Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2502.00823 · neural information processing systems

Online Learning of Pure States is as Hard as Mixed States

Maxime Meyer, Soumik Adhikary, Naixu Guo, Patrick Rebentrost

Published Jan 1, 2025• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum state tomography, the task of learning an unknown quantum state, is a fundamental problem in quantum information.In standard settings, the complexity of this problem depends significantly on the type of quantum state that one is trying to learn, with pure states being substantially easier to learn than general mixed states.A natural question is whether this separation holds for any quantum state learning setting.In this work, we consider the online learning framework and prove the surprising result that learning pure states in this setting is as hard as learning mixed states.More specifically, we show that both classes share almost the same sequential fat-shattering dimension, leading to identical regret scaling.We also generalize previous results on full quantum state tomography in the online setting to (i) the ϵ-realizable setting and (ii) learning the density matrix only partially, using smoothed analysis.However, for many practical problems, such as certification of a quantum device [Gross et al.,

DOI
10.52202/085713-4497

Related papers

Online learning of quantum states*

Scott Aaronson, Xinyi Chen, Elad Hazan +2 more

Abstract Suppose we have many copies of an unknown n -qubit state . We measure some copies of using a known two-outcome measurement E 1 , then other copies using a measurement E 2 , and so on. At each stage t , we generate a current hypothesis about the state , using the outcomes of the previous measurements. We show that it is possible to do this in a way that guarantees that , the error in our prediction for the next measurement, is at least at most times. Even in the ‘non-realizable’ setting—where there could be arbitrary noise in the measurement outcomes—we show how to output hypothesis states that incur at most excess loss over the best possible state on the first T measurements. These results generalize a 2007 theorem by Aaronson on the PAC-learnability of quantum states, to the online and regret-minimization settings. We give three different ways to prove our results—using convex optimization, quantum postselection, and sequential fat-shattering dimension—which have different advantages in terms of parameters and portability.

arXiv:1802.09025•Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment•Dec 1, 2019•67 citations

Regret Lower Bound for Online Learning of Quantum States with Logarithmic Loss, with Applications to Quantum State Tomography and Confidence Sequences for Matrix Means

Yen-Huan Li, Wei-Fu Tseng

We study the problem of online learning of quantum states with logarithmic loss, which is a quantum generalization of online portfolio selection and has applications to quantum state tomography, the task of estimating an unknown quantum state from measurement outcomes. We first establish a regret lower bound, showing that the regret rates of Exponential Weights and the algorithm of Tseng et al. (2025) have optimal polynomial dependence on the dimension. Our analysis leads to two further results. First, our lower-bound proof leads to a quantum state tomography algorithm that is sample optimal up to polylogarithmic factors in the sample size. Second, we develop an algorithm for constructing confidence sequences for the mean of a matrix-valued random variable. A numerical experiment shows that the latter algorithm is competitive with existing methods.

cs.LGCross-listedarXiv:2610.21273•Oct 16, 2026•0 citations

Learning pure quantum states almost without regret

Josep Lumbreras, Mikhail V. Terekhov, Marco Tomamichel

We initiate the study of sample-optimal quantum state tomography with minimal disturbance to the samples. Can we efficiently learn a precise description of a quantum state through sequential measurements of samples while at the same time ensuring that the post-measurement states are only minimally perturbed? We quantify the accumulated cost of the protocol over T samples by an additive regret objective, which controls the cumulative expected post-measurement infidelity of the consumed copies. The challenge is to balance informative measurements with measurements that keep this accumulated cost small. Here, we answer this question for all pure states by exhibiting an adaptive protocol whose expected regret is \(O({d}^{3}{\log }^{2}T)\) , while the infidelity of the online estimate after t samples scales as \(\widetilde{O}(1/t)\) . We also prove a logarithmic lower bound, showing that for fixed dimension, the dependence on the number of samples is optimal up to one logarithmic factor.

arXiv:2406.18370•npj Quantum Information•Jun 26, 2026•14 citations

Online learning of quantum states under structure

Akshay Bansal, Jiahui Liu

Quantum state tomography is fundamental to quantum information processing but becomes infeasible at scale due to the exponential growth of the state space. Shadow tomography alleviates this challenge by focusing on predicting measurement outcomes rather than reconstructing the full state. Its online variant models adaptive and potentially adversarial measurement scenarios, where a learner sequentially predicts outcomes while competing with the best fixed quantum state in hindsight. We show that exploiting additional structure in the measurements leads to significantly stronger regret guarantees. In particular, under the assumption that the adversarial measurements have bounded Frobenius norm, we analyze online mirror descent and derive optimal regret bounds that depend on intrinsic structural properties, such as rank or sparsity in the standard basis, rather than the dimension of the measurement operators. As a complementary result, we also show that, even in the setting where adversarial measurements are known to be sparse in the Pauli basis commonly used in variational quantum eigensolvers and near-term quantum error mitigation, the underlying regret bound for learning quantum states is the same as that obtained in the generic setting, where the adversarial measurements are not known to possess any particular structure.

quant-pharXiv:2608.05740•Aug 7, 2026•0 citations

Learning Pure Quantum States in Any Dimension (Almost) Without Regret

Josep Lumbreras, Marco Tomamichel

We extend quantum state tomography with minimal cumulative disturbance, first investigated in [arXiv:2406.18370], to arbitrary finite-dimensional pure states. A learner sequentially receives fresh copies of an unknown pure state, chooses a rank-one projector for each copy using the previous outcomes, and performs the corresponding two-outcome projective measurement. The goal is to learn the state while keeping the chosen projectors close to the unknown state in order to minimize disturbance. The qubit solution relies on the special geometry of the Bloch sphere and does not extend directly to qudits, where pure states form a curved manifold. We show that this obstruction can be overcome by working locally on the pure-state manifold. The algorithm proceeds in epochs. In each epoch, it fixes a current estimate, measures pairs of nearby rank-one projectors obtained by moving in opposite tangent directions, and takes differences of the corresponding outcomes. This gives an exact linear observation of the tangent component of the error. The resulting local linear models are combined with a robust variance-adaptive estimator and a hot-start regularization that transfers precision across epochs. For every unknown pure state in dimension \(d\), after \(T\) measured copies, our protocol achieves cumulative regret \(\mathcal{O}(d^3\log^2 T)\), and at each intermediate time \(t\leq T\) its current estimate has online infidelity \(\mathcal{O}(d^3\log(T)/t)\). Hence, pure-state tomography with essentially no cumulative disturbance is not a peculiarity of qubits but a geometric phenomenon that persists for qudits.

quant-pharXiv:2605.09019•May 12, 2026•1 citation

Revisiting Online Quantum State Learning

Feidiao Yang, Jiaqing Jiang, Jialin Zhang +1 more

In this paper, we study the online quantum state learning problem which is recently proposed by Aaronson et al. (2018). In this problem, the learning algorithm sequentially predicts quantum states based on observed measurements and losses and the goal is to minimize the regret. In the previous work, the existing algorithms may output mixed quantum states. However, in many scenarios, the prediction of a pure quantum state is required. In this paper, we first propose a Follow-the-Perturbed-Leader (FTPL) algorithm that can guarantee to predict pure quantum states. Theoretical analysis shows that our algorithm can achieve an O(√T) expected regret under some reasonable settings. In the case that the pure state prediction is not mandatory, we propose another deterministic learning algorithm which is simpler and more efficient. The algorithm is based on the online gradient descent (OGD) method and can also achieve an O(√T) regret bound. The main technical contribution of this result is an algorithm of projecting an arbitrary Hermitian matrix onto the set of density matrices with respect to the Frobenius norm. We think this subroutine is of independent interest and can be widely used in many other problems in the quantum computing area. In addition to the theoretical analysis, we evaluate the algorithms with a series of simulation experiments. The experimental results show that our FTPL method and OGD method outperform the existing RFTL approach proposed by Aaronson et al. (2018) in almost all settings. In the implementation of the RFTL approach, we give a closed-form solution to the algorithm. This provides an efficient, accurate, and completely executable solution to the RFTL method.

Proceedings of the AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence•Apr 3, 2020•8 citations
Quantum state tomography, the task of learning an unknown quantum state, is a fundamental problem in quantum information.In standard settings, the complexity of this problem depends significantly on the type of quantum state that one is trying to learn, with pure states being substantially easier to learn than general mixed states.A natural question is whether this separation holds for any quantum state learning setting.In this work, we consider the online learning framework and prove the surprising result that learning pure states in this setting is as hard as learning mixed states.More specifically, we show that both classes share almost the same sequential fat-shattering dimension, leading to identical regret scaling.We also generalize previous results on full quantum state tomography in the online setting to (i) the ϵ-realizable setting and (ii) learning the density matrix only partially, using smoothed analysis.However, for many practical problems, such as certification of a quantum device [Gross et al.,
Abstract Suppose we have many copies of an unknown n -qubit state . We measure some copies of using a known two-outcome measurement E 1 , then other copies using a measurement E 2 , and so on. At each stage t , we generate a current hypothesis about the state , using the outcomes of the previous measurements. We show that it is possible to do this in a way that guarantees that , the error in our prediction for the next measurement, is at least at most times. Even in the ‘non-realizable’ setting—where there could be arbitrary noise in the measurement outcomes—we show how to output hypothesis states that incur at most excess loss over the best possible state on the first T measurements. These results generalize a 2007 theorem by Aaronson on the PAC-learnability of quantum states, to the online and regret-minimization settings. We give three different ways to prove our results—using convex optimization, quantum postselection, and sequential fat-shattering dimension—which have different advantages in terms of parameters and portability.
We study the problem of online learning of quantum states with logarithmic loss, which is a quantum generalization of online portfolio selection and has applications to quantum state tomography, the task of estimating an unknown quantum state from measurement outcomes. We first establish a regret lower bound, showing that the regret rates of Exponential Weights and the algorithm of Tseng et al. (2025) have optimal polynomial dependence on the dimension. Our analysis leads to two further results. First, our lower-bound proof leads to a quantum state tomography algorithm that is sample optimal up to polylogarithmic factors in the sample size. Second, we develop an algorithm for constructing confidence sequences for the mean of a matrix-valued random variable. A numerical experiment shows that the latter algorithm is competitive with existing methods.
We initiate the study of sample-optimal quantum state tomography with minimal disturbance to the samples. Can we efficiently learn a precise description of a quantum state through sequential measurements of samples while at the same time ensuring that the post-measurement states are only minimally perturbed? We quantify the accumulated cost of the protocol over T samples by an additive regret objective, which controls the cumulative expected post-measurement infidelity of the consumed copies. The challenge is to balance informative measurements with measurements that keep this accumulated cost small. Here, we answer this question for all pure states by exhibiting an adaptive protocol whose expected regret is O(d3log⁡2T)O({d}^{3}{\log }^{2}T)O(d3log2T) , while the infidelity of the online estimate after t samples scales as O~(1/t)\widetilde{O}(1/t)O(1/t) . We also prove a logarithmic lower bound, showing that for fixed dimension, the dependence on the number of samples is optimal up to one logarithmic factor.
Quantum state tomography is fundamental to quantum information processing but becomes infeasible at scale due to the exponential growth of the state space. Shadow tomography alleviates this challenge by focusing on predicting measurement outcomes rather than reconstructing the full state. Its online variant models adaptive and potentially adversarial measurement scenarios, where a learner sequentially predicts outcomes while competing with the best fixed quantum state in hindsight. We show that exploiting additional structure in the measurements leads to significantly stronger regret guarantees. In particular, under the assumption that the adversarial measurements have bounded Frobenius norm, we analyze online mirror descent and derive optimal regret bounds that depend on intrinsic structural properties, such as rank or sparsity in the standard basis, rather than the dimension of the measurement operators. As a complementary result, we also show that, even in the setting where adversarial measurements are known to be sparse in the Pauli basis commonly used in variational quantum eigensolvers and near-term quantum error mitigation, the underlying regret bound for learning quantum states is the same as that obtained in the generic setting, where the adversarial measurements are not known to possess any particular structure.
We extend quantum state tomography with minimal cumulative disturbance, first investigated in [arXiv:2406.18370], to arbitrary finite-dimensional pure states. A learner sequentially receives fresh copies of an unknown pure state, chooses a rank-one projector for each copy using the previous outcomes, and performs the corresponding two-outcome projective measurement. The goal is to learn the state while keeping the chosen projectors close to the unknown state in order to minimize disturbance. The qubit solution relies on the special geometry of the Bloch sphere and does not extend directly to qudits, where pure states form a curved manifold. We show that this obstruction can be overcome by working locally on the pure-state manifold. The algorithm proceeds in epochs. In each epoch, it fixes a current estimate, measures pairs of nearby rank-one projectors obtained by moving in opposite tangent directions, and takes differences of the corresponding outcomes. This gives an exact linear observation of the tangent component of the error. The resulting local linear models are combined with a robust variance-adaptive estimator and a hot-start regularization that transfers precision across epochs. For every unknown pure state in dimension ddd, after TTT measured copies, our protocol achieves cumulative regret O(d3log⁡2T)\mathcal{O}(d^3\log^2 T)O(d3log2T), and at each intermediate time t≤Tt\leq Tt≤T its current estimate has online infidelity O(d3log⁡(T)/t)\mathcal{O}(d^3\log(T)/t)O(d3log(T)/t). Hence, pure-state tomography with essentially no cumulative disturbance is not a peculiarity of qubits but a geometric phenomenon that persists for qudits.
In this paper, we study the online quantum state learning problem which is recently proposed by Aaronson et al. (2018). In this problem, the learning algorithm sequentially predicts quantum states based on observed measurements and losses and the goal is to minimize the regret. In the previous work, the existing algorithms may output mixed quantum states. However, in many scenarios, the prediction of a pure quantum state is required. In this paper, we first propose a Follow-the-Perturbed-Leader (FTPL) algorithm that can guarantee to predict pure quantum states. Theoretical analysis shows that our algorithm can achieve an O(√T) expected regret under some reasonable settings. In the case that the pure state prediction is not mandatory, we propose another deterministic learning algorithm which is simpler and more efficient. The algorithm is based on the online gradient descent (OGD) method and can also achieve an O(√T) regret bound. The main technical contribution of this result is an algorithm of projecting an arbitrary Hermitian matrix onto the set of density matrices with respect to the Frobenius norm. We think this subroutine is of independent interest and can be widely used in many other problems in the quantum computing area. In addition to the theoretical analysis, we evaluate the algorithms with a series of simulation experiments. The experimental results show that our FTPL method and OGD method outperform the existing RFTL approach proposed by Aaronson et al. (2018) in almost all settings. In the implementation of the RFTL approach, we give a closed-form solution to the algorithm. This provides an efficient, accurate, and completely executable solution to the RFTL method.