Quantifying physical concepts in terms of the ultimate performance of a given task has been central to theoretical progress, as illustrated by thermodynamic entropy and entanglement entropy, which quantify irreversibility and quantum correlations, respectively. Symmetry breaking is equally universal yet lacks such an operational quantification. While an operational characterization of symmetry breaking through asymptotic state-conversion efficiency is a central goal of the resource theory of asymmetry (RTA), such a characterization has so far been completed only for the U(1) group among continuous symmetries. Here, we identify the complete measure of symmetry breaking for a general continuous symmetry described by any compact Lie group. Specifically, we show that the asymptotic conversion rate between many copies of pure states in RTA is determined by the quantum geometric tensor, thereby establishing it as the complete measure of symmetry breaking. As an immediate consequence of our conversion rate formula, we also resolve the Marvian-Spekkens conjecture on conditions for reversible conversion in RTA, which has remained unproven for over a decade. Leveraging the connection between symmetry breaking and the theory of quantum reference frames, we also systematically introduce a standardized reference state for frameness based on our asymptotic conversion theory. In addition, by applying our analysis to a standard quantum-thermodynamic scenario, we show that asymptotic state conversion in contact with heat baths generally requires macroscopic coherence in the thermodynamic limit.
Quantifying physical concepts in terms of the ultimate performance of a given task has been central to theoretical progress, as illustrated by thermodynamic entropy and entanglement entropy, which quantify irreversibility and quantum correlations, respectively. Symmetry breaking is equally universal yet lacks such an operational quantification. While an operational characterization of symmetry breaking through asymptotic state-conversion efficiency is a central goal of the resource theory of asymmetry (RTA), such a characterization has so far been completed only for the U(1) group among continuous symmetries. Here, we identify the complete measure of symmetry breaking for a general continuous symmetry described by any compact Lie group. Specifically, we show that the asymptotic conversion rate between many copies of pure states in RTA is determined by the quantum geometric tensor, thereby establishing it as the complete measure of symmetry breaking. As an immediate consequence of our conversion rate formula, we also resolve the Marvian-Spekkens conjecture on conditions for reversible conversion in RTA, which has remained unproven for over a decade. Leveraging the connection between symmetry breaking and the theory of quantum reference frames, we also systematically introduce a standardized reference state for frameness based on our asymptotic conversion theory. In addition, by applying our analysis to a standard quantum-thermodynamic scenario, we show that asymptotic state conversion in contact with heat baths generally requires macroscopic coherence in the thermodynamic limit.
Quantifying properties of quantum states through the limits of their manipulation is a central goal of quantum resource theories. For symmetry breaking, the quantum geometric tensor (QGT) governs asymptotic pure-state conversion, but a complete characterization for general mixed states has remained elusive. Here we fully resolve this problem for finite-dimensional systems under compact Lie group symmetries in the i.i.d. asymptotic regime. Specifically, we establish a single-letter formula for the optimal conversion rate between arbitrary states, with vanishing trace-distance error, in the resource theory of asymmetry. The rate is determined by a one-parameter family of metric adjusted QGTs, obtained by rescaling quantum Fisher information (QFI) matrices that interpolate between the symmetric logarithmic derivative and right logarithmic derivative (RLD) QFIs. For pure states, the RLD endpoint recovers the standard QGT. No state-independent finite subset of this family suffices in general, even for U(1) symmetry, revealing a qualitative distinction from pure-state conversion. Our formula further yields an exact pure-state distillation-rate formula in terms of a single asymmetry measure, characterizes asymptotically reversible interconversion, and identifies bound asymmetry for quantum clocks. Complementarity among members of the metric adjusted QGT family also reveals an activation mechanism: a state with zero conversion rate to a mixed clock state can still enhance another input's yield under joint processing. Our proof relies on two developments of independent interest. First, we extend quantum local asymptotic normality to unitary models with arbitrary rank and spectral degeneracy. Second, we characterize convertibility between quantum Gaussian shift models in terms of the same one-parameter family of QFIs.
Quantifying how much a quantum state breaks a symmetry is essential for characterizing phases, nonequilibrium dynamics, and open-system behavior. For mixed states, however, conventional diagnostics of weak symmetry breaking can miss a stronger form of symmetry breaking associated with the possibility of exchanging conserved charges with an environment. We develop a resource theory of strong symmetry breaking by identifying the appropriate free states and free operations, and, for channels on a fixed system, by showing that the latter are precisely the operations realizable without exchanging the conserved charge with the environment. We systematically construct measures of strong symmetry breaking, including strong entanglement asymmetry and covariance matrices of symmetry generators, for a broad class of symmetry groups. We further completely characterize i.i.d. convertibility between arbitrary states under any compact Lie group strong symmetry. This identifies the combinations of resource-theoretically valid measures that quantify strong symmetry breaking for arbitrary states, including all mixed states. In particular, for U(1) symmetry, if the states have positive variances of the conserved quantity and equal strong-symmetry periods, the conversion rate is completely determined by the variance ratio whenever the input is pure or the output is weak symmetric. Thus, for these state conversions, the variance of the conserved quantity plays an operational role analogous to that of entanglement entropy in entanglement theory or quantum Fisher information in the resource theory of weak asymmetry. We further show how weak symmetry breaking is irreversibly converted into strong symmetry breaking in open-system dynamics. We illustrate the framework with examples from quantum field theory, strong-to-weak spontaneous symmetry breaking, and a strong-symmetry analogue of Mpemba-type dynamics.
Resource theories provide a universal framework for quantifying properties of quantum states, such as entanglement, magic, athermality, and asymmetry, as resources under various constraints encountered in quantum science. Since realistic settings typically impose several constraints at once, it is important to study multi-resource theories that combine them. Among these, combinations with asymmetry are especially natural, as symmetry is fundamental and ubiquitous in physics. Here we develop a general theory that treats combinations of finite-group asymmetry with a broad range of resource theories in a unified manner. Our key observation is that the effect of combining the two constraints is governed by the accessibility of symmetry information under the underlying resource theory: whether the information needed for the conversion can be extracted from the input and used to control free operations. If this can be done with asymptotically vanishing error, we show that the conversion rate of the combined theory equals the smaller of the rates of the two constituent theories, so combining them incurs no additional cost. This condition holds for LOCC on arbitrary mixed multipartite states, magic-state conversion of multiqubit systems under Clifford symmetries, and Gibbs-preserving operations. Thermal operations, being time-translation covariant, can access only limited symmetry information, giving an additional compatibility condition between the two symmetries. We also analyze symmetry imposed on elementary operations rather than only on the resulting channel. We establish analogous results for LOCC and thermal operations under suitable assumptions, and for magic when the symmetry is represented by Pauli operators. Finally, we show that finite-group symmetry does not reduce the asymptotic ergotropy per copy and hence introduces no new completely passive states.
We identify exact and approximate conversion rates between i.i.d. pure states under covariant operations in the resource theory of asymmetry for symmetries described by finite groups. We establish the formula for the exact conversion rate by completely specifying the relevant set of resource measures. The exact conversion is generally asymptotically irreversible due to the existence of multiple independent resource measures, and we find the necessary and sufficient condition for asymptotic reversibility. On the other hand, we show that the approximate conversion rates diverge or vanish, which implies that the asymmetry can be infinitely amplified if we allow a vanishingly small error. We reveal the underlying mechanism of such a counterintuitive phenomenon by utilizing the properties of maximally asymmetric states.
Abstract Asymmetry is a useful physical resource which quantifies the extent to which a quantum state breaks a symmetry. Based on the generalization of Wigner–Yanase–Dyson skew information of quantum states for any operator (not necessarily Hermitian), we introduce an asymmetry measure of a quantum state with respect to a compact Lie group as the average skew information of this state for each operator in its unitary representation and prove that it meets the requirements for the resource theory of asymmetry. For several significant symmetry groups, such as the group U (1), the full unitary group, the local unitary group, the group UU , the group U U ̄ , and the orthogonal group OO , we calculate the asymmetry of quantum states. Furthermore, we compare the asymmetry measure of quantum states with respect to a compact Lie group with the asymmetry measure of quantum states with respect to the corresponding Lie algebras introduced in (2020 Europhys. Lett. 130 30004 ) and illustrate that they are closely related, although they capture different aspects of asymmetry of quantum states.
In recent years it has been recognized that properties of physical systems such as entanglement, athermality, and asymmetry, can be viewed as resources for important tasks in quantum information, thermodynamics, and other areas of physics. This recognition was followed by the development of specific quantum resource theories (QRTs), such as entanglement theory, determining how quantum states that cannot be prepared under certain restrictions may be manipulated and used to circumvent the restrictions. Here we discuss the general structure of QRTs, and show that under a few assumptions (such as convexity of the set of free states), a QRT is asymptotically reversible if its set of allowed operations is maximal, that is, if the allowed operations are the set of all operations that do not generate (asymptotically) a resource. In this case, the asymptotic conversion rate is given in terms of the regularized relative entropy of a resource which is the unique measure or quantifier of the resource in the asymptotic limit of many copies of the state. This measure also equals the smoothed version of the logarithmic robustness of the resource.