Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2410.23980 · International ITG Conference on Systems, Communications and Coding (SCC)

A Comparative Study of Ensemble Decoding Methods for Short Length LDPC Codes

Felix Krieg, Jannis Clausius, Marvin Rübenacke, Stephan ten Brink

Published Mar 10, 2025• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

To alleviate the suboptimal performance of belief propagation (BP) decoding of short low-density parity-check (LDPC) codes, a plethora of improved decoding algorithms has been proposed over the last two decades. Many of these methods can be described using the same general framework, which we call ensemble decoding: A set of independent constituent decoders works in parallel on the received sequence, each proposing a code-word candidate. From this list, the maximum likelihood (ML) decision is designated as the decoder output. In this paper, we qualitatively and quantitatively compare different realizations of the ensemble decoder, namely multiple-bases belief propagation (MBBP), automorphism ensemble decoding (AED), scheduling ensemble decoding (SED), noise-aided ensemble decoding (NED) and saturated belief propagation (SBP). While all algorithms can provide gains over traditional BP decoding, ensemble methods that exploit the code structure, such as MBBP and AED, typically show greater performance improvements.

DOI
10.1109/ieeeconf62907.2025.10949101

Related papers

Subcode Ensemble Decoding of Linear Block Codes

Jonathan Mandelbaum, Holger Jäkel, Laurent Schmalen

Low-density parity-check (LDPC) codes together with belief propagation (BP) decoding yield exceptional error correction capabilities in the large block length regime. Yet, there remains a gap between BP decoding and maximum likelihood decoding for short block length LDPC codes. In this context, ensemble decoding schemes yield both reduced latency and good error rates. In this paper, we propose subcode ensemble decoding (SCED), which employs an ensemble of decodings on different subcodes of the code. To ensure that all codewords are decodable, we use the concept of linear coverings and explore approaches for sampling suitable ensembles for short block length LDPC codes. Monte-Carlo simulations conducted for three LDPC codes demonstrate that SCED improves decoding performance compared to stand-alone decoding and automorphism ensemble decoding. In particular, in contrast to existing schemes, e.g., multiple bases belief propagation and automorphism ensemble decoding, SCED does not require the NP-complete search for low-weight dual codewords or knowledge of the automorphism group of the code, which is often unknown.

arXiv:2501.11993•IEEE International Symposium on Information Theory (ISIT)•Jun 22, 2025•2 citations

Row-Boosted Ensemble Belief Propagation for Short LDPC Codes

Paul Bezner, Felix Krieg, Stephan ten Brink

Belief-propagation (BP) decoding of short and moderate-length low-density parity-check (LDPC) codes is limited by finite-length graph effects: a single decoder trajectory can become trapped or oscillatory even when an alternative trajectory would decode the received word. Existing ensemble-BP decoders create the required diversity through multiple parity-check matrices, automorphisms, modified schedules, subcodes, or altered update rules. We introduce row-boosted ensemble (RBE) decoding as a minimal decoder-side diversity mechanism: all ensemble members share the same parity-check matrix and the same BP kernel, and differ only in a small set of parity-check rows whose outgoing messages are boosted. On the 5G~NR BG1 \((144,96)\) code, RBE with \(32\) members lowers the frame-error rate of BP with \(20\) iterations (BP-20) from \(1.6\times10^{-2}\) to \(1.6\times10^{-3}\) at \(E_\mathrm{b}/N_0=4.0\,\mathrm{dB}\), outperforming saturated-min-sum and affine subcode ensembles of equal size. Increasing the ensemble size yields additional gains, indicating that RBE provides a scalable performance-complexity tradeoff. The gains transfer across 5G~NR block lengths and rates, to non-5G short LDPC codes, and across flooding and layered schedules.

arXiv:2608.09560•Aug 10, 2026•0 citations

Enhancing the Decoding of Short LDPC Codes with Stochastic Sequences

Yuyuan Gu, Haien Li

Low-Density Parity-Check (LDPC) codes are one of the most popular codes used in nowadays’ communication due to their high coding efficiency at low decoding complexity. With these characteristics, LDPC codes are suitable for high-speed information transmission systems. The widely used decoding algorithm for LDPC codes is Belief Propagation (BP) decoding with which the performance of LDPC codes can approach the Shannon limit. With the development of 5G, a lot of attention is given to the so-called ultra-reliable low latency communication scenario which needs the short code to transmit. However, short codes will not have a very good performance with BP decoding. To solve this problem, investigations have been done such as multiple-bases BP decoding. Although this decoding method has a better performance than BP decoding, it will cause a high complexity in the hardware implementation. Besides, an investigation on the stochastic decoding for shortcodes was proposed in 2003. This decoding method is hardware friendly, but its performance can only approach BP decoding. Inspired by multiple-bases BP decoding and stochastic decoding, binary stochastic decoding with parallel decoders is proposed in this thesis firstly. It represents stochastic sequences with multiple parallel Tanner graphs and uses hard-decision decoding in the iterative part because of the binary input bits. However, this decoding method has a severe performance loss compared to BP decoding. To avoid this problem, the enhancement method is used to make the binary sequences be non-binary sequences that can form more powerful parallel decoders. Then the non-binary symbols of these new sequences are transformed to their corresponding log-likelihood ratio which enables the iterative part to use BP decoding. In addition, combining with the ML decision of list decoding, the decision part of our stochastic decoder can fully utilize the output to increase the efficiency of the decoding method. After ensuring the performance of our non-binary stochastic decoding to be better than BP decoding, the complexity of the decoder is reduced to save the computational resources. Finally, with constant adjustments, the bit width of each non-binary symbol is determined to be 15, and the sequence length is reduced to 20 which can let the non-binary stochastic decoding has an acceptable complexity while keeping good performance.

•Jan 1, 2021•1 citation

Automorphism Ensemble Decoding of Quasi-Cyclic LDPC Codes by Breaking Graph Symmetries

Marvin Geiselhart, Moustafa Ebada, Ahmed Elkelesh +2 more

We consider automorphism ensemble decoding (AED) of quasi-cyclic (QC) low-density parity-check (LDPC) codes. Belief propagation (BP) decoding on the conventional factor graph is equivariant to the quasi-cyclic automorphisms and therefore prevents gains by AED. However, by applying small modifications to the parity-check matrix at the receiver side, we can break the symmetry without changing the code at the transmitter. This way, we can leverage a gain in error-correcting performance using an ensemble of identical BP decoders, without increasing the worst-case decoding latency. The proposed method is demonstrated using LDPC codes from the CCSDS, 802.11n and 5G standards and produces gains of 0.2 to 0.3 dB over conventional BP decoding. Compared to the similarly performing saturated BP (SBP), the proposed algorithm reduces the average decoding latency by more than eight times.

arXiv:2202.00287•IEEE Communications Letters•May 11, 2022•16 citations

Affine Subcode Ensemble Decoding of Linear Block Codes

Jonathan Mandelbaum, Paul Bezner, Holger Jäkel +2 more

In the short block length regime, ensemble decoding schemes with their inherently parallel structure can improve error correction performance and reduce latency compared to stand-alone suboptimal decoders such as belief propagation (BP). In this work, we introduce affine subcode ensemble decoding (aSCED), which uses an ensemble of decoders operating on linear block codes and both linear and strictly affine subcodes. This generalizes the recently proposed subcode ensemble decoding (SCED), which is restricted to linear subcodes. We derive BP update rules for affine subcodes and show that aSCED simplifies ensemble design compared to SCED, multiple bases BP, and automorphism ensemble decoding. Monte-Carlo simulations of two low-density parity-check codes and two Bose-Chaudhuri-Hocquenghem (BCH) codes demonstrate improved error correction performance of aSCED over competing existing ensemble schemes. Notably, for one BCH code, when combining ensemble design with algorithms for constructing high-performance parity-check matrices, aSCED achieves near-maximum likelihood performance using only 64 BP decoding paths.

arXiv:2604.06889•IEEE Transactions on Communications•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Multiple-Bases Belief Propagation List Decoding for Quantum LDPC Codes

Sheida Rabeti, Hessam Mahdavifar

In this paper, we propose a belief-propagation (BP)-based decoder, termed the Multiple-Bases Belief-Propagation List Decoder (MBBP-LD), for quantum low-density parity-check (QLDPC) codes. The key idea is to generate \emph{structured decoding diversity} by constructing multiple redundant parity-check representations via cycle-free subtree decompositions of the Tanner graph, and running BP decoding in parallel across these representations. This extends the classical Multiple-Bases Belief-Propagation (MBBP) framework to the quantum setting while preserving the linear-time complexity and efficiency of standard BP decoding, and avoids the need for super-linear post-processing. Simulation results demonstrate that MBBP-LD improves upon existing BP-based decoders, including BP with ordered statistics decoding (BP-OSD) and belief propagation with guided decimation (BPGD) across several QLDPC codes, while requiring substantially fewer total BP iterations. For bivariate bicycle codes $[[144,12,12]]$ and $[[288,12,18]]$, MBBP-LD achieves up to $20\%$ reduction in error rate compared to BPGD and up to $30\%$ compared to BP-OSD in the low- and moderate-error regimes. For the larger B1 code $[[882, 24, 18 \leq d \leq 24]]$, MBBP-LD attains comparable or improved performance relative to BPGD while maintaining BP-like decoding latency under parallel implementation.

arXiv:2605.14170•May 13, 2026•0 citations
To alleviate the suboptimal performance of belief propagation (BP) decoding of short low-density parity-check (LDPC) codes, a plethora of improved decoding algorithms has been proposed over the last two decades. Many of these methods can be described using the same general framework, which we call ensemble decoding: A set of independent constituent decoders works in parallel on the received sequence, each proposing a code-word candidate. From this list, the maximum likelihood (ML) decision is designated as the decoder output. In this paper, we qualitatively and quantitatively compare different realizations of the ensemble decoder, namely multiple-bases belief propagation (MBBP), automorphism ensemble decoding (AED), scheduling ensemble decoding (SED), noise-aided ensemble decoding (NED) and saturated belief propagation (SBP). While all algorithms can provide gains over traditional BP decoding, ensemble methods that exploit the code structure, such as MBBP and AED, typically show greater performance improvements.
Low-density parity-check (LDPC) codes together with belief propagation (BP) decoding yield exceptional error correction capabilities in the large block length regime. Yet, there remains a gap between BP decoding and maximum likelihood decoding for short block length LDPC codes. In this context, ensemble decoding schemes yield both reduced latency and good error rates. In this paper, we propose subcode ensemble decoding (SCED), which employs an ensemble of decodings on different subcodes of the code. To ensure that all codewords are decodable, we use the concept of linear coverings and explore approaches for sampling suitable ensembles for short block length LDPC codes. Monte-Carlo simulations conducted for three LDPC codes demonstrate that SCED improves decoding performance compared to stand-alone decoding and automorphism ensemble decoding. In particular, in contrast to existing schemes, e.g., multiple bases belief propagation and automorphism ensemble decoding, SCED does not require the NP-complete search for low-weight dual codewords or knowledge of the automorphism group of the code, which is often unknown.
Belief-propagation (BP) decoding of short and moderate-length low-density parity-check (LDPC) codes is limited by finite-length graph effects: a single decoder trajectory can become trapped or oscillatory even when an alternative trajectory would decode the received word. Existing ensemble-BP decoders create the required diversity through multiple parity-check matrices, automorphisms, modified schedules, subcodes, or altered update rules. We introduce row-boosted ensemble (RBE) decoding as a minimal decoder-side diversity mechanism: all ensemble members share the same parity-check matrix and the same BP kernel, and differ only in a small set of parity-check rows whose outgoing messages are boosted. On the 5G~NR BG1 (144,96)(144,96)(144,96) code, RBE with 323232 members lowers the frame-error rate of BP with 202020 iterations (BP-20) from 1.6×10−21.6\times10^{-2}1.6×10−2 to 1.6×10−31.6\times10^{-3}1.6×10−3 at Eb/N0=4.0 dBE_\mathrm{b}/N_0=4.0\,\mathrm{dB}Eb​/N0​=4.0dB, outperforming saturated-min-sum and affine subcode ensembles of equal size. Increasing the ensemble size yields additional gains, indicating that RBE provides a scalable performance-complexity tradeoff. The gains transfer across 5G~NR block lengths and rates, to non-5G short LDPC codes, and across flooding and layered schedules.
Low-Density Parity-Check (LDPC) codes are one of the most popular codes used in nowadays’ communication due to their high coding efficiency at low decoding complexity. With these characteristics, LDPC codes are suitable for high-speed information transmission systems. The widely used decoding algorithm for LDPC codes is Belief Propagation (BP) decoding with which the performance of LDPC codes can approach the Shannon limit. With the development of 5G, a lot of attention is given to the so-called ultra-reliable low latency communication scenario which needs the short code to transmit. However, short codes will not have a very good performance with BP decoding. To solve this problem, investigations have been done such as multiple-bases BP decoding. Although this decoding method has a better performance than BP decoding, it will cause a high complexity in the hardware implementation. Besides, an investigation on the stochastic decoding for shortcodes was proposed in 2003. This decoding method is hardware friendly, but its performance can only approach BP decoding. Inspired by multiple-bases BP decoding and stochastic decoding, binary stochastic decoding with parallel decoders is proposed in this thesis firstly. It represents stochastic sequences with multiple parallel Tanner graphs and uses hard-decision decoding in the iterative part because of the binary input bits. However, this decoding method has a severe performance loss compared to BP decoding. To avoid this problem, the enhancement method is used to make the binary sequences be non-binary sequences that can form more powerful parallel decoders. Then the non-binary symbols of these new sequences are transformed to their corresponding log-likelihood ratio which enables the iterative part to use BP decoding. In addition, combining with the ML decision of list decoding, the decision part of our stochastic decoder can fully utilize the output to increase the efficiency of the decoding method. After ensuring the performance of our non-binary stochastic decoding to be better than BP decoding, the complexity of the decoder is reduced to save the computational resources. Finally, with constant adjustments, the bit width of each non-binary symbol is determined to be 15, and the sequence length is reduced to 20 which can let the non-binary stochastic decoding has an acceptable complexity while keeping good performance.
We consider automorphism ensemble decoding (AED) of quasi-cyclic (QC) low-density parity-check (LDPC) codes. Belief propagation (BP) decoding on the conventional factor graph is equivariant to the quasi-cyclic automorphisms and therefore prevents gains by AED. However, by applying small modifications to the parity-check matrix at the receiver side, we can break the symmetry without changing the code at the transmitter. This way, we can leverage a gain in error-correcting performance using an ensemble of identical BP decoders, without increasing the worst-case decoding latency. The proposed method is demonstrated using LDPC codes from the CCSDS, 802.11n and 5G standards and produces gains of 0.2 to 0.3 dB over conventional BP decoding. Compared to the similarly performing saturated BP (SBP), the proposed algorithm reduces the average decoding latency by more than eight times.
In the short block length regime, ensemble decoding schemes with their inherently parallel structure can improve error correction performance and reduce latency compared to stand-alone suboptimal decoders such as belief propagation (BP). In this work, we introduce affine subcode ensemble decoding (aSCED), which uses an ensemble of decoders operating on linear block codes and both linear and strictly affine subcodes. This generalizes the recently proposed subcode ensemble decoding (SCED), which is restricted to linear subcodes. We derive BP update rules for affine subcodes and show that aSCED simplifies ensemble design compared to SCED, multiple bases BP, and automorphism ensemble decoding. Monte-Carlo simulations of two low-density parity-check codes and two Bose-Chaudhuri-Hocquenghem (BCH) codes demonstrate improved error correction performance of aSCED over competing existing ensemble schemes. Notably, for one BCH code, when combining ensemble design with algorithms for constructing high-performance parity-check matrices, aSCED achieves near-maximum likelihood performance using only 64 BP decoding paths.
In this paper, we propose a belief-propagation (BP)-based decoder, termed the Multiple-Bases Belief-Propagation List Decoder (MBBP-LD), for quantum low-density parity-check (QLDPC) codes. The key idea is to generate \emph{structured decoding diversity} by constructing multiple redundant parity-check representations via cycle-free subtree decompositions of the Tanner graph, and running BP decoding in parallel across these representations. This extends the classical Multiple-Bases Belief-Propagation (MBBP) framework to the quantum setting while preserving the linear-time complexity and efficiency of standard BP decoding, and avoids the need for super-linear post-processing. Simulation results demonstrate that MBBP-LD improves upon existing BP-based decoders, including BP with ordered statistics decoding (BP-OSD) and belief propagation with guided decimation (BPGD) across several QLDPC codes, while requiring substantially fewer total BP iterations. For bivariate bicycle codes [[144,12,12]][[144,12,12]][[144,12,12]] and [[288,12,18]][[288,12,18]][[288,12,18]], MBBP-LD achieves up to 20%20\%20% reduction in error rate compared to BPGD and up to 30%30\%30% compared to BP-OSD in the low- and moderate-error regimes. For the larger B1 code [[882,24,18≤d≤24]][[882, 24, 18 \leq d \leq 24]][[882,24,18≤d≤24]], MBBP-LD attains comparable or improved performance relative to BPGD while maintaining BP-like decoding latency under parallel implementation.