Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2411.13705 · Journal of High Energy Physics

A critical state under weak measurement is not critical

Qicheng Tang, Xueda Wen

Published Sep 19, 2025• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A bstract Critical systems host nontrivial entanglement structure that is generally sensitive to additional couplings. In the present work, we study the effect of weak measurements on the entanglement Hamiltonian of massless free fermions which are prepared in their critical ground state. While the power-law decaying correlation and logarithmic growing entanglement entropy have been observed as typical signatures of quantum criticality after the weak measurement, in this work we show that the conformal symmetry is lost and the entanglement Hamiltonian generally becomes gapped for arbitrary small measurement strength. To reveal this unconventional entanglement structure, we consider a field-theory description that allows us to establish an analytic mapping between the entanglement Hamiltonians before and after the weak measurements. From this mapping, we find that although the measurements lead to a significant modification of the entanglement spectrum, the real-space distribution of the eigenfunction of the kernel of entanglement Hamiltonian is unchanged, which is responsible for the coexistence of a gapped entanglement Hamiltonian and the logarithmic entanglement entropy. Moreover, as the mapping works for arbitrarily many disjoint intervals, the multi-interval entanglement entropy also exhibits the same scaling behavior as the critical ground state, and shares the same effective central charge with the single-interval case. We numerically demonstrate these field-theory results on a lattice model, where the entanglement Hamiltonian after weak measurements exhibits the typical signature of a finite gap and becomes long-ranged even in the single-interval case. This is distinct from the critical ground state, where the entanglement Hamiltonian for a single interval is gapless and local.

DOI
10.1007/jhep09(2025)168

Related papers

Entanglement in a one-dimensional critical state after measurements

Zhou Yang, Dan Mao, Chao‐Ming Jian

The entanglement entropy (EE) of the ground state of a one-dimensional Hamiltonian at criticality has a universal logarithmic scaling with a prefactor given by the central charge $c$ of the underlying $(1+1)$-dimensional conformal field theory. When the system is probed by measurements, the entanglement in the critical ground state is inevitably affected due to wave-function collapse. In this paper, we study the effect of weak measurements on the entanglement scaling in the ground state of the one-dimensional critical transverse-field Ising model. For the measurements of the spins along their transverse spin axis, we identify interesting postmeasurement states associated with spatially uniform measurement outcomes. The EE in these states still satisfies the logarithmic scaling but with an alternative prefactor given by the effective central charge ${c}_{\mathrm{eff}}$. We derive the analytical expression of ${c}_{\mathrm{eff}}$ as a function of the measurement strength. With both numerical simulations and analytical studies, we show that for the EE averaged over all postmeasurement states based on their Born-rule probabilities, the effective central charge is independent of the measurement strength, contrary to the usual expectation that local and nonoverlapping measurements reduce the entanglement in the system. We also examine the behavior of the average EE under (biased) forced measurements where the measurement outcomes are sampled with a predetermined probability distribution without intersite correlations. In particular, we find an optimal probability distribution that can serve as a mean-field approximation to the Born-rule probabilities and lead to the same ${c}_{\mathrm{eff}}$ behavior. The effects of the measurements along the longitudinal spin axis and the postmeasurement correlation functions are also discussed.

arXiv:2301.08255•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Oct 13, 2023•47 citations

Nonlocality and entanglement in measured critical quantum Ising chains

Zack Weinstein, Rohith Sajith, Ehud Altman +1 more

We study the effects of measurements, performed with a finite density in space, on the ground state of the one-dimensional transverse-field Ising model at criticality. Local degrees of freedom in critical states exhibit long-range entanglement, and as a result, local measurements can have highly nonlocal effects. Our analytical investigation of correlations and entanglement in the ensemble of measured states is based on properties of the Ising conformal field theory (CFT), where measurements appear as $(1+0)$-dimensional defects in the $(1+1)$-dimensional Euclidean spacetime. So that we can verify our predictions using large-scale free-fermion numerics, we restrict ourselves to parity-symmetric measurements. To describe their averaged effects analytically we use a replica approach, and we show that the defect arising in the replica theory is an irrelevant perturbation to the Ising CFT. Strikingly, the asymptotic scalings of averaged correlations and entanglement entropy are therefore unchanged relative to the ground state. In contrast, the defect generated by postselecting on the most likely measurement outcomes is exactly marginal. We then find that the exponent governing postmeasurement order parameter correlations, as well as the ``effective central charge'' governing the scaling of entanglement entropy, vary continuously with the density of measurements in space. Our work establishes connections between the effects of measurements on many-body quantum states and of physical defects on low-energy equilibrium properties.

arXiv:2301.08268•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jun 22, 2023•40 citations

Universal crossovers in weakly-monitored quantum critical states

Abhishek Kumar, Rushikesh A. Patil, Andreas W. W. Ludwig +1 more

We study post-measurement ensembles of ground states of tricritical and critical 1D quantum Ising Hamiltonians subjected, respectively, to weak energy and spin measurements without post-selection. These measurements act as relevant perturbations about the unmeasured critical ground states. Using finite-size renormalization group (RG) crossover analyses, we characterize their universal properties through the entanglement effective central charge, effective Affleck-Ludwig boundary entropy, and signatures of multifractality from moments of measurement-averaged correlation functions. In both cases, we find evidence for "measurement-dominated" or "measurement-altered" fixed points governed by the underlying Born-rule randomness. For critical Ising, we find a direct RG flow to a projective-measurement fixed point with area-law entanglement, whereas for the tricritical Ising model, we find evidence for a weak-measurement fixed point with logarithmic entanglement. These results clarify the RG-flow structure of weakly measured multicritical Ising ground states and show how intrinsic measurement-induced randomness can generate complex and rich universal long-distance scaling behavior in the post-measurement ensembles, accessible to controlled analytical RG and numerical finite-size RG crossover analyses.

arXiv:2608.02716•Aug 3, 2026•0 citations

Effective Hamiltonian description on monitored Majorana chains: correlated power-law hoppings and unconventional entanglement scaling

Ken Mochizuki, Hisanori Oshima, Ryusuke Hamazaki +1 more

We investigate the structure of effective Hamiltonians governing monitored dynamics of a one-dimensional Majorana chain using Lyapunov spectral analysis. We focus on the gapless phase of the Lyapunov spectrum, where the effective Hamiltonians behave differently from conventional critical Hamiltonians in isolated systems; the spectral gap closes faster than $1/L$ but slower than $1/L^2$ and the entanglement entropy grows as $[\ln(L)]^2$ where $L$ is the system size. We find that the effective Hamiltonians have random long-range power-law hoppings with nontrivial magnitude correlations, rather than being independently and identically distributed. To elucidate the role of these non-Gaussian correlations, we construct random power-law hopping models that capture the essential features of the effective Hamiltonians. The spectral gaps of the constructed models decay faster than $1/L$ but slower than $1/L^2$. We find that, in the absence of hopping correlations, the ground-state entanglement exhibits $\ln(L)$ scaling. In the presence of correlations, by contrast, the entanglement entropy is enhanced and its system-size dependence is consistent with $[\ln(L)]^2$ scaling over the system sizes studied. These results suggest that correlations among long-range hopping magnitudes are responsible for the entanglement scaling rarely encountered in the ground states of conventional isolated quantum systems.

cond-mat.stat-mechCross-listedarXiv:2609.04091•Sep 4, 2026•0 citations

Entanglement Hamiltonians for non-critical quantum chains

Viktor Eisler, Giuseppe Di Giulio, Erik Tonni C +1 more

Abstract We study the entanglement Hamiltonian for finite intervals in infinite quantum chains for two different free-particle systems: coupled harmonic oscillators and fermionic hopping models with dimerization. Working in the ground state, the entanglement Hamiltonian describes again free bosons or fermions and is obtained from the correlation functions via high-precision numerics for up to several hundred sites. Far away from criticality, the dominant on-site and nearest-neighbour terms have triangular profiles that can be understood from the analytical results for a half-infinite interval. Near criticality, the longer-range couplings, although small, lead to a more complex picture. A comparison between the exact spectra and entanglement entropies and those resulting from the dominant terms in the Hamiltonian is also reported.

arXiv:2007.01804•Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment•Oct 1, 2020•43 citations

Entanglement Hamiltonians for non-criticalquantum chains

Viktor Eisler, Giuseppe Di Giulio, Erik Tonni C +1 more

We study the entanglement Hamiltonian for finite intervals in infinite quantum chains for two different free-particle systems: coupled harmonic oscillators and fermionic hopping models with dimerization. Working in the ground state, the entanglement Hamiltonian describes again free bosons or fermions and is obtained from the correlation functions via high-precision numerics for up to several hundred sites. Far away from criticality, the dominant on-site and nearest-neighbour terms have triangular profiles that can be understood from the analytical results for a half-infinite interval. Near criticality, the longer-range couplings, although small, lead to a more complex picture. A comparison between the exact spectra and entanglement entropies and those resulting from the dominant terms in the Hamiltonian is also reported.

•Jan 1, 2020•29 citations
A bstract Critical systems host nontrivial entanglement structure that is generally sensitive to additional couplings. In the present work, we study the effect of weak measurements on the entanglement Hamiltonian of massless free fermions which are prepared in their critical ground state. While the power-law decaying correlation and logarithmic growing entanglement entropy have been observed as typical signatures of quantum criticality after the weak measurement, in this work we show that the conformal symmetry is lost and the entanglement Hamiltonian generally becomes gapped for arbitrary small measurement strength. To reveal this unconventional entanglement structure, we consider a field-theory description that allows us to establish an analytic mapping between the entanglement Hamiltonians before and after the weak measurements. From this mapping, we find that although the measurements lead to a significant modification of the entanglement spectrum, the real-space distribution of the eigenfunction of the kernel of entanglement Hamiltonian is unchanged, which is responsible for the coexistence of a gapped entanglement Hamiltonian and the logarithmic entanglement entropy. Moreover, as the mapping works for arbitrarily many disjoint intervals, the multi-interval entanglement entropy also exhibits the same scaling behavior as the critical ground state, and shares the same effective central charge with the single-interval case. We numerically demonstrate these field-theory results on a lattice model, where the entanglement Hamiltonian after weak measurements exhibits the typical signature of a finite gap and becomes long-ranged even in the single-interval case. This is distinct from the critical ground state, where the entanglement Hamiltonian for a single interval is gapless and local.
The entanglement entropy (EE) of the ground state of a one-dimensional Hamiltonian at criticality has a universal logarithmic scaling with a prefactor given by the central charge ccc of the underlying (1+1)(1+1)(1+1)-dimensional conformal field theory. When the system is probed by measurements, the entanglement in the critical ground state is inevitably affected due to wave-function collapse. In this paper, we study the effect of weak measurements on the entanglement scaling in the ground state of the one-dimensional critical transverse-field Ising model. For the measurements of the spins along their transverse spin axis, we identify interesting postmeasurement states associated with spatially uniform measurement outcomes. The EE in these states still satisfies the logarithmic scaling but with an alternative prefactor given by the effective central charge ceff{c}_{\mathrm{eff}}ceff​. We derive the analytical expression of ceff{c}_{\mathrm{eff}}ceff​ as a function of the measurement strength. With both numerical simulations and analytical studies, we show that for the EE averaged over all postmeasurement states based on their Born-rule probabilities, the effective central charge is independent of the measurement strength, contrary to the usual expectation that local and nonoverlapping measurements reduce the entanglement in the system. We also examine the behavior of the average EE under (biased) forced measurements where the measurement outcomes are sampled with a predetermined probability distribution without intersite correlations. In particular, we find an optimal probability distribution that can serve as a mean-field approximation to the Born-rule probabilities and lead to the same ceff{c}_{\mathrm{eff}}ceff​ behavior. The effects of the measurements along the longitudinal spin axis and the postmeasurement correlation functions are also discussed.
We study the effects of measurements, performed with a finite density in space, on the ground state of the one-dimensional transverse-field Ising model at criticality. Local degrees of freedom in critical states exhibit long-range entanglement, and as a result, local measurements can have highly nonlocal effects. Our analytical investigation of correlations and entanglement in the ensemble of measured states is based on properties of the Ising conformal field theory (CFT), where measurements appear as (1+0)(1+0)(1+0)-dimensional defects in the (1+1)(1+1)(1+1)-dimensional Euclidean spacetime. So that we can verify our predictions using large-scale free-fermion numerics, we restrict ourselves to parity-symmetric measurements. To describe their averaged effects analytically we use a replica approach, and we show that the defect arising in the replica theory is an irrelevant perturbation to the Ising CFT. Strikingly, the asymptotic scalings of averaged correlations and entanglement entropy are therefore unchanged relative to the ground state. In contrast, the defect generated by postselecting on the most likely measurement outcomes is exactly marginal. We then find that the exponent governing postmeasurement order parameter correlations, as well as the ``effective central charge'' governing the scaling of entanglement entropy, vary continuously with the density of measurements in space. Our work establishes connections between the effects of measurements on many-body quantum states and of physical defects on low-energy equilibrium properties.
We study post-measurement ensembles of ground states of tricritical and critical 1D quantum Ising Hamiltonians subjected, respectively, to weak energy and spin measurements without post-selection. These measurements act as relevant perturbations about the unmeasured critical ground states. Using finite-size renormalization group (RG) crossover analyses, we characterize their universal properties through the entanglement effective central charge, effective Affleck-Ludwig boundary entropy, and signatures of multifractality from moments of measurement-averaged correlation functions. In both cases, we find evidence for "measurement-dominated" or "measurement-altered" fixed points governed by the underlying Born-rule randomness. For critical Ising, we find a direct RG flow to a projective-measurement fixed point with area-law entanglement, whereas for the tricritical Ising model, we find evidence for a weak-measurement fixed point with logarithmic entanglement. These results clarify the RG-flow structure of weakly measured multicritical Ising ground states and show how intrinsic measurement-induced randomness can generate complex and rich universal long-distance scaling behavior in the post-measurement ensembles, accessible to controlled analytical RG and numerical finite-size RG crossover analyses.
We investigate the structure of effective Hamiltonians governing monitored dynamics of a one-dimensional Majorana chain using Lyapunov spectral analysis. We focus on the gapless phase of the Lyapunov spectrum, where the effective Hamiltonians behave differently from conventional critical Hamiltonians in isolated systems; the spectral gap closes faster than 1/L1/L1/L but slower than 1/L21/L^21/L2 and the entanglement entropy grows as [ln⁡(L)]2[\ln(L)]^2[ln(L)]2 where LLL is the system size. We find that the effective Hamiltonians have random long-range power-law hoppings with nontrivial magnitude correlations, rather than being independently and identically distributed. To elucidate the role of these non-Gaussian correlations, we construct random power-law hopping models that capture the essential features of the effective Hamiltonians. The spectral gaps of the constructed models decay faster than 1/L1/L1/L but slower than 1/L21/L^21/L2. We find that, in the absence of hopping correlations, the ground-state entanglement exhibits ln⁡(L)\ln(L)ln(L) scaling. In the presence of correlations, by contrast, the entanglement entropy is enhanced and its system-size dependence is consistent with [ln⁡(L)]2[\ln(L)]^2[ln(L)]2 scaling over the system sizes studied. These results suggest that correlations among long-range hopping magnitudes are responsible for the entanglement scaling rarely encountered in the ground states of conventional isolated quantum systems.
Abstract We study the entanglement Hamiltonian for finite intervals in infinite quantum chains for two different free-particle systems: coupled harmonic oscillators and fermionic hopping models with dimerization. Working in the ground state, the entanglement Hamiltonian describes again free bosons or fermions and is obtained from the correlation functions via high-precision numerics for up to several hundred sites. Far away from criticality, the dominant on-site and nearest-neighbour terms have triangular profiles that can be understood from the analytical results for a half-infinite interval. Near criticality, the longer-range couplings, although small, lead to a more complex picture. A comparison between the exact spectra and entanglement entropies and those resulting from the dominant terms in the Hamiltonian is also reported.
We study the entanglement Hamiltonian for finite intervals in infinite quantum chains for two different free-particle systems: coupled harmonic oscillators and fermionic hopping models with dimerization. Working in the ground state, the entanglement Hamiltonian describes again free bosons or fermions and is obtained from the correlation functions via high-precision numerics for up to several hundred sites. Far away from criticality, the dominant on-site and nearest-neighbour terms have triangular profiles that can be understood from the analytical results for a half-infinite interval. Near criticality, the longer-range couplings, although small, lead to a more complex picture. A comparison between the exact spectra and entanglement entropies and those resulting from the dominant terms in the Hamiltonian is also reported.