arXiv:2412.16574

Heading towards an Algebraic Heisenberg Cut

Mathias van den Bossche, Philippe Grangier

Published Dec 21, 2024• 0 citations

Abstract

In previous papers we have explained how a sequence of theorems by John von Neumann on infinite tensor products (ITP) can be understood as providing elements to support both sectorisation of the Hilbert space of large quantum systems, and a mechanism of self decoherence thereof. These two effects may help understanding the articulation of the classical and quantum realms. However, as they involve considering an infinite number of quantum degrees of freedom, legitimate concerns can be raised on their applicability. In this paper, we address explicitly the interface between both realms through the example of a simplified model of a photon polarisation measurement device. Guided by the fact that there is von Neumann sectorisation at infinity, and by the necessity of classical contexts to perform measurements, we show that this limit can be under control, and that although the full force of the sectorisation theorems requires taking the infinite limit, early signs of the macroscopic behaviour appear before infinity. In our example, this shows up in photodiodes through diverging electron avalanches that simultaneously make the system classical, localise it randomly in a macroscopic sector and provide a macroscopic signal. This lays the grounds for justifying the inclusion in quantum physics of the ITP formalism, which involves non-separable Hilbert spaces and potentially type-III von Neumann algebras. Such an approach could make sense of the quantum-classical transition as a primarily algebraic one.

DOI: 10.48550/arxiv.2412.16574

Related papers

Anatomical Review of "Heading towards an Algebraic Heisenberg Cut": Sectorisation, Self-Decoherence, and the Algebraic Foundations of the Quantum–Classical Transition

Syed Muntasir Mamun

This review provides a detailed anatomical dissection of the recent paper by Van Den Bossche and Grangier (2025), which advances an algebraic approach to the quantum measurement problem grounded in von Neumann's theorems on infinite tensor products (ITP). The target work models photon polarisation detection via avalanche photodiodes (APDs), demonstrating that sectorisation of the Hilbert space and effective self-decoherence emerge dynamically through the exponential growth of the electron avalanche, even in the absence of conventional environmental baths. I evaluate the mathematical structure, physical idealisations, and philosophical commitments of the CSM (Contexts, Systems, Modalities) framework within which the argument is embedded. Strengths include the controlled treatment of the infinite limit, explicit computation of sector-parameter convergence, and the proposal of an "algebraic Heisenberg cut". Limitations centre on model idealisation, the persistent role of infinity for full orthogonality, and limited engagement with experimental constraints or competing interpretations. The review situates the contribution against leading global research in decoherence, consistent histories, many-worlds, and algebraic quantum theory. Epistemological and ontological implications are drawn, particularly regarding contextuality, the co-fundamentality of quantum and classical realms, and the status of modalities as primary ontology. Also available on Academia.edu: https://www.academia.edu/attachments/133038530/download_file?s=portfolio

Jun 8, 20260 citations

Anatomical Review of "Heading towards an Algebraic Heisenberg Cut" – Volume III: Experimental Interfaces, Signatures of Sectorisation versus Conventional Decoherence

Syed Muntasir Mamun

This volume turns from the mathematical foundations established in Volumes I and II to the concrete question of experimental testability. We ask how the distinctive mechanism of von Neumann sectorisation—self-decoherence arising solely from the exponential growth of the Hilbert-space dimension in an infinite tensor product—can be isolated from conventional environment-induced decoherence in laboratory settings. Two classes of platforms are examined in detail: (i) carefully engineered mesoscopic detectors in which the number of participating microscopic degrees of freedom can be tuned while external baths are minimised, and (ii) quantum-non-demolition (QND) measurement schemes, both optical and circuitQED based, in which the system under test remains unperturbed. Quantitative signatures are derived: the double-exponential decay of inter-sector overlap as a function of avalanche generation number, the absence of dissipation or heating correlated with coherence loss, and the preservation of system coherence in QND realisations. Feasibility with current technology (superconducting circuits, quantum dots, trapped ions, and Rydberg-atom ensembles) is assessed, together with proposed control experiments that would falsify or confirm the sectorisation picture. The analysis remains anchored in the avalanche-photodiode model of Van Den Bossche and Grangier (2025) while indicating clear pathways toward its generalisation. K 1 S C Also available on Academia.edu: https://www.academia.edu/attachments/133072773/download_file?s=portfolio

Jun 11, 20260 citations

Anatomical Review of "Heading towards an Algebraic Heisenberg Cut" – Volume II: The Centre of the Type-III Algebra, Information Geometry, and Non-Commutative Probability

Syed Muntasir Mamun

Building directly upon Volume I of this series, the present volume undertakes a rigorous mathematical dissection of the emergent von Neumann algebraic structure arising in the infinite-tensor-product (ITP) limit of the avalanche-photodiode model introduced by Van Den Bossche and Grangier (2025). We focus on the precise classification of the centre Z(M) of the type-III von Neumann algebra M generated by the limiting sector parameters. The centre is shown to be a non-trivial abelian von Neumann algebra, isomorphic to L∞ (Ω, µ) where Ω is the space of superselection sectors. We then explore natural embeddings of this centre into the framework of quantum information geometry, interpreting the sector parameters as coordinates on a statistical manifold equipped with the quantum Fisher information metric. Finally, we recast the entire construction within non-commutative probability theory, exhibiting a faithful conditional expectation onto the centre and discussing its implications for the modular automorphism group and the algebraic Heisenberg cut. All arguments remain faithful to the concrete APD dynamics while extending the original analysis into the rich territory of operator algebras, differential geometry on state spaces, and quantum probability. K 1 S Also available on Academia.edu: https://www.academia.edu/attachments/133072735/download_file?s=portfolio

Jun 11, 20260 citations

Algebraic Sectorisation, Information Geometry, and the Quantum-Classical Transition A Synthesis of the Anatomical Reviews (Vol-VI)

Syed Muntasir Mamun

This paper synthesizes the "Anatomical Reviews" to redefine the quantum-classical transition through an intrinsic operator-algebraic framework. It moves away from standard environment-induced decoherence toward a model where classicality emerges from the sectorisation of infinite-dimensional Hilbert spaces within isolated systems. Utilizing the Avalanche Photodiode (APD) model, the study demonstrates that macroscopic definiteness arises from double-exponential divergence in state overlap, creating a rigorous structural transition. The work formalizes this transition as a geometric degeneracy in the quantum Fisher information metric, linking fractal avalanche geometry to Tomita-Takesaki modular theory and providing a falsifiable experimental foundation for the algebraic Heisenberg cut. KSCCN Mamun, SM (2026) ……………………………….1 Algebraic Sectorisation, Information Geometry, and the Quantum-Classical Transition A Synthesis of the Anatomical Reviews (Vol-VI) Also available on Academia.edu: https://www.academia.edu/attachments/133083183/download_file?s=portfolio

Jan 1, 20260 citations

Quantum interference on the non-commutative plane and the quantum-to-classical transition

I B Pittaway, Frederik G. Scholtz

Abstract We explore a possible link between the structure of space at short length scales and the emergence of classical phenomena at macroscopic scales. To this end we adopt the paradigm of non-commutative space at short length scales and explicitly compute the outcomes of a double slit experiment and a von Neumann measurement in the non-commutative plane. A very consistent picture of a continuous quantum-to-classical transition emerges. The mechanism driving this transition is standard decoherence, which arises quite naturally from the tensor product structure of the non-commutative quantum Hilbert space. The double slit calculation enables us to establish a lower bound on the non-commutative parameter for this transition to become effective at particle numbers of the order of Avogadro’s number. Similarly, the result of the von Neumann measurement establishes a criterion involving the non-commutative parameter, apparatus size and coupling between system and apparatus for classicality to emerge.

arXiv:2101.06108Journal of Physics A Mathematical and TheoreticalMar 13, 20236 citations

"Heading towards an Algebraic Heisenberg Cut": Sectorisation, Self-Decoherence, and the Algebraic Foundations of the Quantum–Classical Transition – Volume V: Lifting the Information-Geometric Metric to a Quantum Riemannian Structure on Type-III Algebras and Fractal Quantum States V

Syed Muntasir Mamun

This fifth volume completes the core mathematical arc of the series by lifting the classical information-geometric structure on the centre Z(M) (Volume II) to a full quantum Riemannian geometry on the state space of the emergent type-III algebra M. We construct a quantum Fisher information metric on the manifold of normal states of M that is compatible with the direct-integral decomposition and reduces to the classical Fisher metric on the centre. The resulting Riemannian structure is shown to be invariant under the modular flow and to encode the fractal dimension of the avalanche tree (Volume IV) as a curvature invariant. Connections are drawn to recent developments in quantum information geometry on non-commutative algebras and to the programme of fractal quantum states. The unified Riemannian picture furnishes a geometric characterisation of the algebraic Heisenberg cut as the locus where the quantum metric degenerates to its classical projection. All constructions remain anchored in the avalanche-photodiode model while providing a coherent geometric language that unifies the algebraic, modular, fractal and information-geometric threads developed across the series. K 1 S Also available on Academia.edu: https://www.academia.edu/attachments/133072858/download_file?s=portfolio

Jun 11, 20260 citations