Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2402.04628 · The European Physical Journal C

Distinguishing pure and thermal states by Landauer’s principle in open systems

Hao Xu

Published Apr 4, 2024• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract Starting from Polchinski’s thought experiment on how to distinguish between pure and thermal states, we construct a specific system to study the interaction between qubit and cavity quantum field theory (QFT) in order to provide a more operational point of view. Without imposing any restrictions on the initial states of qubit and cavity QFT, we compute the evolution of the system order by order by the perturbation method. We choose Landauer’s principle, an important bound in quantum computation and quantum measurement, as the basis for the determination of the thermal state. By backtracking the initial state form, we obtain the conditions that must be satisfied by the cavity QFT: the expectation value of the annihilation operator should be zero, and the expectation value of the particle number operator should satisfy the Bose–Einstein distribution. We also discuss the difference between the thermal state and a possible alternative to the thermal state: the canonical thermal pure quantum (CTPQ) state.

DOI
10.1140/epjc/s10052-024-12729-2

Related papers

Decoherence and Landauer’s principle in qubit-cavity quantum-field-theory interaction

Hao Xu, Si Yu Chen, Yen Chin Ong

Abstract We consider quantum decoherence and Landauer’s principle in qubit-cavity quantum field theory (QFT) interaction, treating the qubit as the system and cavity QFT as the environment. In particular, we investigate the changes that occur in the system with a pure initial state and environment during the decoherence process, with or without energy dissipation, and compare the results with the case in which the initial state of the system is a mixed state and thus decoherence is absent. When we choose an interaction Hamiltonian such that the energy and coherence of the system change simultaneously, the population change of the system and the energy change are the same when the initial state is mixed. However, the decoherence terms increase the von Neumann entropy of the system. In this case the energy change and decoherence of the system are not independent physical processes. The decoherence process maintains unitarity. On the other hand, if the interaction Hamiltonian does not change the energy of the system, there is only the decoherence effect. The environment will be a distribution in the basis of the displaced number state and always increases the energy. Landauer’s principle is satisfied in both cases.

arXiv:2207.06702•The European Physical Journal C•Jan 10, 2023•6 citations

Minimising the heat dissipation of quantum information erasure

Majid Mohammady, Masoud Mohseni, Yasser Omar

Quantum state engineering and quantum computation rely on information erasure procedures that, up to some fidelity, prepare a quantum object in a pure state. Such processes occur within Landauer's framework if they rely on an interaction between the object and a thermal reservoir. Landauer's principle dictates that this must dissipate a minimum quantity of heat, proportional to the entropy reduction that is incurred by the object, to the thermal reservoir. However, this lower bound is only reachable for some specific physical situations, and it is not necessarily achievable for any given reservoir. The main task of our work can be stated as the minimisation of heat dissipation given probabilistic information erasure, i.e., minimising the amount of energy transferred to the thermal reservoir as heat if we require that the probability of preparing the object in a specific pure state | φ 1 ⟩ be no smaller than p φ 1 max − δ . Here p φ 1 max is the maximum probability of information erasure that is permissible by the physical context, and δ ⩾ 0 the error. To determine the achievable minimal heat dissipation of quantum information erasure within a given physical context, we explicitly optimise over all possible unitary operators that act on the composite system of object and reservoir. Specifically, we characterise the equivalence class of such optimal unitary operators, using tools from majorisation theory, when we are restricted to finite-dimensional Hilbert spaces. Furthermore, we discuss how pure state preparation processes could be achieved with a smaller heat cost than Landauer's limit, by operating outside of Landauer's framework.

arXiv:1510.02062•New Journal of Physics•Jan 15, 2016•16 citations

Heat transfer operators associated with quantum operations

Ç Aksak, S Turgut

Any quantum operation applied on a physical system is performed as a unitary transformation on a larger extended system. If the extension used is a heat bath in thermal equilibrium, the concomitant change in the state of the bath necessarily implies a heat exchange with it. The dependence of the average heat transferred to the bath on the initial state of the system can then be found from the expectation value of a Hermitian operator, which is named as the heat transfer operator (HTO). The purpose of this paper is to investigate the relation between the HTOs and the associated quantum operations. Since any given quantum operation on a system can be realized by different baths and unitaries, many different HTOs are possible for each quantum operation. On the other hand, there are also strong restrictions on the HTOs which arise from the unitarity of the transformations. The most important of these is the Landauer erasure principle. This paper is concerned with the question of finding a complete set of restrictions on the HTOs that are associated with a given quantum operation. An answer to this question has been found only for a subset of quantum operations. For erasure operations, these characterizations are equivalent to the generalized Landauer erasure principle. For the case of generic quantum operations, however, it appears that the HTOs obey further restrictions which cannot be obtained from the entropic restrictions of the generalized Landauer erasure principle.

arXiv:1002.0733•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Jun 3, 2011•2 citations

Thermalization from a general canonical principle

Shuai Cui, Cao, Jun-Peng, Hui Jing +2 more

We investigate the time evolution of a generic and finite isolated quantum many-body system starting from a pure quantum state. We find the kinematical general canonical principle proposed by Popescu-Short-Winter for statistical mechanics can be built in a more solid ground by studying the thermalization, i.e. comparing the density matrices themselves rather than the measures of distances. In particular, this allows us to explicitly identify that, from any instantaneous pure state after thermalization, the state of subsystem is like from a microcanonical ensemble or a generalized Gibbs ensemble, but neither a canonical nor a thermal ones due to finite-size effect. Our results are expected to bring the task of characterizing the state after thermalization to completion. In addition, thermalization of coupled systems with different temperatures corresponding to mixed initial states is studied.

arXiv:1110.4690•Oct 21, 2011•2 citations

Quantum Pure States Statistics towards Quantum Dynamics Simulations

Maurizio Coden

Despite early developments on the foundations of quantum mechanics concern the wave function, quantum statistics has been developed with the density matrix formalism, leading to very important results in explaining molecular observations. Only recently, several authors argued a new interpretation by focusing on the wave function representing the quantum state of an isolated system, showing how a single wave function can exhibit statistical properties and generate the same results expected in the standard quantum statistical framework. Starting from these results, investigation on the foundations of quantum statistical mechanics has gained recently a renewed interest. As a matter of fact, the possibility of studying single molecule properties as well as the need of a better understanding of the effect of quantum dynamics, in order to develop new nanoscaled materials suitable to quantum computing tasks, have opened new intriguing questions leading to quantum statistical approaches far from being well understood and accepted. In this framework the behaviour of a single realization of quantum systems has gained a central role in the description of molecular systems. Furthermore, in recent years, an increasing number of studies has been presented on quantum dynamics through the numerical solution of the Schrödinger equation for systems of interacting components. These studies demonstrates that Quantum Dynamics Simulations could be a practicable route. In order to study phenomena such as dissipation, relaxation and thermalization, the focus has to be moved from isolated molecules to modular systems made of mutual interacting components, with model Hamiltonians possessing a sufficiently low dimensional representation. An important issue concerns the rules to be employed for the choice of the initial quantum state for the simulation of isolated systems. As long as one considers molecular degrees of freedom interacting with a (model) environment, there are no reasons to select a particular quantum state for the overall system and, therefore, a random choice has to be performed amongst a well defined statistical ensemble of pure states. Furthermore, one would like to operate a choice assuring that the simulation of the system is in a well defined thermal state with given temperature. This necessarily calls for a statistical description like for classical systems. A useful parametrization of the wave function will be presented in order to highlight the most appropriate variable for the statistical analysis. In particular some of them, called phases, retain all the dynamical information whereas the others, called populations, are the constants of motion. The latter, in particular are very important because they describe the equilibrium properties strictly related to the thermodynamic description. Since the dynamics of wave function does not supply any information about populations, the definition of a probability distribution on these variables is required. Different probability distributions on populations have been proposed, only on the bases of reasonable assumptions and they validation has been performed only with a posteriori considerations. In particular Fresch and Moro have demonstrated how the agreement with thermodynamics can be employed to discriminate different probability distributions on pure states. This had led the uniform ensembles to be, up to now, the most self-consistent models for quantum pure states. However, in this thesis I will highlight a drawback of the uniform distribution ensemble that can be described as follow: if we bring into contact two systems, even through a perturbative interaction, we are not able to describe the equilibrium properties after the interaction within the uniform distribution statistics, since the uniform character is lost. It represents a severe shortcoming of the statistical ensemble from a methodological point of view, since closed systems can be always considered as the result of interaction among previously isolated systems. On the other hand this drawback introduces a further requirement of a different nature that can be used for the definition of a new statistical ensemble. In this work I intend to find and characterize a statistical ensemble for populations that overcomes the drawbacks of the uniform distribution of pure states. The invariance of the thermal state in the coupling of identical systems will be used as a guideline in the definition af a new probability distribution on populations. Such an ensemble for pure states, called Thermalization Resilient Ensemble, provides a convenient framework for treating the interactions between quantum systems, as long as the structure of the statistical distribution is preserved and the identification of thermodynamic properties is assured. In perspective it should be the privileged statistical ensemble to implement Quantum Dynamics Simulations. Once the average properties of the Thermalization Resilient Ensemble have been introduced, I will obtain a probability distribution on pure states with the use of a geometrical analysis on the Hilbert space. The surface elements of an ellipsoidal manifold will be related to the probability density on populations. As a matter of fact the explicit form of the probability distribution is a prerequisite in order to perform Quantum Dynamical Simulations. However the results obtained through the geometrical analysis cannot be easily extended to systems with unbounded energy spectrum and an alternative strategy has been developed. A scaling algorithm on the basis of the uniform statistical ensemble will be described and this allows a well defined sampling of a probability distribution with desired averages. In this framework I demonstrate the emergence of thermodynamic behavior in the limit of macroscopic systems. In the last part of the thesis I consider the dynamical features of the thermalization experiment. Two identical systems, initially at different temperature, will be brought in interaction and the analysis of the final equilibrium state will be performed for two different generic forms of the interaction Hamiltonian, highlighting how the statistical approach can be very useful in the definition of the equilibrium in complex quantum systems.

•Jan 1, 2016•0 citations

Vacuum Diagrams in Perturbative Thermo Field Dynamics

H. Matsumoto, Hiroomi Umezawa, J. P. Whitehead

Perturbation theory in thermofield dynamics (a real time finite temperature quantum field theory) is formulated in the interaction representation and a diagrammatic expansion for the expectation value of time ordered products is derived solely on the basis of the thermal state condition and the algebraic properties of the operators. This new formulation has a much wider domain of applicability than those presented previously. The method is applicable even in the case of purely quantum mechanical systems. When certain bosonic operators, which commute with the unperturbed Hamiltonian, contribute to the renormalization of the thermal state vacuum the vacuum diagrams do not cancel in the usual way. It will be shown how these diagrams arise and how they may be computed.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Jul 1, 1986•15 citations
Abstract Starting from Polchinski’s thought experiment on how to distinguish between pure and thermal states, we construct a specific system to study the interaction between qubit and cavity quantum field theory (QFT) in order to provide a more operational point of view. Without imposing any restrictions on the initial states of qubit and cavity QFT, we compute the evolution of the system order by order by the perturbation method. We choose Landauer’s principle, an important bound in quantum computation and quantum measurement, as the basis for the determination of the thermal state. By backtracking the initial state form, we obtain the conditions that must be satisfied by the cavity QFT: the expectation value of the annihilation operator should be zero, and the expectation value of the particle number operator should satisfy the Bose–Einstein distribution. We also discuss the difference between the thermal state and a possible alternative to the thermal state: the canonical thermal pure quantum (CTPQ) state.
Abstract We consider quantum decoherence and Landauer’s principle in qubit-cavity quantum field theory (QFT) interaction, treating the qubit as the system and cavity QFT as the environment. In particular, we investigate the changes that occur in the system with a pure initial state and environment during the decoherence process, with or without energy dissipation, and compare the results with the case in which the initial state of the system is a mixed state and thus decoherence is absent. When we choose an interaction Hamiltonian such that the energy and coherence of the system change simultaneously, the population change of the system and the energy change are the same when the initial state is mixed. However, the decoherence terms increase the von Neumann entropy of the system. In this case the energy change and decoherence of the system are not independent physical processes. The decoherence process maintains unitarity. On the other hand, if the interaction Hamiltonian does not change the energy of the system, there is only the decoherence effect. The environment will be a distribution in the basis of the displaced number state and always increases the energy. Landauer’s principle is satisfied in both cases.
Quantum state engineering and quantum computation rely on information erasure procedures that, up to some fidelity, prepare a quantum object in a pure state. Such processes occur within Landauer's framework if they rely on an interaction between the object and a thermal reservoir. Landauer's principle dictates that this must dissipate a minimum quantity of heat, proportional to the entropy reduction that is incurred by the object, to the thermal reservoir. However, this lower bound is only reachable for some specific physical situations, and it is not necessarily achievable for any given reservoir. The main task of our work can be stated as the minimisation of heat dissipation given probabilistic information erasure, i.e., minimising the amount of energy transferred to the thermal reservoir as heat if we require that the probability of preparing the object in a specific pure state | φ 1 ⟩ be no smaller than p φ 1 max − δ . Here p φ 1 max is the maximum probability of information erasure that is permissible by the physical context, and δ ⩾ 0 the error. To determine the achievable minimal heat dissipation of quantum information erasure within a given physical context, we explicitly optimise over all possible unitary operators that act on the composite system of object and reservoir. Specifically, we characterise the equivalence class of such optimal unitary operators, using tools from majorisation theory, when we are restricted to finite-dimensional Hilbert spaces. Furthermore, we discuss how pure state preparation processes could be achieved with a smaller heat cost than Landauer's limit, by operating outside of Landauer's framework.
Any quantum operation applied on a physical system is performed as a unitary transformation on a larger extended system. If the extension used is a heat bath in thermal equilibrium, the concomitant change in the state of the bath necessarily implies a heat exchange with it. The dependence of the average heat transferred to the bath on the initial state of the system can then be found from the expectation value of a Hermitian operator, which is named as the heat transfer operator (HTO). The purpose of this paper is to investigate the relation between the HTOs and the associated quantum operations. Since any given quantum operation on a system can be realized by different baths and unitaries, many different HTOs are possible for each quantum operation. On the other hand, there are also strong restrictions on the HTOs which arise from the unitarity of the transformations. The most important of these is the Landauer erasure principle. This paper is concerned with the question of finding a complete set of restrictions on the HTOs that are associated with a given quantum operation. An answer to this question has been found only for a subset of quantum operations. For erasure operations, these characterizations are equivalent to the generalized Landauer erasure principle. For the case of generic quantum operations, however, it appears that the HTOs obey further restrictions which cannot be obtained from the entropic restrictions of the generalized Landauer erasure principle.
We investigate the time evolution of a generic and finite isolated quantum many-body system starting from a pure quantum state. We find the kinematical general canonical principle proposed by Popescu-Short-Winter for statistical mechanics can be built in a more solid ground by studying the thermalization, i.e. comparing the density matrices themselves rather than the measures of distances. In particular, this allows us to explicitly identify that, from any instantaneous pure state after thermalization, the state of subsystem is like from a microcanonical ensemble or a generalized Gibbs ensemble, but neither a canonical nor a thermal ones due to finite-size effect. Our results are expected to bring the task of characterizing the state after thermalization to completion. In addition, thermalization of coupled systems with different temperatures corresponding to mixed initial states is studied.
Despite early developments on the foundations of quantum mechanics concern the wave function, quantum statistics has been developed with the density matrix formalism, leading to very important results in explaining molecular observations. Only recently, several authors argued a new interpretation by focusing on the wave function representing the quantum state of an isolated system, showing how a single wave function can exhibit statistical properties and generate the same results expected in the standard quantum statistical framework. Starting from these results, investigation on the foundations of quantum statistical mechanics has gained recently a renewed interest. As a matter of fact, the possibility of studying single molecule properties as well as the need of a better understanding of the effect of quantum dynamics, in order to develop new nanoscaled materials suitable to quantum computing tasks, have opened new intriguing questions leading to quantum statistical approaches far from being well understood and accepted. In this framework the behaviour of a single realization of quantum systems has gained a central role in the description of molecular systems. Furthermore, in recent years, an increasing number of studies has been presented on quantum dynamics through the numerical solution of the Schrödinger equation for systems of interacting components. These studies demonstrates that Quantum Dynamics Simulations could be a practicable route. In order to study phenomena such as dissipation, relaxation and thermalization, the focus has to be moved from isolated molecules to modular systems made of mutual interacting components, with model Hamiltonians possessing a sufficiently low dimensional representation. An important issue concerns the rules to be employed for the choice of the initial quantum state for the simulation of isolated systems. As long as one considers molecular degrees of freedom interacting with a (model) environment, there are no reasons to select a particular quantum state for the overall system and, therefore, a random choice has to be performed amongst a well defined statistical ensemble of pure states. Furthermore, one would like to operate a choice assuring that the simulation of the system is in a well defined thermal state with given temperature. This necessarily calls for a statistical description like for classical systems. A useful parametrization of the wave function will be presented in order to highlight the most appropriate variable for the statistical analysis. In particular some of them, called phases, retain all the dynamical information whereas the others, called populations, are the constants of motion. The latter, in particular are very important because they describe the equilibrium properties strictly related to the thermodynamic description. Since the dynamics of wave function does not supply any information about populations, the definition of a probability distribution on these variables is required. Different probability distributions on populations have been proposed, only on the bases of reasonable assumptions and they validation has been performed only with a posteriori considerations. In particular Fresch and Moro have demonstrated how the agreement with thermodynamics can be employed to discriminate different probability distributions on pure states. This had led the uniform ensembles to be, up to now, the most self-consistent models for quantum pure states. However, in this thesis I will highlight a drawback of the uniform distribution ensemble that can be described as follow: if we bring into contact two systems, even through a perturbative interaction, we are not able to describe the equilibrium properties after the interaction within the uniform distribution statistics, since the uniform character is lost. It represents a severe shortcoming of the statistical ensemble from a methodological point of view, since closed systems can be always considered as the result of interaction among previously isolated systems. On the other hand this drawback introduces a further requirement of a different nature that can be used for the definition of a new statistical ensemble. In this work I intend to find and characterize a statistical ensemble for populations that overcomes the drawbacks of the uniform distribution of pure states. The invariance of the thermal state in the coupling of identical systems will be used as a guideline in the definition af a new probability distribution on populations. Such an ensemble for pure states, called Thermalization Resilient Ensemble, provides a convenient framework for treating the interactions between quantum systems, as long as the structure of the statistical distribution is preserved and the identification of thermodynamic properties is assured. In perspective it should be the privileged statistical ensemble to implement Quantum Dynamics Simulations. Once the average properties of the Thermalization Resilient Ensemble have been introduced, I will obtain a probability distribution on pure states with the use of a geometrical analysis on the Hilbert space. The surface elements of an ellipsoidal manifold will be related to the probability density on populations. As a matter of fact the explicit form of the probability distribution is a prerequisite in order to perform Quantum Dynamical Simulations. However the results obtained through the geometrical analysis cannot be easily extended to systems with unbounded energy spectrum and an alternative strategy has been developed. A scaling algorithm on the basis of the uniform statistical ensemble will be described and this allows a well defined sampling of a probability distribution with desired averages. In this framework I demonstrate the emergence of thermodynamic behavior in the limit of macroscopic systems. In the last part of the thesis I consider the dynamical features of the thermalization experiment. Two identical systems, initially at different temperature, will be brought in interaction and the analysis of the final equilibrium state will be performed for two different generic forms of the interaction Hamiltonian, highlighting how the statistical approach can be very useful in the definition of the equilibrium in complex quantum systems.
Perturbation theory in thermofield dynamics (a real time finite temperature quantum field theory) is formulated in the interaction representation and a diagrammatic expansion for the expectation value of time ordered products is derived solely on the basis of the thermal state condition and the algebraic properties of the operators. This new formulation has a much wider domain of applicability than those presented previously. The method is applicable even in the case of purely quantum mechanical systems. When certain bosonic operators, which commute with the unperturbed Hamiltonian, contribute to the renormalization of the thermal state vacuum the vacuum diagrams do not cancel in the usual way. It will be shown how these diagrams arise and how they may be computed.