Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2412.13330

Simulating imperfect quantum optical circuits using unsymmetrized bases

John Steinmetz, Maike Ostmann, Alex Neville, Brendan Pankovich, Adel Sohbi

Published Dec 17, 2024• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Fault-tolerant photonic quantum computing requires the generation of large entangled resource states. The required size of these states makes it challenging to simulate the effects of errors such as loss and partial distinguishability. For an interferometer with $N$ partially distinguishable input photons and $M$ spatial modes, the Fock basis can have up to ${N+NM-1\choose N}$ elements. We show that it is possible to use a much smaller unsymmetrized basis with size $M^N$ without discarding any information. This enables simulations of the joint effect of loss and partial distinguishability on larger states than is otherwise possible. We demonstrate the technique by providing the first-ever simulations of the generation of imperfect qubits encoded using quantum parity codes, including an example where the Hilbert space is over $60$ orders of magnitude smaller than the $N$-photon Fock space. As part of the analysis, we derive the loss mechanism for partially distinguishable photons.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2412.13330

Related papers

Simulating lossy and partially distinguishable quantum optical circuits: theory, algorithms, and applications to experiment validation and state preparation

Jacob F. F. Bulmer, Javier Martínez-Cifuentes, Bryn A. Bell +1 more

To understand quantum optics experiments, we must perform calculations that consider the principal sources of noise, such as losses, spectral impurity, and partial distinguishability. In both discrete and continuous variable systems, these can be modeled as mixed Gaussian states over multiple modes. The modes are not all resolved by photon-number measurements and so require calculations on coarse-grained photon-number distributions. Existing methods can lead to a combinatorial explosion in the time complexity, making this task unfeasible for even moderately sized experiments of interest. We prove that the computation of this type of distribution can be done in exponential time, providing a combinatorial speed-up. We develop numerical techniques that allow us to determine coarse-grained photon number distributions of Gaussian states, as well as density matrix elements of heralded non-Gaussian states prepared in the presence of spectral impurity and partial distinguishability. These results offer significant speed-up and accuracy improvements to validation tests of both Fock and Gaussian boson samplers that rely on binned probability distributions. Moreover, they pave the way to a more efficient simulation of realistic photonic circuits, unlocking the ability to perform exact calculations at scales that were previously out of reach. In addition, our results, including loop Hafnian master theorems, may be of interest to the fields of combinatorics and graph theory.

arXiv:2412.17742•Advanced Photonics•Feb 18, 2026•15 citations

Simulating lossy and partially distinguishable quantum optical circuits: theory, algorithms and applications to experiment validation and state preparation

Nicolás Quesada

To understand quantum optics experiments, we must perform calculations that consider the principal sources of noise, such as losses, spectral impurity and partial distinguishability. In both discrete and continuous variable systems, these can be modeled as mixed Gaussian states over multiple modes. The modes are not all resolved by photon-number measurements and so require calculations on coarse-grained photon-number distribution. Existing methods can lead to a combinatorial explosion in the time complexity, making this task unfeasible for even moderate sized experiments of interest. In this work, we prove that the computation of this type of distributions can be done in exponential time, providing a combinatorial speedup. We develop numerical techniques that allow us to determine coarse-grained photon number distributions of Gaussian states, as well as density matrix elements of heralded non-Gaussian states prepared in the presence of spectral impurity and partial distinguishability. These results offer significant speed-up and accuracy improvements to validation tests of both Fock and Gaussian boson samplers that rely on binned probability distributions.

Photonics for Quantum (PfQ)•Jul 18, 2025•1 citation

Distinguishability Errors in Linear Optical Quantum Computing

Chris Sparrow

Proposals for linear optical quantum computation (LOQC) rely on quantum interference between single photons which, when coupled with photon detection, provides a mechanism to generate photonic entanglement. However, ideal quantum interference between photons only occurs if the photons are completely indistinguishable in all degrees of freedom except the one being interfered. In practice, no photons will be perfectly indistinguishable and therefore it is important to understand how using partially-distinguishable photons will affect the quantum information within the linear optical quantum computer. Here we describe how states of partially-distinguishable photons are transformed by linear-optical networks and measured by photon-counting detectors. In addition we show how to calculate the logical content of a given photonic state containing partially-distinguishable photons. Using a realistic model of single photon sources, we then apply these tools to calculate the resulting logical error rates on recent proposals for universal LOQC. Understanding the connection between physical imperfections and logical errors is crucial in assessing the fault-tolerance prospects of a quantum computation platform. Our results will help inform error correction strategies and allow one to specify the necessary fabrication and operational tolerances required for scalability.

•Jan 1, 2016•0 citations

Loss and distinguishability effects in heralded entangled state generation with Gaussian resources

Yun-Long Cao, Xiao-Ye Xu, Wiwittawin Sukmas +2 more

The effects of optical loss and photon distinguishability on the heralded generation of entangled states based on Gaussian resources are quantitatively investigated. By incorporating mode-dependent loss and the statistical characteristics of partially distinguishable photons into a phase-space representation, an efficient numerical framework is established to optimize target-state fidelity and success probability, with a specific focus on the enhancement triggered by non-Gaussian operations such as photon addition and subtraction. The numerical optimization results indicate that a non-vacuum post-selection strategy within a dual-rail encoding framework, combined with the simultaneous tuning of squeezing parameters and the interferometer network, effectively suppresses vacuum noise, enabling the generation of high-fidelity Bell, GHZ, and W states under realistic experimental constraints. The results show that introducing non-Gaussian operations can successfully enhance the state generation performance under realistic imperfections analogous to the enhancements observed under ideal conditions. This study demonstrates that experimental imperfections primarily scale down the success probability rather than fundamentally compromising the state fidelity, providing practical design guidelines for scalable state engineering on integrated photonic platforms.

quant-pharXiv:2607.23048•Jul 28, 2026•0 citations

Errors in heralded circuits for linear optical entanglement generation

Reece D. Shaw, Alex E. Jones, Patrick Yard +1 more

The heralded generation of entangled states underpins many photonic quantum technologies. As quantum error correction thresholds are determined by underlying physical noise mechanisms, a detailed and faithful characterization of resource states is required. Non-computational leakage, e.g. more than one photon occupying a dual-rail encoded qubit, is an error not captured by standard forms of state tomography, which postselect on photons remaining in the computational subspace. Here we use the continuous-variable (CV) formalism and first quantized state representation to develop a simulation framework that reconstructs photonic quantum states in the presence of partial distinguishability and resulting non-computational leakage errors. Using these tools, we analyze a variety of Bell state generation circuits and find that the five photon discrete Fourier transform (DFT) Bell state generation scheme [Phys Rev. Lett. 126 23054 (2021)] is most robust to such errors for near-ideal photons. Through characterization of a photonic entangling gate, we demonstrate how leakage errors prevent a modular characterization of concatenated gates using current tomographical procedures. Our work is a necessary step in revealing the true noise models that must be addressed in fault-tolerant photonic quantum computing architectures.

arXiv:2305.08452•May 15, 2023•10 citations

Tailoring Fusion-Based Photonic Quantum Computing Schemes to Quantum Emitters

Ming Lai Chan, Thomas J. Bell, Love A. Pettersson +4 more

Fusion-based quantum computation is a promising quantum computing model where small-sized photonic resource states are simultaneously entangled and measured by fusion gates. Such operations can be readily implemented with scalable photonic hardware: resource states can be deterministically generated by quantum emitters and fusions require only shallow linear-optical circuits. Here, we propose fusion-based architectures tailored to the capabilities and noise models in quantum emitters. We show that high tolerance to dominant physical error mechanisms can be achieved, with fault-tolerance thresholds of 8% for photon loss, 4% for photon distinguishability between emitters, and spin noise thresholds well above memory-induced errors for typical spin-photon interfaces. Our construction and analysis provide guidelines for the development of photonic quantum hardware targeting fault-tolerant applications with quantum emitters.

arXiv:2410.06784•PRX Quantum•Apr 4, 2025•40 citations
Fault-tolerant photonic quantum computing requires the generation of large entangled resource states. The required size of these states makes it challenging to simulate the effects of errors such as loss and partial distinguishability. For an interferometer with NNN partially distinguishable input photons and MMM spatial modes, the Fock basis can have up to (N+NM−1N){N+NM-1\choose N}(NN+NM−1​) elements. We show that it is possible to use a much smaller unsymmetrized basis with size MNM^NMN without discarding any information. This enables simulations of the joint effect of loss and partial distinguishability on larger states than is otherwise possible. We demonstrate the technique by providing the first-ever simulations of the generation of imperfect qubits encoded using quantum parity codes, including an example where the Hilbert space is over 606060 orders of magnitude smaller than the NNN-photon Fock space. As part of the analysis, we derive the loss mechanism for partially distinguishable photons.
To understand quantum optics experiments, we must perform calculations that consider the principal sources of noise, such as losses, spectral impurity, and partial distinguishability. In both discrete and continuous variable systems, these can be modeled as mixed Gaussian states over multiple modes. The modes are not all resolved by photon-number measurements and so require calculations on coarse-grained photon-number distributions. Existing methods can lead to a combinatorial explosion in the time complexity, making this task unfeasible for even moderately sized experiments of interest. We prove that the computation of this type of distribution can be done in exponential time, providing a combinatorial speed-up. We develop numerical techniques that allow us to determine coarse-grained photon number distributions of Gaussian states, as well as density matrix elements of heralded non-Gaussian states prepared in the presence of spectral impurity and partial distinguishability. These results offer significant speed-up and accuracy improvements to validation tests of both Fock and Gaussian boson samplers that rely on binned probability distributions. Moreover, they pave the way to a more efficient simulation of realistic photonic circuits, unlocking the ability to perform exact calculations at scales that were previously out of reach. In addition, our results, including loop Hafnian master theorems, may be of interest to the fields of combinatorics and graph theory.
To understand quantum optics experiments, we must perform calculations that consider the principal sources of noise, such as losses, spectral impurity and partial distinguishability. In both discrete and continuous variable systems, these can be modeled as mixed Gaussian states over multiple modes. The modes are not all resolved by photon-number measurements and so require calculations on coarse-grained photon-number distribution. Existing methods can lead to a combinatorial explosion in the time complexity, making this task unfeasible for even moderate sized experiments of interest. In this work, we prove that the computation of this type of distributions can be done in exponential time, providing a combinatorial speedup. We develop numerical techniques that allow us to determine coarse-grained photon number distributions of Gaussian states, as well as density matrix elements of heralded non-Gaussian states prepared in the presence of spectral impurity and partial distinguishability. These results offer significant speed-up and accuracy improvements to validation tests of both Fock and Gaussian boson samplers that rely on binned probability distributions.
Proposals for linear optical quantum computation (LOQC) rely on quantum interference between single photons which, when coupled with photon detection, provides a mechanism to generate photonic entanglement. However, ideal quantum interference between photons only occurs if the photons are completely indistinguishable in all degrees of freedom except the one being interfered. In practice, no photons will be perfectly indistinguishable and therefore it is important to understand how using partially-distinguishable photons will affect the quantum information within the linear optical quantum computer. Here we describe how states of partially-distinguishable photons are transformed by linear-optical networks and measured by photon-counting detectors. In addition we show how to calculate the logical content of a given photonic state containing partially-distinguishable photons. Using a realistic model of single photon sources, we then apply these tools to calculate the resulting logical error rates on recent proposals for universal LOQC. Understanding the connection between physical imperfections and logical errors is crucial in assessing the fault-tolerance prospects of a quantum computation platform. Our results will help inform error correction strategies and allow one to specify the necessary fabrication and operational tolerances required for scalability.
The effects of optical loss and photon distinguishability on the heralded generation of entangled states based on Gaussian resources are quantitatively investigated. By incorporating mode-dependent loss and the statistical characteristics of partially distinguishable photons into a phase-space representation, an efficient numerical framework is established to optimize target-state fidelity and success probability, with a specific focus on the enhancement triggered by non-Gaussian operations such as photon addition and subtraction. The numerical optimization results indicate that a non-vacuum post-selection strategy within a dual-rail encoding framework, combined with the simultaneous tuning of squeezing parameters and the interferometer network, effectively suppresses vacuum noise, enabling the generation of high-fidelity Bell, GHZ, and W states under realistic experimental constraints. The results show that introducing non-Gaussian operations can successfully enhance the state generation performance under realistic imperfections analogous to the enhancements observed under ideal conditions. This study demonstrates that experimental imperfections primarily scale down the success probability rather than fundamentally compromising the state fidelity, providing practical design guidelines for scalable state engineering on integrated photonic platforms.
The heralded generation of entangled states underpins many photonic quantum technologies. As quantum error correction thresholds are determined by underlying physical noise mechanisms, a detailed and faithful characterization of resource states is required. Non-computational leakage, e.g. more than one photon occupying a dual-rail encoded qubit, is an error not captured by standard forms of state tomography, which postselect on photons remaining in the computational subspace. Here we use the continuous-variable (CV) formalism and first quantized state representation to develop a simulation framework that reconstructs photonic quantum states in the presence of partial distinguishability and resulting non-computational leakage errors. Using these tools, we analyze a variety of Bell state generation circuits and find that the five photon discrete Fourier transform (DFT) Bell state generation scheme [Phys Rev. Lett. 126 23054 (2021)] is most robust to such errors for near-ideal photons. Through characterization of a photonic entangling gate, we demonstrate how leakage errors prevent a modular characterization of concatenated gates using current tomographical procedures. Our work is a necessary step in revealing the true noise models that must be addressed in fault-tolerant photonic quantum computing architectures.
Fusion-based quantum computation is a promising quantum computing model where small-sized photonic resource states are simultaneously entangled and measured by fusion gates. Such operations can be readily implemented with scalable photonic hardware: resource states can be deterministically generated by quantum emitters and fusions require only shallow linear-optical circuits. Here, we propose fusion-based architectures tailored to the capabilities and noise models in quantum emitters. We show that high tolerance to dominant physical error mechanisms can be achieved, with fault-tolerance thresholds of 8% for photon loss, 4% for photon distinguishability between emitters, and spin noise thresholds well above memory-induced errors for typical spin-photon interfaces. Our construction and analysis provide guidelines for the development of photonic quantum hardware targeting fault-tolerant applications with quantum emitters.