Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2507.17740 · Physical Review Letters

Quantum Stroboscopy for Time Measurements

Seth Lloyd, Lorenzo Maccone, Lionel Martellini, Simone Roncallo

Published Feb 20, 2026• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Mielnik's cannonball argument uses the Zeno effect to argue that projective measurements for time of arrival are impossible. If one repeatedly measures the position of a particle (or a cannonball!) that has yet to arrive at a detector, the Zeno effect will repeatedly collapse its wave function away from it: the particle never arrives. Here we introduce quantum stroboscopic measurements where we accumulate statistics of projective position measurements, performed on different copies of the system at different times, to obtain a time-of-arrival distribution. We show that, under appropriate limits, this gives the same statistics as time measurements of conventional "always on" particle detectors that bypass Mielnik's argument using nonprojective, weak continuous measurements. In addition to time of arrival, quantum stroboscopy can describe distributions of general time measurements. It can also be adapted to obtain the conditional probability distribution of arrival times, given that the particle was not previously detected at the detector.

DOI
10.1103/58vf-m1yx

Related papers

Quantum dynamics under continuous projective measurements: Non-Hermitian description and the continuum-space limit

Varun Dubey, Cédric Bernardin, Abhishek Dhar

The problem of the time of arrival of a quantum system in a specified state is considered in the framework of the repeated measurement protocol and in particular the limit of continuous measurements is discussed. It is shown that for a particular choice of system-detector coupling, the Zeno effect is avoided and the system can be described effectively by a non-Hermitian effective Hamiltonian. As a specific example we consider the evolution of a quantum particle on a one-dimensional lattice that is subjected to position measurements at a specific site. By solving the corresponding non-Hermitian wave-function evolution equation, we present analytic closed-form results on the survival probability and the first arrival time distribution. Finally we discuss the limit of vanishing lattice spacing and show that this leads to a continuum description where the particle evolves via the free Schr\"odinger equation with complex Robin boundary conditions at the detector site. Several interesting physical results for this dynamics are presented.

arXiv:2012.01196•Physical Review A•Mar 29, 2021•38 citations

Disclosing hidden information in the quantum Zeno effect: Pulsed measurement of the quantum time of arrival

Javier Echanobe, Adolfo del Campo, Juan Gonzalo Muga

Repeated measurements of a quantum particle to check its presence in a region of space was proposed long ago [G. R. Allcock, Ann. Phys. 53, 286 (1969)] as a natural way to determine the distribution of times of arrival at the orthogonal subspace, but the method was discarded because of the quantum Zeno effect: in the limit of very frequent measurements the wave function is reflected and remains in the original subspace. We show that by normalizing the small bits of arriving (removed) norm, an ideal time distribution emerges in correspondence with a classical local-kinetic-energy distribution.

arXiv:0712.0670•Physical Review A•Mar 25, 2008•43 citations

Projective quantum measurements in a tight-binding chain: Stochastic localization and Zeno effect

Debraj Das, Sushanta Dattagupta, Shamik Gupta

We address here the issue of quantum measurement in which the interaction between the system at hand and the measuring apparatus causes a collapse of the wave function or the density operator. The analysis is carried out for the prototypical tight-binding chain involving a quantum particle hopping between nearest-neighbour sites on a lattice, with the system subject to repeated projective measurements to a detector site. However, unlike previous work, the measurements are performed at random times. In the absence of measurement, the particle while starting from a site is known to spread out to farther sites as time progresses, leading to complete delocalization of the particle in time. In presence of measurements, we derive exact results for the probability at a given time for the particle to be found on different sites and averaged with respect to different realizations of the dynamics. We consider the representative case in which the time gap between successive measurements are sampled independently from an exponential distribution. The novel result of our findings is the revelation of the striking effect of Stochastic Localization, whereby the particle has at long times time-independent probabilities to be on different sites. This implies localization of the particle at long times, achieved through classical stochasticity involved with the random times for measurements. An extreme case of such localization is attained if the measurements are done very frequently, when the particle is completely localized at the detector site! We also point out the stochastic version of the Zeno effect, whereby dynamical evolution of a quantum system is arrested through repeated measurements at frequent-enough times. In the wake of recent experiments on projective measurements at random times achieved through randomly-pulsed sequences, our proposition is amenable to experimental realization.

•Jun 27, 2021•0 citations

Passive Quantum Measurement: Arrival Time, Quantum Zeno Effect and Gambler's Fallacy

Tajron Jurić, Hrvoje Nikolić

Abstract Classical measurements are passive, in the sense that they do not affect the physical properties of the measured system. Normally, quantum measurements are not passive in that sense. In the infinite dimensional Hilbert space, however, it is found that quantum projective measurement can be passive in a way which is impossible in finite dimensional Hilbert spaces. Specifically, it is found that expectation value of a hermitian Hamiltonian can have an imaginary part in the infinite dimensional Hilbert space and that such an imaginary part implies a possibility to avoid quantum Zeno effect, which can physically be realized in quantum arrival experiments. The avoidance of quantum Zeno effect can also be understood as avoidance of a quantum version of gambler's fallacy, leading to the notion of passive quantum measurement that updates information about the physical system without affecting its physical properties. The arrival time probability distribution of a particle is found to be given by the flux of the probability current. Possible negative fluxes correspond to regimes at which there is no arrival at all, physically understood as regimes at which the particle departs rather than arrives.

arXiv:2207.09140•Fortschritte der Physik•Jul 2, 2023•3 citations

Nonclassical time correlation functions in continuous quantum measurement

Adam Bednorz, Wolfgang Belzig, Abraham Nitzan

A continuous projective measurement of a quantum system often leads to a suppression of the dynamics, known as the Zeno effect. Alternatively, generalized nonprojective, so-called 'weak' measurements can be carried out. Such a measurement is parameterized by its strength parameter that can interpolate continuously between the ideal strong measurement with no dynamics—the strict Zeno effect, and a weak measurement characterized by almost free dynamics but blurry observations. Here we analyze the stochastic properties of this uncertainty component in the resulting observation trajectory. The observation uncertainty results from intrinsic quantum uncertainty, the effect of measurement on the system (backaction) and detector noise. It is convenient to separate the latter, system-independent contribution from the system-dependent uncertainty, and this paper shows how to accomplish this separation. The system-dependent uncertainty is found in terms of a quasi-probability, which, despite its weaker properties, is shown to satisfy a weak positivity condition. We discuss the basic properties of this quasi-probability with special emphasis on its time correlation functions as well as their relationship to the full correlation functions along the observation trajectory, and illustrate our general results with simple examples. We demonstrate a violation of classical macrorealism using the fourth-order time correlation functions with respect to the quasi-probability in the two-level system.

arXiv:1104.4126•New Journal of Physics•Jan 6, 2012•49 citations

Arbitrarily precise arrival time measurements in quantum mechanics

Lawrence Frolov

The quantum Zeno effect is often regarded as an obstruction to precise arrival time measurements in quantum mechanics. Here, an arbitrarily precise arrival time measurement procedure is constructed using a localized detection process and a suitably chosen boundary condition. The arrival time of an incoming particle is recorded in the position of a clock particle that is emitted by the apparatus upon detection. A non-zero probability of arrival is shown to survive even in the limit as exact arrival time measurement precision is achieved. In this limit, it is also found that the interaction between the incoming particle and the detector is described by an absorbing boundary condition. This justifies the claim of Tumulka that absorbing boundary conditions may be used to model idealized detectors capable of registering particles at the instant of their arrival.

quant-pharXiv:2606.01005•Jun 2, 2026•0 citations
Mielnik's cannonball argument uses the Zeno effect to argue that projective measurements for time of arrival are impossible. If one repeatedly measures the position of a particle (or a cannonball!) that has yet to arrive at a detector, the Zeno effect will repeatedly collapse its wave function away from it: the particle never arrives. Here we introduce quantum stroboscopic measurements where we accumulate statistics of projective position measurements, performed on different copies of the system at different times, to obtain a time-of-arrival distribution. We show that, under appropriate limits, this gives the same statistics as time measurements of conventional "always on" particle detectors that bypass Mielnik's argument using nonprojective, weak continuous measurements. In addition to time of arrival, quantum stroboscopy can describe distributions of general time measurements. It can also be adapted to obtain the conditional probability distribution of arrival times, given that the particle was not previously detected at the detector.
The problem of the time of arrival of a quantum system in a specified state is considered in the framework of the repeated measurement protocol and in particular the limit of continuous measurements is discussed. It is shown that for a particular choice of system-detector coupling, the Zeno effect is avoided and the system can be described effectively by a non-Hermitian effective Hamiltonian. As a specific example we consider the evolution of a quantum particle on a one-dimensional lattice that is subjected to position measurements at a specific site. By solving the corresponding non-Hermitian wave-function evolution equation, we present analytic closed-form results on the survival probability and the first arrival time distribution. Finally we discuss the limit of vanishing lattice spacing and show that this leads to a continuum description where the particle evolves via the free Schr\"odinger equation with complex Robin boundary conditions at the detector site. Several interesting physical results for this dynamics are presented.
Repeated measurements of a quantum particle to check its presence in a region of space was proposed long ago [G. R. Allcock, Ann. Phys. 53, 286 (1969)] as a natural way to determine the distribution of times of arrival at the orthogonal subspace, but the method was discarded because of the quantum Zeno effect: in the limit of very frequent measurements the wave function is reflected and remains in the original subspace. We show that by normalizing the small bits of arriving (removed) norm, an ideal time distribution emerges in correspondence with a classical local-kinetic-energy distribution.
We address here the issue of quantum measurement in which the interaction between the system at hand and the measuring apparatus causes a collapse of the wave function or the density operator. The analysis is carried out for the prototypical tight-binding chain involving a quantum particle hopping between nearest-neighbour sites on a lattice, with the system subject to repeated projective measurements to a detector site. However, unlike previous work, the measurements are performed at random times. In the absence of measurement, the particle while starting from a site is known to spread out to farther sites as time progresses, leading to complete delocalization of the particle in time. In presence of measurements, we derive exact results for the probability at a given time for the particle to be found on different sites and averaged with respect to different realizations of the dynamics. We consider the representative case in which the time gap between successive measurements are sampled independently from an exponential distribution. The novel result of our findings is the revelation of the striking effect of Stochastic Localization, whereby the particle has at long times time-independent probabilities to be on different sites. This implies localization of the particle at long times, achieved through classical stochasticity involved with the random times for measurements. An extreme case of such localization is attained if the measurements are done very frequently, when the particle is completely localized at the detector site! We also point out the stochastic version of the Zeno effect, whereby dynamical evolution of a quantum system is arrested through repeated measurements at frequent-enough times. In the wake of recent experiments on projective measurements at random times achieved through randomly-pulsed sequences, our proposition is amenable to experimental realization.
Abstract Classical measurements are passive, in the sense that they do not affect the physical properties of the measured system. Normally, quantum measurements are not passive in that sense. In the infinite dimensional Hilbert space, however, it is found that quantum projective measurement can be passive in a way which is impossible in finite dimensional Hilbert spaces. Specifically, it is found that expectation value of a hermitian Hamiltonian can have an imaginary part in the infinite dimensional Hilbert space and that such an imaginary part implies a possibility to avoid quantum Zeno effect, which can physically be realized in quantum arrival experiments. The avoidance of quantum Zeno effect can also be understood as avoidance of a quantum version of gambler's fallacy, leading to the notion of passive quantum measurement that updates information about the physical system without affecting its physical properties. The arrival time probability distribution of a particle is found to be given by the flux of the probability current. Possible negative fluxes correspond to regimes at which there is no arrival at all, physically understood as regimes at which the particle departs rather than arrives.
A continuous projective measurement of a quantum system often leads to a suppression of the dynamics, known as the Zeno effect. Alternatively, generalized nonprojective, so-called 'weak' measurements can be carried out. Such a measurement is parameterized by its strength parameter that can interpolate continuously between the ideal strong measurement with no dynamics—the strict Zeno effect, and a weak measurement characterized by almost free dynamics but blurry observations. Here we analyze the stochastic properties of this uncertainty component in the resulting observation trajectory. The observation uncertainty results from intrinsic quantum uncertainty, the effect of measurement on the system (backaction) and detector noise. It is convenient to separate the latter, system-independent contribution from the system-dependent uncertainty, and this paper shows how to accomplish this separation. The system-dependent uncertainty is found in terms of a quasi-probability, which, despite its weaker properties, is shown to satisfy a weak positivity condition. We discuss the basic properties of this quasi-probability with special emphasis on its time correlation functions as well as their relationship to the full correlation functions along the observation trajectory, and illustrate our general results with simple examples. We demonstrate a violation of classical macrorealism using the fourth-order time correlation functions with respect to the quasi-probability in the two-level system.
The quantum Zeno effect is often regarded as an obstruction to precise arrival time measurements in quantum mechanics. Here, an arbitrarily precise arrival time measurement procedure is constructed using a localized detection process and a suitably chosen boundary condition. The arrival time of an incoming particle is recorded in the position of a clock particle that is emitted by the apparatus upon detection. A non-zero probability of arrival is shown to survive even in the limit as exact arrival time measurement precision is achieved. In this limit, it is also found that the interaction between the incoming particle and the detector is described by an absorbing boundary condition. This justifies the claim of Tumulka that absorbing boundary conditions may be used to model idealized detectors capable of registering particles at the instant of their arrival.