We introduce the notion of empirical coordination for quantum correlations. Quantum mechanics enables the calculation of probabilities for experimental outcomes, emphasizing statistical averages rather than detailed descriptions of individual events. This makes empirical coordination a natural and operationally meaningful framework for quantum systems, particularly in the context of nonlocal games, which rely on repeated measurements to assess performance. We discuss how coordination performance provides new insights into the implementation and simulation of quantum nonlocal games in the empirical regime.We begin by analyzing networks with classical links, focusing on the cascade network. We establish the optimal coordination rates, which indicate the minimal resources required to simulate a quantum state on average. We then consider networks with quantum links, focusing on a broadcast setting where a single transmitter distributes entanglement between multiple receivers. Our capacity result determines the necessary and sufficient resources required for preparing correlations that can subsequently be used in quantum nonlocal games.
We introduce the notion of empirical coordination for quantum correlations. Quantum mechanics enables the calculation of probabilities for experimental outcomes, emphasizing statistical averages rather than detailed descriptions of individual events. This makes empirical coordination a natural and operationally meaningful framework for quantum systems, particularly in the context of nonlocal games, which rely on repeated measurements to assess performance. We discuss how coordination performance provides new insights into the implementation and simulation of quantum nonlocal games in the empirical regime.We begin by analyzing networks with classical links, focusing on the cascade network. We establish the optimal coordination rates, which indicate the minimal resources required to simulate a quantum state on average. We then consider networks with quantum links, focusing on a broadcast setting where a single transmitter distributes entanglement between multiple receivers. Our capacity result determines the necessary and sufficient resources required for preparing correlations that can subsequently be used in quantum nonlocal games.
We introduce the notion of empirical coordination for quantum correlations. Quantum mechanics enables the calculation of probabilities for experimental outcomes, emphasizing statistical averages rather than detailed descriptions of individual events. Empirical coordination is thus a natural framework for quantum systems. Focusing on the cascade network, the optimal coordination rates are established, indicating the minimal resources required to simulate, on average, a quantum state. As we consider a network with classical communication links, superposition cannot be maintained, hence the quantum correlations are separable (i.e., a convex combination of product states). This precludes entanglement. Providing the users with shared randomness, before communication begins, does not affect the optimal rates for empirical coordination. We begin with a rate characterization for a basic two-node network, and then generalize to a cascade network. The special case of a network with an isolated node is considered as well. The results can be further generalized to other networks as our analysis includes a generic achievability scheme. The optimal rate formula involves optimization over a collection of state extensions. This is a unique feature of the quantum setting, as the classical parallel does not include optimization. As demonstrated through examples, the performance depends heavily on the choice of decomposition. We further discuss the consequences of our results for quantum cooperative games.
Coordination is a fundamental primitive in communication and information theory, in which distributed systems must collectively generate correlated behavior rather than merely exchange messages. In quantum networks, the nature of entanglement, quantum measurements, and nonclassical correlations introduces coordination possibilities unavailable classically. This article reviews recent advances in coordination over classical and quantum communication networks, focusing on empirical and strong coordination in multi-user settings.
We consider the implications of coordination for nonlocal games, showing how it provides a natural framework for understanding the correlations that enable spatially separated players to improve their probability of winning. We present a unified framework for coordination using classical or quantum communication and pre-shared correlation resources. The review covers simulation of both entanglement and separable correlations across a variety of network architectures, including two-node, cascade, broadcast, and multiple-access networks. We study the operational differences between empirical and strong coordination, and the tradeoffs between communication and correlation resources, such as pre-shared randomness and entanglement.
Coordination plays a major role in device-independent quantum key distribution (DI-QKD) schemes, in which parties can generate a secret key even if the devices used in the process have been prepared by an adversary. Furthermore, we examine the role of coordination in quantum repeaters, where distributed entanglement serves as a resource for long-distance quantum communication. The review highlights connections between coordination theory and applications such as distributed quantum systems, quantum internet architectures, and future communication networks.
Quantum coordination is considered in networks with classical and quantum links. We begin with networks withclassical links, and characterize the generation of separable and classical-quantum correlations in three primary models: 1) a two-node network with limited common randomness (CR), 2) a no-communication network, and 3) a broadcast network, which consists of a single sender and two receivers. We establish the optimal tradeoff between the classical communication and CR rates in each setting, thus characterizing the minimal resources for simulating classical-quantum correlations. Next, we consider coordination in networks withquantum links. We study the following models: 1) a cascade network with limited entanglement, 2) a broadcast network, and 3) a multiple-access network with two senders and a single receiver. We establish the optimal tradeoff between quantum communication and entanglement rates in each setting, characterizing the minimal resources for entanglement coordination. The examples demonstrate that coordination of entanglement and coordination of separable correlations behave differently. At last, we show the implications of our results on nonlocal games with quantum strategies.
The optimal coordination rates are determined in three primary settings of multi-user quantum networks, thus characterizing the minimal resources required in order to simulate a joint quantum state among multiple parties. We study the following models: (1) a cascade network with rate-limited entanglement, (2) a broadcast network, which consists of a single sender and two receivers, (3) a multiple-access network with two senders and a single receiver. We establish the necessary and sufficient conditions on the asymptotically-achievable communication and entanglement rates in each setting. At last, we show the implications of our results on nonlocal games with quantum strategies.
Remote entanglement enables coordinated decision making without communication and produces correlations beyond those achievable by any classical strategy, representing a practical quantum advantage in time-critical distributed decision-making problems. However, existing analyses of quantum-classical gaps in such latency-constrained tacit coordination (LCTC) have focused on idealized models that neglect the finite stationary window of the LCTC, finite operation times, and limited entanglement generation rates, leaving fundamental constraints unaccounted for. In this work, we develop a comprehensive framework to quantitatively analyze quantum advantage in LCTC that explicitly incorporates finite-duration and finite-rate operations, as well as generalized utility structures with a limited stationary window. These advances are made possible by adapting statistical certification methods for nonlocal games to the decision-making scenarios of LCTC, identifying operational criteria that must be satisfied by the hardware implementations to realize quantum advantage with sufficient statistical significance. To meet the stringent criteria, we propose time-multiplexed, event-ready operations of cavity-assisted trapped-atom quantum network nodes that provide a continuous stream of entangled qubit pairs, with decision latencies of a microsecond and decision rates of 8×103s−1 per channel for a representative metropolitan-scale 50-km fiber network to keep up with the fast-changing environment, such as financial markets and electric grid networks. These results bridge the gap between the theoretical notions of the quantum-classical gap in nonlocal games and concrete implementations that meet the stringent operational criteria for achieving robust quantum advantage in realistic coordination tasks.
Network coordination is considered in three basic settings, characterizing the generation of separable and classical-quantum correlations among multiple parties. First, we consider the simulation of a classical-quantum state between two nodes with rate-limited common randomness (CR) and communication. Furthermore, we study the preparation of a separable state between multiple nodes with rate-limited CR and no communication. At last, we consider a broadcast setting, where a sender and two receivers simulate a classical-quantum-quantum state using rate-limited CR and communication. We establish the optimal tradeoff between communication and CR rates in each setting.