Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2501.18569 · SciPost Physics

Derivation of free energy, entropy and specific heat for planar Ising models: Application to Archimedean lattices and their duals

Laurent Pierre, B. Bernu, Laura Messio

Published Jul 18, 2025• 6 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The 2d ferromagnetic Ising model was solved by Onsager on the square lattice in 1944, and an explicit expression of the free energy density f f is presently available for some other planar lattices. But determining exactly the critical temperature T_c T c only requires a partial derivation of f f . It has been performed on many lattices, including the 11 Archimedean lattices. In this article, we give general expressions of the free energy, energy, entropy and specific heat for planar lattices with a single type of non-crossing links. It is known that the specific heat exhibits a logarithmic singularity at T_c T c : c_V(T)\sim -A\ln|1-T_c/T| c V ( T ) ∼ − A ln | 1 − T c / T | , in all the ferromagnetic and some antiferromagnetic cases. While the non-universal weight A A of the leading term has often been evaluated, this is not the case for the sub-leading order term B B such that c_V(T)+A\ln|1-T_c/T|\sim B c V ( T ) + A ln | 1 − T c / T | ∼ B , despite its significant impact on the c_V(T) c V ( T ) values in the vicinity of T_c T c , particularly important in experimental measurements. Explicit values of T_c T c , A A , B B and other thermodynamic quantities are given for the Archimedean lattices and their duals for both ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic interactions.

DOI
10.21468/scipostphys.19.1.025

Related papers

Critical two-dimensional Ising model with free, fixed ferromagnetic, fixed antiferromagnetic, and double antiferromagnetic boundaries

Xintian Wu, Nickolay Izmailyan

The critical two-dimensional Ising model is studied with four types boundary conditions: free, fixed ferromagnetic, fixed antiferromagnetic, and fixed double antiferromagnetic. Using bond propagation algorithms with surface fields, we obtain the free energy, internal energy, and specific heat numerically on square lattices with a square shape and various combinations of the four types of boundary conditions. The calculations are carried out on the square lattices with size N×N and 30<N<1000. The numerical data are analyzed with finite-size scaling. The bulk, edge, and corner terms are extracted very accurately. The exact results are conjectured for the corner logarithmic term in the free energy, the edge logarithmic term in the internal energy, and the corner logarithmic term in the specific heat. The corner logarithmic terms in the free energy agree with the conformal field theory very well.

arXiv:1409.6153•Physical Review E•Jan 5, 2015•14 citations

Ising Model with Second-Neighbor Interaction. I. Some Exact Results and an Approximate Solution

Chungpeng Fan, Fa Yueh Wu

The square Ising lattice with unequal first- and second-neighbor interactions has been considered. Among the exact results discussed, we show that the lowest energy state can be ferromagnetic, antiferromagnetic, or superantiferromagnetic, and the transition temperature should vanish in some cases. It is also shown that this problem is a special case of a more general problem arising in the statistical consideration of the hydrogen-bonded crystals. A well-defined approximation procedure is then introduced to solve the latter problem and to derive the (approximate) critical condition and expressions for the thermodynamic functions. The critical temperature thus determined is exact for the regular Ising lattice and for the lattices with ${T}_{c}=0$ while for the equivalent neighbor model the error is less than 2%. The specific heat possesses the usual logarithmic singularity in all cases.

Physical Review•Mar 10, 1969•179 citations

Dependence of Critical Parameters of 2D Ising Model on Lattice Size

B. V. Kryzhanovsky, M. Yu. Malsagov, Iakov Karandashev

For the 2D Ising model, we analyzed dependences of thermodynamic characteristics on number of spins by means of computer simulations. We compared experimental data obtained using the Fisher-Kasteleyn algorithm on a square lattice with N = l × l spins and the asymptotic Onsager solution ( N → ∞). We derived empirical expressions for critical parameters as functions of N and generalized the Onsager solution on the case of a finite-size lattice. Our analytical expressions for the free energy and its derivatives (the internal energy, the energy dispersion and the heat capacity) describe accurately the results of computer simulations. We showed that when N increased the heat capacity in the critical point increased as ln N . We specified restrictions on the accuracy of the critical temperature due to finite size of our system. Also in the finite-dimensional case, we obtained expressions describing temperature dependences of the magnetization and the correlation length. They are in a good qualitative agreement with the results of computer simulations by means of the dynamic Metropolis Monte Carlo method.

arXiv:2002.00615•Optical Memory and Neural Networks•Jan 1, 2018•7 citations

Square-lattice Ising model in a weak uniform magnetic field: Renormalization-group analysis

Miron Kaufman

For the two-dimensional ferromagnetic Ising critical point, I show that the known values of the critical exponents imply the absence of logarithms of the reduced temperature in the leading contributions to any field derivative of the free energy at zero magnetic field. For the square-lattice Ising antiferromagnet in a weak magnetic field, I compute the critical line ${T}_{c}$(H)=${T}_{c}^{0}$(1-0.038 023 259${H}^{2}$) and the leading contribution to the susceptibility \ensuremath{\chi}=0.014 718 006 6${H}^{2}$ln(1/\ensuremath{\Vert}t\ensuremath{\Vert}), where t is the reduced temperature.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Sep 1, 1987•31 citations

Universality of the Ising and the S=1 model on Archimedean lattices: A Monte Carlo determination

Anastasios Malakis, Gül Gülpınar, Yenal Karaaslan +2 more

The Ising models S=1/2 and S=1 are studied by efficient Monte Carlo schemes on the (3,4,6,4) and the (3,3,3,3,6) Archimedean lattices. The algorithms used, a hybrid Metropolis-Wolff algorithm and a parallel tempering protocol, are briefly described and compared with the simple Metropolis algorithm. Accurate Monte Carlo data are produced at the exact critical temperatures of the Ising model for these lattices. Their finite-size analysis provide, with high accuracy, all critical exponents which, as expected, are the same with the well-known 2D Ising model exact values. A detailed finite-size scaling analysis of our Monte Carlo data for the S=1 model on the same lattices provides very clear evidence that this model obeys, also very well, the 2D Ising model critical exponents. As a result, we find that recent Monte Carlo simulations and attempts to define effective dimensionality for the S=1 model on these lattices are misleading. Accurate estimates are obtained for the critical amplitudes of the logarithmic expansions of the specific heat for both models on the two Archimedean lattices.

arXiv:1203.4507•Physical Review E•Mar 29, 2012•10 citations

On Ising models

Hoede, C., Zandvliet, Henricus J.W.

For various Ising models two approaches are discussed, one is that of simulating lattices, also called gauging on exact equations, the other is that of calculating analytical expressions for the boundary free energy of Ising lattices. The first approach allows to conjecture a solution for some Ising models, that have sofar not been solved, once some exact partial result for the problem is known. The second approach aims at furnishing such a partial result in the form of a condition for the critical temperature. An example of such a result was recently given for the 2D Ising square lattice with nearest and next-nearest-neighbor interactions. The critical line that separates the ordered (ferromagnetic) phase from the disordered (paramagnetic) phase showed good agreement in the moderate and strong nearest neighbor coupling limit with several results obtained by Monte Carlo, transfer matrix and series expansion results. We extend the discussion of the critical line, finding an excellent fit, now also in other points, like the Padé point, as well as cusp behavior at the Onsager point where the lattice decouples into two 2D square lattices with only nearest-neighbor interaction. Combination of this result with a geometrical argument in the simulation approach leads to a critical exponent $2-\sqrt{2} \approx 0.5858,$ comparable to the exponent $4/7 \approx 0.5714$ found from renormalization arguments.

•Jun 1, 2006•0 citations
The 2d ferromagnetic Ising model was solved by Onsager on the square lattice in 1944, and an explicit expression of the free energy density f f is presently available for some other planar lattices. But determining exactly the critical temperature T_c T c only requires a partial derivation of f f . It has been performed on many lattices, including the 11 Archimedean lattices. In this article, we give general expressions of the free energy, energy, entropy and specific heat for planar lattices with a single type of non-crossing links. It is known that the specific heat exhibits a logarithmic singularity at T_c T c : c_V(T)\sim -A\ln|1-T_c/T| c V ( T ) ∼ − A ln | 1 − T c / T | , in all the ferromagnetic and some antiferromagnetic cases. While the non-universal weight A A of the leading term has often been evaluated, this is not the case for the sub-leading order term B B such that c_V(T)+A\ln|1-T_c/T|\sim B c V ( T ) + A ln | 1 − T c / T | ∼ B , despite its significant impact on the c_V(T) c V ( T ) values in the vicinity of T_c T c , particularly important in experimental measurements. Explicit values of T_c T c , A A , B B and other thermodynamic quantities are given for the Archimedean lattices and their duals for both ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic interactions.
The critical two-dimensional Ising model is studied with four types boundary conditions: free, fixed ferromagnetic, fixed antiferromagnetic, and fixed double antiferromagnetic. Using bond propagation algorithms with surface fields, we obtain the free energy, internal energy, and specific heat numerically on square lattices with a square shape and various combinations of the four types of boundary conditions. The calculations are carried out on the square lattices with size N×N and 30<N<1000. The numerical data are analyzed with finite-size scaling. The bulk, edge, and corner terms are extracted very accurately. The exact results are conjectured for the corner logarithmic term in the free energy, the edge logarithmic term in the internal energy, and the corner logarithmic term in the specific heat. The corner logarithmic terms in the free energy agree with the conformal field theory very well.
The square Ising lattice with unequal first- and second-neighbor interactions has been considered. Among the exact results discussed, we show that the lowest energy state can be ferromagnetic, antiferromagnetic, or superantiferromagnetic, and the transition temperature should vanish in some cases. It is also shown that this problem is a special case of a more general problem arising in the statistical consideration of the hydrogen-bonded crystals. A well-defined approximation procedure is then introduced to solve the latter problem and to derive the (approximate) critical condition and expressions for the thermodynamic functions. The critical temperature thus determined is exact for the regular Ising lattice and for the lattices with Tc=0{T}_{c}=0Tc​=0 while for the equivalent neighbor model the error is less than 2%. The specific heat possesses the usual logarithmic singularity in all cases.
For the 2D Ising model, we analyzed dependences of thermodynamic characteristics on number of spins by means of computer simulations. We compared experimental data obtained using the Fisher-Kasteleyn algorithm on a square lattice with N = l × l spins and the asymptotic Onsager solution ( N → ∞). We derived empirical expressions for critical parameters as functions of N and generalized the Onsager solution on the case of a finite-size lattice. Our analytical expressions for the free energy and its derivatives (the internal energy, the energy dispersion and the heat capacity) describe accurately the results of computer simulations. We showed that when N increased the heat capacity in the critical point increased as ln N . We specified restrictions on the accuracy of the critical temperature due to finite size of our system. Also in the finite-dimensional case, we obtained expressions describing temperature dependences of the magnetization and the correlation length. They are in a good qualitative agreement with the results of computer simulations by means of the dynamic Metropolis Monte Carlo method.
For the two-dimensional ferromagnetic Ising critical point, I show that the known values of the critical exponents imply the absence of logarithms of the reduced temperature in the leading contributions to any field derivative of the free energy at zero magnetic field. For the square-lattice Ising antiferromagnet in a weak magnetic field, I compute the critical line Tc{T}_{c}Tc​(H)=Tc0{T}_{c}^{0}Tc0​(1-0.038 023 259H2{H}^{2}H2) and the leading contribution to the susceptibility \ensuremath{\chi}=0.014 718 006 6H2{H}^{2}H2ln(1/\ensuremath{\Vert}t\ensuremath{\Vert}), where t is the reduced temperature.
The Ising models S=1/2 and S=1 are studied by efficient Monte Carlo schemes on the (3,4,6,4) and the (3,3,3,3,6) Archimedean lattices. The algorithms used, a hybrid Metropolis-Wolff algorithm and a parallel tempering protocol, are briefly described and compared with the simple Metropolis algorithm. Accurate Monte Carlo data are produced at the exact critical temperatures of the Ising model for these lattices. Their finite-size analysis provide, with high accuracy, all critical exponents which, as expected, are the same with the well-known 2D Ising model exact values. A detailed finite-size scaling analysis of our Monte Carlo data for the S=1 model on the same lattices provides very clear evidence that this model obeys, also very well, the 2D Ising model critical exponents. As a result, we find that recent Monte Carlo simulations and attempts to define effective dimensionality for the S=1 model on these lattices are misleading. Accurate estimates are obtained for the critical amplitudes of the logarithmic expansions of the specific heat for both models on the two Archimedean lattices.
For various Ising models two approaches are discussed, one is that of simulating lattices, also called gauging on exact equations, the other is that of calculating analytical expressions for the boundary free energy of Ising lattices. The first approach allows to conjecture a solution for some Ising models, that have sofar not been solved, once some exact partial result for the problem is known. The second approach aims at furnishing such a partial result in the form of a condition for the critical temperature. An example of such a result was recently given for the 2D Ising square lattice with nearest and next-nearest-neighbor interactions. The critical line that separates the ordered (ferromagnetic) phase from the disordered (paramagnetic) phase showed good agreement in the moderate and strong nearest neighbor coupling limit with several results obtained by Monte Carlo, transfer matrix and series expansion results. We extend the discussion of the critical line, finding an excellent fit, now also in other points, like the Padé point, as well as cusp behavior at the Onsager point where the lattice decouples into two 2D square lattices with only nearest-neighbor interaction. Combination of this result with a geometrical argument in the simulation approach leads to a critical exponent 2−2≈0.5858,2-\sqrt{2} \approx 0.5858,2−2​≈0.5858, comparable to the exponent 4/7≈0.57144/7 \approx 0.57144/7≈0.5714 found from renormalization arguments.