Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2505.17361

Quantum Statistics Forbids Particle Exchange Statistics beyond Bosons and Fermions in 3D

Chi-Chun Zhou, Shuai A. Chen, Chen, Yu-Zhu, Yao Shen, Fulin Zhang, Wu-Sheng Dai

Published May 23, 2025• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum matter in three spatial dimensions is observed to consist exclusively of bosons and fermions. Whether this empirical fact follows from basic consistency requirements of quantum theory itself or must be imposed as an additional principle has for 80 years remained a fundamental conceptual gap. Here we close this gap by establishing a no-go theorem that excludes any particle exchange statistics beyond bosons and fermions in three dimensions. We identify the consistency conditions linking the many-body Hilbert-space structure of quantum mechanics with the statistical microstate counting of indistinguishable particles. As a corollary, we demonstrate that higher-dimensional representations of the symmetric group cannot give rise to genuinely distinct particle exchange statistics in any spatial dimension.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2505.17361

Related papers

Particle exchange in post-quantum theories

Oscar Dahlsten, Andrew J. P. Garner, Jayne E. Thompson +2 more

In quantum theory, particles in three spatial dimensions come in two different types: bosons or fermions, which exhibit sharply contrasting behaviours due to their different exchange statistics. Could more general forms of probabilistic theories admit more exotic types of particles? Here, we propose a thought experiment to identify more exotic particles in general post-quantum theories. We consider how in quantum theory the phase introduced by swapping indistinguishable particles can be measured. We generalise this to post-quantum scenarios whilst imposing indistinguishability and locality principles. We show that our ability to witness exotic particle exchange statistics depends on which symmetries are admitted within a theory. These exotic particles can manifest unusual behaviour, such as non-abelianicity even in topologically simple three-dimensional space.

arXiv:1307.2529•Jul 9, 2013•3 citations

Particle exchange statistics beyond fermions and bosons

Zhiyuan Wang, Kaden R. A. Hazzard

Abstract It is commonly believed that there are only two types of particle exchange statistics in quantum mechanics, fermions and bosons, with the exception of anyons in two dimensions 1–5 . In principle, a second exception known as parastatistics, which extends outside two dimensions, has been considered 6 but was believed to be physically equivalent to fermions and bosons 7–9 . Here we show that non-trivial parastatistics inequivalent to either fermions or bosons can exist in physical systems. These new types of identical particle obey generalized exclusion principles, leading to exotic free-particle thermodynamics distinct from any system of free fermions and bosons. We formulate our theory by developing a second quantization of paraparticles that naturally includes exactly solvable non-interacting theories and incorporates physical constraints such as locality. We then construct a family of exactly solvable quantum spin models in one and two dimensions, in which free paraparticles emerge as quasiparticle excitations, and their exchange statistics can be physically observed and are notably distinct from fermions and bosons. This demonstrates the possibility of a new type of quasiparticle in condensed matter systems and—more speculatively—the potential for previously unconsidered types of elementary particle.

arXiv:2308.05203•Nature•Jan 8, 2025•32 citations

Quantum Statistics of Identical Particles

J. C. Garrison

Abstract The empirical rule that systems of identical particles always obey either Bose or Fermi statistics is customarily imposed on the theory by adding it to the axioms of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics, with the result that other statistical behaviors are excluded a priori. A more general approach is to ask what other many-particle statistics are consistent with the indistinguishability of identical particles. This strategy offers a way to discuss possible violations of the Pauli Exclusion Principle, and it leads to some interesting issues related to preparation of states and a superselection rule arising from invariance under the permutation group.

arXiv:2207.13231•Foundations of Physics•Jul 14, 2022•1 citation

Invariance under quantum permutations rules out parastatistics

Manuel Mekonnen, Thomas D. Galley, Markus P. Müller

Quantum systems invariant under particle exchange are either Bosons or Fermions, even though quantum theory in principle admits more general behavior under permutations. But why do we not observe such paraparticles in nature? The analysis of this question was previously limited primarily to specific quantum field theory models. Here we give two distinct model-independent arguments that rule out parastatistics, i.e. fundamentally indistinguishable quantum systems transforming under higher-dimensional representations of the symmetric group, which draw on quantum information theory and recent research on internal quantum reference frames. First, we introduce a notion of complete invariance: quantum systems should not only preserve their local state under permutations, but also the quantum information they carry about other systems, in analogy to the notion of complete positivity in quantum information theory. Second, we demand that quantum systems are invariant under quantum permutations, i.e. permutations conditioned on values of permutation-invariant observables. For both, we show that the respective principle is fulfilled if and only if the particle is a Boson or Fermion. Our results show how quantum reference frames can shed light on a longstanding problem of quantum physics, they underline the crucial role played by the compositional structure of quantum information, and demonstrate the explanatory power but also subtle limitations of recently proposed quantum covariance principles.

arXiv:2502.17576•Nature Communications•May 28, 2026•2 citations

Entropy of fermion systems

Don S. Lemons

Symmetries and wave functions An important difference between the classical and quantum perspectives is their different criteria of distinguishability. Identical particles are classically distinguishable when separated in phase space. On the other hand, identical particles are always quantum mechanically indistinguishable for the purpose of counting distinct microstates. But these concepts and these distinctions do not tell the whole story of how we count the microstates and determine the multiplicity of a quantized system. There are actually two different ways of counting the accessible microstates of a quantized system of identical, and so indistinguishable, particles. While these two ways were discovered in the years 1924–1926 independently of Erwin Schrödinger’s (1887–1961) invention of wave mechanics in 1926, their most convincing explanation is in terms of particle wave functions. The following two paragraphs may be helpful to those familiar with the basic features of wave mechanics. A system of identical particles has, as one might expect, a probability density that is symmetric under particle exchange, that is, the probability density is invariant under the exchange of two identical particles. But here wave mechanics surprises the classical physicist. A system wave function may either keep the same sign or change signs under particle exchange. In particular, a system wave function may be either symmetric or antisymmetric under particle exchange.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Aug 29, 2013•0 citations

The exclusion principle and indistinguishability of identical particles in quantum mechanics

Inna G Kaplan

The connection between the exclusion principle and the principle of indistinguishability of identical particles in quantum mechanics is discussed. It is shown with the aid of a density matrix defined for states with arbitrary permutation symmetry that the particles are indistinguishable only for one-dimensional representations of the permutation group (symmetrical and antisymmetrycal), and are distinguishable in all the states that are degenerate in the permutations. It is demonstrated by the same token that the exclusion principle follows from the principle of indistinguishability of identical particles and the Pauli theorem on the connection between spin and statistics.

Soviet Physics Uspekhi•Dec 31, 1975•17 citations
Quantum matter in three spatial dimensions is observed to consist exclusively of bosons and fermions. Whether this empirical fact follows from basic consistency requirements of quantum theory itself or must be imposed as an additional principle has for 80 years remained a fundamental conceptual gap. Here we close this gap by establishing a no-go theorem that excludes any particle exchange statistics beyond bosons and fermions in three dimensions. We identify the consistency conditions linking the many-body Hilbert-space structure of quantum mechanics with the statistical microstate counting of indistinguishable particles. As a corollary, we demonstrate that higher-dimensional representations of the symmetric group cannot give rise to genuinely distinct particle exchange statistics in any spatial dimension.
In quantum theory, particles in three spatial dimensions come in two different types: bosons or fermions, which exhibit sharply contrasting behaviours due to their different exchange statistics. Could more general forms of probabilistic theories admit more exotic types of particles? Here, we propose a thought experiment to identify more exotic particles in general post-quantum theories. We consider how in quantum theory the phase introduced by swapping indistinguishable particles can be measured. We generalise this to post-quantum scenarios whilst imposing indistinguishability and locality principles. We show that our ability to witness exotic particle exchange statistics depends on which symmetries are admitted within a theory. These exotic particles can manifest unusual behaviour, such as non-abelianicity even in topologically simple three-dimensional space.
Abstract It is commonly believed that there are only two types of particle exchange statistics in quantum mechanics, fermions and bosons, with the exception of anyons in two dimensions 1–5 . In principle, a second exception known as parastatistics, which extends outside two dimensions, has been considered 6 but was believed to be physically equivalent to fermions and bosons 7–9 . Here we show that non-trivial parastatistics inequivalent to either fermions or bosons can exist in physical systems. These new types of identical particle obey generalized exclusion principles, leading to exotic free-particle thermodynamics distinct from any system of free fermions and bosons. We formulate our theory by developing a second quantization of paraparticles that naturally includes exactly solvable non-interacting theories and incorporates physical constraints such as locality. We then construct a family of exactly solvable quantum spin models in one and two dimensions, in which free paraparticles emerge as quasiparticle excitations, and their exchange statistics can be physically observed and are notably distinct from fermions and bosons. This demonstrates the possibility of a new type of quasiparticle in condensed matter systems and—more speculatively—the potential for previously unconsidered types of elementary particle.
Abstract The empirical rule that systems of identical particles always obey either Bose or Fermi statistics is customarily imposed on the theory by adding it to the axioms of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics, with the result that other statistical behaviors are excluded a priori. A more general approach is to ask what other many-particle statistics are consistent with the indistinguishability of identical particles. This strategy offers a way to discuss possible violations of the Pauli Exclusion Principle, and it leads to some interesting issues related to preparation of states and a superselection rule arising from invariance under the permutation group.
Quantum systems invariant under particle exchange are either Bosons or Fermions, even though quantum theory in principle admits more general behavior under permutations. But why do we not observe such paraparticles in nature? The analysis of this question was previously limited primarily to specific quantum field theory models. Here we give two distinct model-independent arguments that rule out parastatistics, i.e. fundamentally indistinguishable quantum systems transforming under higher-dimensional representations of the symmetric group, which draw on quantum information theory and recent research on internal quantum reference frames. First, we introduce a notion of complete invariance: quantum systems should not only preserve their local state under permutations, but also the quantum information they carry about other systems, in analogy to the notion of complete positivity in quantum information theory. Second, we demand that quantum systems are invariant under quantum permutations, i.e. permutations conditioned on values of permutation-invariant observables. For both, we show that the respective principle is fulfilled if and only if the particle is a Boson or Fermion. Our results show how quantum reference frames can shed light on a longstanding problem of quantum physics, they underline the crucial role played by the compositional structure of quantum information, and demonstrate the explanatory power but also subtle limitations of recently proposed quantum covariance principles.
Symmetries and wave functions An important difference between the classical and quantum perspectives is their different criteria of distinguishability. Identical particles are classically distinguishable when separated in phase space. On the other hand, identical particles are always quantum mechanically indistinguishable for the purpose of counting distinct microstates. But these concepts and these distinctions do not tell the whole story of how we count the microstates and determine the multiplicity of a quantized system. There are actually two different ways of counting the accessible microstates of a quantized system of identical, and so indistinguishable, particles. While these two ways were discovered in the years 1924–1926 independently of Erwin Schrödinger’s (1887–1961) invention of wave mechanics in 1926, their most convincing explanation is in terms of particle wave functions. The following two paragraphs may be helpful to those familiar with the basic features of wave mechanics. A system of identical particles has, as one might expect, a probability density that is symmetric under particle exchange, that is, the probability density is invariant under the exchange of two identical particles. But here wave mechanics surprises the classical physicist. A system wave function may either keep the same sign or change signs under particle exchange. In particular, a system wave function may be either symmetric or antisymmetric under particle exchange.
The connection between the exclusion principle and the principle of indistinguishability of identical particles in quantum mechanics is discussed. It is shown with the aid of a density matrix defined for states with arbitrary permutation symmetry that the particles are indistinguishable only for one-dimensional representations of the permutation group (symmetrical and antisymmetrycal), and are distinguishable in all the states that are degenerate in the permutations. It is demonstrated by the same token that the exclusion principle follows from the principle of indistinguishability of identical particles and the Pauli theorem on the connection between spin and statistics.