Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2409.10498 · Quantum Science and Technology

The role of higher-order terms in trapped-ion quantum computing with magnetic gradient induced coupling

Sebastian Nagies, Kevin T. Geier, Javed Akram, Junichi Okamoto, Dimitrios Bantounas, Christof Wunderlich, M. Johanning, Philipp Hauke

Published Mar 18, 2025• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract Trapped-ion hardware based on the magnetic gradient induced coupling (MAGIC) scheme is emerging as a promising platform for quantum computing. Nevertheless, in this—as in any other—quantum-computing platform, many technical questions still have to be resolved before large-scale and error-tolerant applications are possible. In this work, we present a thorough discussion of the structure and effects of higher-order terms in the MAGIC setup, which can occur due to anharmonicities in the external potential of the ion crystal (e.g. through Coulomb repulsion) or through curvature of the applied magnetic field. These terms generate systematic shifts in the leading-order interactions and take the form of three-spin couplings, two-spin couplings, local fields, as well as diverse phonon–phonon conversion mechanisms. We find that most of these are negligible in realistic situations, with only two contributions that need careful attention. First, there are undesired longitudinal fields contributing shifts to the resonance frequency, whose strength increases with chain length and phonon occupation numbers; while their mean effect can easily be compensated by additional Z rotations, phonon number fluctuations need to be avoided for precise gate operations. Second, anharmonicities of the Coulomb interaction can lead to well-known two-to-one conversions of phonon excitations. Both of these error terms can be mitigated by sufficiently cooling the phonons to the ground-state. Our detailed analysis constitutes an important contribution on the way of making magnetic-gradient trapped-ion quantum technology fit for large-scale applications, and it may inspire new ways to purposefully design interaction terms.

DOI
10.1088/2058-9565/adc1fe

Related papers

Robust quantum control for higher order coupling term in trapped ions

Jingbo B. Wang

Trapped ion hardware has made significant progress recently and is now one of the leading platforms for quantum computing. To construct two-qubit gates in trapped ions, experimental manipulation approaches for ion chains are becoming increasingly prevalent. Given the restricted control technology, how implementing high-fidelity quantum gate operations is crucial. Many works in current pulse design optimization focus on ion-phonon and effective ion-ion coupling while ignoring the higher-order expansion impacts of these two terms brought on by experiment defects. This paper proposed a novel robust quantum control optimization method in trapped ions. By introducing the higher-order terms caused by the error into the optimization cost function, we generated an extremely robust Molmer-Sorensen gate with infidelity below $10^{-3}$ under drift noise range $\pm 10$ kHz and time noise range $\pm 0.02$. Our work reveals the vital role of higher-order coupling terms in trapped ion pulse control optimization, especially the higher ion-ion coupling order, and provides a robust optimization scheme for realizing more efficient entangled states in trapped ion platforms.

arXiv:2211.08150•Nov 15, 2022•1 citation

Robust quantum gate optimization with first-order derivatives of ion–phonon and ion–ion couplings in trapped ions

Jingbo B. Wang

Abstract Trapped ion hardware has made significant progress recently and is now one of the leading platforms for quantum computing. To construct two-qubit gates in trapped ions, experimental manipulation approaches for ion chains are becoming increasingly prevalent. Given the restricted control technology, how implementing high-fidelity quantum gate operations is crucial. Many works in current pulse design optimization focus on ion–phonon and effective ion–ion couplings while ignoring the first-order derivative terms expansion impacts of these two terms brought on by experiment defects. This paper proposes a novel robust quantum control optimization method in trapped ions. By introducing the first-order derivative terms caused by the error into the optimization cost function, we generate an extremely robust Mølmer–Sørensen gate with infidelity below 10−3 under a drift noise range of ±10 kHz, the relative robustness achieves a tolerance of ±5%, compared to the 200-kHz frequency spacing between phonon modes, and for time noise drift, the tolerance reached to 2%. Our work reveals the vital role of the first-order derivative terms of coupling in trapped ion pulse control optimization, especially the first-order derivative terms of ion–ion coupling. It provides a robust optimization scheme for realizing more efficient entangled states in trapped ion platforms.

Chinese Physics B•Feb 8, 2025•1 citation

Designing spin-spin interactions with one and two dimensional ion crystals in planar micro traps

J. Welzel, A. Bautista-Salvador, C. Abarbanel +4 more

We discuss the experimental feasibility of quantum simulation with trapped ion crystals, using magnetic field gradients. We describe a micro structured planar ion trap, which contains a central wire loop generating a strong magnetic gradient of about 20 T/m in an ion crystal held about 160 μm above the surface. On the theoretical side, we extend a proposal about spin-spin interactions via magnetic gradient induced coupling (MAGIC) [J. Phys. B At. Mol. Opt. Phys. 42, 154009 (2009)]. We describe aspects where planar ion traps promise novel physics: spin-spin coupling strengths of transversal eigenmodes exhibit significant advantages over the coupling schemes in longitudinal direction that have been previously investigated. With a chip device and a magnetic field coil with small inductance, a resonant enhancement of magnetic spin forces through the application of alternating magnetic field gradients is proposed. Such resonantly enhanced spin-spin coupling may be used, for instance, to create Schrödinger cat states. Finally we investigate magnetic gradient interactions in two-dimensional ion crystals, and discuss frustration effects in such two-dimensional arrangements.

arXiv:1102.3645•The European Physical Journal D•Jul 27, 2011•45 citations

Controlled inter-site coupling in a two-dimensional ion trap array

Frederick Hakelberg

The understanding of quantum mechanical systems is essential to modern physics and its applications. However, already for entangled systems of a few tens of constituents, exact numerical simulations on classical computers can become impossible. Quantum simulators based on well-controlled quantum system might provide the only effective approach to these systems. Trapped atomic ions offer a uniquely precise and controllable platform. They are used as platforms for, e.g., future quantum computers, quantum simulators, and extremely precise clocks. Quantum-simulation problems of interest and out-of-reach for modern theoretical methods include the dynamics of one-dimensional systems on long time scales and more-than-one dimensional systems with long-range interaction. For the latter, two-dimensional arrays of ions, individually trapped and controlled above microfabricated surface-electrode traps, present a promising approach. In the first realizations so far, the inter-site distance between the ions was too large to allow for sufficient inter-site coupling. We aim for a scalable approach to an analog quantum simulator based on a two-dimensional array of individually trapped ions. As a first demonstration, we operate an array of three magnesium ions in triangular arrangement with a side-length of 40µm. Therein, we previously demonstrated the individual control of internal (electronic) and external (motional) degrees of freedom of the ions. Here, we present the first realization of inter-site coupling in the two-dimensional array. We demonstrate the coupling by a transfer of large coherent states of motion between the sites. We investigate the influence of the amplitude of these motional states in the anharmonic trapping potential and extrapolate to future experiments on the single-phonon level. We apply the real-time control of the coupling and concatenate the two-site coupling to transfer motional excitation between all three sites of the array. To demonstrate the scalability of our techniques, we couple all three sites simultaneously and investigate the evolution of an initial excitation at one and two sites of the array. The latter shows interference effects of the different pathways in the triangle. Current motional heating rates on the order of the inter-site coupling, preclude working with single phonons near the motional ground-state. We present a new experimental apparatus and vacuum chamber which will allow in-situ cleaning of surface-electrode traps. This has shown to reduce motional heating rates by two orders of magnitude. In this apparatus, we additionally realize a magnetic-field insensitive qubit in 25Mg+ with a coherence time exceeding six seconds. We generate the magnetic field around 10.9mT by a hybrid magnet assembly based on solid-state magnets and fine-tuned by electric coils. Once we have reduced the heating rate in the triangle trap array using the new setup, first quantum simulation experiments, investigating spin-frustration or artificial gauge fields, will come in reach. Here our triangle represents a basic, scalable, building block of future latices designed at will.

•Jan 1, 2019•0 citations

Intrinsic anharmonic effects on the phonon frequencies and effective spin-spin interactions in a quantum simulator made from trapped ions in a linear Paul trap

M. McAneny, James K. Freericks

The Coulomb repulsion between ions in a linear Paul trap gives rise to anharmonic terms in the potential energy when expanded about the equilibrium positions. We examine the effect of these anharmonic terms on the accuracy of a quantum simulator made from trapped ions. To be concrete, we consider a linear chain of ${\text{Yb}}^{171+}$ ions stabilized close to the zigzag transition. We find that for typical experimental temperatures, frequencies change by no more than a factor of $0.01%$ due to the anharmonic couplings. Furthermore, shifts in the effective spin-spin interactions (driven by a spin-dependent optical dipole force) are also, in general, less than $0.01%$ for detunings to the blue of the transverse center-of-mass frequency. However, detuning the spin interactions near other frequencies can lead to non-negligible anharmonic contributions to the effective spin-spin interactions. We also examine an odd behavior exhibited by the harmonic spin-spin interactions for a range of intermediate detunings, where nearest-neighbor spins with a larger spatial separation on the ion chain interact more strongly than nearest neighbors with a smaller spatial separation.

arXiv:1406.5416•Physical Review A•Nov 6, 2014•6 citations

Normal modes of trapped ions in the presence of anharmonic trap potentials

Jonathan Home, David Hanneke, John D. Jost +2 more

We theoretically and experimentally examine the effects of anharmonic terms in the trapping potential for linear chains of trapped ions. We concentrate on two different effects that become significant at different levels of anharmonicity. The first is a modification of the oscillation frequencies and amplitudes of the ions' normal modes of vibration for multi-ion crystals, resulting from each ion experiencing a different curvature in the potential. In the second effect, which occurs with increased anharmonicity or higher excitation amplitude, amplitude-dependent shifts of the normal-mode frequencies become important. We evaluate normal-mode frequency and amplitude shifts, and comment on the implications for quantum information processing and quantum state engineering. Since the ratio of the anharmonic to harmonic terms typically increases as the ion–electrode distance decreases, anharmonic effects will become more significant as ion trap sizes are reduced. To avoid unwanted problems, anharmonicities should therefore be taken into account at the design stage of trap development.

arXiv:1105.4752•New Journal of Physics•Jul 20, 2011•102 citations
Abstract Trapped-ion hardware based on the magnetic gradient induced coupling (MAGIC) scheme is emerging as a promising platform for quantum computing. Nevertheless, in this—as in any other—quantum-computing platform, many technical questions still have to be resolved before large-scale and error-tolerant applications are possible. In this work, we present a thorough discussion of the structure and effects of higher-order terms in the MAGIC setup, which can occur due to anharmonicities in the external potential of the ion crystal (e.g. through Coulomb repulsion) or through curvature of the applied magnetic field. These terms generate systematic shifts in the leading-order interactions and take the form of three-spin couplings, two-spin couplings, local fields, as well as diverse phonon–phonon conversion mechanisms. We find that most of these are negligible in realistic situations, with only two contributions that need careful attention. First, there are undesired longitudinal fields contributing shifts to the resonance frequency, whose strength increases with chain length and phonon occupation numbers; while their mean effect can easily be compensated by additional Z rotations, phonon number fluctuations need to be avoided for precise gate operations. Second, anharmonicities of the Coulomb interaction can lead to well-known two-to-one conversions of phonon excitations. Both of these error terms can be mitigated by sufficiently cooling the phonons to the ground-state. Our detailed analysis constitutes an important contribution on the way of making magnetic-gradient trapped-ion quantum technology fit for large-scale applications, and it may inspire new ways to purposefully design interaction terms.
Trapped ion hardware has made significant progress recently and is now one of the leading platforms for quantum computing. To construct two-qubit gates in trapped ions, experimental manipulation approaches for ion chains are becoming increasingly prevalent. Given the restricted control technology, how implementing high-fidelity quantum gate operations is crucial. Many works in current pulse design optimization focus on ion-phonon and effective ion-ion coupling while ignoring the higher-order expansion impacts of these two terms brought on by experiment defects. This paper proposed a novel robust quantum control optimization method in trapped ions. By introducing the higher-order terms caused by the error into the optimization cost function, we generated an extremely robust Molmer-Sorensen gate with infidelity below 10−310^{-3}10−3 under drift noise range ±10\pm 10±10 kHz and time noise range ±0.02\pm 0.02±0.02. Our work reveals the vital role of higher-order coupling terms in trapped ion pulse control optimization, especially the higher ion-ion coupling order, and provides a robust optimization scheme for realizing more efficient entangled states in trapped ion platforms.
Abstract Trapped ion hardware has made significant progress recently and is now one of the leading platforms for quantum computing. To construct two-qubit gates in trapped ions, experimental manipulation approaches for ion chains are becoming increasingly prevalent. Given the restricted control technology, how implementing high-fidelity quantum gate operations is crucial. Many works in current pulse design optimization focus on ion–phonon and effective ion–ion couplings while ignoring the first-order derivative terms expansion impacts of these two terms brought on by experiment defects. This paper proposes a novel robust quantum control optimization method in trapped ions. By introducing the first-order derivative terms caused by the error into the optimization cost function, we generate an extremely robust Mølmer–Sørensen gate with infidelity below 10−3 under a drift noise range of ±10 kHz, the relative robustness achieves a tolerance of ±5%, compared to the 200-kHz frequency spacing between phonon modes, and for time noise drift, the tolerance reached to 2%. Our work reveals the vital role of the first-order derivative terms of coupling in trapped ion pulse control optimization, especially the first-order derivative terms of ion–ion coupling. It provides a robust optimization scheme for realizing more efficient entangled states in trapped ion platforms.
We discuss the experimental feasibility of quantum simulation with trapped ion crystals, using magnetic field gradients. We describe a micro structured planar ion trap, which contains a central wire loop generating a strong magnetic gradient of about 20 T/m in an ion crystal held about 160 μm above the surface. On the theoretical side, we extend a proposal about spin-spin interactions via magnetic gradient induced coupling (MAGIC) [J. Phys. B At. Mol. Opt. Phys. 42, 154009 (2009)]. We describe aspects where planar ion traps promise novel physics: spin-spin coupling strengths of transversal eigenmodes exhibit significant advantages over the coupling schemes in longitudinal direction that have been previously investigated. With a chip device and a magnetic field coil with small inductance, a resonant enhancement of magnetic spin forces through the application of alternating magnetic field gradients is proposed. Such resonantly enhanced spin-spin coupling may be used, for instance, to create Schrödinger cat states. Finally we investigate magnetic gradient interactions in two-dimensional ion crystals, and discuss frustration effects in such two-dimensional arrangements.
The understanding of quantum mechanical systems is essential to modern physics and its applications. However, already for entangled systems of a few tens of constituents, exact numerical simulations on classical computers can become impossible. Quantum simulators based on well-controlled quantum system might provide the only effective approach to these systems. Trapped atomic ions offer a uniquely precise and controllable platform. They are used as platforms for, e.g., future quantum computers, quantum simulators, and extremely precise clocks. Quantum-simulation problems of interest and out-of-reach for modern theoretical methods include the dynamics of one-dimensional systems on long time scales and more-than-one dimensional systems with long-range interaction. For the latter, two-dimensional arrays of ions, individually trapped and controlled above microfabricated surface-electrode traps, present a promising approach. In the first realizations so far, the inter-site distance between the ions was too large to allow for sufficient inter-site coupling. We aim for a scalable approach to an analog quantum simulator based on a two-dimensional array of individually trapped ions. As a first demonstration, we operate an array of three magnesium ions in triangular arrangement with a side-length of 40µm. Therein, we previously demonstrated the individual control of internal (electronic) and external (motional) degrees of freedom of the ions. Here, we present the first realization of inter-site coupling in the two-dimensional array. We demonstrate the coupling by a transfer of large coherent states of motion between the sites. We investigate the influence of the amplitude of these motional states in the anharmonic trapping potential and extrapolate to future experiments on the single-phonon level. We apply the real-time control of the coupling and concatenate the two-site coupling to transfer motional excitation between all three sites of the array. To demonstrate the scalability of our techniques, we couple all three sites simultaneously and investigate the evolution of an initial excitation at one and two sites of the array. The latter shows interference effects of the different pathways in the triangle. Current motional heating rates on the order of the inter-site coupling, preclude working with single phonons near the motional ground-state. We present a new experimental apparatus and vacuum chamber which will allow in-situ cleaning of surface-electrode traps. This has shown to reduce motional heating rates by two orders of magnitude. In this apparatus, we additionally realize a magnetic-field insensitive qubit in 25Mg+ with a coherence time exceeding six seconds. We generate the magnetic field around 10.9mT by a hybrid magnet assembly based on solid-state magnets and fine-tuned by electric coils. Once we have reduced the heating rate in the triangle trap array using the new setup, first quantum simulation experiments, investigating spin-frustration or artificial gauge fields, will come in reach. Here our triangle represents a basic, scalable, building block of future latices designed at will.
The Coulomb repulsion between ions in a linear Paul trap gives rise to anharmonic terms in the potential energy when expanded about the equilibrium positions. We examine the effect of these anharmonic terms on the accuracy of a quantum simulator made from trapped ions. To be concrete, we consider a linear chain of Yb171+{\text{Yb}}^{171+}Yb171+ ions stabilized close to the zigzag transition. We find that for typical experimental temperatures, frequencies change by no more than a factor of 0.010.01%0.01 due to the anharmonic couplings. Furthermore, shifts in the effective spin-spin interactions (driven by a spin-dependent optical dipole force) are also, in general, less than 0.010.01%0.01 for detunings to the blue of the transverse center-of-mass frequency. However, detuning the spin interactions near other frequencies can lead to non-negligible anharmonic contributions to the effective spin-spin interactions. We also examine an odd behavior exhibited by the harmonic spin-spin interactions for a range of intermediate detunings, where nearest-neighbor spins with a larger spatial separation on the ion chain interact more strongly than nearest neighbors with a smaller spatial separation.
We theoretically and experimentally examine the effects of anharmonic terms in the trapping potential for linear chains of trapped ions. We concentrate on two different effects that become significant at different levels of anharmonicity. The first is a modification of the oscillation frequencies and amplitudes of the ions' normal modes of vibration for multi-ion crystals, resulting from each ion experiencing a different curvature in the potential. In the second effect, which occurs with increased anharmonicity or higher excitation amplitude, amplitude-dependent shifts of the normal-mode frequencies become important. We evaluate normal-mode frequency and amplitude shifts, and comment on the implications for quantum information processing and quantum state engineering. Since the ratio of the anharmonic to harmonic terms typically increases as the ion–electrode distance decreases, anharmonic effects will become more significant as ion trap sizes are reduced. To avoid unwanted problems, anharmonicities should therefore be taken into account at the design stage of trap development.