Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2506.10069 · Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical

Quantum speed limits from symmetries in quantum control

Marco Wiedmann, Daniel Klaus Burgarth

Published Jan 29, 2026• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract In quantum control, quantum speed limits provide fundamental lower bounds on the time that is needed to implement certain unitary transformations. Using Lie algebraic methods, we link these speed limits to symmetries of the control Hamiltonians and provide quantitative bounds that can be calculated without solving the controlled system dynamics. In particular we focus on two scenarios: On one hand, we provide bounds on the time that is needed for a control system to implement a given target unitary U and on the other hand we bound the time to implement the most difficult to reach evolution e − i θ H s of a target Hamiltonian H s . We apply our abstract bounds on physically relevant systems like coupled qubits, spin chains, globally controlled Rydberg atoms and NMR molecules and compare our results to the existing literature. We hope that our bounds can aid experimentalists to identify bottlenecks and design faster quantum control systems.

DOI
10.1088/1751-8121/ae3f68

Related papers

Exact and lower bounds for the quantum speed limit in finite-dimensional systems

Mattias Johnsson, Lauritz van Luijk, Daniel Klaus Burgarth

A fundamental problem in quantum engineering is determining the lowest time required to ensure that all possible unitaries can be generated with the tools available, which is one of a number of possible quantum speed limits. We examine this problem from the perspective of quantum control, where the system of interest is described by a drift Hamiltonian and set of control Hamiltonians. Our approach uses a combination of Lie algebra theory, Lie groups, and differential geometry and formulates the problem in terms of geodesics on a differentiable manifold. We provide explicit lower bounds on the quantum speed limit for the case of an arbitrary drift, requiring only that the control Hamiltonians generate a topologically closed subgroup of the full unitary group, and formulate criteria as to when our expression for the speed limit is exact and not merely a lower bound. These analytic results are then tested and confirmed using a numerical optimization scheme. Finally, we extend the analysis to find a lower bound on the quantum speed limit in the common case where the system is described by a drift Hamiltonian and a single control Hamiltonian.

arXiv:2304.06617•Physical Review A•Nov 2, 2023•4 citations

Dependence of the quantum speed limit on system size and control complexity

Juneseo Lee, Christian Arenz, HERSCHEL A. RABITZ +1 more

We extend the work in 2017 New J. Phys. 19 103015 by deriving a lower bound for the minimum time necessary to implement a unitary transformation on a generic, closed quantum system with an arbitrary number of classical control fields. This bound is explicitly analyzed for a specific N -level system similar to those used to represent simple models of an atom, or the first excitation sector of a Heisenberg spin chain, both of which are of interest in quantum control for quantum computation. Specifically, it is shown that the resultant bound depends on the dimension of the system, and on the number of controls used to implement a specific target unitary operation. The value of the bound determined numerically, and an estimate of the true minimum gate time are systematically compared for a range of system dimension and number of controls; special attention is drawn to the relationship between these two variables. It is seen that the bound captures the scaling of the minimum time well for the systems studied, and quantitatively is correct in the order of magnitude.

arXiv:1803.00027•New Journal of Physics•May 22, 2018•21 citations

Geometric quantum speed limits and short-time accessibility to unitary operations

Pablo M. Poggi

The notion of a quantum speed limit (QSL) refers to the fundamental fact that two quantum states become completely distinguishable upon dynamical evolution only after a finite amount of time, called the QSL time. A different but related concept is that of minimum control time (MCT), which is the minimum evolution time needed for a state to be driven (by suitable, generally time-dependent, control fields) to a given target state. While the QSL can give information about the MCT, it usually imposes little restrictions on it and is thus impractical for control purposes. In this work, we revisit this issue by first presenting a theory of geometrical QSL for unitary transformations, rather than for states, and discuss its implications and limitations. Then, we propose a framework for bounding the MCT for realizing unitary transformations that goes beyond the QSL results and gives much more meaningful information to understand the controlled dynamics of the system at short times.

arXiv:1901.02042•Physical Review A•Apr 22, 2019•36 citations

Lie-Algebraic Bounds on Quantum Control Time via the Baker-Campbell-Hausdorff Formula

Go Kato, Masaki Owari, Koji Maruyama

The time required to implement a desired unitary operation is a central issue in quantum control, especially for many-body systems with limited control access. While controllability theory determines whether a target unitary is reachable in principle, it does not directly quantify the implementation time. Here we derive a Baker-Campbell-Hausdorff (BCH)-based inequality that connects these two questions at the operator level. Whenever a target unitary is implemented by the available Hamiltonians, an effective logarithmic generator can be chosen within the corresponding dynamical Lie algebra, and its normalized traceless Hilbert-Schmidt norm is bounded by the time integral of the same norm of the applied Hamiltonian. This induces a global-phase-insensitive distance on the reachable subgroup and yields a protocol-independent lower bound on the control time that explicitly respects Lie-algebraic restrictions. We compare the resulting bound with familiar quantum-speed-limit estimates and show that it refines a stabilizer-based control-time bound for an XY spin chain in the single-excitation subspace. Our result thus provides an algebraic link between controllability and quantitative bounds on unitary implementation time.

arXiv:2411.13155•Nov 20, 2024•0 citations

ANALYSIS OF LOWER BOUNDS FOR QUANTUM CONTROL TIMES AND THEIR RELATION TO THE QUANTUM SPEED LIMIT

Pablo M. Poggi

Limitations to the speed of evolution of quantum systems, typically referred to as quantum speed limits (QSLs), have important consequences for quantum control problems. However, in its standard formulation, is not straightforward to obtain meaningful QSL bounds for time-dependent Hamiltonians with unknown control parameters. In this paper we present a short introductory overview of quantum speed limit for unitary dynamics and its connection to quantum control. We then analyze potential methods for obtaining new bounds on control times inspired by the QSL. We finally extend the work in [Poggi, Lombardo and WisniackiEPL104 40005 (2013)] by studying the properties and limitations of these new bounds in the context of a driven two-level quantum system.

arXiv:2002.11147•Anales/Anales AFA•Apr 1, 2020•11 citations

The roles of drift and control field constraints upon quantum control speed limits

Christian Arenz, Benjamin Russell, Daniel Klaus Burgarth +1 more

In this work we derive a lower bound for the minimum time required to implement a target unitary transformation through a classical time-dependent field in a closed quantum system. The bound depends on the target gate, the strength of the internal Hamiltonian and the highest permitted control field amplitude. These findings reveal some properties of the reachable set of operations, explicitly analyzed for a single qubit. Moreover, for fully controllable systems, we identify a lower bound for the time at which all unitary gates become reachable. We use numerical gate optimization in order to study the tightness of the obtained bounds. It is shown that in the single qubit case our analytical findings describe the relationship between the highest control field amplitude and the minimum evolution time remarkably well. Finally, we discuss both challenges and ways forward for obtaining tighter bounds for higher dimensional systems, offering a discussion about the mathematical form and the physical meaning of the bound.

arXiv:1704.06289•New Journal of Physics•Oct 23, 2017•35 citations
Abstract In quantum control, quantum speed limits provide fundamental lower bounds on the time that is needed to implement certain unitary transformations. Using Lie algebraic methods, we link these speed limits to symmetries of the control Hamiltonians and provide quantitative bounds that can be calculated without solving the controlled system dynamics. In particular we focus on two scenarios: On one hand, we provide bounds on the time that is needed for a control system to implement a given target unitary U and on the other hand we bound the time to implement the most difficult to reach evolution e − i θ H s of a target Hamiltonian H s . We apply our abstract bounds on physically relevant systems like coupled qubits, spin chains, globally controlled Rydberg atoms and NMR molecules and compare our results to the existing literature. We hope that our bounds can aid experimentalists to identify bottlenecks and design faster quantum control systems.
A fundamental problem in quantum engineering is determining the lowest time required to ensure that all possible unitaries can be generated with the tools available, which is one of a number of possible quantum speed limits. We examine this problem from the perspective of quantum control, where the system of interest is described by a drift Hamiltonian and set of control Hamiltonians. Our approach uses a combination of Lie algebra theory, Lie groups, and differential geometry and formulates the problem in terms of geodesics on a differentiable manifold. We provide explicit lower bounds on the quantum speed limit for the case of an arbitrary drift, requiring only that the control Hamiltonians generate a topologically closed subgroup of the full unitary group, and formulate criteria as to when our expression for the speed limit is exact and not merely a lower bound. These analytic results are then tested and confirmed using a numerical optimization scheme. Finally, we extend the analysis to find a lower bound on the quantum speed limit in the common case where the system is described by a drift Hamiltonian and a single control Hamiltonian.
We extend the work in 2017 New J. Phys. 19 103015 by deriving a lower bound for the minimum time necessary to implement a unitary transformation on a generic, closed quantum system with an arbitrary number of classical control fields. This bound is explicitly analyzed for a specific N -level system similar to those used to represent simple models of an atom, or the first excitation sector of a Heisenberg spin chain, both of which are of interest in quantum control for quantum computation. Specifically, it is shown that the resultant bound depends on the dimension of the system, and on the number of controls used to implement a specific target unitary operation. The value of the bound determined numerically, and an estimate of the true minimum gate time are systematically compared for a range of system dimension and number of controls; special attention is drawn to the relationship between these two variables. It is seen that the bound captures the scaling of the minimum time well for the systems studied, and quantitatively is correct in the order of magnitude.
The notion of a quantum speed limit (QSL) refers to the fundamental fact that two quantum states become completely distinguishable upon dynamical evolution only after a finite amount of time, called the QSL time. A different but related concept is that of minimum control time (MCT), which is the minimum evolution time needed for a state to be driven (by suitable, generally time-dependent, control fields) to a given target state. While the QSL can give information about the MCT, it usually imposes little restrictions on it and is thus impractical for control purposes. In this work, we revisit this issue by first presenting a theory of geometrical QSL for unitary transformations, rather than for states, and discuss its implications and limitations. Then, we propose a framework for bounding the MCT for realizing unitary transformations that goes beyond the QSL results and gives much more meaningful information to understand the controlled dynamics of the system at short times.
The time required to implement a desired unitary operation is a central issue in quantum control, especially for many-body systems with limited control access. While controllability theory determines whether a target unitary is reachable in principle, it does not directly quantify the implementation time. Here we derive a Baker-Campbell-Hausdorff (BCH)-based inequality that connects these two questions at the operator level. Whenever a target unitary is implemented by the available Hamiltonians, an effective logarithmic generator can be chosen within the corresponding dynamical Lie algebra, and its normalized traceless Hilbert-Schmidt norm is bounded by the time integral of the same norm of the applied Hamiltonian. This induces a global-phase-insensitive distance on the reachable subgroup and yields a protocol-independent lower bound on the control time that explicitly respects Lie-algebraic restrictions. We compare the resulting bound with familiar quantum-speed-limit estimates and show that it refines a stabilizer-based control-time bound for an XY spin chain in the single-excitation subspace. Our result thus provides an algebraic link between controllability and quantitative bounds on unitary implementation time.
Limitations to the speed of evolution of quantum systems, typically referred to as quantum speed limits (QSLs), have important consequences for quantum control problems. However, in its standard formulation, is not straightforward to obtain meaningful QSL bounds for time-dependent Hamiltonians with unknown control parameters. In this paper we present a short introductory overview of quantum speed limit for unitary dynamics and its connection to quantum control. We then analyze potential methods for obtaining new bounds on control times inspired by the QSL. We finally extend the work in [Poggi, Lombardo and WisniackiEPL104 40005 (2013)] by studying the properties and limitations of these new bounds in the context of a driven two-level quantum system.
In this work we derive a lower bound for the minimum time required to implement a target unitary transformation through a classical time-dependent field in a closed quantum system. The bound depends on the target gate, the strength of the internal Hamiltonian and the highest permitted control field amplitude. These findings reveal some properties of the reachable set of operations, explicitly analyzed for a single qubit. Moreover, for fully controllable systems, we identify a lower bound for the time at which all unitary gates become reachable. We use numerical gate optimization in order to study the tightness of the obtained bounds. It is shown that in the single qubit case our analytical findings describe the relationship between the highest control field amplitude and the minimum evolution time remarkably well. Finally, we discuss both challenges and ways forward for obtaining tighter bounds for higher dimensional systems, offering a discussion about the mathematical form and the physical meaning of the bound.