arXiv:2412.06562 · IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity
Towards Novel Tunability Schemes for Hybrid Ferromagnetic Transmon Qubits
Halima Giovanna Ahmad, Raffaella Ferraiuolo, Giuseppe Serpico, Roberta Satariano, Anna Levochkina, Antonio Vettoliere, C. Granata, Domenico Montemurro, Martina Esposito, G. Ausanio, L. Parlato, Giovanni Piero Pepe, Alessandro Bruno, Francesco Tafuri, D. Massarotti
Flux tuning of qubit frequencies in superconducting quantum processors is fundamental for implementing single and multi-qubit gates in quantum algorithms. Typical architectures involve the use of DC or fast RF lines. However, these lines introduce significant heat dissipation and undesirable decoherence mechanisms, leading to a severe bottleneck for scalability. Among different solutions to overcome this issue, we propose integrating tunnel Superconductor-Insulating-thin superconducting interlayer-Ferromagnet-Superconductor Josephson junctions (SIsFS JJs) into a novel transmon qubit design, the so-called ferrotransmon. SIsFS JJs provide memory properties due to the presence of ferromagnetic barriers and preserve at the same time the low-dissipative behavior of tunnel-insulating JJs, thus promoting an alternative tuning of the qubit frequency. In this work, we discuss the fundamental steps towards the implementation of this hybrid ferromagnetic transmon. We will give a special focus on the design, simulations, and preliminary experimental characterization of superconducting lines to provide in-plane magnetic fields, fundamental for an on-chip control of the qubit frequencies in the ferrotransmon.
Flux tuning of qubit frequencies in superconducting quantum processors is fundamental for implementing single and multi-qubit gates in quantum algorithms. Typical architectures involve the use of DC or fast RF lines. However, these lines introduce significant heat dissipation and undesirable decoherence mechanisms, leading to a severe bottleneck for scalability. Among different solutions to overcome this issue, we propose integrating tunnel Superconductor-Insulating-thin superconducting interlayer-Ferromagnet-Superconductor Josephson junctions (SIsFS JJs) into a novel transmon qubit design, the so-called ferrotransmon. SIsFS JJs provide memory properties due to the presence of ferromagnetic barriers and preserve at the same time the low-dissipative behavior of tunnel-insulating JJs, thus promoting an alternative tuning of the qubit frequency. In this work, we discuss the fundamental steps towards the implementation of this hybrid ferromagnetic transmon. We will give a special focus on the design, simulations, and preliminary experimental characterization of superconducting lines to provide in-plane magnetic fields, fundamental for an on-chip control of the qubit frequencies in the ferrotransmon.
We discuss the capabilities of ferromagnetic (F) Josephson junctions (JJs) in a variety of layouts and configurations. The main goal is to demonstrate the potential of these hybrid JJs to disclose new physics and the possibility to integrate them in superconducting classical and quantum electronics for various applications. The feasible path towards the use of ferromagnetic Josephson junctions in quantum circuits starts from experiments demonstrating macroscopic quantum tunneling in NbN/GdN/NbN junctions with ferro-insulator barriers and with triplet components of the supercurrent, supported by a self-consistent electrodynamic characterization as a function of the barrier thickness. This has inspired further studies on tunnel ferromagnetic junctions with a different layout and promoted the first generation of ferromagnetic Al-based JJs, specifically Al/AlOx/Al/Py/Al. This layout takes advantage of the capability to integrate the ferromagnetic layer in the junction without affecting the quality of the superconducting electrodes and of the tunnel barrier. The high quality of the devices paves the way for the possible implementation of Al tunnel-ferromagnetic JJs in superconducting quantum circuits. These achievements have promoted the notion of a novel type of qubit incorporating ferromagnetic JJs. This qubit is based on a transmon design featuring a tunnel JJ in parallel with a ferromagnetic JJ inside a SQUID loop capacitively coupled to a superconducting readout resonator. The effect of an external RF field on the magnetic switching processes of ferromagnetic JJs has been also investigated.
The coexistence between ferromagnetic ordering and superconducting transport in tunnel ferromagnetic Josephson junctions (SFS JJs) accounts for a wide range of unconventional physical properties. The integration of both insulating ferromagnets or multi-layered insulator-ferromagnet barriers allows to combine ferromagnetic switching properties with peculiar low quasiparticle dissipation, which could enhance the capabilities of SFS JJs as active elements in quantum circuits. Here we show that split-transmon qubits based on tunnel ferromagnetic JJs realize an ideal playground to study noise fluctuations in ferromagnetic Josephson devices. By considering the transport properties of measured Al-based tunnel SFS JJs, we report on a theoretical study of the competition between intrinsic magnetization fluctuations in the barrier and quasiparticles dissipation, thus providing specific operation regimes to identify and disentangle the two noise sources, depending on the peculiar properties of the F layer and F/S interface.
We propose to exploit currently available tunnel ferromagnetic Josephson junctions to realize a hybrid superconducting qubit. We show that the characteristic hysteretic behavior of the ferromagnetic barrier provides an alternative and intrinsically digital tuning of the qubit frequency by means of magnetic field pulses. To illustrate functionalities and limitation of the device, we discuss the coupling to a readout resonator and the effect of magnetic fluctuations. The possibility to use the qubit as a noise detector and its relevance to investigate the subtle interplay of magnetism and superconductivity is envisaged.
Superconducting transmon qubits based on hybrid superconductor-semiconductor Josephson junctions (gatemons) offer gate tunability, but their relaxation times remain well below those of state-of-the-art transmons, and the origin of this discrepancy is not fully understood. Here, we co-fabricate gatemons and SIS-junction transmons with nominally identical circuit layouts, gate dielectrics, and control lines, so that the Josephson element is the only intentional distinction. Across multiple chips, transmons in this architecture reach relaxation times in the tens of microseconds, whereas gatemons saturate in the few-microsecond range. Using the transmons as on-chip references, we construct a loss budget including Purcell decay, spontaneous emission through the control line, and internal dielectric loss, and find that the corresponding T1 limits exceed all measured gatemon values by more than an order of magnitude. Temperature-dependent T1 measurements follow a common quasiparticle-activation model and yield similar superconducting gaps for S-Sm-S and SIS junctions, indicating that the reduced gatemon coherence is dominated by additional temperature-independent, junction-intrinsic dissipation.
Superconducting qubit based on superconducting circuits consist of a superconducting capacitor and a Josephson junction with the transmon geometry is extensively used in advanced quantum processors, pursuing scalable quantum computing. The tuning of the qubit frequency of the transmon relies on magnetic flux dependent interference between the supercurrents of two superconductor-insulator superconductor(S-I-S) Josephson junctions in a superconducting loop. Josephson junction based on superconductor-semiconductor-superconductor (S-Sm-S) materialsopens up a possibility to the gate-tunable transmon, referred to as the "gatemon", in which the qubit frequency can be tuned by electrostatic mean. Recent realizations of gatemons on III-V material platforms show impressive development on the alternative to the transmon, yet still leave a big question on the scalability. The silicon-germanium (SiGe) heterostructure is one of the potential platforms to host hybrid devices due to its high hole mobility and the low Schottky barrier at the Ge-metal interface. Additionally, the compatibility with the silicon-based semiconductor industry is a capable advantage for the scaling-up qubit platform.In this thesis, we develop gatemons based on the Al-Ge-Al Josephson junction in the SiGe heterostructure. Firstly, the robust fabrication recipe, found on a top down approach, for Josephson Field Effect Transistors (JoFETs) is established. We perform measurements exhaustively on the JoFETs to study their properties as a function of the gate voltage, temperature, and magnetic field. The devices show gate-tunability of the critical current (IC) and the normal state resistance (RN). The devices are estimated to have a high-transparency superconductor/semiconductor interface, as demonstrated by the high ICRN product on the SiGe heterostructure. In the finite-voltage regime, the features corresponded to multiple Andreev reflections (MARs) are observed. Then, we fabricate and characterize niobium nitride (NbN) superconducting resonators on SiGe heterostructure. We measure the resonators in the transmission mode and extract the resonant frequency (fr), internal quality factor (Qi), and coupling quality factor (Qc) from the transmission coefficient (S21). Following that, we develop the fabrication process to integrate Al-Ge-Al junctions shunted with capacitors, or, in other words,gatemon, into the resonator scheme and perform the fabrication according to the design. We demonstrate the anticrossing feature in one of the fabricated gatemons. The resonant frequency of the gatemon is mapped using the two-tone spectroscopy technique and is found to be gate-tunable. The qubit has large spectral linewidth, implying a low coherence time. Additionally, we conduct the current-phase relationship (CPR) measurement on the junctions in the Superconducting QUantum Interference Device (SQUID) geometry. We can demonstrate that the junctions pose non-sinusoidal CPR. Further, the integer and half-integer Shapiro steps are observed in the current-voltage characteristic curves of irradiated junctions. This indicates that our junctions have the cos 2φ element, which can open up another possibility toward protected qubits.
Superconducting qubit based on superconducting circuits consist of a superconducting capacitor and a Josephson junction with the transmon geometry is extensively used in advanced quantum processors, pursuing scalable quantum computing. The tuning of the qubit frequency of the transmon relies on magnetic flux-dependent interference between the supercurrents of two superconductor-insulator-superconductor (S-I-S) Josephson junctions in a superconducting loop. Josephson junction based on superconductor-semiconductor-superconductor (S-Sm-S) materials opens up a possibility to the gate-tunable transmon, referred to as the "gatemon", in which the qubit frequency can be tuned by electrostatic mean. Recent realizations of gatemons on III-V material platforms show impressive development on the alternative to the transmon, yet still leave a big question on the scalability. The silicon-germanium (SiGe) heterostructure is one of the potential platforms to host hybrid devices due to its high hole mobility and the low Schottky barrier at the Ge-metal interface. Additionally, the compatibility with the silicon-based semiconductor industry is a capable advantage for the scaling-up qubit platform.In this thesis, we develop gatemons based on the Al-Ge-Al Josephson junction in the SiGe heterostructure. Firstly, the robust fabrication recipe, found on a top-down approach, for Josephson Field Effect Transistors (JoFETs) is established. We perform measurements exhaustively on the JoFETs to study their properties as a function of the gate voltage, temperature, and magnetic field. The devices show gate-tunability of the critical current and the normal state resistance . The devices are estimated to have a high-transparency superconductor-semiconductor interface, as demonstrated by the high product on the SiGe heterostructure. In the finite-voltage regime, the features corresponded to multiple Andreev reflections (MARs) are observed. Then, we fabricate and characterize niobium nitride (NbN) superconducting resonators on SiGe heterostructure. We measure the resonators in the transmission mode and extract the resonant frequency , internal quality factor, and coupling quality factor from the transmission coefficient. Following that, we develop the fabrication process to integrate Al-Ge-Al junctions shunted with capacitors, or, in other words, gatemon, into the resonator scheme and perform the fabrication according to the design. We demonstrate the anticrossing feature in one of the fabricated gatemons. The resonant frequency of the gatemon is mapped using the two-tone spectroscopy technique and is found to be gate-tunable. The qubit has large spectral linewidth, implying a low coherence time. Additionally, we conduct the current-phase relationship (CPR) measurement on the junctions in the Superconducting QUantum Interference Device (SQUID) geometry. We can demonstrate that the junctions pose non-sinusoidal CPR. Further, the integer and half-integer Shapiro steps are observed in the current-voltage characteristic curves of irradiated junctions. This indicates that our junctions have the element, which can open up another possibility toward protected qubits.