arXiv:2501.19269 · Classical and Quantum Gravity

Information metrics and possible limitations of local information objectivity in quantum gravity

Per Berglund, Andrew A. Geraci, Tristan Hübsch, David Mattingly, Djordje Minić

Published Jun 23, 2026• 0 citations

Abstract

Abstract Local information objectivity, that local, independent observers can infer the same information about a model upon exchange of independently acquired experimental data, is fundamental to science. It is mathematically encoded via Čencov’s theorem: the Fisher information metric is the unique metric invariant under the assumptions of independent, identically distributed sampling and sufficient statistics. However, quantum gravity typically violates these assumptions, permitting contextual deviations from the Fisher metric that reflect the dynamical experimental and environmental configurations. This yields a possible extension of spacetime general covariance to information geometry. Since compatibility with the metric on probability spaces heavily restricts the form of the Born rule for quantum mechanics, deviations from the Fisher metric also can induce modifications of the Born rule, leading it to vary between observers. We explain some possible variations, advocate for experimental tests, and suggest a new quantum gravity approach based on generally covariant information geometry.

DOI: 10.1088/1361-6382/ae811a

Related papers

Physical limits on information metrics and quantum gravity as gravitized quantum theory

Per Berglund, Andrew A. Geraci, Tristan Hübsch +2 more

There is a long history in both general relativity and quantum mechanics of removing fixed background structures, thereby making observed objects and measurement processes dynamical. We continue this evolution by combining central insights from both theories to argue that physical limits on information collection resulting from quantum gravity coupled with general covariance preclude the fixed information geometry still assumed in both information theory and quantum mechanics. As a consequence there must be a gravitized, generally covariant extension of both theories. We also propose a novel experimental test involving intrinsic triple and higher-order quantum interferences that would provide evidence for dynamical information metrics and a dynamical Born rule.

arXiv:2504.12925International Journal of Modern Physics DJul 18, 20251 citation

Failures of information geometry

John Skilling

Information H is a unique relationship between probabilities, based on the property of independence which is central to scientific methodology. Information Geometry makes the tempting but fallacious assumption that a local metric (conventionally based on information) can be used to endow the space of probability distributions with a preferred global Riemannian metric. No such global metric can conform to H, which is “from-to” asymmetric whereas geometrical length is by definition symmetric. Accordingly, any Riemannian metric will contradict the required structure of the very distributions which are supposedly being triangulated. It follows that probabilities do not form a metric space. We give counter-examples in which alternative formulations of information, and the use of information geometry, lead to unacceptable results.

AIP conference proceedingsJan 1, 20150 citations

Quantum Gravity Without Metric Quantization: From Hidden Variables to Hidden Spacetime Curvatures

Mohamed Hatifi

Bohmian mechanics offers a deterministic alternative to conventional quantum theory through well-defined particle trajectories. While successful in nonrelativistic contexts, its extension to curved spacetime-and hence quantum gravity-remains unresolved. Here, we develop a covariant extension of Bohmian mechanics in curved spacetime that removes the need for metric quantization. From a Lagrangian formulation, we derive a generalized guidance equation in which Bohmian trajectories generate hidden curvature, replacing metric superposition with a statistical ensemble constrained by Heisenberg uncertainty, offering a novel perspective on quantum gravity. Consequently, in our approach, measuring the gravitational potential at a point unveils a pre-existing trajectory and its associated curvature-a departure from the observer-centric paradigm of standard quantum mechanics-providing an alternative in which gravitational effects emerge from deterministic quantum trajectories rather than wavefunction collapse. Numerical simulations in Robertson-Walker and cigar soliton spacetimes reveal that while quantum interference is curvature-sensitive, Zitterbewegung remains invariant, distinguishing fundamental quantum effects. Moreover, deviations from the Born rule in inhomogeneous spacetimes are observed and suggest gravity-induced quantum non-equilibrium. This new approach has far-reaching implications for the role of determinism and potential observational signatures of quantum non-equilibrium in cosmology.

arXiv:2502.08421Feb 12, 20251 citation

A new information metric and a possible higher bound for a class of measurements in the Quantum Estimation Problem

Demetris P. K. Ghikas, Fotios D. Oikonomou

Information metrics give lower bounds for the estimation of parameters. The Cencov-Morozova-Petz Theorem classifies the monotone quantum Fisher metrics. The optimum bound for the quantum estimation problem is offered by the metric which is obtained from the symmetric logarithmic derivative. To get a better bound, it means to go outside this family of metrics, and thus inevitably, to relax some general conditions. In the paper we defined logarithmic derivatives through a phase-space correspondence. This introduces a function which quantifies the deviation from the symmetric derivative. Using this function we have proved that there exist POVMs for which the new metric gives a higher bound from that of the symmetric derivative. The analysis was performed for the one qubit case.

arXiv:1210.1977Oct 6, 20120 citations

Geometric Models for Quantum Statistical Inference

Dorje C. Brody, Lane P. Hughston

Abstract Our purpose here is to draw attention to an interesting relationship that can be shown to hold between (a) information geometry, and (b) quantum geometry. By ‘information geometry’, we mean the natural geometry associated with families of probability distributions. This is a subject that goes back more than half a century to the pioneering work of Rao (1945), who showed that the Fisher information matrix associated with a parametrised family of probability dis tributions gives rise to a natural Riemannian metric on the parameter space. This then allows one to speak in a precise way of the ‘distance’ between two probability distributions, an idea that turns out to be useful in problems of statistical inference. An extensive literature has thus developed, following this line of enquiry, on applications of differential geometry to statistics (see, e.g., Amari (1985), Barndorff-Nielsen et al. (1986), Murray and Rice (1993)). By ‘quantum geometry’, on the other hand, we mean the geometry of the manifold of states associated with a given quantum mechanical system. In particular, we consider the manifold of ‘pure’ states associated with a given complex Hilbert space. This is the space of ‘rays’ through the origin in the Hilbert space, which has the structure of a complex projective space. It is known that the usual rules of quantum mechanics allow one to construct a natural metric on this space, namely the Fubini-Study metric, the specification of which is equivalent to all the familiar structure associated with ordinary quantum mechanics.

Apr 30, 19984 citations

No Third Slot: A Local Entropy–Phase Closure of "Quantum Gravity" Within Standard Quantum Mechanics

Radu Necsanu

Within orthodox quantum mechanics, the only empirical content of any physical claim is a change in the outcome statistics of a declared measurement. In the modern formulation of measurement theory this declaration is an instrument (a family of completely positive maps) or equivalently a POVM together with an implementation. In curved spacetimes, localized measurement theory supplies the appropriate notion of a “local interface”: a finite laboratory worldtube with finite switching, whose induced observables lie in the causal hull and whose instruments compose causally. This paper proves a closure result: for any declared localized measurement, all geometric dependence (metric, connection, curvature, horizons) can affect outcome statistics only through exactly two operational apertures: • Phase / support aperture: the implemented localized instrument or channel on the accessible algebra, including any differential proper‑time or propagation‑dependent phase and any geometry‑dependent support of the induced observable. • Entropy aperture: the accessibility restriction itself (restriction of the global state to the accessible algebra), equivalently a trace over inaccessible degrees of freedom, with the corresponding mixedness/entropy as the interface invariant. There is no third independent slot in the quantum‑mechanical probability rule into which “quantum gravity” can be inserted. Common‑mode phases are operationally null. Sub‑resolution “micro‑selection” is inadmissible without a refined POVM/instrument. And “mediator” talk without a mediator POVM is non‑identifiable, because Stinespring dilations are never unique. The closure is robust: within finite‑response classes, small perturbations of couplings or geometry produce proportionally small changes in outcome statistics. The result does not deny the possibility of new physics beyond orthodox QM. It eliminates a specific move that has repeatedly appeared in quantum‑gravity discourse: treating curvature as an additional, independently specifiable ingredient of orthodox quantum‑mechanical prediction at a local interface.

Feb 3, 20260 citations