Different choices of quantum error-correcting codes can reduce the demands on the physical hardware needed to build a quantum computer. To achieve the full potential of a code, we must develop practical decoding algorithms that can correct errors that have occurred with high likelihood. Matching decoders are very good at correcting local errors while also demonstrating fast run times that can keep pace with physical quantum devices. We implement variations of a matching decoder for a three-dimensional, non-CSS, low-density parity check code known as the Chamon code, which has a non-trivial structure that does not lend itself readily to this type of decoding. The non-trivial structure of the syndrome of this code means that we can supplement the decoder with additional steps to improve the threshold error rate, below which the logical failure rate decreases with increasing code distance. We find that a generalized matching decoder that is augmented by a belief-propagation step prior to matching gives a threshold of 10.5% for depolarizing noise.
Different choices of quantum error-correcting codes can reduce the demands on the physical hardware needed to build a quantum computer. To achieve the full potential of a code, we must develop practical decoding algorithms that can correct errors that have occurred with high likelihood. Matching decoders are very good at correcting local errors while also demonstrating fast run times that can keep pace with physical quantum devices. We implement variations of a matching decoder for a three-dimensional, non-CSS, low-density parity check code known as the Chamon code, which has a non-trivial structure that does not lend itself readily to this type of decoding. The non-trivial structure of the syndrome of this code means that we can supplement the decoder with additional steps to improve the threshold error rate, below which the logical failure rate decreases with increasing code distance. We find that a generalized matching decoder that is augmented by a belief-propagation step prior to matching gives a threshold of 10.5% for depolarizing noise.
Two-dimensional color codes are a promising candidate for fault-tolerant quantum computing, as they have high encoding rates, transversal implementation of logical Clifford gates, and resource-efficient magic state preparation schemes. However, decoding color codes presents a significant challenge due to their structure, where elementary errors violate three checks instead of just two (a key feature in surface code decoding), and the complexity of extracting syndrome is greater. We introduce an efficient color-code decoder that tackles these issues by combining two matching decoders for each color, generalized to handle circuit-level noise by employing detector error models. We provide comprehensive analyses of the decoder, covering its threshold and sub-threshold scaling both for bit-flip noise with ideal measurements and for circuit-level noise. Our simulations reveal that this decoding strategy nearly reaches the best possible scaling of logical failure ( pfail∼pd/2 ) for both noise models, where p is the noise strength, in the regime of interest for fault-tolerant quantum computing. While its noise thresholds are comparable with other matching-based decoders for color codes ( 8.2% for bit-flip noise and 0.46% for circuit-level noise), the scaling of logical failure rates below threshold significantly outperforms the best matching-based decoders.
Topological quantum error-correcting codes are a promising candidate for building fault-tolerant quantum computers. Decoding topological codes optimally, however, is known to be a computationally hard problem. Various decoders have been proposed that achieve approximately optimal error thresholds. Due to practical constraints, it is not known if there exists an obvious choice for a decoder. In this paper, we introduce a framework which can combine arbitrary decoders for any given code to significantly reduce the logical error rates. We rely on the crucial observation that two different decoding techniques, while possibly having similar logical error rates, can perform differently on the same error syndrome. We classify each error syndrome to the decoder which is more likely to decode it correctly using machine learning techniques. We apply our framework to an ensemble of minimum-weight perfect matching (MWPM) and hard-decision re-normalization-group decoders for the surface code in the depolarizing noise model. Our simulations show an improvement of 38.4%, 14.6%, and 7.1% over the pseudothreshold of MWPM in the instance of distance 5, 7, and 9 codes, respectively. Lastly, we discuss the advantages and limitations of our framework and applicability to other error-correcting codes. Our framework can provide a significant boost to error correction by combining the strengths of various decoders. In particular, it may allow for combining very fast decoders with moderate error-correcting capability to create a very fast ensemble decoder with high error-correcting capability.
Noise is a major obstacle in the development of practical schemes for quantum computation and communication. Similar to the case of classical communication, this noise can be protected against by employing a code, which provides a means for encoding quantum states prior to transmission and allows for errors to be inferred, and hopefully corrected, by a decoder at the receiver. Unfortunately, designing good codes and decoders is typically a difficult problem. This thesis focuses on developing low-complexity heuristic approaches to three such problems: the design of modified belief propagation decoders for quantum low-density parity-check codes, the design of stabilizer codes for asymmetric channels, and the design of codeword stabilized codes. Quantum low-density parity-check codes are stabilizer codes with low-weight generators. Such codes permit low-complexity decoding via the use of belief propagation, which is an iterative message passing algorithm that takes place on a factor graph defined by the code. However, the performance of such a decoder is limited both by code structure and the degenerate nature of quantum errors. To overcome these limitations, at least in part, a number of modifications to belief propagation are developed. Central among these is the augmented decoder, which in the case of a decoding error, iteratively reattempts decoding using modified factor graph. This heuristic modification simply involves the duplication of a randomly selected subset of the graph’s check nodes, which are in one-to-one correspondence with the code’s stabilizer generators. Across a range of codes, it is shown that the decoders developed perform as well as or better than other modified decoders presented in literature. For a number of channels of physical interest, phase-flip errors occur far more frequently than bit-flip errors. When transmitting across these so-called asymmetric channels, the decoding error rate can be minimized by tailoring the code used to the channel. However, assessing the performance of codes on a given channel is made difficult by the #P-completeness of optimal decoding. To address this complexity, it is shown that the decoding error rate can be accurately approximated using only a small fraction of the possible errors caused by the channel. This approximation is then used to identify a number of cyclic stabilizer codes that perform well on two different asymmetric channels. To further build on this, a heuristic is demonstrated for assessing code performance based on the decoding error rate of an associated classical code. The complexity of calculating this classical error rate is relatively low, and it is shown that it can be used as the basis for a hill-climbing search algorithm. Such searches have yielded a large number of highly performant codes satisfying various structure constraints. The family of codeword stabilized codes encompasses both the stabilizer codes as well as many of the best known nonadditive codes. Constructing a standard form codeword stabilized code is a matter of selecting a simple undirected graph and a binary classical code. This makes designing optimal codes difficult as the number of possible graphs grows exponentially with code length, and the clique search required to construct the classical code is NP-hard. To address the exponential growth of the search space, a heuristic is developed for assessing graphs. This heuristic is then employed by a genetic algorithm that also makes use of a novel crossover operation based on spectral bisection, which is show to be superior to more standard crossover operations. With a graph selected, it is demonstrated that the complexity of the clique search required to construct the associated classical code can be mitigated through the use of a heuristic clique finding algorithm. A number of best known codes are presented that have been found using this approach.
For quantum computers to reach their full potential will require error correction. We study the surface code, one of the most promising quantum error correcting codes, in the context of predominantly dephasing (Z-biased) noise, as found in many quantum architectures. We find that the surface code is highly resilient to Y-biased noise, and tailor it to Z-biased noise, whilst retaining its practical features. We demonstrate ultrahigh thresholds for the tailored surface code: ~39% with a realistic bias of = 100, and ~50% with pure Z noise, far exceeding known thresholds for the standard surface code: ~11% with pure Z noise, and ~19% with depolarizing noise. Furthermore, we provide strong evidence that the threshold of the tailored surface code tracks the hashing bound for all biases. We reveal the hidden structure of the tailored surface code with pure Z noise that is responsible for these ultrahigh thresholds. As a consequence, we prove that its threshold with pure Z noise is 50%, and we show that its distance to Z errors, and the number of failure modes, can be tuned by modifying its boundary. For codes with appropriately modified boundaries, the distance to Z errors is O(n) compared to O(n1/2) for square codes, where n is the number of physical qubits. We demonstrate that these characteristics yield a significant improvement in logical error rate with pure Z and Z-biased noise. Finally, we introduce an efficient approach to decoding that exploits code symmetries with respect to a given noise model, and extends readily to the fault-tolerant context, where measurements are unreliable. We use this approach to define a decoder for the tailored surface code with Z-biased noise. Although the decoder is suboptimal, we observe exceptionally high fault-tolerant thresholds of ~5% with bias = 100 and exceeding 6% with pure Z noise. Our results open up many avenues of research and, recent developments in bias-preserving gates, highlight their direct relevance to experiment.
flip is an extremely simple and maximally local classical decoder which has been used to great effect in certain classes of classical codes. When applied to quantum codes there exist constant-weight errors (such as half of a stabiliser) which are uncorrectable for this decoder, so previous studies have considered modified versions of flip , sometimes in conjunction with other decoders. We argue that this may not always be necessary, and present numerical evidence for the existence of a threshold for flip when applied to the looplike syndromes of a three-dimensional toric code on a cubic lattice. This result can be attributed to the fact that the lowest-weight uncorrectable errors for this decoder are closer (in terms of Hamming distance) to correctable errors than to other uncorrectable errors, and so they are likely to become correctable in future code cycles after transformation by additional noise. Introducing randomness into the decoder can allow it to correct these "uncorrectable" errors with finite probability, and for a decoding strategy that uses a combination of belief propagation and probabilistic flip we observe a threshold of ∼5.5% under phenomenological noise. This is comparable to the best known threshold for this code ( ∼7.1% ) which was achieved using belief propagation and ordered statistics decoding [Higgott and Breuckmann, 2022], a strategy with a runtime of O(n3) as opposed to the O(n) ( O(1) when parallelised) runtime of our local decoder. We expect that this strategy could be generalised to work well in other low-density parity check codes, and hope that these results will prompt investigation of other previously overlooked decoders.
Quantum error correction is instrumental in protecting quantum systems from noise in quantum computing and communication settings. Pauli channels can be efficiently simulated and threshold values for Pauli error rates under a variety of error-correcting codes have been obtained. However, realistic quantum systems can undergo noise processes that differ significantly from Pauli noise. In this paper, we present an efficient hard decoding algorithm for optimizing thresholds and lowering failure rates of an error-correcting code under general completely positive and trace-preserving (i.e., Markovian) noise. We use our hard decoding algorithm to study the performance of several error-correcting codes under various non-Pauli noise models by computing threshold values and failure rates for these codes. We compare the performance of our hard decoding algorithm to decoders optimized for depolarizing noise and show improvements in thresholds and reductions in failure rates by several orders of magnitude. Our hard decoding algorithm can also be adapted to take advantage of a code's non-Pauli transversal gates to further suppress noise. For example, we show that using the transversal gates of the 5-qubit code allows arbitrary rotations around certain axes to be perfectly corrected. Furthermore, we show that Pauli twirling can increase or decrease the threshold depending upon the code properties. Lastly, we show that even if the physical noise model differs slightly from the hypothesized noise model used to determine an optimized decoder, failure rates can still be reduced by applying our hard decoding algorithm.