arXiv:2507.04650

From Wavefunctional Entanglement to Entangled Wavefunctional Degrees of Freedom

Bhattacharya, Aniruddha

Published Jul 7, 2025• 0 citations

Abstract

The question of whether entanglement between photons is equivalent to entanglement between their characteristic field modes, specifically, the single-particle wavefunctions that are composed and superposed to describe particles in such modes, is a key, open problem concerning multi-partite optical degrees of freedom, and has profound implications for topics ranging from quantum foundations to quantum computation. Here, I offer a fresh, deeper, physical insight into this subtle, albeit enduring, issue by describing a situation in which the entangling interactions between optical modes, namely, the wavefunctions, can be distilled into genuine entanglement between the physical, observable properties of the photons, which are the wavefunctional degrees of freedom. This theoretical observation also highlights the salience of the measurement context, especially, of clearly disambiguating between the choice of the quantum subsystem and the decision to measure an observable along a particular axis of measurement, while quantifying and transforming quantum optical entanglement. This theoretical observation might be applied to formulate a new class of protocols for performing quantum information tasks, using entangled photons within inseparable field modes.

DOI: 10.48550/arxiv.2507.04650

Related papers

Entanglement between dependent degrees of freedom: Quasiparticle correlations

Franziska Barkhausen, Laura Ares, Stefan Schumacher +1 more

Common notions of entanglement are based on well-separated subsystems. However, obtaining such independent degrees of freedom is not always possible because of physical constraints. In this work, we explore the notion of entanglement in the context of dependent degrees of freedom. As a physically relevant application, we specifically study quantum correlation features for quasiparticle descriptions. Those are paramount for interacting light-matter systems, utilizing excitations of fermion-boson hybrid modes. By comparing independent and dependent degrees of freedom, we uncover that certain states are nonentangled although they would be entangled when only focusing on the common, independent description, and vice versa. Therefore, insight is provided into the resourcefulness of quantum correlations within the rarely discussed context of dependent degrees of freedom for light-matter links in quantum information applications.

arXiv:2410.14290Physical Review AMar 4, 20251 citation

Philosophy of Polarization-Path Entanglement in Quantum Optics

Artur Czerwiński

This paper explores the formal structure and philosophical implications of polarization-path entanglement in quantum optics, where different degrees of freedom of a single photon become entangled. We examine the mathematical conditions under which coherence is preserved or lost, emphasizing the role of distinguishability and information flow. The analysis is situated within major interpretational frameworks (including Copenhagen, Many-Worlds, QBism, and Bohmian mechanics) to evaluate whether such entanglement reflects physical reality or epistemic constraints. Finally, we discuss experimental realizations, relevance to quantum information processing, and open conceptual questions regarding the ontological status of single-particle entanglement.

OpticsAug 18, 20252 citations

Introduction to Measurement Space and Application to Operationally Useful Entanglement and Mode Entanglement

Sebastian Meznaric

We introduce the idea that the knowable quantum reality depends not only on the state but also on measurements. Mathematically, we map the states from the ordinary Hilbert space into new states in what we call the measurement space. The state vectors in the measurement space contain only the information accessible with a particular set of measurements. The space can be used to find the operational equivalent of any information theoretic quantity. We use the formalism to define the operationally meaningful entanglement, explore its properties and apply it to mode entanglement. There we find that a mode-entangled state of a single particle has no operationally useful entanglement unless additional degrees of freedom are introduced to the system.

arXiv:1004.4854Apr 27, 20100 citations

Exploring High-dimensional Hilbert spaces by Quantum Optics

Andrea Chiuri, Paolo Mataloni

In the case of mixed states ρAB of the composite system A ⊗ B, the previous relation generalizes to ρAB = ∑ k pkρ A k ⊗ρk , where pk are probabilities and ρk ’s (ρk ’s) are generic density matrix of the system A (B). The entanglement derives from “subtle” nonlocal correlations between the parts of a quantum system and combines three basic structural elements of quantum theory: the superposition principle, the quantum non-separability property and the exponential scaling of the state space with the number of partitions. This unique resource can be used to perform computational and cryptographic tasks otherwise impossible with classical systems. An entangled state shared by two or more separated parties is a valuable resource for fundamental quantum protocols, such as quantum teleportation [2], quantum computing [3] and quantum cryptography. By using entangled states we can deeply investigate the nonlocal properties of the quantum world. In fact, an entangled system exhibits correlations between two (or more) parties, which cannot be reproduced by a classical theory or, in general, by a Local Hidden Variables Theory (LHVT). Quantum optics represents an excellent experimental test bench for various novel concepts introduced within the framework of quantum information theory. Quantum states of photons, generally produced by a probabilistic process, namely spontaneous parametric down conversion (SPDC), may be easily and accurately manipulated using linear and nonlinear optical devices and measured by efficient single-photon detectors. Photonic qubits represent the typical carrier of quantum information and can be distributed over long distances, either in free-space or in low-loss optical fibers. Two-particle experiments correspond to operate with qubits belonging to a (2 × 2) Hilbert space. Many quantum information tasks and fundamental tests of quantum mechanics, such as the simulation of properties of quantum systems, the realization of quantum algorithms of increasing complexity and the investigation of the quantum world at a mesoscopic level, deal with a large number of qubits. In order to take full advantage of the possibilities offered by quantum mechanics, more qubits must be added to a quantum state. Two approaches may be followed to increase the number of qubits. The first one consists of increasing the number of entangled particles. In this way, multi-qubit entangled states are created by distributing the qubits between the particles so that each particle carries one qubit. A second strategy consists of encoding more than one qubit in each particle, by exploiting different degrees of freedom (DOFs) of the photon such as the polarization, the path, the emission time, the orbital angular momentum. This has been used to create two-photon fourand six-qubit states and up to five-photon ten-qubit graph states. The entanglement of two particles in different DOFs corresponds to socalled hyperentanglement. It is worth noting that multi-qubit hyperentanglement allows to achieve higher

Jan 1, 20120 citations

Entanglement of particles versus entanglement of fields: Independent quantum resources

Jan Sperling, Elizabeth Agudelo

Nature allows one to explore a manifold of remarkable quantum effects. Most prominently, quantum entanglement can be observed in many-particle systems, between multiple quantized fields, and in hybrid combinations thereof. This diversity, however, also leads to contradicting conclusions about what truly constitutes entanglement in any given physical scenario. By explicitly allowing various perspectives, we rigorously consider different notions of entanglement in the context of first and second quantization. By providing instructive examples, we show that particle entanglement and field entanglement are actually distinct phenomena that can occur and be observed independently of each other. This conclusion not only affects our fundamental understanding but has direct implications for quantum technology which can harness those independent forms of entanglement in practical scenarios.

arXiv:2204.06245Physical Review AApr 17, 20234 citations

Modular variables in quantum information

Andreas Ketterer

Quantum information can be processed in two fundamentally different ways, using either discrete or continuous variable implementations. Each one of them provides different practical advantages and drawbacks. In this thesis we study theoretical means allowing to implement quantum information protocols originally formulated for discrete quantum systems in physical objects characterized by continuous variables. At the heart of our considerations is the use of modular variables as helpful technique to reveal discrete structure in continuous-variable states, operations and observables. The present work is strongly guided by the experimental applicability of our ideas in quantum optics experiments, with a particular focus on the transverse degrees of freedom of single photons.One of the main themes of this thesis is the formulation of a framework for quantum information processing in phase-space based on the use of modular variables. The term modular variables refers to a specific class of observables that are periodic with respect to some pair of conjugate variables. In our framework we use these periodic observables in order to encode discrete quantum information in Hilbert spaces of infinite dimension. In particular, we consider protocols that involve measurements of judiciously chosen logical observables enabling the readout of the encoded discrete quantum information from the corresponding logical states. Using this framework we show how to perform tests of fundamental properties of quantum mechanics, such as entanglement, Bell nonlocality and contextuality, in Hilbert spaces of various dimensions. Particularly, we generalize known tests of each of these properties, that were originally formulated for measurements with discrete outcomes, to more general measurement contexts comprising the case of bounded continuous outcomes. Concerning experimental implementations of the presented theoretical elaborations we discuss the transverse degrees of freedom of single photons as a natural platform to manipulate and measure modular variables. In particular, we demonstrate how to process discrete quantum information encoded in the spatial distribution of single photons via the optical Talbot effect - a near-field interference effect. Finally, we show how to produce d-dimensional entangled Talbot photon pairs without post-selection, using spontaneous parametric down-conversion and linear optical elements only. As last topic we explore the nonlocal properties of a specific class of hybrid entanglement between particle-like and wave-like optical qubits. Using a hybrid measurement scheme of Pauli and displaced parity measurements we show that, even after including realistic experimental losses, a violation of local-realism is theoretically possible.

Oct 14, 20164 citations