Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2503.12614 · npj Quantum Information

Virtual purification complements quantum error correction in quantum metrology

Hyukgun Kwon, Changhun Oh, Youngrong Lim, Hyunseok Jeong, Seung-Woo Lee, Liang Jiang

Published Apr 9, 2026• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum resources enable one to achieve quantum-enhanced estimation sensitivity beyond its classical counterpart. Many studies mainly focus on reducing statistical error, under the assumption that one can always set an unbiased estimator. However, setting an unbiased estimator is not always feasible, especially when one cannot fully characterize noise. Such incomplete noise characterization induces a bias and eventually makes it impossible to attain the enhanced-estimation. In this work, we explore two systematic approaches; quantum error correction (QEC) and the virtual purification (VP) to reduce the bias, and compare their performance. First, we show that when the noise is indistinguishable from the signal, QEC cannot reduce the bias since it is impossible to construct a QEC code that corrects the noise while preserving the signal. We then show that VP can mitigate indistinguishable error that eventually enable a more accurate estimation compared to QEC. Our findings reveal that VP offers a robust alternative to QEC in scenarios where indistinguishable errors pose significant challenges. We then demonstrate that VP with a stabilizer state probe can efficiently suppress the bias under local depolarizing noise, thereby yielding a significant improvement in estimation performance compared to the QEC-based approach.

DOI
10.1038/s41534-026-01231-0

Related papers

Complementing Quantum Error Correction in Quantum Metrology via Swap Test

Xiaodie Lin, Linxuan Li, Haidong Yuan

The precision and sensitivity achievable in quantum metrology are often compromised by the presence of noise. While quantum error correction has emerged as a promising strategy, it is ineffective in addressing noise that is indistinguishable from the signal. To address this challenge, virtual state purification was introduced as a complementary approach to quantum error correction. However, significant noise accumulation can impede its performance. To overcome this limitation, we propose a swap test-based method specifically designed to address indistinguishable noise, even under high noise levels. A systematic error-scaling analysis demonstrates that this method enables quantum-enhanced precision in certain scenarios. Furthermore, numerical simulations demonstrate that our method surpasses virtual state purification in both single- and multi-parameter estimation tasks. The significant improvements in precision across diverse settings underscore the robustness and practicality of our method for real-world applications.

quant-pharXiv:2605.23792•May 25, 2026•0 citations

Efficacy of virtual purification-based error mitigation on quantum metrology

Hyukgun Kwon, Changhun Oh, Youngrong Lim +2 more

Noise is the main source that hinders us from fully exploiting quantum advantages in various quantum informational tasks. However, characterizing and calibrating the effect of noise is not always feasible in practice. Especially for quantum parameter estimation, an estimator constructed without precise knowledge of noise entails an inevitable bias. Recently, virtual purification-based error mitigation (VPEM) has been proposed to apply for quantum metrology to reduce such a bias occurring from unknown noise. While it was demonstrated to work for particular cases, whether VPEM always reduces a bias for general estimation schemes is unclear. For more general applications of VPEM to quantum metrology, we study factors determining whether VPEM can reduce the bias. We find that the closeness between the dominant eigenvector of a noisy state and the ideal quantum probe (without noise) with respect to an observable determines the reducible amount of bias by VPEM. Next, we show that one should carefully choose the reference point of the target parameter, which gives a smaller bias than others because the bias depends on the reference point. Otherwise, even if the dominant eigenvector and the ideal quantum probe are close, the bias of the mitigated case could be larger than the nonmitigated one. Finally, we analyze the error mitigation for a phase estimation scheme under various noises. Based on our analysis, we predict whether VPEM can effectively reduce a bias and numerically verify our results.

arXiv:2303.15838•Physical Review A•Feb 7, 2024•7 citations

Error-mitigated quantum metrology via enhanced virtual purification

Xiaodie Lin, Haidong Yuan

Abstract Quantum metrology stands as a leading application of quantum science and technology, yet noise often constrains its precision and sensitivity. In near-term quantum metrology, existing protocols largely depend on virtual state purification, but significant noise accumulation and additional noise from the implementations of these protocols can impede their effectiveness. We propose enhanced virtual channel purification to address these problems, yielding enhanced virtual state purification as a by-product. Within sequential quantum metrology schemes, our error analysis reveals substantial bias reduction and quantum advantages in sampling cost when the number of encoding channels is $${\mathcal{O}}({p}^{-1})$$ O ( p − 1 ) , where p represents the error rate of encoding channels. In this range, our methods demonstrate significant improvements in parameter estimation precision and robustness against practical noise, as evidenced by numerical simulations for both single- and multi-parameter tasks. Particularly, these methods can naturally extend beyond quantum metrology, indicating their broad applicability in quantum information and quantum computation.

arXiv:2506.07618•Communications Physics•Nov 26, 2025•3 citations

Hybrid Quantum Error Correction and Mitigation by Purification

Jonathan Raghoonanan, Tim Byrnes

Quantum error correction physically removes errors from a quantum state, while quantum error mitigation improves observable estimates by processing noisy measurement data. We introduce \emph{purification quantum error suppression} (PQES), a hybrid approach that uses multiple noisy copies of an unknown state to combine these two ideas. The protocol uses SWAP tests to physically reduce errors by purification, while the full outcome record is used to combine all branches without postselection. In this way, PQES avoids the fixed-success-outcome requirement of standard SWAP-test purification while still accessing the power-purified state $ρ^N$. The SWAP identities allow purification steps to be interleaved with unitary circuit blocks, so errors can be suppressed during a computation rather than only at the final measurement. We provide both a parallel binary-tree implementation and a more compact register-recycled implementation using $O(M\ell)$ coherent data qubits for an $M$-qubit register and $N=2^\ell$ input copies. We analyze the resulting error thresholds under representative noise models. For local depolarizing noise on the product-state family studied here, the threshold is $p_{\mathrm{th}}=3/4$ for any register size, while local dephasing of $|+\rangle^{\otimes M}$ has a threshold of $p_{\mathrm{th}}=1/2$. Local Clifford twirling can be used to convert dephasing into a depolarization channel and restore the higher threshold.

quant-pharXiv:2603.11568•Mar 13, 2026•0 citations

Noise-Symmetry Optimization of Quantum Error-Corrected Metrology

Shuyun Su, Shengshi Pang

Quantum error correction (QEC) codes have emerged as a powerful tool to protect quantum-enhanced metrology against noise. However, the ability to correct errors alone does not guarantee high metrological sensitivity, as the encoded states may become insensitive to the parameter of interest. Here we show that this limitation can be overcome by exploiting an intrinsic freedom of QEC codes: for a fixed set of correctable errors, the Knill-Laflamme conditions admit an equivalence class of encodings. When the correctable noise possesses unitary symmetries, these symmetries generate continuous transformations within this class, allowing systematic optimization of the encoding to increase the quantum Fisher information while preserving the correctable set of noise. Based on this observation, we develop a symmetry-based optimization approach and derive criteria identifying when such optimization can enhance metrological sensitivity. In particular, for stabilizer-sum Hamiltonians, symmetry optimization can convert a code with vanishing QFI into one achieving the standard quantum limit in general or even Heisenberg scaling in specific cases, illustrating the power of symmetry optimization for QEC-assisted quantum metrology.

quant-pharXiv:2608.21842•Physical Review Letters•Aug 25, 2026•0 citations

Error-Mitigated Quantum Metrology via Virtual Purification

Kaoru Yamamoto, Suguru Endo, Hideaki Hakoshima +2 more

Quantum metrology with entangled resources aims to achieve sensitivity beyond the standard quantum limit by harnessing quantum effects even in the presence of environmental noise. So far, sensitivity has been mainly discussed from the viewpoint of reducing statistical errors under the assumption of perfect knowledge of a noise model. However, we cannot always obtain complete information about a noise model due to coherence time fluctuations, which are frequently observed in experiments. Such unknown fluctuating noise leads to systematic errors and nullifies the quantum advantages. Here, we propose an error-mitigated quantum metrology that can filter out unknown fluctuating noise with the aid of purification-based quantum error mitigation. We demonstrate that our protocol mitigates systematic errors and recovers superclassical scaling in a practical situation with time-inhomogeneous bias-inducing noise. Our result is the first demonstration to reveal the usefulness of purification-based error mitigation for unknown fluctuating noise, thus paving the way not only for practical quantum metrology but also for quantum computation affected by such noise.

arXiv:2112.01850•Physical Review Letters•Dec 16, 2022•52 citations
Quantum resources enable one to achieve quantum-enhanced estimation sensitivity beyond its classical counterpart. Many studies mainly focus on reducing statistical error, under the assumption that one can always set an unbiased estimator. However, setting an unbiased estimator is not always feasible, especially when one cannot fully characterize noise. Such incomplete noise characterization induces a bias and eventually makes it impossible to attain the enhanced-estimation. In this work, we explore two systematic approaches; quantum error correction (QEC) and the virtual purification (VP) to reduce the bias, and compare their performance. First, we show that when the noise is indistinguishable from the signal, QEC cannot reduce the bias since it is impossible to construct a QEC code that corrects the noise while preserving the signal. We then show that VP can mitigate indistinguishable error that eventually enable a more accurate estimation compared to QEC. Our findings reveal that VP offers a robust alternative to QEC in scenarios where indistinguishable errors pose significant challenges. We then demonstrate that VP with a stabilizer state probe can efficiently suppress the bias under local depolarizing noise, thereby yielding a significant improvement in estimation performance compared to the QEC-based approach.
The precision and sensitivity achievable in quantum metrology are often compromised by the presence of noise. While quantum error correction has emerged as a promising strategy, it is ineffective in addressing noise that is indistinguishable from the signal. To address this challenge, virtual state purification was introduced as a complementary approach to quantum error correction. However, significant noise accumulation can impede its performance. To overcome this limitation, we propose a swap test-based method specifically designed to address indistinguishable noise, even under high noise levels. A systematic error-scaling analysis demonstrates that this method enables quantum-enhanced precision in certain scenarios. Furthermore, numerical simulations demonstrate that our method surpasses virtual state purification in both single- and multi-parameter estimation tasks. The significant improvements in precision across diverse settings underscore the robustness and practicality of our method for real-world applications.
Noise is the main source that hinders us from fully exploiting quantum advantages in various quantum informational tasks. However, characterizing and calibrating the effect of noise is not always feasible in practice. Especially for quantum parameter estimation, an estimator constructed without precise knowledge of noise entails an inevitable bias. Recently, virtual purification-based error mitigation (VPEM) has been proposed to apply for quantum metrology to reduce such a bias occurring from unknown noise. While it was demonstrated to work for particular cases, whether VPEM always reduces a bias for general estimation schemes is unclear. For more general applications of VPEM to quantum metrology, we study factors determining whether VPEM can reduce the bias. We find that the closeness between the dominant eigenvector of a noisy state and the ideal quantum probe (without noise) with respect to an observable determines the reducible amount of bias by VPEM. Next, we show that one should carefully choose the reference point of the target parameter, which gives a smaller bias than others because the bias depends on the reference point. Otherwise, even if the dominant eigenvector and the ideal quantum probe are close, the bias of the mitigated case could be larger than the nonmitigated one. Finally, we analyze the error mitigation for a phase estimation scheme under various noises. Based on our analysis, we predict whether VPEM can effectively reduce a bias and numerically verify our results.
Abstract Quantum metrology stands as a leading application of quantum science and technology, yet noise often constrains its precision and sensitivity. In near-term quantum metrology, existing protocols largely depend on virtual state purification, but significant noise accumulation and additional noise from the implementations of these protocols can impede their effectiveness. We propose enhanced virtual channel purification to address these problems, yielding enhanced virtual state purification as a by-product. Within sequential quantum metrology schemes, our error analysis reveals substantial bias reduction and quantum advantages in sampling cost when the number of encoding channels is O(p−1){\mathcal{O}}({p}^{-1})O(p−1) O ( p − 1 ) , where p represents the error rate of encoding channels. In this range, our methods demonstrate significant improvements in parameter estimation precision and robustness against practical noise, as evidenced by numerical simulations for both single- and multi-parameter tasks. Particularly, these methods can naturally extend beyond quantum metrology, indicating their broad applicability in quantum information and quantum computation.
Quantum error correction physically removes errors from a quantum state, while quantum error mitigation improves observable estimates by processing noisy measurement data. We introduce \emph{purification quantum error suppression} (PQES), a hybrid approach that uses multiple noisy copies of an unknown state to combine these two ideas. The protocol uses SWAP tests to physically reduce errors by purification, while the full outcome record is used to combine all branches without postselection. In this way, PQES avoids the fixed-success-outcome requirement of standard SWAP-test purification while still accessing the power-purified state ρNρ^NρN. The SWAP identities allow purification steps to be interleaved with unitary circuit blocks, so errors can be suppressed during a computation rather than only at the final measurement. We provide both a parallel binary-tree implementation and a more compact register-recycled implementation using O(Mℓ)O(M\ell)O(Mℓ) coherent data qubits for an MMM-qubit register and N=2ℓN=2^\ellN=2ℓ input copies. We analyze the resulting error thresholds under representative noise models. For local depolarizing noise on the product-state family studied here, the threshold is pth=3/4p_{\mathrm{th}}=3/4pth​=3/4 for any register size, while local dephasing of ∣+⟩⊗M|+\rangle^{\otimes M}∣+⟩⊗M has a threshold of pth=1/2p_{\mathrm{th}}=1/2pth​=1/2. Local Clifford twirling can be used to convert dephasing into a depolarization channel and restore the higher threshold.
Quantum error correction (QEC) codes have emerged as a powerful tool to protect quantum-enhanced metrology against noise. However, the ability to correct errors alone does not guarantee high metrological sensitivity, as the encoded states may become insensitive to the parameter of interest. Here we show that this limitation can be overcome by exploiting an intrinsic freedom of QEC codes: for a fixed set of correctable errors, the Knill-Laflamme conditions admit an equivalence class of encodings. When the correctable noise possesses unitary symmetries, these symmetries generate continuous transformations within this class, allowing systematic optimization of the encoding to increase the quantum Fisher information while preserving the correctable set of noise. Based on this observation, we develop a symmetry-based optimization approach and derive criteria identifying when such optimization can enhance metrological sensitivity. In particular, for stabilizer-sum Hamiltonians, symmetry optimization can convert a code with vanishing QFI into one achieving the standard quantum limit in general or even Heisenberg scaling in specific cases, illustrating the power of symmetry optimization for QEC-assisted quantum metrology.
Quantum metrology with entangled resources aims to achieve sensitivity beyond the standard quantum limit by harnessing quantum effects even in the presence of environmental noise. So far, sensitivity has been mainly discussed from the viewpoint of reducing statistical errors under the assumption of perfect knowledge of a noise model. However, we cannot always obtain complete information about a noise model due to coherence time fluctuations, which are frequently observed in experiments. Such unknown fluctuating noise leads to systematic errors and nullifies the quantum advantages. Here, we propose an error-mitigated quantum metrology that can filter out unknown fluctuating noise with the aid of purification-based quantum error mitigation. We demonstrate that our protocol mitigates systematic errors and recovers superclassical scaling in a practical situation with time-inhomogeneous bias-inducing noise. Our result is the first demonstration to reveal the usefulness of purification-based error mitigation for unknown fluctuating noise, thus paving the way not only for practical quantum metrology but also for quantum computation affected by such noise.