arXiv:2412.17801 · Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
Observation of emergent scaling of spin–charge correlations at the onset of the pseudogap
Thomas Chalopin, Petar Bojović, Si Wang, Titus Franz, Aritra Sinha, Zhenjiu Wang, Dominik Bourgund, Johannes Obermeyer, Fabian Grusdt, Annabelle Bohrdt, Lode Pollet, Alexander Wietek, Antoine Georges, Timon Hilker, Immanuel Bloch
In strongly correlated materials, interacting electrons are entangled and form collective quantum states, resulting in rich low-temperature phase diagrams. Notable examples include cuprate superconductors, in which superconductivity emerges at low doping out of an unusual "pseudogap" metallic state above the critical temperature. The Fermi-Hubbard model, describing a wide range of phenomena associated with strong electron correlations, still offers major computational challenges despite its simple formulation. In this context, ultracold atoms quantum simulators have provided invaluable insights into the microscopic nature of correlated quantum states. Here, we use a quantum gas microscope Fermi-Hubbard simulator to explore a wide range of dopings and temperatures in a regime where a pseudogap is known to develop. By measuring multipoint correlation functions up to fifth order, we uncover a universal scaling behavior in magnetic and higher-order spin-charge correlations characterized by a doping-dependent temperature scale. Accurate comparisons with determinant Quantum Monte Carlo and Minimally Entangled Typical Thermal States simulations confirm that this temperature scale is comparable to the pseudogap temperature [Formula: see text]. Our quantitative findings reveal a qualitative behavior of magnetic properties and spin-charge correlations in an emergent pseudogap and pave the way toward the exploration of charge pairing and collective phenomena expected at lower temperatures.
In strongly correlated materials, interacting electrons are entangled and form collective quantum states, resulting in rich low-temperature phase diagrams. Notable examples include cuprate superconductors, in which superconductivity emerges at low doping out of an unusual "pseudogap" metallic state above the critical temperature. The Fermi-Hubbard model, describing a wide range of phenomena associated with strong electron correlations, still offers major computational challenges despite its simple formulation. In this context, ultracold atoms quantum simulators have provided invaluable insights into the microscopic nature of correlated quantum states. Here, we use a quantum gas microscope Fermi-Hubbard simulator to explore a wide range of dopings and temperatures in a regime where a pseudogap is known to develop. By measuring multipoint correlation functions up to fifth order, we uncover a universal scaling behavior in magnetic and higher-order spin-charge correlations characterized by a doping-dependent temperature scale. Accurate comparisons with determinant Quantum Monte Carlo and Minimally Entangled Typical Thermal States simulations confirm that this temperature scale is comparable to the pseudogap temperature [Formula: see text]. Our quantitative findings reveal a qualitative behavior of magnetic properties and spin-charge correlations in an emergent pseudogap and pave the way toward the exploration of charge pairing and collective phenomena expected at lower temperatures.
Among the most compelling targets for quantum simulation are strongly correlated phases and electronic-structure problems, where interactions organize electrons into collective states and produce intricate low-temperature phase diagrams. Cuprate superconductors are a canonical example: at low doping, superconductivity emerges from a metallic regime that exhibits a pseudogap above the critical temperature. Ultracold atoms in optical lattices provide a well-controlled, tunable setting to probe the microscopic mechanisms behind this behavior and, in fermion-native architectures, to implement electronic structure dynamics directly. This thesis demonstrates both large scale systematic analog quantum simulations in the most interesting regime of doped antiferromagnets and elementary high-fidelity gates as the basis for a digital or hybrid fermionic quantum processors in an optical lattice. Working with ultracold Lithium-6 in a two–dimensional optical superlattice, we first map the parameter space of the Fermi–Hubbard model over a wide range of temperatures and dopings. More than 40000 single-site spin- and density-resolved snapshots, spanning over a dense grid of doping levels and temperatures in a numerically challenging parameter space, reveal antiferromagnetic correlations extending across the system size and into the pseudogap regime. Temperatures down to T/t=0.2 are realized, determined by benchmarking the data to state-of-the-art numerical methods. By evaluating spin–charge correlators up to fifth order, we experimentally uncover a universal scaling behavior across the pseudogap crossover, governed by a single, doping-dependent temperature scale. These findings provide the first microscopic evidence of universal scaling in multi-point correlators and establish stringent benchmarks for future theoretical developments. On the same apparatus, we demonstrate that the controlled motion of fermions in double wells enables high-fidelity entanglement. Double-well potentials are used to engineer coherent pair-tunnelling and spin-exchange interactions that act as native SWAP^α operations. We demonstrate the collisional gate fidelities up to 99.8% and Bell-state lifetimes exceeding ten seconds, limited mainly by residual inhomogeneities in the optical potential. A composite pulse sequence isolates the pair-exchange channel, realizing the elementary building block required for fermionic quantum-chemistry algorithms. With the addition of site-selective addressing, our results mark a key step towards a fully digital, scalable fermionic quantum computer based on the controlled motion and entanglement of fermionic neutral atoms. The work establishes a hybrid analog-digital architecture: analog evolution under the Hubbard Hamiltonian yields thermodynamic states whose magnetic properties match and extend theoretical benchmarks, while digital collisional gates provide building blocks for error-corrected quantum computation and complex state preparation.
Studying the low-temperature phases of doped Hubbard models, including the emergence of collective order and exotic normal phases, is at the heart of strongly correlated physics. This thesis offers new theoretical insights into the low-energy physics of doped Hubbard models, with a particular emphasis on leveraging quantum simulation as a powerful investigative tool. We explore the emergence of collective order driven by many-body interactions, by predicting and observing stripe-like structures in quantum gas microscopes of engineered Hamiltonians. These fluctuating stripe patterns are developed into a theoretical framework for the pseudogap— a highly enigmatic phase in hole-doped cuprates—where we show how fluctuating domain walls yield effective toric code descriptions. Ultracold atoms in optical lattices provide a unique platform for directly probing and testing this theory. We further investigate unconventional bilayer nickelate superconductors, predicting an exceptionally stable superfluid state in a single-band Hubbard model at experimentally accessible temperatures. By proposing schemes to observe coherent pair-pair correlations, this advances the long-standing goal of realizing and observing long-range superconducting order in ultracold atomic systems in optical lattices. On non-bipartite lattices, we examine kinetic magnetism in Hubbard models and moiré heterostructures. Additionally, the low-temperature regime of doped Hubbard models with enhanced symmetries is analyzed, revealing exotic phenomena such as sub-dimensional polaronic particles. We develop machine learning techniques to extract key physical insights from many-body snapshots, offering a new avenue for understanding intricate quantum phases. Finally, we go beyond the Fermi-Hubbard paradigm and show how non-local strongly correlated models can be leveraged to address classical optimization problems through quantum annealing.
Despite decades of intense theoretical and experimental investigation, the two-dimensional Fermi-Hubbard model still resists a complete microscopic understanding. Conventional approaches typically probe global observables and locally resolved correlation functions. Here, we develop a complementary perspective based on the measurement of entanglement. Using both an ultracold-atom quantum simulator and numerical simulations based on the dynamical vertex approximation, we find that entanglement is closely tied to the onset of the enigmatic pseudogap regime: spin-singlet entanglement emerges only as the pseudogap sets in and, in contrast to classical correlations, remains confined to nearest-neighbour sites in this regime. Our results, therefore, disfavour purely classical-fluctuation theories of the pseudogap and constrain microscopic models to those that develop nearest-neighbour spin-singlet entanglement at the pseudogap onset.
Magnetic correlations of doped Mott insulators hold the key to the unusual characteristics of many quantum materials. Recent experiments with ultracold atoms in optical lattices have provided new information about the magnetic properties of the Fermi-Hubbard model on a square lattice. We demonstrate that recent measurements indicate that a single doping-dependent energy scale determines both static correlations and dynamical response of these systems. To understand these experimental findings, we employ a self-consistent formalism to describe the coupling between antiferromagnetic magnons and doped holes, and we uncover the emergence of a universal magnetic energy scale at finite doping, which we denote by J∗. We present the single- and two-magnon spectral properties at finite doping and discuss the appearance of a bimagnon peak in lattice-modulation spectroscopy, at frequencies set by J∗. Furthermore, we argue that this same energy scale sets the onset of pseudogap phenomena, leading to the hypothesis kBT∗=cJ∗, with c an order one number. We identify another low-energy scale emerging from our analysis of magnetic excitations, and argue that it controls the stability of Néel order at the lowest temperatures, ultimately driving a transition to an incommensurate spin-density-wave at finite doping. We discuss the relation between this low-energy scale and the nature of fermionic quasiparticles. Our analysis suggests that stability of the commensurate antiferromagentic phase at finite doping can be controlled experimentally by introducing additional quasiparticle broadening via disorder or low-frequency noise.
We compute high-resolution angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy of the Hubbard model using the unbiased determinant quantum Monte Carlo algorithm, revealing an asymmetry between electron and hole doping. Electron doping exhibits more coherent quasiparticles and stronger antiferromagnetic correlations compared to hole doping. At low doping, a nodal-antinodal dichotomy on the Fermi surface is observed, similar to cuprate experiments. The dichotomy reflects the momentum dependence of the Mott gap, as manifested in both the spectral function and the self-energy. For hole doping, we observe a transition towards the pseudogap, without signature of pocket formation. The simulated nuclear magnetic resonance pseudogap temperatures do not necessarily agree with the temperature determined by spectroscopy. These findings collectively suggest the pseudogap is a smooth crossover driven by strong correlations.
Traditionally, one- and two-point correlation functions are used to characterize many-body systems. In strongly correlated quantum materials, such as the doped 2D Fermi-Hubbard system, these may no longer be sufficient, because higher-order correlations are crucial to understanding the character of the many-body system and can be numerically dominant. Experimentally, such higher-order correlations have recently become accessible in ultracold atom systems. Here, we reveal strong non-Gaussian correlations in doped quantum antiferromagnets and show that higher-order correlations dominate over lower-order terms. We study a single mobile hole in the t-J model using the density matrix renormalization group and reveal genuine fifth-order correlations which are directly related to the mobility of the dopant. We contrast our results to predictions using models based on doped quantum spin liquids which feature significantly reduced higher-order correlations. Our predictions can be tested at the lowest currently accessible temperatures in quantum simulators of the 2D Fermi-Hubbard model. Finally, we propose to experimentally study the same fifth-order spin-charge correlations as a function of doping. This will help to reveal the microscopic nature of charge carriers in the most debated regime of the Hubbard model, relevant for understanding high-T_{c} superconductivity.