In this paper, we explore the potential for quantum annealing to solve realistic routing problems. We focus on two NP-Hard problems, including the Traveling Salesman Problem with Time Windows and the Capacitated Vehicle Routing Problem with Time Windows. We utilize D-Wave's Quantum Annealer and Constrained Quadratic Model (CQM) solver within a hybrid framework to solve these problems. We demonstrate that while the CQM solver effectively minimizes route costs, it struggles to maintain time window feasibility as the problem size increases. To address this limitation, we implement a heuristic method that fixes infeasible solutions through a series of swapping operations. Testing on benchmark instances shows our method achieves promising results with an average optimality gap of 3.86%.
In this paper, we explore the potential for quantum annealing to solve realistic routing problems. We focus on two NP-Hard problems, including the Traveling Salesman Problem with Time Windows and the Capacitated Vehicle Routing Problem with Time Windows. We utilize D-Wave's Quantum Annealer and Constrained Quadratic Model (CQM) solver within a hybrid framework to solve these problems. We demonstrate that while the CQM solver effectively minimizes route costs, it struggles to maintain time window feasibility as the problem size increases. To address this limitation, we implement a heuristic method that fixes infeasible solutions through a series of swapping operations. Testing on benchmark instances shows our method achieves promising results with an average optimality gap of 3.86%.
The Capacitated Vehicle Routing Problem (CVRP) is an NP-optimization problem (NPO) that has been of great interest for decades for both, science and industry. The CVRP is a variant of the vehicle routing problem characterized by capacity constrained vehicles. The aim is to plan tours for vehicles to supply a given number of customers as efficiently as possible. The problem is the combinatorial explosion of possible solutions, which increases superexponentially with the number of customers. Classical solutions provide good approximations to the globally optimal solution. D-Wave's quantum annealer is a machine designed to solve optimization problems. This machine uses quantum effects to speed up computation time compared to classic computers. The problem on solving the CVRP on the quantum annealer is the particular formulation of the optimization problem. For this, it has to be mapped onto a quadratic unconstrained binary optimization (QUBO) problem. Complex optimization problems such as the CVRP can be translated to smaller subproblems and thus enable a sequential solution of the partitioned problem. This work presents a quantum-classic hybrid solution method for the CVRP. It clarifies whether the implemenation of such a method pays off in comparison to existing classical solution methods regarding computation time and solution quality. Several approaches to solving the CVRP are elaborated, the arising problems are discussed, and the results are evaluated in terms of solution quality and computation time.
Quantum computing (QC) is expected to solve incredibly difficult problems, including finding optimal solutions to combinatorial optimization problems. However, to date, QC alone is still far to demonstrate this capability except on small-sized problems. Hybrid approaches where QC and classical computing work together have shown the most potential for solving real-world scale problems. This work aims to show that we can enhance a classical optimization algorithm with QC so that it can overcome this limitation. We present a new hybrid quantum-classical tabu search (HQTS) algorithm to solve the capacitated vehicle routing problem (CVRP). Based on our prior work, HQTS leverages QC for routing within a classical tabu search framework. The quantum component formulates the traveling salesman problem (TSP) for each route as a QUBO, solved using D-Wave's Advantage system. Experiments investigate the impact of quantum routing frequency and starting solution methods. While different starting solution methods, including quantum-based and classical heuristics methods, it shows minimal overall impact. HQTS achieved optimal or near-optimal solutions for several CVRP problems, outperforming other hybrid CVRP algorithms and significantly reducing the optimality gap compared to preliminary research. The experimental results demonstrate that more frequent quantum routing improves solution quality and runtime. The findings highlight the potential of integrating QC within meta-heuristic frameworks for complex optimization in vehicle routing problems.
Quantum computing (QC) is expected to solve incredibly difficult problems, including finding optimal solutions to combinatorial optimization problems. However, to date, QC alone has still been unable to demonstrate this capability except for small-sized problems. Hybrid approaches, where QC and classical computing work together, have shown the most potential for solving real-world-scale problems. This work aims to show that we can enhance a classical optimization algorithm with QC so that it can overcome this limitation. We present a new Hybrid Quantum-classical Tabu Search (HQTS) algorithm to solve the Capacitated Vehicle Routing Problem (CVRP). Based on our prior work, HQTS leverages QC for routing within a classical tabu search framework. The quantum component formulates the Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP) for each route as a Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization (QUBO) and solves it using D-Wave’s Advantage system. Experiments investigate the impact of quantum routing frequency and starting solution methods. Across different starting solution methods, including quantum-based and classical heuristics, it shows minimal overall impact. HQTS achieved optimal or near-optimal solutions for several CVRP problems, outperforming other hybrid CVRP algorithms and significantly reducing the optimality gap relative to preliminary research. The experimental results demonstrate that more frequent quantum routing improves solution quality and runtime. The findings highlight the potential of integrating QC within meta-heuristic frameworks for complex optimization in vehicle routing problems.
Abstract Optimization of pre-production vehicle configurations is one of the challenges in the automotive industry. Given a list of tests requiring cars with certain features, it is desirable to find the minimum number of cars that cover the tests and obey the configuration rules. In this paper, we model the problem in the framework of satisfiability and solve it utilizing the newly introduced hybrid constrained quadratic model (CQM) solver provided by D-Wave. The problem definition is based on the “Optimizing the Production of Test Vehicles” use-case given in the BMW quantum computing challenge. We formulate a constrained quadratic model for the problem and use a greedy algorithm to configure the cars. We benchmark the results obtained from the CQM solver with the results from the classical solvers like coin-or branch and cut and Gurobi solver. We conclude that the performance of the CQM solver is comparable to the classical solvers in optimizing the number of test vehicles, given the noise-prone quantum hardware. However, the CQM solver takes much more time, which prohibits obtaining useful quantum advantages. As an extension to the problem, we describe how the scheduling of the tests can be incorporated into the model.
This study explores Quantum Annealing (QA) versus Classical Computing (CC) approaches in solving the Capacitated Vehicle Routing Problem with Time Windows (CVRPTW), using real-world logistics data from Siemens Advanta. By modeling the problem as a Service Network Design (SND) with binary variables and framing CVRPTW within a quantum mechanical paradigm suitable for QA, this approach leverages quantum annealing in a novel manner to tackle the complex optimization challenges inherent in the VRP. Contrasting it with the performance of the traditional branch and cut solver---a specific CC technique---this research unveils the prospective benefits and existing challenges of QA in complex optimization scenarios, thereby emphasizing the need for advancing quantum computing.
Quantum computing (QC) stands at the cusp of revolutionizing computation, yet its near-term potential, constrained by Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) devices, remains underexplored. This dissertation investigates how hybrid quantum-classical algorithms can address combinatorial optimization challenges in logistics, focusing on vehicle routing and drone delivery—NP-hard problems with exponential solution spaces that defy classical exhaustive methods. Amidst NISQ limitations like limited qubits and high noise, we confront key challenges: encoding complex constraints, e.g., time windows, battery capacity, into quantum models, balancing quantum and classical components for scalability, and accessing scarce quantum resources. By integrating quantum annealing (QA) and the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) with classical heuristics, this work demonstrates QC’s practical utility, advancing both optimization theory and real-world logistics applications. The dissertation unfolds across four core contributions. First, the Hybrid Quantum Tabu Search (HQTS) optimally solves the 50-location Capacitated Vehicle Routing Problem (CVRP), achieving a 4.72% optimality gap. Secondly, we refine HQTS to reach a 2.15% gap with enhanced QA utilization, outperforming prior hybrids on standard datasets. Third, adapting HQTS for the CVRPTWwith D-Wave’s Constrained Quadratic Model solver yields a 3.85% gap on 100-location instances, leveraging a novel heuristic to ensure time-window feasibility where quantum outputs falter. Lastly, QUADRO, a pioneering framework for drone delivery, employs QAOA-driven routing and hybrid scheduling, minimizing transit time and makespan for fleets of 2–11 drones needing fewer than 100 qubits, rivaling classical benchmarks on adapted Augerat datasets. These advances, tested via D-Wave’s Advantage system and Qiskit simulations, showcase hybrid strategies that mitigate NISQ constraints, delivering scalable, feasible solutions to logistics challenges. This work establishes near-term QC’s viability for combinatorial optimization, bridging theoretical promise with practical impact. Synthesizing quantum exploration with classical refinement achieves competitive performance, e.g., matching or surpassing Google ORTools in select CVRPTW cases, while illuminating NISQ limits, such as feasibility degradation beyond small scales. These hybrid strategies deliver scalable, feasible solutions, from a 2.15% optimality gap for CVRP to effective drone fleet management with fewer than 100 qubits, illuminating quantum computing’s potential despite its current constraints. Ultimately, this dissertation positions hybrid QC as a transformative tool for optimization challenges, offering a robust foundation for scaling quantum optimization into operational reality.