© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

Terms Privacy Legal Notice

arXiv:2405.11170 · Physica Scripta

Optimal quantum controls robust against detuning error

Shingo Kukita, Haruki Kiya, Yasushi Kondo

Published Oct 2, 2024• 0 citations

Abstract

Abstract Precise control of quantum systems is one of the most important milestones for achieving practical quantum technologies, such as computation, sensing, and communication. Several factors deteriorate the control precision and thus their suppression is strongly demanded. One of the dominant factors is systematic errors, which are caused by discord between an expected parameter in control and its actual value. Error-robust control sequences, known as composite pulses, have been invented in the field of nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR). These sequences mainly focus on the suppression of errors in one-qubit control. The one-qubit control, which is the most fundamental in a wide range of quantum technologies, often suffers from detuning error. As there are many possible control sequences robust against the detuning error, it will practically be important to find ‘optimal’ robust controls with respect to several cost functions such as time required for operation, and pulse-area during the operation, which corresponds to the energy necessary for control. In this paper, we utilize the Pontryagin’s maximum principle (PMP), a tool for solving optimization problems under inequality constraints, to solve the time and pulse-area optimization problems. We analytically obtain pulse-area optimal controls robust against the detuning error. Moreover, we found that short-CORPSE, which is the shortest known composite pulse so far, is a probable candidate of the time optimal solution according to the PMP. We evaluate the performance of the pulse-area optimal robust control and the short-CORPSE, comparing with that of the direct operation.

DOI: 10.1088/1402-4896/ad8281

Related papers

Lower bound on operation time of composite quantum gates robust against pulse length error

Shingo Kukita, Haruki Kiya, Yasushi Kondo

Abstract Precise control of quantum systems is a cornerstone for realizing high-quality quantum technology such as quantum computing and quantum communication. The performance of control of systems often deteriorates due to systematic errors. In one-qubit control, the pulse length error (PLE) is a typical systematic error, which is often caused by deviation of the strength of the control field. A composite quantum gate (CQG) is a method for suppressing effects of such systematic errors at the cost of a long operation time. A longer operation time implies stronger decoherence, and thus a shorter CQG is preferable from the viewpoint of noise immunity. However, it has not been clear how short CQG can be implemented. This problem can be regarded as an optimization problem under constraints: optimizing the operation time while requiring the error robustness. In this paper, we find a lower bound on operation time of all CQGs with first-order robustness against the PLE, in which effects of the error are eliminated up to its first order. The derivation of this bound is based on a geometric property of robustness against the PLE. This can be used for search after high-performance CQGs.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Oct 30, 2023•1 citation

Optimal Control of Quantum Systems by Pontryagin Maximum Principle

Nahid Binandeh Dehaghani, Фернандо Лобо Перейра

Optimal control provides powerful tools and concepts that can be applied to control quantum systems. It has been used extensively to improve the performance of quantum processes in a variety of active areas in quantum technologies. This paper reviews the necessary conditions of optimality in the form of a Pontryagin Maximum Principle (PMP), and introduces its formulations for quantum systems. After formulating an optimal control problem for a two-level quantum system, we then study the application of PMP to obtain an optimal control strategy.

U Porto Journal of Engineering•Apr 28, 2022•9 citations

General off-resonance-error-robust symmetric composite pulses with three elementary operations

Shingo Kukita, Haruki Kiya, Yasushi Kondo

Accurate quantum control is a key technology for realizing quantum information processing, such as quantum communication and quantum computation. In reality, a quantum state under control suffers from undesirable effects caused by systematic errors. A composite pulse (CP) is used to eliminate the effects of systematic errors during control. One-qubit control, which is the most fundamental in quantum control, is typically affected by two errors: pulse length error and off-resonance error (ORE). In this paper, we focus on ORE-robust CPs and systematically construct symmetric ones comprising three elementary operations in order to understand their properties. We find an infinitely large number of ORE-robust CPs, including the well-known CORPSE family, and evaluate their performance according to gate infidelity and operation time, both of which are important for the realization of accurate quantum control.

arXiv:2203.05754•Physical Review A•Oct 25, 2022•6 citations

Composite pulses for optimal robust control in two-level systems

Hai-Ning Wu, Cheng Zhang, Jie Song +2 more

In this work, we put forward an approach of constructing the optimal composite pulse sequence for robust population transfer in two-level systems. This approach is quite universal and applicable to a variety of systems, because the modulation parameters of composite pulses are obtained by minimizing the homemade cost function rather than nullifying the error coefficients of the transition probability. Specifically, we design different forms of the cost function for implementing optimal robustness with respect to the single or multiple errors. When slightly adjusting the constraints of the cost function, this approach can be easily extended to achieve arbitrary population transfer. The numerical results demonstrate that the optimized sequences are immune from various systematic errors, allowing us to produce a broadening excitation range of the transition probability. Therefore, this work offers an optimal robust design for controlling quantum states in error-prone environments.

Physical Review A•Feb 3, 2023•34 citations

Analytically parametrized solutions for robust quantum control using smooth pulses

Utkan Güngördü, J. P. Kestner

Achieving high-fidelity control of quantum systems is essential for realization of a practical quantum computer. Composite pulse sequences which suppress different types of errors can be nested to suppress a wide variety of errors but the result is often not optimal, especially in the presence of constraints such as bandwidth limitations. Robust smooth pulse shaping provides flexibility but obtaining such analytical pulse shapes is a nontrivial problem and choosing the appropriate parameters typically requires a numerical search in a high-dimensional space. In this work, we extend a previous analytical treatment of robust smooth pulses to allow the determination of pulse parameters without numerical search. We also show that the problem can be reduced to a set of coupled ordinary differential equations which allows for a more streamlined numerical treatment.

arXiv:1906.12289•Physical Review A•Dec 6, 2019•26 citations

Constructing Noise-Robust Quantum Gates via Pontryagin's Maximum Principle

Joshua Hanson, Dennis G. Lucarelli

Reliable quantum information technologies depend on precise actuation and techniques to mitigate the effects of un-desired disturbances such as environmental noise and imperfect calibration. In this work, we present a general framework based in geometric optimal control theory to synthesize smooth control pulses for implementing arbitrary noise-robust quantum gates. The methodology applies to generic unitary quantum dynamics with any number of qubits or energy levels, any number of control fields, and any number of disturbances, extending existing dynamical decoupling approaches that are only applicable for limited gate sets or small systems affected by one or two disturbances. The noise-suppressing controls are computed via indirect trajectory optimization based on Pontryagin's maximum principle, eliminating the need to make heuristic structural assumptions on parameterized pulse envelopes.

arXiv:2409.12287•IEEE International Conference on Quantum Computing and Engineering (QCE)•Sep 15, 2024•2 citations

Abstract Precise control of quantum systems is one of the most important milestones for achieving practical quantum technologies, such as computation, sensing, and communication. Several factors deteriorate the control precision and thus their suppression is strongly demanded. One of the dominant factors is systematic errors, which are caused by discord between an expected parameter in control and its actual value. Error-robust control sequences, known as composite pulses, have been invented in the field of nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR). These sequences mainly focus on the suppression of errors in one-qubit control. The one-qubit control, which is the most fundamental in a wide range of quantum technologies, often suffers from detuning error. As there are many possible control sequences robust against the detuning error, it will practically be important to find ‘optimal’ robust controls with respect to several cost functions such as time required for operation, and pulse-area during the operation, which corresponds to the energy necessary for control. In this paper, we utilize the Pontryagin’s maximum principle (PMP), a tool for solving optimization problems under inequality constraints, to solve the time and pulse-area optimization problems. We analytically obtain pulse-area optimal controls robust against the detuning error. Moreover, we found that short-CORPSE, which is the shortest known composite pulse so far, is a probable candidate of the time optimal solution according to the PMP. We evaluate the performance of the pulse-area optimal robust control and the short-CORPSE, comparing with that of the direct operation.

Abstract Precise control of quantum systems is a cornerstone for realizing high-quality quantum technology such as quantum computing and quantum communication. The performance of control of systems often deteriorates due to systematic errors. In one-qubit control, the pulse length error (PLE) is a typical systematic error, which is often caused by deviation of the strength of the control field. A composite quantum gate (CQG) is a method for suppressing effects of such systematic errors at the cost of a long operation time. A longer operation time implies stronger decoherence, and thus a shorter CQG is preferable from the viewpoint of noise immunity. However, it has not been clear how short CQG can be implemented. This problem can be regarded as an optimization problem under constraints: optimizing the operation time while requiring the error robustness. In this paper, we find a lower bound on operation time of all CQGs with first-order robustness against the PLE, in which effects of the error are eliminated up to its first order. The derivation of this bound is based on a geometric property of robustness against the PLE. This can be used for search after high-performance CQGs.

Optimal control provides powerful tools and concepts that can be applied to control quantum systems. It has been used extensively to improve the performance of quantum processes in a variety of active areas in quantum technologies. This paper reviews the necessary conditions of optimality in the form of a Pontryagin Maximum Principle (PMP), and introduces its formulations for quantum systems. After formulating an optimal control problem for a two-level quantum system, we then study the application of PMP to obtain an optimal control strategy.

Accurate quantum control is a key technology for realizing quantum information processing, such as quantum communication and quantum computation. In reality, a quantum state under control suffers from undesirable effects caused by systematic errors. A composite pulse (CP) is used to eliminate the effects of systematic errors during control. One-qubit control, which is the most fundamental in quantum control, is typically affected by two errors: pulse length error and off-resonance error (ORE). In this paper, we focus on ORE-robust CPs and systematically construct symmetric ones comprising three elementary operations in order to understand their properties. We find an infinitely large number of ORE-robust CPs, including the well-known CORPSE family, and evaluate their performance according to gate infidelity and operation time, both of which are important for the realization of accurate quantum control.

In this work, we put forward an approach of constructing the optimal composite pulse sequence for robust population transfer in two-level systems. This approach is quite universal and applicable to a variety of systems, because the modulation parameters of composite pulses are obtained by minimizing the homemade cost function rather than nullifying the error coefficients of the transition probability. Specifically, we design different forms of the cost function for implementing optimal robustness with respect to the single or multiple errors. When slightly adjusting the constraints of the cost function, this approach can be easily extended to achieve arbitrary population transfer. The numerical results demonstrate that the optimized sequences are immune from various systematic errors, allowing us to produce a broadening excitation range of the transition probability. Therefore, this work offers an optimal robust design for controlling quantum states in error-prone environments.

Achieving high-fidelity control of quantum systems is essential for realization of a practical quantum computer. Composite pulse sequences which suppress different types of errors can be nested to suppress a wide variety of errors but the result is often not optimal, especially in the presence of constraints such as bandwidth limitations. Robust smooth pulse shaping provides flexibility but obtaining such analytical pulse shapes is a nontrivial problem and choosing the appropriate parameters typically requires a numerical search in a high-dimensional space. In this work, we extend a previous analytical treatment of robust smooth pulses to allow the determination of pulse parameters without numerical search. We also show that the problem can be reduced to a set of coupled ordinary differential equations which allows for a more streamlined numerical treatment.

Reliable quantum information technologies depend on precise actuation and techniques to mitigate the effects of un-desired disturbances such as environmental noise and imperfect calibration. In this work, we present a general framework based in geometric optimal control theory to synthesize smooth control pulses for implementing arbitrary noise-robust quantum gates. The methodology applies to generic unitary quantum dynamics with any number of qubits or energy levels, any number of control fields, and any number of disturbances, extending existing dynamical decoupling approaches that are only applicable for limited gate sets or small systems affected by one or two disturbances. The noise-suppressing controls are computed via indirect trajectory optimization based on Pontryagin's maximum principle, eliminating the need to make heuristic structural assumptions on parameterized pulse envelopes.