arXiv:2504.02893 · Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical

Simultaneous optical phase and loss estimation revisited: measurement and probe incompatibility

M. E. O. Bezerra, Francesco Albarelli, Rafał Demkowicz-Dobrzański

Published Jun 16, 2025• 3 citations

Abstract

Abstract Quantum multiparameter metrology is hindered by incompatibility issues, such as finding a single probe state (probe incompatibility) and a single measurement (measurement incompatibility) optimal for all parameters. The simultaneous estimation of phase shift and loss in a single optical mode is a paradigmatic multiparameter metrological problem in which such tradeoffs are present. We consider two settings: single-mode or two-mode probes (with a reference lossless mode), and for each setting we consider either Gaussian states or arbitrary quantum states of light restricted only by a maximal number of photons allowed. We find numerically that, as the number of photons increases, there are quantum states of light for which probe incompatibility disappears both in the single- and two-mode scenarios. On the other hand, for Gaussian states, probe incompatibility is present in the single-mode case and may be removed only in the two-mode setting thanks to the entanglement with the reference mode. Finally, we provide strong arguments that the fundamental incompatibility aspect of the model is measurement incompatibility, which persists for all the scenarios considered, and unlike probe-incompatibility cannot be overcome even in the large photon number limit.

DOI: 10.1088/1751-8121/ade516

Related papers

Multiparameter quantum metrology

Philip J. D. Crowley, Animesh Datta, Marco Barbieri +1 more

Interferometry with quantum light is known to provide enhanced precision for estimating a single phase. However, depending on the parameters involved, the quantum limit for the simultaneous estimation of multiple parameters may not attainable, leading to trade-offs in the attainable precisions. Here we study the simultaneous estimation of two parameters related to optical interferometry: phase and loss, using a fixed number of photons. We derive a trade-off in the estimation of these two parameters which shows that, in contrast to single-parameter estimation, it is impossible to design a strategy saturating the quantum Cramer-Rao bound for loss and phase estimation in a single setup simultaneously. We design optimal quantum states with a fixed number of photons achieving the best possible simultaneous precisions. Our results reveal general features about concurrently estimating Hamiltonian and dissipative parameters, and has implications for sophisticated sensing scenarios such as quantum imaging.

May 31, 201213 citations

Granice wspólnej precyzji i kompatybilność pomiarów w realistycznych fotonicznych czujnikach kwantowych

Jayanth Jayakumar

The sensitivity of a probe to a parameter characterizing a system can be described within the single-parameter estimation framework.In the simplest treatment, the parameter is estimated under ideal conditions, neglecting imperfections from system-environment interactions.More advanced analyses consider estimation in the presence of known environmental noise.Although Heisenberglimited sensitivity is lost, suitably engineered probes can still offer quantum enhancements.When the noise itself is unknown, the estimation problem becomes more complex, requiring a multiparameter approach.Fundamental precision bounds for multiparameter estimation are well established, but their practical attainability remains elusive due to the challenge of constructing measurements with good multiparameter sensitivity.For a given probe, the incompatibility of optimal observables associated with different parameters poses an additional roadblock to achieving simultaneous optimal estimation.In practice, assessing the compatibility of separable measurements is essential, since very often collective strategies that are impractical are required to saturate the bound capturing fundamental incompatibility.To this end, we consider the joint estimation of phase and phase diffusion, introducing quantifiers for information extraction and availability.We find that double homodyne measurement on states generated by the interference of N photons injected into one beamsplitter port yields the highest sensitivity.With respect to measurement compatibility, we study the joint estimation of phase and photon loss, and of phase and phase diffusion.Using the same multiphoton states, we compare double homodyne detection and photon counting against multiparameter precision benchmarks for collective and separable measurements.Among the cases considered, photon counting generally offers better performance for joint phase and loss estimation, while double homodyne still performs reasonably in some regimes for both estimation problems.

Jan 1, 20260 citations

Tradeoff in simultaneous quantum-limited phase and loss estimation in interferometry

Philip J. D. Crowley, Animesh Datta, Marco Barbieri +1 more

Interferometry with quantum light is known to provide enhanced precision for estimating a single phase. However, depending on the parameters involved, the quantum limit for the simultaneous estimation of multiple parameters may not be attainable, leading to tradeoffs in the attainable precisions. Here we study the simultaneous estimation of two parameters related to optical interferometry: phase and loss, using a fixed number of photons. We derive a tradeoff in the estimation of these two parameters which shows that, in contrast to single-parameter estimation, it is impossible to design a strategy saturating the quantum Cram\'er-Rao bound for loss and phase estimation in a single setup simultaneously. We design optimal quantum states with a fixed number of photons achieving the best possible simultaneous precisions. Our results reveal general features about concurrently estimating Hamiltonian and dissipative parameters and have implications for sophisticated sensing scenarios such as quantum imaging.

arXiv:1206.0043Physical Review AFeb 27, 2014141 citations

Multiparameter Gaussian quantum metrology

Rosanna Nichols, Pietro Liuzzo-Scorpo, Paul A. Knott +1 more

We investigate the ultimate precision achievable in Gaussian quantum metrology. We derive general analytical expressions for the quantum Fisher information matrix and for the measurement compatibility condition, ensuring asymptotic saturability of the quantum Cram\'er-Rao bound, for the estimation of multiple parameters encoded in multimode Gaussian states. We then apply our results to the joint estimation of a phase shift and two parameters characterizing Gaussian phase covariant noise in optical interferometry. In such a scheme, we show that two-mode displaced squeezed input probes with optimally tuned squeezing and displacement fulfill the measurement compatibility condition and enable the simultaneous estimation of all three parameters, with an advantage over individual estimation schemes that quickly rises with increasing mean energy of the probes.

arXiv:1711.09132Physical Review AJul 11, 2018130 citations

Minimal Trade-off and Optimal Measurement for Multiparameter Quantum Estimation

Lingna Wang, Hongzhen Chen, Haidong Yuan

A fundamental challenge in multiparameter quantum estimation arises from the incompatibility of optimal measurements for different parameters, leading to intricate precision trade-offs that obscure the understanding of ultimate quantum limits. Here, we present an approach that precisely quantifies these trade-offs for an arbitrary number of parameters encoded in pure quantum states. Our approach not only derives tight analytical bounds for the trade-offs induced by measurement incompatibility but also provides a systematic methodology to design optimal measurement strategies that saturate these limits. To demonstrate the practical significance of our findings, we apply our framework to quantum radar and obtain a refined Arthurs-Kelly relation that characterizes the ultimate performance for the simultaneous estimation of range and velocity with any given amount of entanglement. This showcases the transformative potential of our findings for a wide range of applications in quantum metrology, sensing, and beyond.

quant-pharXiv:2605.23514Physical Review LettersMay 25, 20260 citations

Measurement incompatibility in Bayesian multiparameter quantum estimation

Francesco Albarelli, Dominic Branford, Jesús Rubio

We present a comprehensive and pedagogical formulation of Bayesian multiparameter quantum estimation. Within this framework, we analyse the role of measurement incompatibility and establish its quantitative effect on attainable precision. We achieve this by deriving upper bounds based on the pretty good measurement -- a notion from hypothesis testing -- combined with the evaluation of the Nagaoka-Hayashi lower bound. In general, we prove that, as in the many-copy regime of local estimation theory, incompatibility can at most double the minimum loss relative to the idealised scenario in which individually optimal measurements are assumed jointly implementable. Therefore, in practical situations, the latter may provide a sufficient and computationally efficient benchmark without solving the full optimisation problem. Our results, which we illustrate through applications of discrete phase imaging, phase and dephasing estimation, and qubit sensing, provide analytical and numerical tools for assessing ultimate precision limits and the role of measurement incompatibility in Bayesian multiparameter quantum metrology, including an open-source package for all the bounds discussed here.

quant-pharXiv:2511.16645QuantumNov 21, 20250 citations