Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2408.09318 · npj Quantum Information

Practical security of twin-field quantum key distribution with optical phase-locked loop under wavelength-switching attack

Qingquan Peng, Jiu-Peng Chen, Tianyi Xing, Dongyang Wang, Yizhi Wang, Yang Liu, Anqi Huang

Published Jan 18, 2025• 20 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The twin-field class quantum key distribution (TF-class QKD) has experimentally demonstrated the ability to surpass the fundamental rate-distance limit without requiring a quantum repeater, as a revolutional milestone. In TF-class QKD implementation, an optical phase-locked loop (OPLL) structure is commonly employed to generate a reference light with correlated phase, ensuring coherence of optical fields between Alice and Bob. In this configuration, the reference light, typically located in the untrusted station Charlie, solely provides wavelength reference for OPLL and does not participate in quantum-state encoding. However, the reference light may open a door for Eve to enter the source stations that are supposed to be well protected. Here, by identifying vulnerabilities of an acousto-optic modulator (AOM) in the OPLL scheme, we propose and demonstrate a wavelength-switching attack on a TF-class QKD system. This attack involves Eve deliberately manipulating the wavelength of the reference light to increase mean photon number of prepared quantum states, while maintaining stable interference between Alice and Bob as required by TF-class QKD protocols. The maximum observed increase in mean photon number is 8.7%, which has been theoretically proven to compromise the security of a TF-class QKD system. Moreover, we have shown that with well calibration of the modulators, the attack can be eliminated. Through this study, we highlight the importance of system calibration in the practical security in TF-class QKD implementation.

DOI
10.1038/s41534-025-00963-9

Related papers

Implementation Security of Twin-Field Quantum Key Distribution using Optical Injection Locking

Sergio Juárez, A. Marcomini, Mikhail Petrov +5 more

Twin-field quantum key distribution (TF-QKD) has become a leading protocol to bring quantum communications to the national scale. The protocol requires the establishment of a shared phase and frequency reference between distant parties, which is commonly achieved by using an external reference laser in an optical injection locking (OIL) architecture. In this work, we analyze the side channels in OIL-based TF-QKD that may arise from adversarial manipulation of the various degrees of freedom of this untrusted reference beam. We experimentally demonstrate two realistic attack scenarios: fast intensity modulation of the reference laser, and additional signals embedded in the reference light exploiting wavelengths undetectable by conventional monitoring techniques. These attacks can allow a potential eavesdropper to deterministically increase the mean photon number of the sources, or circumvent the decoy-state technique, respectively. To counter these vulnerabilities, we propose practical and highly effective countermeasures that reinforce the security of TF-QKD systems without significant additional complexity or performance degradation.

arXiv:2508.21763•Physical Review A•Jan 1, 2026•2 citations

Experimental repeater-like quantum communications over 600 km of optical fibre aided by wavelength-multiplexed phase stabilization

Mirko Pittaluga, Mariella Minder, Marco Lucamarini +4 more

Twin-field (TF) quantum key distribution (QKD) fundamentally alters the rate-distance relationship of QKD, offering the scaling of a single-node quantum repeater. Although recent experiments have demonstrated the new opportunities for secure long-distance communications allowed by TF-QKD, formidable challenges remain to unlock its true potential. Here, we introduce a novel wavelength-multiplexed stabilisation scheme that overcomes past limitations and can be adapted to other phase-sensitive single-photon applications. In our work, we develop a setup that provides key rates over a record fibre distance of 605 km and increases the secure key rate at long distances by two orders of magnitude to values of practical significance.

Quantum Computing, Communication, and Simulation•Mar 9, 2022•0 citations

Analysis of an injection-locking-loophole attack from an external source for quantum key distribution

Xiaoxu Zhang, Mu-Sheng Jiang, Yang Wang +5 more

Many security loopholes exist in quantum key distribution (QKD) due to the imperfections of realistic devices. On the source side, the decoy-state method can defend against the most severe photon-number-splitting (PNS) attack and improve the performance of QKD. Measurement-device-independent QKD and twin-field QKD have further closed all loopholes on the detection side. In this paper, we propose a valuable optical injection-locking loophole for the case when the internal isolator inside the laser is removed. We first introduce the effects of the injection locking with different injection intensities on the source frequency. Through the successive responses of adjacent pulses from frequency ports of the dense wavelength division multiplexer, the decoy state and the signal state can be partially distinguished. The specific injection-locking-loophole analysis of the isolatorless decoy phase-encoding Bennet-Brassard 1984 QKD and decoy phase-matching QKD protocols with external optical injection has been deeply studied. Simulation results show that, if we maintain the same observed gain statistics as normal after an external optical injection locking, the loophole cannot be exploited for a PNS attack when the QKD distance is short. As the QKD distance increases, a PNS attack at a medium distance using the optical injection-locking loophole does not threaten the security; the security is still valid. With the further increase of the QKD distance, the lower-bound secure key rate is higher than the upper-bound secure key rate given by a PNS attack at a long distance, some of the keys must be insecure, and information will be leaked.

Physical Review A•Dec 12, 2022•7 citations

Direct intensity and phase modulation for quantum key distribution transmitters

Hui Liu, Gleb Nazarikov, Idelfonso Tafur Monroy

The decoy-state method serves as a cornerstone for practical quantum key distribution (QKD) with inherent immunity to photon-number-splitting attacks. Leveraging optical injection locking, we propose a directly modulated light source with a scheme that simultaneously generates intensity- and phase-modulated signals without external modulators. Removing external modulators eliminates modulator-related side-channel vulnerabilities, fundamentally enhancing QKD security. Integrated into a high-speed phase-encoding BB84 system with optimized one-decoy protocol and finite-size analysis, our system achieves positive key rates up to 20 dB channel loss (100 km fiber) with commercial InGaAs single-photon detectors, reducing transmitter complexity while ensuring security for practical QKD applications.

Optics Express•May 15, 2026•0 citations

Twin-field quantum key distribution with optical injection locking and phase encoding on-chip

Han Du, Taofiq K. Paraïso, Mirko Pittaluga +3 more

Twin-field (TF) quantum key distribution (QKD) has been proved to overcome the linear rate-distance limit of repeaterless quantum communications and has the capability to generate high key rates over long distances compared with other QKD protocols. Photonic integration has proven a promising technique for the large-scale deployment of QKD. While it has been adopted to implement a range of linearly scaling QKD protocols, there is to date no demonstration of TF QKD using photonic integrated chips. One important challenge resides in establishing high coherence between remote laser chips. In this study, we exploit optical injection locking to implement phase dissemination to independent lasers integrated onto photonic circuits and further demonstrate complete phase control on the same chip using electro-optic phase modulators. We achieve high laser coherence between remote transmitter nodes, which lets us demonstrate a quadratic key-rate improvement of the secure key rate beyond 80 dB of channel attenuation. The experimental results are in excellent agreement with the theory in both finite size and asymptotic regimes, in which the fundamental rate-distance limit is overcome. Our work paves the way for the deployment of large-scale TF QKD networks enabled by compact, low-cost, and high-yield chip-based devices.

Optica•Sep 5, 2024•19 citations

Proof-of-Principle Experimental Demonstration of Twin-Field Type Quantum Key Distribution

Xiaoqing Zhong, Jianyong Hu, Marcos Curty +2 more

The twin-field (TF) quantum key distribution (QKD) protocol and its variants are highly attractive because they can beat the well-known fundamental limit of the secret key rate for point-to-point QKD without quantum repeaters (repeaterless bound). In this Letter, we perform a proof-of-principle experimental demonstration of TFQKD based on the protocol proposed by Curty, Azuma, and Lo, which removes the need for postselection on the matching of a global phase from the original TFQKD scheme and can deliver a high secret key rate. Furthermore, we employ a Sagnac loop structure to help overcome the major difficulty in the practical implementation of TFQKD, namely, the need to stabilize the phase of the quantum state over kilometers of fiber. As a proof-of-principle demonstration, the estimated secure key rate from our experimental TFQKD data at the high loss region surpasses the repeaterless bound of QKD with current technology.

arXiv:1902.10209•Physical Review Letters•Sep 5, 2019•196 citations
The twin-field class quantum key distribution (TF-class QKD) has experimentally demonstrated the ability to surpass the fundamental rate-distance limit without requiring a quantum repeater, as a revolutional milestone. In TF-class QKD implementation, an optical phase-locked loop (OPLL) structure is commonly employed to generate a reference light with correlated phase, ensuring coherence of optical fields between Alice and Bob. In this configuration, the reference light, typically located in the untrusted station Charlie, solely provides wavelength reference for OPLL and does not participate in quantum-state encoding. However, the reference light may open a door for Eve to enter the source stations that are supposed to be well protected. Here, by identifying vulnerabilities of an acousto-optic modulator (AOM) in the OPLL scheme, we propose and demonstrate a wavelength-switching attack on a TF-class QKD system. This attack involves Eve deliberately manipulating the wavelength of the reference light to increase mean photon number of prepared quantum states, while maintaining stable interference between Alice and Bob as required by TF-class QKD protocols. The maximum observed increase in mean photon number is 8.7%, which has been theoretically proven to compromise the security of a TF-class QKD system. Moreover, we have shown that with well calibration of the modulators, the attack can be eliminated. Through this study, we highlight the importance of system calibration in the practical security in TF-class QKD implementation.
Twin-field quantum key distribution (TF-QKD) has become a leading protocol to bring quantum communications to the national scale. The protocol requires the establishment of a shared phase and frequency reference between distant parties, which is commonly achieved by using an external reference laser in an optical injection locking (OIL) architecture. In this work, we analyze the side channels in OIL-based TF-QKD that may arise from adversarial manipulation of the various degrees of freedom of this untrusted reference beam. We experimentally demonstrate two realistic attack scenarios: fast intensity modulation of the reference laser, and additional signals embedded in the reference light exploiting wavelengths undetectable by conventional monitoring techniques. These attacks can allow a potential eavesdropper to deterministically increase the mean photon number of the sources, or circumvent the decoy-state technique, respectively. To counter these vulnerabilities, we propose practical and highly effective countermeasures that reinforce the security of TF-QKD systems without significant additional complexity or performance degradation.
Twin-field (TF) quantum key distribution (QKD) fundamentally alters the rate-distance relationship of QKD, offering the scaling of a single-node quantum repeater. Although recent experiments have demonstrated the new opportunities for secure long-distance communications allowed by TF-QKD, formidable challenges remain to unlock its true potential. Here, we introduce a novel wavelength-multiplexed stabilisation scheme that overcomes past limitations and can be adapted to other phase-sensitive single-photon applications. In our work, we develop a setup that provides key rates over a record fibre distance of 605 km and increases the secure key rate at long distances by two orders of magnitude to values of practical significance.
Many security loopholes exist in quantum key distribution (QKD) due to the imperfections of realistic devices. On the source side, the decoy-state method can defend against the most severe photon-number-splitting (PNS) attack and improve the performance of QKD. Measurement-device-independent QKD and twin-field QKD have further closed all loopholes on the detection side. In this paper, we propose a valuable optical injection-locking loophole for the case when the internal isolator inside the laser is removed. We first introduce the effects of the injection locking with different injection intensities on the source frequency. Through the successive responses of adjacent pulses from frequency ports of the dense wavelength division multiplexer, the decoy state and the signal state can be partially distinguished. The specific injection-locking-loophole analysis of the isolatorless decoy phase-encoding Bennet-Brassard 1984 QKD and decoy phase-matching QKD protocols with external optical injection has been deeply studied. Simulation results show that, if we maintain the same observed gain statistics as normal after an external optical injection locking, the loophole cannot be exploited for a PNS attack when the QKD distance is short. As the QKD distance increases, a PNS attack at a medium distance using the optical injection-locking loophole does not threaten the security; the security is still valid. With the further increase of the QKD distance, the lower-bound secure key rate is higher than the upper-bound secure key rate given by a PNS attack at a long distance, some of the keys must be insecure, and information will be leaked.
The decoy-state method serves as a cornerstone for practical quantum key distribution (QKD) with inherent immunity to photon-number-splitting attacks. Leveraging optical injection locking, we propose a directly modulated light source with a scheme that simultaneously generates intensity- and phase-modulated signals without external modulators. Removing external modulators eliminates modulator-related side-channel vulnerabilities, fundamentally enhancing QKD security. Integrated into a high-speed phase-encoding BB84 system with optimized one-decoy protocol and finite-size analysis, our system achieves positive key rates up to 20 dB channel loss (100 km fiber) with commercial InGaAs single-photon detectors, reducing transmitter complexity while ensuring security for practical QKD applications.
Twin-field (TF) quantum key distribution (QKD) has been proved to overcome the linear rate-distance limit of repeaterless quantum communications and has the capability to generate high key rates over long distances compared with other QKD protocols. Photonic integration has proven a promising technique for the large-scale deployment of QKD. While it has been adopted to implement a range of linearly scaling QKD protocols, there is to date no demonstration of TF QKD using photonic integrated chips. One important challenge resides in establishing high coherence between remote laser chips. In this study, we exploit optical injection locking to implement phase dissemination to independent lasers integrated onto photonic circuits and further demonstrate complete phase control on the same chip using electro-optic phase modulators. We achieve high laser coherence between remote transmitter nodes, which lets us demonstrate a quadratic key-rate improvement of the secure key rate beyond 80 dB of channel attenuation. The experimental results are in excellent agreement with the theory in both finite size and asymptotic regimes, in which the fundamental rate-distance limit is overcome. Our work paves the way for the deployment of large-scale TF QKD networks enabled by compact, low-cost, and high-yield chip-based devices.
The twin-field (TF) quantum key distribution (QKD) protocol and its variants are highly attractive because they can beat the well-known fundamental limit of the secret key rate for point-to-point QKD without quantum repeaters (repeaterless bound). In this Letter, we perform a proof-of-principle experimental demonstration of TFQKD based on the protocol proposed by Curty, Azuma, and Lo, which removes the need for postselection on the matching of a global phase from the original TFQKD scheme and can deliver a high secret key rate. Furthermore, we employ a Sagnac loop structure to help overcome the major difficulty in the practical implementation of TFQKD, namely, the need to stabilize the phase of the quantum state over kilometers of fiber. As a proof-of-principle demonstration, the estimated secure key rate from our experimental TFQKD data at the high loss region surpasses the repeaterless bound of QKD with current technology.