Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2403.04842 · Physical Review Research

Entanglement generation from athermality

A. de Oliveira, Jeongrak Son, Jakub Czartowski, Nelly H. Y. Ng

Published Sep 3, 2024• 9 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We investigate the thermodynamic constraints on the pivotal task of entanglement generation using out-of-equilibrium states through a model-independent framework with minimal assumptions. We establish a necessary and sufficient condition for a thermal process to generate bipartite qubit entanglement, starting from an initially separable state. Consequently, we identify the set of system states that cannot be entangled, when no external work is invested. In the regime of infinite temperature, we analytically construct this set; while for finite temperature, we provide a simple criterion to verify whether any given initial state is or is not entangleable. Furthermore, we provide an explicit construction of the future thermal cone of entanglement—the set of entangled states that a given separable state can thermodynamically evolve to. We offer a detailed discussion on the properties of this cone, focusing on the interplay between entanglement and its volumetric properties. We conclude with several key remarks on the generation of entanglement beyond two-qubit systems, and discuss its dynamics in the presence of dissipation. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

DOI
10.1103/physrevresearch.6.033236

Related papers

Harnessing quantum entanglement and heat current of a non-equilibrium spin system at high temperatures

B. Mojaveri, Z. Ahmadi

The challenge of harnessing entanglement during the non-equilibrium dynamics of open quantum systems, especially at high temperatures, is highly prominent within recent scientific researches. Due to the ongoing trend of miniaturization of quantum devices that exploit quantum correlations, proposing novel schemes to overcome this challenge is itself a crucial task within current quantum technological research. We contribute to this research by proposing a new scheme to control entanglement dynamics of a non-equilibrium two-qubit Heisenberg XXZ spin chain model in an external magnetic field. The design of the scheme is based on a coupling asymmetry in the model induced by the asymmetrical connection of qubits to two independent thermal reservoirs. While in the absence of the coupling asymmetry, non-equilibrium effects generally suppress the dynamical generation of thermal entanglement, making entanglement production impossible at high mean temperatures of reservoirs, it is shown that this asymmetry in the coupling potentially enables us to generate a maximal non-equilibrium entanglement even in the high mean temperature regime. We show that the coupling asymmetry can also lead to a complete protection of the maximum initial entanglement between the qubits at high mean temperatures of the reservoirs thanks to the non-equilibrium conditions. Depending on the initial state of the two qubits, this can be achieved either by accessing a coherence-free subspace or by fully reviving the initial qubit-qubit entanglement. Furthermore, we investigate the quantum heat transport of the chain, and find that by turning on the asymmetry in the qubit-reservoir coupling, although the chain loses its initial thermal rectification property over time, it regains this property and maintain it until the non-equilibrium steady state is reached. Our results show that, at higher temperature gradients, the chain leverages the steady-state entanglement to completely block the heat released from the hot reservoir. Our findings can be significant for heat management in quantum computing devices such as solid-state thermal circuits.

Scientific Reports•Apr 12, 2025•3 citations

Catalytic transformations for thermal operations

Jakub Czartowski, A. de Oliveira

What are the fundamental limits and advantages of using a catalyst to aid thermodynamic transformations between quantum systems? In this paper, we answer this question by focusing on transformations between energy-incoherent states under the most general energy-conserving interactions among the system, the catalyst, and a thermal environment. The sole constraint is that the catalyst must return unperturbed and uncorrelated with the other subsystems. More precisely, we first upper bound the set of states to which a given initial state can thermodynamically evolve (the catalyzable future) or from which it can evolve (the catalyzable past) with the help of a strict catalyst. Secondly, we derive lower bounds on the dimensionality required for the existence of catalysts under thermal process, along with bounds on the catalyst's state preparation. Finally, we quantify the catalytic advantage in terms of the volume of the catalyzable future and demonstrate its utility in an exemplary task of generating entanglement and cooling a quantum system using thermal resources. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2403.04845•Physical Review Research•Aug 22, 2024•8 citations

Creation and protection of entanglement in systems out of thermal equilibrium

Bruno Bellomo, Mauro Antezza

Abstract. We investigate the creation of entanglement between two quantum emitters interacting with a realistic common stationary electromagnetic field out of thermal equilibrium. In the case of two qubits we show that the absence of equilibrium allows the generation of steady entangled states, which is inaccessible at thermal equilibrium and is realized without any further external action on the two qubits. We first give a simple physical interpretation of the phenomenon in a specific case and then we report a detailed investigation on the dependence of the entanglement dynamics on the various physical parameters involved. Sub- and super-radiant effects are discussed, and qualitative differences in the dynamics concerning both creation and protection of entanglement according to the initial two-qubit state are pointed out.

•Aug 14, 2016•17 citations

Entanglement generation in quantum thermal machines

Milton Aguilar, Nahuel Freitas, Juan Pablo Paz

We show that in a linear quantum machine, a driven quantum system that evolves while coupled with thermal reservoirs, entanglement between the reservoir modes is unavoidably generated. This phenomenon, which occurs at sufficiently low temperatures and is at the heart of the third law of thermodynamics, is a consequence of a simple process: the transformation of the energy of the driving field into pairs of excitations in the reservoirs. For a driving with frequency ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{d}$ we show entanglement exists between environmental modes whose frequencies satisfy the condition ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{i}+{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{j}={\ensuremath{\omega}}_{d}$. We show that this entanglement can persist for temperatures that can be significantly higher than the lowest achievable ones with sideband resolved cooling methods.

arXiv:2010.05885•Physical Review A•Dec 23, 2020•10 citations

Quantum entanglement dynamics based on composite quantum collision model*

Xiaoming Li, Yong-Xu Chen, Yun‐Jie Xia +2 more

By means of composite quantum collision models, we study the entanglement dynamics of a bipartite system, i.e., two qubits S 1 and S 2 interacting directly with an intermediate auxiliary qubit S A, while S A is in turn coupled to a thermal reservoir. We are concerned with how the intracollisions of the reservoir qubits influence the entanglement dynamics. We show that even if the system is initially in the separated state, their entanglement can be generated due to the interaction between the qubits. In the long-time limit, the steady-state entanglement can be generated depending on the initial state of S 1 and S 2 and the environment temperature. We also study the dynamics of tripartite entanglement of the three qubits S 1, S 2, and S A when they are initially prepared in the GHZ state and separated state, respectively. For the GHZ initial state, the tripartite entanglement can be maintained for a long time when the collision strength between the environment qubits is sufficiently large.

Chinese Physics B•Mar 31, 2020•9 citations

Trading athermality for nonstabiliserness

A. de Oliveira Junior, Rafael A. Macedo, Jakub Czartowski +2 more

Quantum advantage arises from quantum states that cannot be efficiently simulated on a classical computer. Such states are characterised by a property known as nonstabiliserness. In this work, we investigate whether nonstabiliserness can be generated by placing an initially stabiliser state in contact with a heat bath. Under minimal thermodynamic assumptions, we derive a necessary and sufficient condition for when this is possible. This yields an analytic characterisation of all nonstabiliser qubit states reachable through such thermal processes, together with explicit bounds on their nonstabiliserness. This, in turn, allows us to identify optimal regimes for generating this resource, including the Hamiltonians that maximise nonstabiliserness and the critical temperatures at which it emerges. Beyond the qubit case, we establish a general trade-off between the nonstabiliserness attainable under thermal operations and the initial nonequilibrium free energy of the system.

quant-pharXiv:2511.13839•Nov 19, 2025•0 citations
We investigate the thermodynamic constraints on the pivotal task of entanglement generation using out-of-equilibrium states through a model-independent framework with minimal assumptions. We establish a necessary and sufficient condition for a thermal process to generate bipartite qubit entanglement, starting from an initially separable state. Consequently, we identify the set of system states that cannot be entangled, when no external work is invested. In the regime of infinite temperature, we analytically construct this set; while for finite temperature, we provide a simple criterion to verify whether any given initial state is or is not entangleable. Furthermore, we provide an explicit construction of the future thermal cone of entanglement—the set of entangled states that a given separable state can thermodynamically evolve to. We offer a detailed discussion on the properties of this cone, focusing on the interplay between entanglement and its volumetric properties. We conclude with several key remarks on the generation of entanglement beyond two-qubit systems, and discuss its dynamics in the presence of dissipation. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
The challenge of harnessing entanglement during the non-equilibrium dynamics of open quantum systems, especially at high temperatures, is highly prominent within recent scientific researches. Due to the ongoing trend of miniaturization of quantum devices that exploit quantum correlations, proposing novel schemes to overcome this challenge is itself a crucial task within current quantum technological research. We contribute to this research by proposing a new scheme to control entanglement dynamics of a non-equilibrium two-qubit Heisenberg XXZ spin chain model in an external magnetic field. The design of the scheme is based on a coupling asymmetry in the model induced by the asymmetrical connection of qubits to two independent thermal reservoirs. While in the absence of the coupling asymmetry, non-equilibrium effects generally suppress the dynamical generation of thermal entanglement, making entanglement production impossible at high mean temperatures of reservoirs, it is shown that this asymmetry in the coupling potentially enables us to generate a maximal non-equilibrium entanglement even in the high mean temperature regime. We show that the coupling asymmetry can also lead to a complete protection of the maximum initial entanglement between the qubits at high mean temperatures of the reservoirs thanks to the non-equilibrium conditions. Depending on the initial state of the two qubits, this can be achieved either by accessing a coherence-free subspace or by fully reviving the initial qubit-qubit entanglement. Furthermore, we investigate the quantum heat transport of the chain, and find that by turning on the asymmetry in the qubit-reservoir coupling, although the chain loses its initial thermal rectification property over time, it regains this property and maintain it until the non-equilibrium steady state is reached. Our results show that, at higher temperature gradients, the chain leverages the steady-state entanglement to completely block the heat released from the hot reservoir. Our findings can be significant for heat management in quantum computing devices such as solid-state thermal circuits.
What are the fundamental limits and advantages of using a catalyst to aid thermodynamic transformations between quantum systems? In this paper, we answer this question by focusing on transformations between energy-incoherent states under the most general energy-conserving interactions among the system, the catalyst, and a thermal environment. The sole constraint is that the catalyst must return unperturbed and uncorrelated with the other subsystems. More precisely, we first upper bound the set of states to which a given initial state can thermodynamically evolve (the catalyzable future) or from which it can evolve (the catalyzable past) with the help of a strict catalyst. Secondly, we derive lower bounds on the dimensionality required for the existence of catalysts under thermal process, along with bounds on the catalyst's state preparation. Finally, we quantify the catalytic advantage in terms of the volume of the catalyzable future and demonstrate its utility in an exemplary task of generating entanglement and cooling a quantum system using thermal resources. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
Abstract. We investigate the creation of entanglement between two quantum emitters interacting with a realistic common stationary electromagnetic field out of thermal equilibrium. In the case of two qubits we show that the absence of equilibrium allows the generation of steady entangled states, which is inaccessible at thermal equilibrium and is realized without any further external action on the two qubits. We first give a simple physical interpretation of the phenomenon in a specific case and then we report a detailed investigation on the dependence of the entanglement dynamics on the various physical parameters involved. Sub- and super-radiant effects are discussed, and qualitative differences in the dynamics concerning both creation and protection of entanglement according to the initial two-qubit state are pointed out.
We show that in a linear quantum machine, a driven quantum system that evolves while coupled with thermal reservoirs, entanglement between the reservoir modes is unavoidably generated. This phenomenon, which occurs at sufficiently low temperatures and is at the heart of the third law of thermodynamics, is a consequence of a simple process: the transformation of the energy of the driving field into pairs of excitations in the reservoirs. For a driving with frequency ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{d}$ we show entanglement exists between environmental modes whose frequencies satisfy the condition ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{i}+{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{j}={\ensuremath{\omega}}_{d}$. We show that this entanglement can persist for temperatures that can be significantly higher than the lowest achievable ones with sideband resolved cooling methods.
By means of composite quantum collision models, we study the entanglement dynamics of a bipartite system, i.e., two qubits S 1 and S 2 interacting directly with an intermediate auxiliary qubit S A, while S A is in turn coupled to a thermal reservoir. We are concerned with how the intracollisions of the reservoir qubits influence the entanglement dynamics. We show that even if the system is initially in the separated state, their entanglement can be generated due to the interaction between the qubits. In the long-time limit, the steady-state entanglement can be generated depending on the initial state of S 1 and S 2 and the environment temperature. We also study the dynamics of tripartite entanglement of the three qubits S 1, S 2, and S A when they are initially prepared in the GHZ state and separated state, respectively. For the GHZ initial state, the tripartite entanglement can be maintained for a long time when the collision strength between the environment qubits is sufficiently large.
Quantum advantage arises from quantum states that cannot be efficiently simulated on a classical computer. Such states are characterised by a property known as nonstabiliserness. In this work, we investigate whether nonstabiliserness can be generated by placing an initially stabiliser state in contact with a heat bath. Under minimal thermodynamic assumptions, we derive a necessary and sufficient condition for when this is possible. This yields an analytic characterisation of all nonstabiliser qubit states reachable through such thermal processes, together with explicit bounds on their nonstabiliserness. This, in turn, allows us to identify optimal regimes for generating this resource, including the Hamiltonians that maximise nonstabiliserness and the critical temperatures at which it emerges. Beyond the qubit case, we establish a general trade-off between the nonstabiliserness attainable under thermal operations and the initial nonequilibrium free energy of the system.