Superdiffusion is surprisingly easily observed even in systems without the integrability underpinning this phenomenon. Indeed, the classical Heisenberg chain-one of the simplest many-body systems, and firmly believed to be nonintegrable-evinces a long-lived regime of anomalous, superdiffusive spin dynamics at finite temperature. Similarly, superdiffusion persists for long timescales, even at high temperature, for small perturbations around a related integrable model. Eventually, however, ordinary diffusion is believed to be asymptotically restored. We examine the timescales governing the lifetime of the superdiffusive regime, and argue that it diverges algebraically fast-both in deviation from the integrable limit, and at low temperature, where we find t^{*}∼T^{-ζ} with an exponent possibly as large as ζ=8. This can render the crossover to ordinary diffusion practically inaccessible.
Superdiffusive finite-temperature transport has been recently observed in a variety of integrable systems with non-Abelian global symmetries. Superdiffusion is caused by giant Goldstone-like quasiparticles stabilized by integrability. Here, we argue that these giant quasiparticles remain long-lived and give divergent contributions to the low-frequency conductivity σ(ω), even in systems that are not perfectly integrable. We find, perturbatively, that σ(ω)∼ω^{-1/3} for translation-invariant static perturbations that conserve energy and σ(ω)∼|logω| for noisy perturbations. The (presumable) crossover to regular diffusion appears to lie beyond low-order perturbation theory. By contrast, integrability-breaking perturbations that break the non-Abelian symmetry yield conventional diffusion. Numerical evidence supports the distinction between these two classes of perturbations.
Superdiffusive transport with dynamical exponent
z=3/2 has been firmly established at finite temperature for a class of integrable systems with a non-abelian global symmetry
G. On the inclusion of integrability-breaking perturbations, diffusive transport with
z=2 is generically expected to hold in the limit of late time. Recent studies of the classical Haldane-Ishimori-Skylanin model have found that perturbations that preserve the global symmetry lead to a much slower timescale for the onset of diffusion, albeit with uncertainty over the exact scaling exponent. That is, for perturbations of strength
λ, the characteristic timescale for diffusion goes as
t∗∼λ−α for some
α. Using large-scale matrix product state simulations, we investigate this behavior for perturbations to the canonical quantum model showing superdiffusion: the
S=1/2 quantum Heisenberg chain. We consider a ladder configuration and look at various perturbations that either break or preserve the
SU(2) symmetry, leading to scaling exponents consistent with those observed in one classical study arXiv:2402.18661:
α=2 for symmetry-breaking terms and
α=6 for symmetry-preserving terms. We also consider perturbations from another integrable point of the ladder model with
G=SU(4) and find consistent results. Finally, we consider a generalization to an
SU(3) ladder and find that the
α=6 scaling appears to be universal across superdiffusive systems when the perturbations preserve the non-abelian symmetry
G.
The isotropic Heisenberg chain represents a particular case of an integrable many-body system exhibiting superdiffusive spin transport at finite temperatures. Here, we show that this model has distinct properties also at finite magnetization $m\ensuremath{\ne}0$, even upon introducing the SU(2) invariant perturbations. Specifically, we observe nonmonotonic dependence of the diffusion constant ${\mathcal{D}}_{0}(\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}})$ on the spin anisotropy $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}$, with a pronounced maximum at $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}=1$. The latter dependence remains true also in the zero magnetization sector, with superdiffusion at $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}=1$ that is remarkably stable against isotropic perturbation (at least in finite-size systems), consistent with recent experiments with cold atoms.
We study magnetization transport in anisotropic spin-
21 chains governed by the integrable XXZ model with and without integrability-breaking perturbations at high temperatures $(T\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty})$ using a hybrid approach that combines exact sum rules with judiciously chosen Ans\"atze. In the integrable XXZ model we find (i) superdiffusion at the isotropic (Heisenberg) point, with frequency dependent conductivity ${\ensuremath{\sigma}}^{\ensuremath{'}}(\ensuremath{\omega}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0)\ensuremath{\sim}{|\ensuremath{\omega}|}^{\ensuremath{\alpha}}$, where $\ensuremath{\alpha}=\ensuremath{-}3/7$ in close numerical agreement with recent
t-DMRG computations; (ii) a continuously drifting exponent from $\ensuremath{\alpha}=\ensuremath{-}{1}^{+}$ in the XY (gapless) limit of the model to $\ensuremath{\alpha}>0$ within the Ising (gapped) regime; and (iii) a diffusion constant saturating in the XY coupling deep in the Ising limit. We consider two kinds of next-nearest-neighbor integrability breaking perturbations---a simple spin-flip term
(J2) and a three-spin assisted variant
(t2), natural in the fermion particle representation of the spin chain. In the first case we discover a remarkable sensitivity of ${\ensuremath{\sigma}}^{\ensuremath{'}}(\ensuremath{\omega})$ to the sign of
J2, with enhanced low frequency spectral weight and a pronounced upward shift in the magnitude of $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ for
J2>0. Perhaps even more surprising, we find subdiffusion $(\ensuremath{\alpha}>0)$ over a range of
J2<0. By contrast, the effects of the ``fermionic'' three-spin perturbation are sign symmetric; this perturbation produces a clearly observable hydrodynamic relaxation. At large strength of the integrability breaking term ${J}_{2}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}\ensuremath{\infty}$ the problem is effectively noninteracting (fermions hopping on odd and even sublattices) and we find $\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{-}1$ behavior reminiscent of the XY limit of the integrable XXZ chain. Exact diagonalization studies largely corroborate these findings over accessible frequencies.
We report a systematic study of finite-temperature spin transport in quantum and classical one-dimensional magnets with isotropic spin interactions, including both integrable and nonintegrable models. Employing a phenomenological framework based on a generalized Burgers' equation in a time-dependent stochastic environment, we identify four different universality classes of spin fluctuations. These comprise, aside from normal spin diffusion, three types of superdiffusive transport: the Kardar-Parisi-Zhang universality class and two distinct types of anomalous diffusion with multiplicative logarithmic corrections. Our predictions are supported by extensive numerical simulations on various examples of quantum and classical chains. Contrary to common belief, we demonstrate that even nonintegrable spin chains can display a diverging spin diffusion constant at finite temperatures.