Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2412.10280 · Physical Review Research

Fractonic superfluids. III. Hybridizing higher moments

Han-Xie Wang, Shuai A. Chen, Peng Ye

Published Jul 14, 2025• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Fractonic superfluids are featured by the interplay of spontaneously broken charge symmetry and mobility constraints on single-particle kinematics due to the conservation of higher moments, such as dipoles, angular charge moments, and quadrupoles. Building on prior studies by Yuan [] and Chen [], we study a class of fractonic superfluids, termed (HFS), in which bosons of multiple species interact while moment hybridization is conserved. We explore the consequences of hybridization via two model series: , conserving total moments of the same order across species, and , conserving total moments of different orders. In Model Series A, we analyze dipole moment hybridization and extend the discussion to higher-order moments, examining the ground state, Goldstone modes, correlation functions, and so on. We compute the minimal spatial dimensions, where the total charge symmetry begins to get partially broken via particle-hole condensation, leading to true off-diagonal long-range order. In Model Series B, we focus on HFS with hybrid dipole-quadrupole conservation. For both series, we introduce Bose-Hubbard–type lattice models that reduce to either of both series in the weak Hubbard interaction regime. We perform a mean-field analysis on the global phase diagram and discuss experimental realizations in strongly tilted optical lattices via a third-order perturbation theory. This work, alongside prior studies, completes a trilogy on fractonic superfluids, uncovering symmetry-breaking physics emerging from higher moment conservation, leaving various promising studies for future investigation.

DOI
10.1103/jvs9-6qkn

Related papers

Many-body physics of spontaneously broken higher-rank symmetry: from fractonic superfluids to dipolar Hubbard model

Shuai A. Chen, Peng Ye

Fractonic superfluids are exotic phases of matter in which bosons are subject to mobility constraints, resulting in features beyond those of conventional superfluids. These exotic phases arise from the spontaneous breaking of higher-rank symmetry (HRS) in many-body systems with higher-moment conservation, such as dipoles, quadrupoles, and angular moments. The aim of this paper is to introduce exciting developments on the theory of spontaneous symmetry breaking in such systems, which we refer to as ``many-fracton systems''. More specifically, we introduce exciting progress on general aspects of HRS, minimal model construction, realization of symmetry-breaking ground states, order parameter, off-diagonal long-range order (ODLRO), Noether currents with continuity equations, Gross-Pitaevskii equations, quantum fluctuations, Goldstone modes, specific heat, generalized Mermin-Wagner theorem, critical current, Landau criterion, symmetry defects, and Kosterlitz-Thouless (KT)-like physics, hydrodynamics, and dipolar Hubbard model realization. This paper is concluded with several future directions.

arXiv:2305.00941•May 1, 2023•1 citation

Hierarchical proliferation of higher-rank symmetry defects in fractonic superfluids

Jian-Keng Yuan, Shuai A. Chen, Peng Ye

Symmetry defects, e.g., vortices in conventional superfluids, play a critical role in a complete description of symmetry breaking phases. In this paper, we develop the theory of symmetry defects in fractonic superfluids, i.e., spontaneously higher-rank symmetry (HRS) breaking phases initially proposed by Yuan et al. [Phys. Rev. Res. 2, 023267 (2020)] and by Chen et al. [Phys. Rev. Res. 3, 013226 (2021)]. By Noether's theorem, HRS is associated with the conservation law of higher moments, e.g., dipoles, quadrupoles, and angular moments. We establish finite-temperature phase diagrams by identifying a series of topological phase transitions via the renormalization group flow equations and Debye-H\"uckel approximation. Accordingly, a series of Kosterlitz-Thouless topological transitions are found to occur successively at different temperatures, which are triggered by proliferation of defects, defect bound states, and so on. Such a hierarchical proliferation brings rich phase structures. Meanwhile, a screening effect from sufficiently high density of defect bound states leads to instability and collapse of the intermediate temperature phases, which further enriches the phase diagrams. For concreteness, we consider a fractonic superfluid in which ``angular moments'' are conserved. We then present the general theory, in which other types of HRS can be analyzed in a similar manner. Further directions are present at the end of the paper.

arXiv:2201.08597•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•May 18, 2023•11 citations

Fractonic superfluids. II. Condensing subdimensional particles

Shuai A. Chen, Jian-Keng Yuan, Peng Ye

As a series of work about "fractonic superfluids," in this paper, we develop an exotic fractonic superfluid phase in d-dimensional space where subdimensional particles-their mobility is partially restricted-are condensed.The off-diagonal long range order (ODLRO) is investigated.To demonstrate, we consider "lineons"-a subdimensional particle whose mobility is free only in certain one-dimensional directions.We start with a d-component microscopic Hamiltonian model.The model respects a higher-rank symmetry such that both particle numbers of each component and angular charge moments are conserved quantities.By performing the Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov approximation, we derive a set of Gross-Pitaevskii equations and a Bogoliubov-de Gennes (BdG) Hamiltonian, which leads to a description of both condensed components and unification of gapless phonons and gapped rotons.With the coherent-path-integral representation, we also derive the longwavelength effective field theory of gapless Goldstone modes and analyze quantum fluctuations around classical ground states.The Euler-Lagrange equations and Noether charges/currents are also studied.In two spatial dimensions and higher, such an ODLRO stays stable against quantum fluctuations.Finally, we study vortex configurations.The higher-rank symmetry enforces a hierarchy of thermal vortex excitations whose structures are dominated by two guiding statements.Specially, we construct two types of vortex excitations, the conventional and dipole vortices.The latter carries a charge with dimension as a momentum.The two statements can be more generally applicable.Further perspectives are discussed.

arXiv:2010.03261•Physical Review Research•Mar 9, 2021•39 citations

Large NNN fractons

Kristan Jensen, Amir Raz

We consider theories of fractons with $N$ fields. These theories have exotic spacetime symmetries, including a conserved dipole moment. Using collective fields we solve these models to leading order in large $N$. The large $N$ solution reveals that these models are strongly correlated, and that interactions generate a momentum-dependent self-energy. Dipole symmetry is spontaneously broken throughout the phase diagram of these models, leading to a low-energy Goldstone description of what we dub "dipole superfluids."

arXiv:2205.01132•May 2, 2022•10 citations

Fracton superfluid hydrodynamics

Charles Stahl, Marvin Qi, Paolo Glorioso +2 more

We examine the hydrodynamics of systems with spontaneously broken multipolar symmetries using a systematic effective field theory. We focus on the simplest nontrivial setting: a system with charge and dipole symmetry, but without momentum conservation. When no symmetries are broken, our formalism reproduces the quartic subdiffusion ($\ensuremath{\omega}\ensuremath{\sim}\ensuremath{-}i{k}^{4}$) characteristic of ``fracton hydrodynamics'' with conserved dipole moment. Our formalism also captures spontaneous breaking of charge and/or dipole symmetry. When charge symmetry is spontaneously broken, the hydrodynamic modes are quadratically propagating and quartically relaxing ($\ensuremath{\omega}\ensuremath{\sim}\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}{k}^{2}\ensuremath{-}i{k}^{4}$). When the dipole symmetry is spontaneously broken but the charge symmetry is preserved, then we find quadratically relaxing (diffusive) transverse modes, plus another mode which, depending on parameters, may be either purely diffusive ($\ensuremath{\omega}\ensuremath{\sim}\ensuremath{-}i{k}^{2}$) or quadratically propagating and quadratically relaxing ($\ensuremath{\omega}\ensuremath{\sim}\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}{k}^{2}\ensuremath{-}i{k}^{2}$). Our work provides concrete predictions that may be tested in near-term cold atom experiments, and also lays out a general framework that may be applied to study systems with spontaneously broken multipolar symmetries.

arXiv:2303.09573•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Oct 20, 2023•20 citations

Ideal fracton superfluids

Jácome Armas, Emil Have

We investigate the thermodynamics of equilibrium thermal states and their near-equilibrium dynamics in systems with fractonic symmetries in arbitrary curved space. By explicitly gauging the fracton algebra we obtain the geometry and gauge fields that field theories with conserved dipole moment couple to. We use the resultant fracton geometry to show that it is not possible to construct an equilibrium partition function for global thermal states unless part of the fractonic symmetries is spontaneously broken. This leads us to introduce two classes of fracton superfluids with conserved energy and momentum, namely p p -wave and s s -wave fracton superfluids. The latter phase is an Aristotelian superfluid at ideal order but with a velocity constraint and can be split into two separate regimes: The U(1) fracton superfluid and the pinned s s -wave superfluid regimes. For each of these classes and regimes we formulate a hydrodynamic expansion and study the resultant modes. We find distinctive features of each of these phases and regimes at ideal order in gradients, without introducing dissipative effects. In particular we note the appearance of a sound mode for s s -wave fracton superfluids. We show that previous work on fracton hydrodynamics falls into these classes. Finally, we study ultra-dense p p -wave fracton superfluids with a large kinetic mass in addition to studying the thermodynamics of ideal Aristotelian superfluids.

arXiv:2304.09596•SciPost Physics•Jan 30, 2024•29 citations
Fractonic superfluids are featured by the interplay of spontaneously broken charge symmetry and mobility constraints on single-particle kinematics due to the conservation of higher moments, such as dipoles, angular charge moments, and quadrupoles. Building on prior studies by Yuan [] and Chen [], we study a class of fractonic superfluids, termed (HFS), in which bosons of multiple species interact while moment hybridization is conserved. We explore the consequences of hybridization via two model series: , conserving total moments of the same order across species, and , conserving total moments of different orders. In Model Series A, we analyze dipole moment hybridization and extend the discussion to higher-order moments, examining the ground state, Goldstone modes, correlation functions, and so on. We compute the minimal spatial dimensions, where the total charge symmetry begins to get partially broken via particle-hole condensation, leading to true off-diagonal long-range order. In Model Series B, we focus on HFS with hybrid dipole-quadrupole conservation. For both series, we introduce Bose-Hubbard–type lattice models that reduce to either of both series in the weak Hubbard interaction regime. We perform a mean-field analysis on the global phase diagram and discuss experimental realizations in strongly tilted optical lattices via a third-order perturbation theory. This work, alongside prior studies, completes a trilogy on fractonic superfluids, uncovering symmetry-breaking physics emerging from higher moment conservation, leaving various promising studies for future investigation.
Fractonic superfluids are exotic phases of matter in which bosons are subject to mobility constraints, resulting in features beyond those of conventional superfluids. These exotic phases arise from the spontaneous breaking of higher-rank symmetry (HRS) in many-body systems with higher-moment conservation, such as dipoles, quadrupoles, and angular moments. The aim of this paper is to introduce exciting developments on the theory of spontaneous symmetry breaking in such systems, which we refer to as ``many-fracton systems''. More specifically, we introduce exciting progress on general aspects of HRS, minimal model construction, realization of symmetry-breaking ground states, order parameter, off-diagonal long-range order (ODLRO), Noether currents with continuity equations, Gross-Pitaevskii equations, quantum fluctuations, Goldstone modes, specific heat, generalized Mermin-Wagner theorem, critical current, Landau criterion, symmetry defects, and Kosterlitz-Thouless (KT)-like physics, hydrodynamics, and dipolar Hubbard model realization. This paper is concluded with several future directions.
Symmetry defects, e.g., vortices in conventional superfluids, play a critical role in a complete description of symmetry breaking phases. In this paper, we develop the theory of symmetry defects in fractonic superfluids, i.e., spontaneously higher-rank symmetry (HRS) breaking phases initially proposed by Yuan et al. [Phys. Rev. Res. 2, 023267 (2020)] and by Chen et al. [Phys. Rev. Res. 3, 013226 (2021)]. By Noether's theorem, HRS is associated with the conservation law of higher moments, e.g., dipoles, quadrupoles, and angular moments. We establish finite-temperature phase diagrams by identifying a series of topological phase transitions via the renormalization group flow equations and Debye-H\"uckel approximation. Accordingly, a series of Kosterlitz-Thouless topological transitions are found to occur successively at different temperatures, which are triggered by proliferation of defects, defect bound states, and so on. Such a hierarchical proliferation brings rich phase structures. Meanwhile, a screening effect from sufficiently high density of defect bound states leads to instability and collapse of the intermediate temperature phases, which further enriches the phase diagrams. For concreteness, we consider a fractonic superfluid in which ``angular moments'' are conserved. We then present the general theory, in which other types of HRS can be analyzed in a similar manner. Further directions are present at the end of the paper.
As a series of work about "fractonic superfluids," in this paper, we develop an exotic fractonic superfluid phase in d-dimensional space where subdimensional particles-their mobility is partially restricted-are condensed.The off-diagonal long range order (ODLRO) is investigated.To demonstrate, we consider "lineons"-a subdimensional particle whose mobility is free only in certain one-dimensional directions.We start with a d-component microscopic Hamiltonian model.The model respects a higher-rank symmetry such that both particle numbers of each component and angular charge moments are conserved quantities.By performing the Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov approximation, we derive a set of Gross-Pitaevskii equations and a Bogoliubov-de Gennes (BdG) Hamiltonian, which leads to a description of both condensed components and unification of gapless phonons and gapped rotons.With the coherent-path-integral representation, we also derive the longwavelength effective field theory of gapless Goldstone modes and analyze quantum fluctuations around classical ground states.The Euler-Lagrange equations and Noether charges/currents are also studied.In two spatial dimensions and higher, such an ODLRO stays stable against quantum fluctuations.Finally, we study vortex configurations.The higher-rank symmetry enforces a hierarchy of thermal vortex excitations whose structures are dominated by two guiding statements.Specially, we construct two types of vortex excitations, the conventional and dipole vortices.The latter carries a charge with dimension as a momentum.The two statements can be more generally applicable.Further perspectives are discussed.
We consider theories of fractons with NNN fields. These theories have exotic spacetime symmetries, including a conserved dipole moment. Using collective fields we solve these models to leading order in large NNN. The large NNN solution reveals that these models are strongly correlated, and that interactions generate a momentum-dependent self-energy. Dipole symmetry is spontaneously broken throughout the phase diagram of these models, leading to a low-energy Goldstone description of what we dub "dipole superfluids."
We examine the hydrodynamics of systems with spontaneously broken multipolar symmetries using a systematic effective field theory. We focus on the simplest nontrivial setting: a system with charge and dipole symmetry, but without momentum conservation. When no symmetries are broken, our formalism reproduces the quartic subdiffusion ($\ensuremath{\omega}\ensuremath{\sim}\ensuremath{-}i{k}^{4}$) characteristic of ``fracton hydrodynamics'' with conserved dipole moment. Our formalism also captures spontaneous breaking of charge and/or dipole symmetry. When charge symmetry is spontaneously broken, the hydrodynamic modes are quadratically propagating and quartically relaxing ($\ensuremath{\omega}\ensuremath{\sim}\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}{k}^{2}\ensuremath{-}i{k}^{4}$). When the dipole symmetry is spontaneously broken but the charge symmetry is preserved, then we find quadratically relaxing (diffusive) transverse modes, plus another mode which, depending on parameters, may be either purely diffusive ($\ensuremath{\omega}\ensuremath{\sim}\ensuremath{-}i{k}^{2}$) or quadratically propagating and quadratically relaxing ($\ensuremath{\omega}\ensuremath{\sim}\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}{k}^{2}\ensuremath{-}i{k}^{2}$). Our work provides concrete predictions that may be tested in near-term cold atom experiments, and also lays out a general framework that may be applied to study systems with spontaneously broken multipolar symmetries.
We investigate the thermodynamics of equilibrium thermal states and their near-equilibrium dynamics in systems with fractonic symmetries in arbitrary curved space. By explicitly gauging the fracton algebra we obtain the geometry and gauge fields that field theories with conserved dipole moment couple to. We use the resultant fracton geometry to show that it is not possible to construct an equilibrium partition function for global thermal states unless part of the fractonic symmetries is spontaneously broken. This leads us to introduce two classes of fracton superfluids with conserved energy and momentum, namely p p -wave and s s -wave fracton superfluids. The latter phase is an Aristotelian superfluid at ideal order but with a velocity constraint and can be split into two separate regimes: The U(1) fracton superfluid and the pinned s s -wave superfluid regimes. For each of these classes and regimes we formulate a hydrodynamic expansion and study the resultant modes. We find distinctive features of each of these phases and regimes at ideal order in gradients, without introducing dissipative effects. In particular we note the appearance of a sound mode for s s -wave fracton superfluids. We show that previous work on fracton hydrodynamics falls into these classes. Finally, we study ultra-dense p p -wave fracton superfluids with a large kinetic mass in addition to studying the thermodynamics of ideal Aristotelian superfluids.