High-dimensional quantum key distribution with resource-efficient detection
Maciej Ogrodnik, Adam Widomski, Dagmar Bruß, Giovanni Chesi, Federico Grasselli, Hermann Kampermann, Chiara Macchiavello, Nathan Walk, Nikolai Wyderka, Michał Karpiński
While quantum key distribution (QKD) based on two-dimensional (qubit) encoding is a mature, field-tested technology, its performance is lacking for many cryptographic applications. High-dimensional encoding for QKD enables increased achievable key rates and robustness as compared to the standard qubit-based systems. However, experimental implementations of such systems are more complicated, expensive, and require careful security analysis as they are less common. In this work, we present a proof-of-principle high-dimensional time-phase BB84 QKD experiment using only one single-photon detector per measurement basis. We employ the temporal Talbot effect to detect QKD symbols in the control basis and show experimentally obtained simplistic key rates for the two-dimensional and four-dimensional cases, including in an urban fiber network. We present a comparison of a simplistic secret key rate obtained from a standard security proof with the one derived from a recently devised proof using a tunable beam splitter to display security issues stemming from asymmetric detection efficiencies in the two bases. Our results contribute to the discussion of the benefits of high-dimensional encoding and highlight the impact of security analysis on the achievable QKD performance.
While quantum key distribution (QKD) based on two-dimensional (qubit) encoding is a mature, field-tested technology, its performance is lacking for many cryptographic applications. High-dimensional encoding for QKD enables increased achievable key rates and robustness as compared to the standard qubit-based systems. However, experimental implementations of such systems are more complicated, expensive, and require careful security analysis as they are less common. In this work, we present a proof-of-principle high-dimensional time-phase BB84 QKD experiment using only one single-photon detector per measurement basis. We employ the temporal Talbot effect to detect QKD symbols in the control basis and show experimentally obtained simplistic key rates for the two-dimensional and four-dimensional cases, including in an urban fiber network. We present a comparison of a simplistic secret key rate obtained from a standard security proof with the one derived from a recently devised proof using a tunable beam splitter to display security issues stemming from asymmetric detection efficiencies in the two bases. Our results contribute to the discussion of the benefits of high-dimensional encoding and highlight the impact of security analysis on the achievable QKD performance.
High-dimensional quantum key distribution (QKD) allows achievement of information-theoretic secure communications, providing high key-generation rates, which cannot, in principle, be obtained by QKD protocols with binary encoding. Nonetheless, the amount of experimental resources needed increases as the quantum states to be detected belong to a larger Hilbert space, thus raising the costs of practical high-dimensional systems. Here, we present an alternative scheme for fiber-based four-dimensional QKD, with time and phase encoding and one-decoy state technique. Quantum state transmission is tested over different channel lengths up to 145 km of standard single-mode fiber, evaluating the enhancement of the secret key rate in comparison to the three-state two-dimensional BB84 protocol, which is tested with the same experimental setup. Our scheme allows measurement of the four-dimensional states with a simplified and compact receiver, where only two single-photon detectors are necessary, thus making it a cost-effective solution for practical and fiber-based QKD.
Abstract High-dimensional quantum key distribution (QKD) offers secure communication with key rates that surpass those of QKD protocols utilizing two-dimensional encoding. However, existing high-dimensional QKD protocols require additional experimental resources, such as multiport interferometers and multiple detectors, thereby increasing the cost of high-dimensional systems and limiting their use. We introduce and analyze a high-dimensional QKD protocol that requires only standard two-dimensional hardware. We provide security analysis against individual and coherent attacks, establishing upper and lower bounds on the secure key rates. We tested our protocol on a standard two-dimensional QKD system over a 40 km fiber link, achieving a twofold increase in secure key rate compared to the standard two-dimensional coherent one-way protocol, without any hardware modifications. This work offers a significant improvement in the performance of already deployed QKD systems through simple software updates and holds broad applicability across various QKD schemes, making high-dimensional QKD practical for widespread use.
Higher Dimensional Quantum Key Distribution (HD-QKD) improves information capacity and security compared to binary QKD systems. Previous HD-QKD implementations have required d+1 (d refers to encoding dimension) single-photon detectors, limiting large-scale implementation. In contrast, another HD-QKD implementation using coherent one-way (COW) protocol hardware with two detectors achieved a secret key rate (SKR) of 155 kbps for an 8-D system and 2.7% QBER tolerance for a 16-D system with qubit scrambling across a time window. In this paper, we theoretically simulate and experimentally demonstrate time-bin encoded HD-QKD using COW protocol hardware with two single-photon detectors operating at standard telecom wavelengths, achieving a remarkable maximum encoding of 6 bits per photon (i.e., 56-d system). Our HD-QKD system incorporates a practical decoy-state technique to counter the photon number splitting attack, allowing greater flexibility in choosing higher mean photon number thereby achieving higher SKR and distances. This implementation demonstrates a remarkable ninefold increase in SKR for a 16-d system (210 kbps over 25 km of standard single-mode fiber) compared to qubit-based systems, with a QBER tolerance of 13.5% for d = 16. Notably, we achieved positive key rates for emulated loss up to 131 km of fiber length for d = 8. By optimizing detector deadtime and mean photon number using our theoretical model, we achieve enhanced key rates and security. Our findings highlight the superiority of our approach and lay the foundation for high throughput HD-QKD implementation, offering a secure and efficient method for transmitting sensitive information.
Quantum key distribution (QKD) exploits the quantum nature of light to share provably secure keys, allowing secure communication in the presence of an eavesdropper. The first QKD schemes used photons encoded in two states, such as polarization. Recently, much effort has turned to large-alphabet QKD schemes, which encode photons in high-dimensional basis states. Compared to binary-encoded QKD, large-alphabet schemes can encode more secure information per detected photon, boosting secure communication rates, and also provide increased resilience to noise and loss. High-dimensional encoding may also improve the efficiency of other quantum information processing tasks, such as performing Bell tests and implementing quantum gates. Here, we demonstrate a large-alphabet QKD protocol based on high-dimensional temporal encoding. We achieve record secret-key rates and perform the first field demonstration of large-alphabet QKD. This demonstrates a new, practical way to optimize secret-key rates and marks an important step towards transmission of high-dimensional quantum states in deployed networks.
Quantum key distribution (QKD) promises provably secure communications. In order to improve the secret key rate, combining a biased basis choice with the decoy-state method is proposed. Concomitantly, there is a basis-independent detection efficiency condition, which usually cannot be satisfied in a practical system, such as the time-phase encoding. Fortunately, this flaw has been recently removed theoretically and experimentally in the four-intensity decoy-state BB84 QKD protocol using the fact that the expected yields of single-photon states prepared in two bases stay the same for a given measurement basis. However, the security proofs do not fully consider the finite-key effects for general attacks. In this work, we provide the rigorous finite-key security bounds in the universally composable framework for the four-intensity decoy-state BB84 QKD protocol. We build a time-phase encoding system with 200 MHz clock to implement this protocol, in which the real-time secret key rate is more than 60 kbps over 50 km single-mode fiber.
Conventional quantum key distribution (QKD) typically uses binary encoding based on photon polarization or time-bin degrees of freedom and achieves a key capacity of at most one bit per photon. Under photon-starved conditions the rate of detection events is much lower than the photon generation rate, because of losses in long distance propagation and the relatively long recovery times of available single-photon detectors. Multi-bit encoding in the photon arrival times can be beneficial in such photon-starved situations. Recent security proofs indicate high-dimensional encoding in the photon arrival times is robust and can be implemented to yield high secure throughput. In this work we demonstrate entanglement-based QKD with high-dimensional encoding whose security against collective Gaussian attacks is provided by a high-visibility Franson interferometer. We achieve unprecedented key capacity and throughput for an entanglement-based QKD system because of four principal factors: Franson interferometry that does not degrade with loss; error correction coding that can tolerate high error rates; optimized time–energy entanglement generation; and highly efficient WSi superconducting nanowire single-photon detectors. The secure key capacity yields as much as 8.7 bits per coincidence. When optimized for throughput we observe a secure key rate of 2.7 Mbit s −1 after 20 km fiber transmission with a key capacity of 6.9 bits per photon coincidence. Our results demonstrate a viable approach to high-rate QKD using practical photonic entanglement and single-photon detection technologies.