Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2407.15944 · IEEE Transactions on Information Theory

Unextendible Entanglement of Quantum Channels

Vishal Singh, Mark M. Wilde

Published May 7, 2025• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum communication relies on the existence of high quality quantum channels to exchange information. In practice, however, all communication links are affected by noise from the environment. Here we investigate the ability of quantum channels to perform quantum communication tasks by restricting the participants to use only local operations and one-way classical communication (one-way LOCC) along with the available quantum channel. In particular, a channel can be used to distill a highly entangled state between two parties, which further enables quantum or private communication. In this work, we invoke the framework of superchannels to study the distillation of a resourceful quantum state, such as a maximally entangled state or a private state, using multiple instances of a point-to-point quantum channel. We use the idea ofk-extendibility to obtain a semidefinite relaxation of the set of one-way LOCC superchannels and define a class of entanglement measures for quantum channels that decrease monotonically under such superchannels; therefore these measures, dubbed collectively the “unextendible entanglement of a channel”, yield upper bounds on several communication-theoretic quantities of interest in the regimes of resource distillation and zero error.We then generalize the formalism ofk-extendibility to bipartite superchannels, thus obtaining functions that are monotone under two-extendible superchannels. This allows us to analyze probabilistic distillation of ebits or secret key bits from a bipartite state when using a resourceful quantum channel. Moreover, we propose semidefinite programs to evaluate several of these quantities, providing a computationally feasible method of comparison between quantum channels for resource distillation.

DOI
10.1109/tit.2025.3566737

Related papers

Extendibility limits quantum-secured communication and key distillation

Vishal Singh, Mark M. Wilde

Secret-key distillation from quantum states and channels is a central task of interest in quantum information theory, as it facilitates private communication over a quantum network. Here, we study the task of secret-key distillation from bipartite states and point-to-point quantum channels using local operations and one-way classical communication (one-way LOCC). We employ the resource theory of unextendible entanglement to study the transformation of a bipartite state under one-way LOCC, and we obtain several efficiently computable upper bounds on the number of secret bits that can be distilled from a bipartite state using one-way LOCC channels; these findings apply not only in the one-shot setting but also in some restricted asymptotic settings. We extend our formalism to private communication over a quantum channel assisted by forward classical communication. We obtain efficiently computable upper bounds on the one-shot forward-assisted private capacity of a channel, thus addressing a question in the theory of quantum-secured communication that has been open for some time now. Our formalism also provides upper bounds on the rate of private communication when using a large number of channels in such a way that the error in the transmitted private data decreases exponentially with the number of channel uses. Moreover, our bounds can be computed using semidefinite programs, thus providing a computationally feasible method to understand the limits of private communication over a quantum network.

arXiv:2410.21393•Reports on Progress in Physics•Apr 15, 2025•1 citation

Quantifying the unextendibility of entanglement*

Kun Wang, Xin Wang, Mark M. Wilde

Abstract Entanglement is a striking feature of quantum mechanics, and it has a key property called unextendibility. In this paper, we present a framework for quantifying and investigating the unextendibility of general bipartite quantum states. First, we define the unextendible entanglement, a family of entanglement measures based on the concept of a state-dependent set of free states. The intuition behind these measures is that the more entangled a bipartite state is, the less entangled each of its individual systems is with a third party. Second, we demonstrate that the unextendible entanglement is an entanglement monotone under two-extendible quantum operations, including local operations and one-way classical communication as a special case. Normalization and faithfulness are two other desirable properties of unextendible entanglement, which we establish here. We further show that the unextendible entanglement provides efficiently computable benchmarks for the rate of exact entanglement or secret key distillation, as well as the overhead of probabilistic entanglement or secret key distillation.

arXiv:1911.07433•New Journal of Physics•Feb 5, 2024•10 citations

Extendible Quantum Measurements and Limitations on Classical Communication

Vishal Singh, Theshani Nuradha, Mark M. Wilde

Unextendibility of quantum states and channels is inextricably linked to the no-cloning theorem of quantum mechanics, it has played an important role in understanding and quantifying entanglement, and more recently it has found applications in providing limitations on quantum error correction and entanglement distillation. Here we generalize the framework of unextendibility to quantum measurements and define $k$-extendible measurements for every integer $k\ge 2$. Our definition provides a hierarchy of semidefinite constraints that specify a set of measurements containing every measurement that can be realized by local operations and one-way classical communication. Furthermore, the set of $k$-extendible measurements converges to the set of measurements that can be realized by local operations and one-way classical communication as $k\to \infty$. To illustrate the utility of $k$-extendible measurements, we establish a semidefinite programming upper bound on the one-shot classical capacity of a channel, which outperforms the best known efficiently computable bound from [Matthews and Wehner, IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory 60, pp. 7317-7329 (2014)] and also leads to efficiently computable upper bounds on the $n$-shot classical capacity of a channel.

arXiv:2412.18556•IEEE International Symposium on Information Theory (ISIT)•Jun 22, 2025•2 citations

Limiting one-way distillable secret key via privacy testing of extendible states

Vishal Singh, Karol Horodecki, Aby Philip +1 more

The notions of privacy tests and $k$-extendible states have both been instrumental in quantum information theory, particularly in understanding the limits of secure communication. In this paper, we determine the maximum probability with which an arbitrary $k$-extendible state can pass a privacy test, and we prove that it is equal to the maximum fidelity between an arbitrary $k$-extendible state and the standard maximally entangled state. Our findings, coupled with the resource theory of $k$-unextendibility, lead to an efficiently computable upper bound on the one-shot, one-way distillable key of a bipartite state, and we prove that it is equal to the best-known efficiently computable upper bound on the one-shot, one-way distillable entanglement. We also establish efficiently computable upper bounds on the one-shot, forward-assisted private capacity of channels. Extending our formalism to the independent and identically distributed setting, we obtain single-letter efficiently computable bounds on the $n$-shot, one-way distillable key of a state and the $n$-shot, forward-assisted private capacity of a channel. For some key examples of interest, our bounds are significantly tighter than other known efficiently computable bounds.

quant-pharXiv:2511.04438•Nov 7, 2025•0 citations

Estimate Distillable Entanglement and Quantum Capacity by Squeezing Useless Entanglement

Chengkai Zhu, Chenghong Zhu, Xin Wang

Quantum Internet relies on quantum entanglement as a fundamental resource for secure and efficient quantum communication, reshaping data transmission. In this context, entanglement distillation emerges as a crucial process that plays a pivotal role in realizing the full potential of the quantum internet. Nevertheless, it remains challenging to accurately estimate the distillable entanglement and its closely related essential quantity, the quantum capacity. In this work, we consider a general resource measure known as the reverse divergence of resources which quantifies the minimum divergence between a target state and the set of free states. Leveraging this measure, we propose efficiently computable upper bounds for both quantities based on the idea that the useless entanglement within a state or a quantum channel does not contribute to the distillable entanglement or the quantum capacity, respectively. Our bounds can be computed via semidefinite programming and have practical applications for purifying maximally entangled states under practical noises, such as depolarizing and amplitude damping noises, leading to improvements in estimating the one-way distillable entanglement. Furthermore, we provide valuable benchmarks for evaluating the quantum capacities of qubit quantum channels, including the Pauli channels and the random mixed unitary channels, which are of great interest for the development of a quantum internet.

arXiv:2303.07228•IEEE Journal on Selected Areas in Communications•Mar 21, 2024•9 citations

From complete channel order to capacity and one-way distillation

Harjas Sandhu

When does a difference in information become a way to communicate? Imagine two quantum channels as competing routes through noise. One might preserve a distinction that the other loses. That difference is interesting on its own; the question here is whether it can be turned into something operational: a channel that can carry private or quantum information at a positive rate. This paper presents a construction intended to make that step. Starting from a failure of complete quantum-channel information order, it constructs a channel claimed to have strictly positive ordinary private and quantum capacity. “Complete” matters because the comparison allows an input to be correlated with a finite quantum reference: information may be visible in the joint system even when it is hidden from the channel output alone. The construction accounts for the resources it uses, including transmission of the reference and uses of an activation helper. Its conclusion concerns strict positivity: a rate greater than zero, however small. It does not claim a uniform positive gap or fixed-error capacity inapproximability. The paper also develops reductions connecting the capacity questions to one-way distillable entanglement and secret key. The state constructions are designed to retain any prescribed lower bound on two-way distillation. On this basis, the manuscript claims exact-zero undecidability classifications for finite rational-complex memoryless channels and corresponding classifications for the one-way quantities. The information-order equivalences and undecidability premises used in these conclusions are developed in the companion paper, Complete information orders of quantum channels: equivalence and undecidability. A further introduction and citation details are available on the manuscript page.

•Oct 14, 2026•0 citations
Quantum communication relies on the existence of high quality quantum channels to exchange information. In practice, however, all communication links are affected by noise from the environment. Here we investigate the ability of quantum channels to perform quantum communication tasks by restricting the participants to use only local operations and one-way classical communication (one-way LOCC) along with the available quantum channel. In particular, a channel can be used to distill a highly entangled state between two parties, which further enables quantum or private communication. In this work, we invoke the framework of superchannels to study the distillation of a resourceful quantum state, such as a maximally entangled state or a private state, using multiple instances of a point-to-point quantum channel. We use the idea ofk-extendibility to obtain a semidefinite relaxation of the set of one-way LOCC superchannels and define a class of entanglement measures for quantum channels that decrease monotonically under such superchannels; therefore these measures, dubbed collectively the “unextendible entanglement of a channel”, yield upper bounds on several communication-theoretic quantities of interest in the regimes of resource distillation and zero error.We then generalize the formalism ofk-extendibility to bipartite superchannels, thus obtaining functions that are monotone under two-extendible superchannels. This allows us to analyze probabilistic distillation of ebits or secret key bits from a bipartite state when using a resourceful quantum channel. Moreover, we propose semidefinite programs to evaluate several of these quantities, providing a computationally feasible method of comparison between quantum channels for resource distillation.
Secret-key distillation from quantum states and channels is a central task of interest in quantum information theory, as it facilitates private communication over a quantum network. Here, we study the task of secret-key distillation from bipartite states and point-to-point quantum channels using local operations and one-way classical communication (one-way LOCC). We employ the resource theory of unextendible entanglement to study the transformation of a bipartite state under one-way LOCC, and we obtain several efficiently computable upper bounds on the number of secret bits that can be distilled from a bipartite state using one-way LOCC channels; these findings apply not only in the one-shot setting but also in some restricted asymptotic settings. We extend our formalism to private communication over a quantum channel assisted by forward classical communication. We obtain efficiently computable upper bounds on the one-shot forward-assisted private capacity of a channel, thus addressing a question in the theory of quantum-secured communication that has been open for some time now. Our formalism also provides upper bounds on the rate of private communication when using a large number of channels in such a way that the error in the transmitted private data decreases exponentially with the number of channel uses. Moreover, our bounds can be computed using semidefinite programs, thus providing a computationally feasible method to understand the limits of private communication over a quantum network.
Abstract Entanglement is a striking feature of quantum mechanics, and it has a key property called unextendibility. In this paper, we present a framework for quantifying and investigating the unextendibility of general bipartite quantum states. First, we define the unextendible entanglement, a family of entanglement measures based on the concept of a state-dependent set of free states. The intuition behind these measures is that the more entangled a bipartite state is, the less entangled each of its individual systems is with a third party. Second, we demonstrate that the unextendible entanglement is an entanglement monotone under two-extendible quantum operations, including local operations and one-way classical communication as a special case. Normalization and faithfulness are two other desirable properties of unextendible entanglement, which we establish here. We further show that the unextendible entanglement provides efficiently computable benchmarks for the rate of exact entanglement or secret key distillation, as well as the overhead of probabilistic entanglement or secret key distillation.
Unextendibility of quantum states and channels is inextricably linked to the no-cloning theorem of quantum mechanics, it has played an important role in understanding and quantifying entanglement, and more recently it has found applications in providing limitations on quantum error correction and entanglement distillation. Here we generalize the framework of unextendibility to quantum measurements and define kkk-extendible measurements for every integer k≥2k\ge 2k≥2. Our definition provides a hierarchy of semidefinite constraints that specify a set of measurements containing every measurement that can be realized by local operations and one-way classical communication. Furthermore, the set of kkk-extendible measurements converges to the set of measurements that can be realized by local operations and one-way classical communication as k→∞k\to \inftyk→∞. To illustrate the utility of kkk-extendible measurements, we establish a semidefinite programming upper bound on the one-shot classical capacity of a channel, which outperforms the best known efficiently computable bound from [Matthews and Wehner, IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory 60, pp. 7317-7329 (2014)] and also leads to efficiently computable upper bounds on the nnn-shot classical capacity of a channel.
The notions of privacy tests and kkk-extendible states have both been instrumental in quantum information theory, particularly in understanding the limits of secure communication. In this paper, we determine the maximum probability with which an arbitrary kkk-extendible state can pass a privacy test, and we prove that it is equal to the maximum fidelity between an arbitrary kkk-extendible state and the standard maximally entangled state. Our findings, coupled with the resource theory of kkk-unextendibility, lead to an efficiently computable upper bound on the one-shot, one-way distillable key of a bipartite state, and we prove that it is equal to the best-known efficiently computable upper bound on the one-shot, one-way distillable entanglement. We also establish efficiently computable upper bounds on the one-shot, forward-assisted private capacity of channels. Extending our formalism to the independent and identically distributed setting, we obtain single-letter efficiently computable bounds on the nnn-shot, one-way distillable key of a state and the nnn-shot, forward-assisted private capacity of a channel. For some key examples of interest, our bounds are significantly tighter than other known efficiently computable bounds.
Quantum Internet relies on quantum entanglement as a fundamental resource for secure and efficient quantum communication, reshaping data transmission. In this context, entanglement distillation emerges as a crucial process that plays a pivotal role in realizing the full potential of the quantum internet. Nevertheless, it remains challenging to accurately estimate the distillable entanglement and its closely related essential quantity, the quantum capacity. In this work, we consider a general resource measure known as the reverse divergence of resources which quantifies the minimum divergence between a target state and the set of free states. Leveraging this measure, we propose efficiently computable upper bounds for both quantities based on the idea that the useless entanglement within a state or a quantum channel does not contribute to the distillable entanglement or the quantum capacity, respectively. Our bounds can be computed via semidefinite programming and have practical applications for purifying maximally entangled states under practical noises, such as depolarizing and amplitude damping noises, leading to improvements in estimating the one-way distillable entanglement. Furthermore, we provide valuable benchmarks for evaluating the quantum capacities of qubit quantum channels, including the Pauli channels and the random mixed unitary channels, which are of great interest for the development of a quantum internet.
When does a difference in information become a way to communicate? Imagine two quantum channels as competing routes through noise. One might preserve a distinction that the other loses. That difference is interesting on its own; the question here is whether it can be turned into something operational: a channel that can carry private or quantum information at a positive rate. This paper presents a construction intended to make that step. Starting from a failure of complete quantum-channel information order, it constructs a channel claimed to have strictly positive ordinary private and quantum capacity. “Complete” matters because the comparison allows an input to be correlated with a finite quantum reference: information may be visible in the joint system even when it is hidden from the channel output alone. The construction accounts for the resources it uses, including transmission of the reference and uses of an activation helper. Its conclusion concerns strict positivity: a rate greater than zero, however small. It does not claim a uniform positive gap or fixed-error capacity inapproximability. The paper also develops reductions connecting the capacity questions to one-way distillable entanglement and secret key. The state constructions are designed to retain any prescribed lower bound on two-way distillation. On this basis, the manuscript claims exact-zero undecidability classifications for finite rational-complex memoryless channels and corresponding classifications for the one-way quantities. The information-order equivalences and undecidability premises used in these conclusions are developed in the companion paper, Complete information orders of quantum channels: equivalence and undecidability. A further introduction and citation details are available on the manuscript page.