Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2412.21118

Efficient Approximate Degenerate Ordered Statistics Decoding for Quantum Codes via Reliable Subset Reduction

Ching-Feng Kung, Kao-Yueh Kuo, Ching–Yi Lai

Published Dec 30, 2024• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Efficient and scalable decoding of quantum codes is essential for high-performance quantum error correction. In this work, we introduce Reliable Subset Reduction (RSR), a reliability-driven preprocessing framework that leverages belief propagation (BP) statistics to identify and remove highly reliable qubits, substantially reducing the effective problem size. Additionally, we identify a degeneracy condition that allows high-order OSD to be simplified to order-0 OSD. By integrating these techniques, we present an ADOSD algorithm that significantly improves OSD efficiency. Our BP+RSR+ADOSD framework extends naturally to circuit-level noise and can handle large-scale codes with more than $10^4$ error variables. Through extensive simulations, we demonstrate improved performance over MWPM and Localized Statistics Decoding for a variety of CSS and non-CSS codes under the code-capacity noise model, and for rotated surface codes under realistic circuit-level noise. At low physical error rates, RSR reduces the effective problem size to as little as 1\% (e.g., for $ε=0.001$ in surface-code DEM), enabling higher-order OSD with drastically reduced computational complexity. These results highlight the practical efficiency and broad applicability of the BP+ADOSD framework for both theoretical and realistic quantum error correction scenarios.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2412.21118

Related papers

Degeneracy Cutting: A Local and Efficient Post-Processing for Belief Propagation Decoding of Quantum Low-Density Parity-Check Codes

Kento Tsubouchi, Hayata Yamasaki, Shiro Tamiya

Quantum low-density parity-check (qLDPC) codes are promising for realizing scalable fault-tolerant quantum computation due to their potential for low-overhead protocols. A common approach to decoding qLDPC codes is to use the belief propagation (BP) decoder, followed by a post-processing step to enhance decoding accuracy. For fast decoding, the post-processing algorithm is desirable to have a small computational cost and rely only on local operations on the Tanner graph to facilitate parallel implementation. To address this requirement, we propose degeneracy cutting (DC), an efficient post-processing technique for the BP decoder that operates on information restricted to the support of each stabilizer generator. DC selectively removes one variable node with the lowest error probability for each stabilizer generator, significantly improving decoding performance while retaining the favorable computational scaling and structure amenable to parallelization inherent to BP. We further extend our method to realistic noise models, including phenomenological and circuit-level noise models, by introducing the detector degeneracy matrix, which generalizes the notion of stabilizer-induced degeneracy to these settings. Numerical simulations demonstrate that BP+DC achieves decoding performance approaching that of BP followed by ordered statistics decoding (BP+OSD) in several settings, while requiring significantly less computational cost. Our results present BP+DC as a promising decoder for fault-tolerant quantum computing, offering a valuable balance of accuracy, efficiency, and suitability for parallel implementation.

arXiv:2510.08695•Oct 9, 2025•0 citations

Evolutionary BP+OSD Decoding for Low-Latency Quantum Error Correction

Hee-Youl Kwak, Seong-Joon Park, Hyunwoo Jung +2 more

Quantum error correction (QEC) for fault-tolerant quantum computing requires a balanced decoding solution that offers high performance, low complexity, and low latency. However, the de facto standard - belief propagation (BP) combined with ordered statistics decoding (OSD) - suffers from excessive iterations in the BP stage and high complexity in the OSD stage. To address these challenges, we propose an evolutionary BP (EBP) decoder optimized via a differential evolution (DE) algorithm. By leveraging the gradient-free nature of DE, we enable end-to-end optimization of the EBP+OSD structure to maximize overall performance. In addition, a multi-objective selection rule is introduced to suppress frequent OSD activation, significantly reducing complexity overhead. Simulation results on surface codes and quantum low-density parity-check (QLDPC) codes demonstrate that EBP+OSD simultaneously achieves both superior decoding performance and substantially lower complexity compared to conventional BP+OSD, particularly in stringent low-latency regimes.

quant-pharXiv:2512.18273•IEEE Journal on Selected Areas in Communications•Dec 23, 2025•0 citations

Best-First Ordered Statistics Decoding of Quantum LDPC Codes

Michele Banfi, Marco Ferrari, Antonino Favano +2 more

Belief Propagation (BP) followed by Ordered Statistics Decoding (OSD) has emerged as the gold standard for decoding quantum low-density parity-check (QLDPC) codes. Recent advancements in this field have proposed new methods and algorithms to lower the complexity of this standard pipeline. Because of code degeneracy, and more in general because multiple distinct error patterns can produce the same syndrome, OSD is inherently a list-decoding technique; that is, it enumerates a set of syndrome-consistent candidates and returns the most probable one. In this work, we propose a variant of OSD, which we call Best-First OSD (BF-OSD), that explores the error-candidate space more efficiently by traversing it in order of decreasing likelihood, rather than by brute-force enumeration of a pre-selected subset. In addition, we depart from the conventional BP+OSD cascade: instead of conditioning the OSD invocation on BP convergence, we invoke OSD after a fixed, small number of BP iterations. This design choice is motivated by the full circuit-level noise regime, in which BP is particularly unreliable. Monte Carlo simulations of a family of Bivariate Bicycle (BB) codes under full circuit-level noise show that BF-OSD matches the performance of the BP+OSD baseline while exploring the solution space with 1/100th of the query budget.

arXiv:2605.25777•May 25, 2026•0 citations

Optimal Decoding of Small Codes by Density Matrix Propagation

Anthony Benois, Pierre Cussenot, Grégoire Misguich +2 more

Accurate and efficient decoding is a crucial component for achieving fault-tolerant quantum computing. Realistic circuit-level noise introduces temporal correlations and degeneracy, making optimal (maximum-likelihood) decoding computationally intractable in general. As a result, practical decoders rely on heuristic approximations, and it is generally difficult to quantify how suboptimal they are, as this strongly depends on the code and noise model considered. In this work, we study the accuracy of practical decoding algorithms under circuit-level noise by comparing them against a maximum likelihood decoding benchmark. Our approach propagates the density matrix through the full memory experiment and computes the optimal decoding decision for each syndrome history. We introduce pruning techniques with rigorous bounds, allowing us to access larger numbers of syndrome-extraction rounds. We apply this framework to small instances of the repetition code and a cellular automaton code, and benchmark minimum-weight perfect matching (MWPM), belief propagation with ordered statistics decoding (BP+OSD), Tesseract, and Planar decoders against optimal decoding. While standard decoders remain close to optimal for the repetition code, we find significant deviations for the cellular automaton code, with BP+OSD deteriorating already in experimentally relevant noise regimes. Moreover, the pruning method developed here highlights that, at low physical error rates, only a narrow fraction of syndrome histories contributes significantly to the logical error rate.

quant-pharXiv:2606.14455•Jun 15, 2026•0 citations

On Belief Propagation Decoding of Quantum Codes with Quaternary Reliability Statistics

Ching-Feng Kung, Kao-Yueh Kuo, Ching–Yi Lai

In this paper, we investigate the use of quaternary reliability statistics for ordered statistics decoding (OSD) of quantum codes. OSD can be used to improve the performance of belief propagation (BP) decoding when it fails to correct the error syndrome. We propose an approach that leverages quaternary reliability information and the hard-decision history output by BP to perform reliability sorting for OSD. This approach improves upon previous methods that separately treat X and Z errors, by preserving the X/Z correlations during the sorting step. Our simulations show that the refined BP with scalar messages and the proposed OSD outperforms previous BP-OSD combinations. We achieve thresholds of roughly 17.5%–17.7% for toric, surface, and XZZX codes, and 15.42% for hexagonal planar color codes.

arXiv:2305.03321•International Symposium on Turbo Codes and Iterative Information Processing•Sep 4, 2023•5 citations

Neural Network Belief Propagation and Ordered Statistics Decoding for Quantum Error Correction Codes

Gong, Christina Susan

In the quest for fault-tolerant quantum computation, the delicate nature of qubits demands the need for robust quantum error correction. Quantum error correcting codes, the quantum counterpart to classical error correcting codes in information theory, have been developed to address the unique challenges quantum bits face against the noise of their environment in storing information. These codes include but are not limited to the Kitaev surface code, toric code, rotated surface code, generalized bicycle code, and bivariate bicycle code. Fast and reliable decoders for these quantum error correcting codes are needed to correct errors and achieve fault tolerance on these qubits. The belief propagation algorithm, which is a efficient and reliable heuristic for decoding classical low-density parity check codes, has been generalized to different types of quantum error correction codes. Paired with the ordered statistics decoding algorithm as a post-processing step from the soft outputs of the belief propagation decoder, belief propagation and ordered statistics decoding has been one of the most promising avenues of efficient quantum error correction. This thesis combines the state-of-the-art belief propagation and ordered statistics decoding algorithms with the exploration of the neural belief propagation algorithm to leverage classical deep learning machines to learn message passing patterns in decoding the newest quantum codes, the rotated surface code and bivariate bicycle code. The neural network exploits the local lattice structure of these codes to adjust the trainable weights and biases to more learn message update patterns more efficiently than the vanilla belief propagation algorithm. In this thesis, we prove a new threshold for the physical error rate on the rotated surface code using a neural belief propagation algorithm and ordered statistics decoding that consistently outperforms the threshold established by the vanilla belief propagation algorithm with ordered statistics decoding. We additionally show the results for similar efforts on the bivariate bicycle codes, and discuss the difficulties in achieving a threshold using the current neural belief propagation algorithms.

•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations
Efficient and scalable decoding of quantum codes is essential for high-performance quantum error correction. In this work, we introduce Reliable Subset Reduction (RSR), a reliability-driven preprocessing framework that leverages belief propagation (BP) statistics to identify and remove highly reliable qubits, substantially reducing the effective problem size. Additionally, we identify a degeneracy condition that allows high-order OSD to be simplified to order-0 OSD. By integrating these techniques, we present an ADOSD algorithm that significantly improves OSD efficiency. Our BP+RSR+ADOSD framework extends naturally to circuit-level noise and can handle large-scale codes with more than 10410^4104 error variables. Through extensive simulations, we demonstrate improved performance over MWPM and Localized Statistics Decoding for a variety of CSS and non-CSS codes under the code-capacity noise model, and for rotated surface codes under realistic circuit-level noise. At low physical error rates, RSR reduces the effective problem size to as little as 1% (e.g., for ε=0.001ε=0.001ε=0.001 in surface-code DEM), enabling higher-order OSD with drastically reduced computational complexity. These results highlight the practical efficiency and broad applicability of the BP+ADOSD framework for both theoretical and realistic quantum error correction scenarios.
Quantum low-density parity-check (qLDPC) codes are promising for realizing scalable fault-tolerant quantum computation due to their potential for low-overhead protocols. A common approach to decoding qLDPC codes is to use the belief propagation (BP) decoder, followed by a post-processing step to enhance decoding accuracy. For fast decoding, the post-processing algorithm is desirable to have a small computational cost and rely only on local operations on the Tanner graph to facilitate parallel implementation. To address this requirement, we propose degeneracy cutting (DC), an efficient post-processing technique for the BP decoder that operates on information restricted to the support of each stabilizer generator. DC selectively removes one variable node with the lowest error probability for each stabilizer generator, significantly improving decoding performance while retaining the favorable computational scaling and structure amenable to parallelization inherent to BP. We further extend our method to realistic noise models, including phenomenological and circuit-level noise models, by introducing the detector degeneracy matrix, which generalizes the notion of stabilizer-induced degeneracy to these settings. Numerical simulations demonstrate that BP+DC achieves decoding performance approaching that of BP followed by ordered statistics decoding (BP+OSD) in several settings, while requiring significantly less computational cost. Our results present BP+DC as a promising decoder for fault-tolerant quantum computing, offering a valuable balance of accuracy, efficiency, and suitability for parallel implementation.
Quantum error correction (QEC) for fault-tolerant quantum computing requires a balanced decoding solution that offers high performance, low complexity, and low latency. However, the de facto standard - belief propagation (BP) combined with ordered statistics decoding (OSD) - suffers from excessive iterations in the BP stage and high complexity in the OSD stage. To address these challenges, we propose an evolutionary BP (EBP) decoder optimized via a differential evolution (DE) algorithm. By leveraging the gradient-free nature of DE, we enable end-to-end optimization of the EBP+OSD structure to maximize overall performance. In addition, a multi-objective selection rule is introduced to suppress frequent OSD activation, significantly reducing complexity overhead. Simulation results on surface codes and quantum low-density parity-check (QLDPC) codes demonstrate that EBP+OSD simultaneously achieves both superior decoding performance and substantially lower complexity compared to conventional BP+OSD, particularly in stringent low-latency regimes.
Belief Propagation (BP) followed by Ordered Statistics Decoding (OSD) has emerged as the gold standard for decoding quantum low-density parity-check (QLDPC) codes. Recent advancements in this field have proposed new methods and algorithms to lower the complexity of this standard pipeline. Because of code degeneracy, and more in general because multiple distinct error patterns can produce the same syndrome, OSD is inherently a list-decoding technique; that is, it enumerates a set of syndrome-consistent candidates and returns the most probable one. In this work, we propose a variant of OSD, which we call Best-First OSD (BF-OSD), that explores the error-candidate space more efficiently by traversing it in order of decreasing likelihood, rather than by brute-force enumeration of a pre-selected subset. In addition, we depart from the conventional BP+OSD cascade: instead of conditioning the OSD invocation on BP convergence, we invoke OSD after a fixed, small number of BP iterations. This design choice is motivated by the full circuit-level noise regime, in which BP is particularly unreliable. Monte Carlo simulations of a family of Bivariate Bicycle (BB) codes under full circuit-level noise show that BF-OSD matches the performance of the BP+OSD baseline while exploring the solution space with 1/100th of the query budget.
Accurate and efficient decoding is a crucial component for achieving fault-tolerant quantum computing. Realistic circuit-level noise introduces temporal correlations and degeneracy, making optimal (maximum-likelihood) decoding computationally intractable in general. As a result, practical decoders rely on heuristic approximations, and it is generally difficult to quantify how suboptimal they are, as this strongly depends on the code and noise model considered. In this work, we study the accuracy of practical decoding algorithms under circuit-level noise by comparing them against a maximum likelihood decoding benchmark. Our approach propagates the density matrix through the full memory experiment and computes the optimal decoding decision for each syndrome history. We introduce pruning techniques with rigorous bounds, allowing us to access larger numbers of syndrome-extraction rounds. We apply this framework to small instances of the repetition code and a cellular automaton code, and benchmark minimum-weight perfect matching (MWPM), belief propagation with ordered statistics decoding (BP+OSD), Tesseract, and Planar decoders against optimal decoding. While standard decoders remain close to optimal for the repetition code, we find significant deviations for the cellular automaton code, with BP+OSD deteriorating already in experimentally relevant noise regimes. Moreover, the pruning method developed here highlights that, at low physical error rates, only a narrow fraction of syndrome histories contributes significantly to the logical error rate.
In this paper, we investigate the use of quaternary reliability statistics for ordered statistics decoding (OSD) of quantum codes. OSD can be used to improve the performance of belief propagation (BP) decoding when it fails to correct the error syndrome. We propose an approach that leverages quaternary reliability information and the hard-decision history output by BP to perform reliability sorting for OSD. This approach improves upon previous methods that separately treat X and Z errors, by preserving the X/Z correlations during the sorting step. Our simulations show that the refined BP with scalar messages and the proposed OSD outperforms previous BP-OSD combinations. We achieve thresholds of roughly 17.5%–17.7% for toric, surface, and XZZX codes, and 15.42% for hexagonal planar color codes.
In the quest for fault-tolerant quantum computation, the delicate nature of qubits demands the need for robust quantum error correction. Quantum error correcting codes, the quantum counterpart to classical error correcting codes in information theory, have been developed to address the unique challenges quantum bits face against the noise of their environment in storing information. These codes include but are not limited to the Kitaev surface code, toric code, rotated surface code, generalized bicycle code, and bivariate bicycle code. Fast and reliable decoders for these quantum error correcting codes are needed to correct errors and achieve fault tolerance on these qubits. The belief propagation algorithm, which is a efficient and reliable heuristic for decoding classical low-density parity check codes, has been generalized to different types of quantum error correction codes. Paired with the ordered statistics decoding algorithm as a post-processing step from the soft outputs of the belief propagation decoder, belief propagation and ordered statistics decoding has been one of the most promising avenues of efficient quantum error correction. This thesis combines the state-of-the-art belief propagation and ordered statistics decoding algorithms with the exploration of the neural belief propagation algorithm to leverage classical deep learning machines to learn message passing patterns in decoding the newest quantum codes, the rotated surface code and bivariate bicycle code. The neural network exploits the local lattice structure of these codes to adjust the trainable weights and biases to more learn message update patterns more efficiently than the vanilla belief propagation algorithm. In this thesis, we prove a new threshold for the physical error rate on the rotated surface code using a neural belief propagation algorithm and ordered statistics decoding that consistently outperforms the threshold established by the vanilla belief propagation algorithm with ordered statistics decoding. We additionally show the results for similar efforts on the bivariate bicycle codes, and discuss the difficulties in achieving a threshold using the current neural belief propagation algorithms.