Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2407.17558 · Physical Review Research

Superfluidity and sound propagation in disordered Bose gases

Kevin T. Geier, Jeff Maki, Alberto Biella, F. Dalfovo, S. Giorgini, S. Stringari

Published Feb 21, 2025• 6 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Superfluidity describes the ability of quantum matter to flow without friction. Due to its fundamental role in many transport phenomena, it is crucial to understand the robustness of superfluid properties to external perturbations. Here, we theoretically study the effects of speckle disorder on the propagation of sound waves in a two-dimensional Bose-Einstein condensate at zero temperature. We numerically solve the Gross-Pitaevskii equation in the presence of disorder and employ a superfluid hydrodynamic approach to elucidate the role of the compressibility and superfluid fraction in the propagation of sound. A key result is that disorder reduces the superfluid fraction and hence the speed of sound; it also introduces damping and mode coupling. In the limit of weak disorder, the predictions for the speed of sound and its damping rate are well reproduced by a quadratic perturbation theory. The hydrodynamic description is valid over a wide range of parameters, while discrepancies become evident if the disorder becomes too strong, the effect being more significant for disorder applied in only one spatial direction. Our predictions are well within the reach of state-of-the-art cold-atom experiments and carry over to more general disorder potentials.

DOI
10.1103/physrevresearch.7.013187

Related papers

Speed of sound in disordered Bose-Einstein condensates

Christopher Gaul, Nina Renner, Cord Axel Müller

Disorder modifies the sound-wave excitation spectrum of Bose-Einstein condensates. We consider the classical hydrodynamic limit, where the disorder correlation length is much longer than the condensate healing length. By perturbation theory, we compute the phonon lifetime and the correction to the speed of sound. This correction is found to be negative in all dimensions, with universal asymptotics for smooth correlations. Considering in detail optical speckle potentials, we find a quite rich intermediate structure. This has consequences for the average density of states, particularly in one dimension, where we find a ``boson dip'' next to a sharp ``boson peak'' as function of frequency. In one dimension, our prediction is verified in detail by a numerical integration of the Gross-Pitaevskii equation.

arXiv:0908.1947•Physical Review A•Nov 20, 2009•22 citations

Collisionless Sound in a Uniform Two-Dimensional Bose Gas

Miki Ota, F. Larcher, F. Dalfovo +3 more

Using linear response theory within the random phase approximation, we investigate the propagation of sound in a uniform two dimensional (2D) Bose gas in the collisionless regime. We show that the sudden removal of a static density perturbation produces a damped oscillatory behavior revealing that sound can propagate also in the absence of collisions, due to mean-field interaction effects. We provide explicit results for the sound velocity and damping as a function of temperature, pointing out the crucial role played by Landau damping. We support our predictions by performing numerical simulations with the stochastic (projected) Gross-Pitaevskii equation. The results are consistent with the recent experimental observation of sound in a weakly interacting 2D Bose gas both below and above the superfluid Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless transition.

arXiv:1804.04032•Physical Review Letters•Oct 3, 2018•49 citations

Bose-Einstein condensate in weak 3d isotropic speckle disorder

B. Abdullaev, Axel Pelster

The effect of a weak three-dimensional (3d) isotropic laser speckle disorder on various thermodynamic properties of a dilute Bose gas is considered at zero temperature. First, we summarize the derivation of the autocorrelation function of laser speckles in 1d and 2d following the seminal work of Goodman. The goal of this discussion is to show that a Gaussian approximation of this function, proposed in some recent papers, is inconsistent with the general background of laser speckle theory. Then we propose a possible experimental realization for an isotropic 3d laser speckle potential and derive its corresponding autocorrelation function. Using a Fourier transform of that function, we calculate both condensate depletion and sound velocity of a Bose- Einstein condensate as disorder ensemble averages of such a weak laser speckle potential within a perturbative solution of the Gross-Pitaevskii equation. By doing so, we reproduce the expression of the normalfluid density obtained earlier within the treatment of Landau. This physically transparent derivation shows that condensate particles, which are scattered by disorder, form a gas of quasiparticles which is responsible for the normalfluid component.

•Jan 1, 2012•6 citations

Sound Propagation in a Uniform Superfluid Two-Dimensional Bose Gas

Jean-Loup Ville, R. Saint-Jalm, É. Le Cerf +4 more

In superfluid systems several sound modes can be excited, such as, for example, first and second sound in liquid helium. Here, we excite running and standing waves in a uniform two-dimensional Bose gas and we characterize the propagation of sound in both the superfluid and normal regimes. In the superfluid phase, the measured speed of sound is in good agreement with the prediction of a two-fluid hydrodynamic model, and the weak damping is well explained by the scattering with thermal excitations. In the normal phase we observe a stronger damping, which we attribute to a departure from hydrodynamic behavior.

arXiv:1804.04037•Physical Review Letters•Oct 3, 2018•100 citations

Excitations in hydrodynamic ultra-cold Bose gases

Adrien E.D. Groot

The field of ultra-cold atomic physics allows probing of two-component quantum liquids with a hydrodynamic normal fluid accompanied by superfluid Bose-Einstein condensates (BEC’s), where the experimental results can be compared to theoretical predictions of the behavior of a weakly interacting two fluid system. Hydrodynamicity in quantum systems like BEC's can have influence on multiple aspects of the collective behavior of the system, such as on the oscillation frequency of quadrupole modes, multiple sound modes in the condensate, but also on high-order excitations which resemble standing sound waves. The hydrodynamicity and excitations of the ultra-cold atomic cloud are the main motivation for the experiments presented in this thesis. In the Utrecht experiment large BEC's up to a few hundred million atoms are produced, which are deeply in the hydrodynamic collisional regime. The macroscopic behavior of the cloud of atoms is dominated by inter-atomic collisions since the mean free path of the individual particles is much smaller than the size of the atomic sample and local equilibrium is established. The influence of the hydrodynamicity on the collective excitations can be investigated by measuring the quadrupole frequency of ultra-cold atomic clouds above the transition temperature Tc, where Bose-Einstein condensation occurs. This quadrupole frequency is determined by measuring the collective shape oscillations of the atomic cloud, where the oscillation frequency is influenced by inter-atomic collisions during the shape oscillations due to the hydrodynamicity of the atomic cloud. The hydrodynamic equations predict the existence of two sound modes in ultra-cold atomic gases below Tc. The speeds of sound are dependent on both the temperature and the chemical potential of the atomic cloud. For low enough temperatures or large enough chemical potential these two speeds of sound become comparable and reaching this regime experimentally allows measuring the speed of sound beyond this avoided crossing. An alternate method of measuring the speed of sound of ultra-cold atomic clouds is exploiting the analogy between a standing sound wave-pattern and high order excitations in BEC's, also referred to as Faraday waves. By exciting the wave-pattern with a frequency and measuring the wavenumber k of the wave-pattern, the speed of sound c can be extracted from the linear dispersion relation. In the process of exciting the standing wave-pattern, remarkable dynamics is discovered in the BECs. As a result of the excitation a large array of other modes are excited next to the wave-pattern. These modes are for example the dipole mode, the axial and radial quadrupole modes, and the scissor mode. This gives rise to complex dynamics in this hydrodynamic quantum mechanical system and although the ultra-cold sample is only excited with a very short pulsed excitation, these modes and the wave-pattern show a large degree of reproducibility during several seconds of time evolution.

•Jun 8, 2015•3 citations

Finite-temperature superfluid depletion of disordered Bose gases

Cord Axel Müller

Abstract At zero temperature, homogeneous interacting Bose-condensed fluids are entirely superfluid, with remarkable transport properties. A non-superfluid, normal component is induced by finite temperatures and spatial inhomogeneity, the combined effects of which are rather intriguing, and difficult to describe quantitatively. By inhomogeneous Bogoliubov theory, applicable to weakly interacting condensed Bose gases in static external potentials with arbitrary spatial correlations, we calculate the normal fluid density via the transverse current–current correlation. We obtain finite-temperature disorder corrections to the normal fraction known since Laudau’s seminal two-fluid theory, using diagrammatic perturbation theory for systems of any dimensionality, with closed analytical expressions to leading, quadratic order in disorder strength.

arXiv:2602.21380•New Journal of Physics•Sep 9, 2026•0 citations
Superfluidity describes the ability of quantum matter to flow without friction. Due to its fundamental role in many transport phenomena, it is crucial to understand the robustness of superfluid properties to external perturbations. Here, we theoretically study the effects of speckle disorder on the propagation of sound waves in a two-dimensional Bose-Einstein condensate at zero temperature. We numerically solve the Gross-Pitaevskii equation in the presence of disorder and employ a superfluid hydrodynamic approach to elucidate the role of the compressibility and superfluid fraction in the propagation of sound. A key result is that disorder reduces the superfluid fraction and hence the speed of sound; it also introduces damping and mode coupling. In the limit of weak disorder, the predictions for the speed of sound and its damping rate are well reproduced by a quadratic perturbation theory. The hydrodynamic description is valid over a wide range of parameters, while discrepancies become evident if the disorder becomes too strong, the effect being more significant for disorder applied in only one spatial direction. Our predictions are well within the reach of state-of-the-art cold-atom experiments and carry over to more general disorder potentials.
Disorder modifies the sound-wave excitation spectrum of Bose-Einstein condensates. We consider the classical hydrodynamic limit, where the disorder correlation length is much longer than the condensate healing length. By perturbation theory, we compute the phonon lifetime and the correction to the speed of sound. This correction is found to be negative in all dimensions, with universal asymptotics for smooth correlations. Considering in detail optical speckle potentials, we find a quite rich intermediate structure. This has consequences for the average density of states, particularly in one dimension, where we find a ``boson dip'' next to a sharp ``boson peak'' as function of frequency. In one dimension, our prediction is verified in detail by a numerical integration of the Gross-Pitaevskii equation.
Using linear response theory within the random phase approximation, we investigate the propagation of sound in a uniform two dimensional (2D) Bose gas in the collisionless regime. We show that the sudden removal of a static density perturbation produces a damped oscillatory behavior revealing that sound can propagate also in the absence of collisions, due to mean-field interaction effects. We provide explicit results for the sound velocity and damping as a function of temperature, pointing out the crucial role played by Landau damping. We support our predictions by performing numerical simulations with the stochastic (projected) Gross-Pitaevskii equation. The results are consistent with the recent experimental observation of sound in a weakly interacting 2D Bose gas both below and above the superfluid Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless transition.
The effect of a weak three-dimensional (3d) isotropic laser speckle disorder on various thermodynamic properties of a dilute Bose gas is considered at zero temperature. First, we summarize the derivation of the autocorrelation function of laser speckles in 1d and 2d following the seminal work of Goodman. The goal of this discussion is to show that a Gaussian approximation of this function, proposed in some recent papers, is inconsistent with the general background of laser speckle theory. Then we propose a possible experimental realization for an isotropic 3d laser speckle potential and derive its corresponding autocorrelation function. Using a Fourier transform of that function, we calculate both condensate depletion and sound velocity of a Bose- Einstein condensate as disorder ensemble averages of such a weak laser speckle potential within a perturbative solution of the Gross-Pitaevskii equation. By doing so, we reproduce the expression of the normalfluid density obtained earlier within the treatment of Landau. This physically transparent derivation shows that condensate particles, which are scattered by disorder, form a gas of quasiparticles which is responsible for the normalfluid component.
In superfluid systems several sound modes can be excited, such as, for example, first and second sound in liquid helium. Here, we excite running and standing waves in a uniform two-dimensional Bose gas and we characterize the propagation of sound in both the superfluid and normal regimes. In the superfluid phase, the measured speed of sound is in good agreement with the prediction of a two-fluid hydrodynamic model, and the weak damping is well explained by the scattering with thermal excitations. In the normal phase we observe a stronger damping, which we attribute to a departure from hydrodynamic behavior.
The field of ultra-cold atomic physics allows probing of two-component quantum liquids with a hydrodynamic normal fluid accompanied by superfluid Bose-Einstein condensates (BEC’s), where the experimental results can be compared to theoretical predictions of the behavior of a weakly interacting two fluid system. Hydrodynamicity in quantum systems like BEC's can have influence on multiple aspects of the collective behavior of the system, such as on the oscillation frequency of quadrupole modes, multiple sound modes in the condensate, but also on high-order excitations which resemble standing sound waves. The hydrodynamicity and excitations of the ultra-cold atomic cloud are the main motivation for the experiments presented in this thesis. In the Utrecht experiment large BEC's up to a few hundred million atoms are produced, which are deeply in the hydrodynamic collisional regime. The macroscopic behavior of the cloud of atoms is dominated by inter-atomic collisions since the mean free path of the individual particles is much smaller than the size of the atomic sample and local equilibrium is established. The influence of the hydrodynamicity on the collective excitations can be investigated by measuring the quadrupole frequency of ultra-cold atomic clouds above the transition temperature Tc, where Bose-Einstein condensation occurs. This quadrupole frequency is determined by measuring the collective shape oscillations of the atomic cloud, where the oscillation frequency is influenced by inter-atomic collisions during the shape oscillations due to the hydrodynamicity of the atomic cloud. The hydrodynamic equations predict the existence of two sound modes in ultra-cold atomic gases below Tc. The speeds of sound are dependent on both the temperature and the chemical potential of the atomic cloud. For low enough temperatures or large enough chemical potential these two speeds of sound become comparable and reaching this regime experimentally allows measuring the speed of sound beyond this avoided crossing. An alternate method of measuring the speed of sound of ultra-cold atomic clouds is exploiting the analogy between a standing sound wave-pattern and high order excitations in BEC's, also referred to as Faraday waves. By exciting the wave-pattern with a frequency and measuring the wavenumber k of the wave-pattern, the speed of sound c can be extracted from the linear dispersion relation. In the process of exciting the standing wave-pattern, remarkable dynamics is discovered in the BECs. As a result of the excitation a large array of other modes are excited next to the wave-pattern. These modes are for example the dipole mode, the axial and radial quadrupole modes, and the scissor mode. This gives rise to complex dynamics in this hydrodynamic quantum mechanical system and although the ultra-cold sample is only excited with a very short pulsed excitation, these modes and the wave-pattern show a large degree of reproducibility during several seconds of time evolution.
Abstract At zero temperature, homogeneous interacting Bose-condensed fluids are entirely superfluid, with remarkable transport properties. A non-superfluid, normal component is induced by finite temperatures and spatial inhomogeneity, the combined effects of which are rather intriguing, and difficult to describe quantitatively. By inhomogeneous Bogoliubov theory, applicable to weakly interacting condensed Bose gases in static external potentials with arbitrary spatial correlations, we calculate the normal fluid density via the transverse current–current correlation. We obtain finite-temperature disorder corrections to the normal fraction known since Laudau’s seminal two-fluid theory, using diagrammatic perturbation theory for systems of any dimensionality, with closed analytical expressions to leading, quadratic order in disorder strength.