved. Indeed, in a many-body system, the elementary excitations (or quasiparticles) are referred to the eigenmodes with well-defined energy, momentum, and dispersion relation. This means the excitations of the system are extended Bloch-like states in the bulk, which is consistent with the physical intuition in a disorder-free system. In this paper, we show that all the above arguments are challenged in some Hermitian bosonic systems, in which all the eigenstates, or quasiparticles are localized at the boundary, indicating that Bloch’s theorem is nonperturbatively broken down. This phenomenon generalizes the concept of the non-Hermitian skin effect from dissipative systems to non-dissipative systems, and can be understood as the Hermitian skin effect in general. Here the physical origin of the Hermitian skin effect is that although the bosonic Hamiltonian is Hermitian, its elementary excitations are determined by a non-Hermitian matrix. In order to understand the quasiparticles in such systems, the so-called generalized Brillouin zone theory is necessary. Finally, based on the Bogoliubov theory, the quench dynamic is also studied to illustrate the non-perturbative breakdown of Bloch’s theorem.