Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2402.02222 · Physical Review A

Pairing properties of an odd-frequency superfluid Fermi gas

Shumpei Iwasaki, Taira Kawamura, Koki Manabe, Yoji Ohashi

Published Jun 5, 2024• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We theoretically investigate strong-coupling properties of an odd-frequency Fermi superfluid. This pairing state has the unique property that Cooper pairs are formed between fermions, not at the same time, but at different times. To see whether or not such unequal-time pairs still exhibit bosonic behavior, we examine the space-time structure of the odd-frequency Cooper-pair wave function at $T=0$, by employing the combined path-integral formalism with the BCS-Eagles-Leggett-type superfluid theory. In the strong-coupling regime, the odd-frequency pair wave function still has different space-time structure from that in the ordinary even-frequency $s$-wave superfluid state; their magnitudes are found to become close to each other, except for the equal-time pairing component. In this regime, we also evaluate the superfluid phase transition temperature ${T}_{\mathrm{c}}$ within the framework of the strong-coupling theory developed by Nozi\`eres and Schmitt-Rink. The calculated ${T}_{\mathrm{c}}$ in the strong-coupling regime of the odd-frequency system is found to be well described by the Bose-Einstein condensation of tightly bound Bose molecules. Our results indicate that, in spite of vanishing equal-time pairing, odd-frequency Cooper pairs still behave like bosons in the strong-coupling regime, as in the even-frequency $s$-wave superfluid case.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.109.063309

Related papers

Strong-Coupling Properties of ap-Wave Interacting Fermi Gas on the Viewpoint of Specific Heat at Constant Volume

Daisuke Inotani, Pieter van Wyk, Yoji Ohashi

We theoretically investigate the specific heat $C_V$ at constant volume in the normal state of a $p$-wave interacting Fermi gas. Including fluctuations in the $p$-wave Cooper channel within the framework of the strong-coupling theory developed by Nozières and Schmitt-Rink, we clarify how $C_V$ as a function of temperature varies, as one moves from the weak-coupling regime to the strong-coupling limit. In the weak-coupling regime, $C_V$ is shown to be enhanced by $p$-wave pairing fluctuations, near the superfluid phase transition temperature $T_{\rm c}$. Similar enhancement of $C_V(T\simeq T_{\rm c})$ is also obtained in the strong-coupling regime, which, however, reflects that system is close an ideal Bose gas of $p$-wave two-body bound molecules. Using these results, we classify the normal state into (1) the normal Fermi gas regime, (2) the $p$-wave molecular Bose gas regime, and (3) the region between the two, where $p$-wave pairing fluctuations are dominant. Since the current experiments can only access the normal phase of a $p$-wave interacting Fermi gas, our results would be useful for experiments to understand strong-coupling properties of this Fermi system above $T_{\rm c}$.

arXiv:1610.08598•Journal of the Physical Society of Japan•Jan 26, 2017•3 citations

Pairing and Superfluid Properties of Dilute Fermion Gases at Unitarity

Nandini Trivedi

We study the system of a dilute gas of fermions in 3-dimensions, with attractive interactions tuned to the unitarity point, using the non-perturbative Restricted Path Integral Monte Carlo (R-PIMC) method. The pairing and superfluid properties of this system are calculated at finite temperature. The total energy at very low temperature from our results agrees closely with that of previous ground-state Quantum Monte Carlo calculations. We identify the temperature T � � 0.70ǫF below which pairing correlations develop, and estimate the critical temperature for the superfluid transition Tc � 0.25ǫF from a finite size scaling analysis of the superfluid density. PACS numbers: The recent experiments, starting with generating a degenerate gas of cold atoms[3], the use of Feshbach resonance to tune the effective interaction between the fermions[4, 5], the measurements of the gap to identify a pairing scale[6] and the measurements of vortices[7] to identify the superfluid state, have all given an impetus to the study of superfluidity in the BCS-BEC crossover regime. The nature of superconductivity or superfluidity in a many-particle system with an increasing pairing attraction was shown [1, 2] to interpolate smoothly between the BCS regime for weak attraction between the fermions, and the Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC) regime for strong coupling. In the weak coupling regime, the Cooper pair size is much larger than the interparticle spacing, and the simultaneous pairing and condensation of fermions is well described by the BCS theory. In the strong coupling regime, fermions form strongly bound bosonic molecules at a pairing temperature scale T ∗ that is considerably higher than the BEC temperature Tc. In a two species system of fermions with an attractive interaction between them, the unitary point is defined by the divergence of the zero energy s-channel scattering length, as, for two particles in free space. The unitary point is interesting since it describes a strongly correlated system with universal properties[8]. In general, there are two length scales that define the system: the interparticle spacing ∝ n −1/3 , and the scattering length as which contains information about the interaction potential. At the unitary point however, since as diverges, all the properties of the system are described by a single length scale k −1

Bulletin of the American Physical Society•Mar 6, 2007•0 citations

Superfluid properties of an ultracold Fermi gas with an orbital Feshbach resonance in the BCS-BEC crossover region

Taro Kamihori, Daichi Kagamihara, Yoji Ohashi

We theoretically investigate the superfluid properties of a two-band gas of $^{173}\mathrm{Yb}$ Fermi atoms with an orbital Feshbach resonance (OFR). To describe the BCS-BEC crossover region, we include superfluid fluctuations caused by interband and intraband pairing interactions associated with OFR by extending the strong-coupling theory developed by Nozi\`eres and Schmitt-Rink to the two-band case below the superfluid phase transition temperature; however, the effects of an experimentally inaccessible deep bound state are removed to model a real $^{173}\mathrm{Yb}$ Fermi gas near OFR. We show that the condensate fraction in the upper closed channel gradually becomes smaller than that in the lower open channel as one moves from the strong- to the weak-coupling regime, because the OFR-pairing mechanism tunes the interaction strengths by adjusting the energy difference between the two bands. However, even when the closed-channel band is much higher in energy than the open-channel band in the weak-coupling regime, the magnitude of the superfluid order parameter in the closed channel is found to be still comparable to that in the open channel. As the reason for this, we point out a pair-tunneling effect by the OFR-induced interband interaction. In addition to these superfluid quantities, we also examine collective modes, such as the Goldstone mode, the Schmid (Higgs) mode, and Leggett mode, to clarify how they appear in the spectral weights of pair-correlation functions in each band. Since the realization of a multiband superfluid Fermi gas is a crucial issue in cold Fermi gas physics, our results would contribute to the basic understanding of this type of Fermi superfluid in the BCS-BEC crossover region.

arXiv:2103.16933•Physical Review A•May 24, 2021•1 citation

Odd-frequency pairing in a binary mixture of bosonic and fermionic cold atoms

Ryan M. Kalas, Alexander V. Balatsky, Dmitry Mozyrsky

We study fermionic superfluidity in a boson-single-species-fermion cold-atom mixture. We argue that apart from the standard $p$-wave fermion pairing mediated by the phonon field of the boson gas, the system also exhibits $s$-wave pairing with the anomalous correlator being an odd function of time or frequency. We show that such a superfluid phase can have a much higher transition temperature than the $p$-wave and may exist for sufficiently strong couplings between fermions and bosons. These conditions for odd-frequency pairing are favorable close to the value of the coupling at which the mixture phase separates. We evaluate the critical temperatures for this system and discuss the experimental realization of this superfluid in ultracold atomic gases.

arXiv:0806.0419•Physical Review B•Nov 18, 2008•19 citations

Quantum Monte Carlo studies of superfluid Fermi gases

Siyuan Chang, Vijay R. Pandharipande, Joseph Carlson +1 more

We report results of quantum Monte Carlo calculations of the ground state of dilute Fermi gases with attractive short-range two-body interactions. The strength of the interaction is varied to study different pairing regimes which are characterized by the product of the $s$-wave scattering length and the Fermi wave vector, $a{k}_{F}$. We report results for the ground-state energy, the pairing gap $\ensuremath{\Delta}$, and the quasiparticle spectrum. In the weak-coupling regime, $1∕a{k}_{F}<\ensuremath{-}1$, we obtain Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer (BCS) superfluid and the energy gap $\ensuremath{\Delta}$ is much smaller than the Fermi gas energy ${E}_{\mathrm{FG}}$. When $a>0$, the interaction is strong enough to form bound molecules with energy ${E}_{\mathrm{mol}}$. For $1∕a{k}_{F}\ensuremath{\gtrsim}0.5$, we find that weakly interacting composite bosons are formed in the superfluid gas with $\ensuremath{\Delta}$ and gas energy per particle approaching $\ensuremath{\mid}{E}_{\mathrm{mol}}\ensuremath{\mid}∕2$. In this region, we seem to have Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC) of molecules. The behavior of the energy and the gap in the BCS-to-BEC transition region, $\ensuremath{-}0.5<1∕a{k}_{F}<0.5$, is discussed.

arXiv:physics/0404115•Physical Review A•Oct 5, 2004•221 citations

Bosonization of Cooper pairs and novel Bose-liquid superconductivity and superfluidity in high-Tc cuprates and other exotic systems

Dzhumanov, S.

Various BCS-like pairing theories are still invariably used to describe the unusual superconducting/superfluid states and properties of condensed matters without clarifying the fermionic or bosonic nature of Cooper pairs and the relevant mechanisms of superconductivity and superfluidity. We show that the bosonization of Cooper pairs and the novel superconductivity and superfluidity resulting from the condensation of an attractive Bose gas of Cooper pairs into a superfluid state in high-Tc cuprates and other exotic systems occur under the condition εF≲2εA (where εF is the Fermi energy, εA is the energy of the effective attraction between fermions). We argue that the simple BCS criterion (i.e. formation of an energy gap on the Fermi surface) is insufficient for the occurrence of unconventional superconductivity (superfluidity) and the superconducting/superfluid transition in attractive Bose systems is more λ-like than the usual Bose–Einstein condensation. The new and specific criteria for unconventional superconductivity and superfluidity are formulated. Mean-field theory of the three- and two-dimensional superfluid Bose condensates of Cooper pairs describes reasonably well the novel superconducting states (i.e., two distinct superconducting phases below the bulk superconducting transition temperature Tc and a vortex-like state above Tc) and properties (such as λ-like transition at Tc, first-order phase transition and gapless bosonic excitations somewhat below Tc or even far below Tc) of high-Tc cuprates in full agreement with the experimental findings. The unusual superconducting/superfluid states and properties of heavy-fermion and organic compounds, Sr2RuO4, 3He, 4He and atomic Fermi gases are explained more clearly by this theory.

•Jan 1, 2019•0 citations
We theoretically investigate strong-coupling properties of an odd-frequency Fermi superfluid. This pairing state has the unique property that Cooper pairs are formed between fermions, not at the same time, but at different times. To see whether or not such unequal-time pairs still exhibit bosonic behavior, we examine the space-time structure of the odd-frequency Cooper-pair wave function at T=0T=0T=0, by employing the combined path-integral formalism with the BCS-Eagles-Leggett-type superfluid theory. In the strong-coupling regime, the odd-frequency pair wave function still has different space-time structure from that in the ordinary even-frequency sss-wave superfluid state; their magnitudes are found to become close to each other, except for the equal-time pairing component. In this regime, we also evaluate the superfluid phase transition temperature Tc{T}_{\mathrm{c}}Tc​ within the framework of the strong-coupling theory developed by Nozi`eres and Schmitt-Rink. The calculated Tc{T}_{\mathrm{c}}Tc​ in the strong-coupling regime of the odd-frequency system is found to be well described by the Bose-Einstein condensation of tightly bound Bose molecules. Our results indicate that, in spite of vanishing equal-time pairing, odd-frequency Cooper pairs still behave like bosons in the strong-coupling regime, as in the even-frequency sss-wave superfluid case.
We theoretically investigate the specific heat CVC_VCV​ at constant volume in the normal state of a ppp-wave interacting Fermi gas. Including fluctuations in the ppp-wave Cooper channel within the framework of the strong-coupling theory developed by Nozières and Schmitt-Rink, we clarify how CVC_VCV​ as a function of temperature varies, as one moves from the weak-coupling regime to the strong-coupling limit. In the weak-coupling regime, CVC_VCV​ is shown to be enhanced by ppp-wave pairing fluctuations, near the superfluid phase transition temperature TcT_{\rm c}Tc​. Similar enhancement of CV(T≃Tc)C_V(T\simeq T_{\rm c})CV​(T≃Tc​) is also obtained in the strong-coupling regime, which, however, reflects that system is close an ideal Bose gas of ppp-wave two-body bound molecules. Using these results, we classify the normal state into (1) the normal Fermi gas regime, (2) the ppp-wave molecular Bose gas regime, and (3) the region between the two, where ppp-wave pairing fluctuations are dominant. Since the current experiments can only access the normal phase of a ppp-wave interacting Fermi gas, our results would be useful for experiments to understand strong-coupling properties of this Fermi system above TcT_{\rm c}Tc​.
We study the system of a dilute gas of fermions in 3-dimensions, with attractive interactions tuned to the unitarity point, using the non-perturbative Restricted Path Integral Monte Carlo (R-PIMC) method. The pairing and superfluid properties of this system are calculated at finite temperature. The total energy at very low temperature from our results agrees closely with that of previous ground-state Quantum Monte Carlo calculations. We identify the temperature T � � 0.70ǫF below which pairing correlations develop, and estimate the critical temperature for the superfluid transition Tc � 0.25ǫF from a finite size scaling analysis of the superfluid density. PACS numbers: The recent experiments, starting with generating a degenerate gas of cold atoms[3], the use of Feshbach resonance to tune the effective interaction between the fermions[4, 5], the measurements of the gap to identify a pairing scale[6] and the measurements of vortices[7] to identify the superfluid state, have all given an impetus to the study of superfluidity in the BCS-BEC crossover regime. The nature of superconductivity or superfluidity in a many-particle system with an increasing pairing attraction was shown [1, 2] to interpolate smoothly between the BCS regime for weak attraction between the fermions, and the Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC) regime for strong coupling. In the weak coupling regime, the Cooper pair size is much larger than the interparticle spacing, and the simultaneous pairing and condensation of fermions is well described by the BCS theory. In the strong coupling regime, fermions form strongly bound bosonic molecules at a pairing temperature scale T ∗ that is considerably higher than the BEC temperature Tc. In a two species system of fermions with an attractive interaction between them, the unitary point is defined by the divergence of the zero energy s-channel scattering length, as, for two particles in free space. The unitary point is interesting since it describes a strongly correlated system with universal properties[8]. In general, there are two length scales that define the system: the interparticle spacing ∝ n −1/3 , and the scattering length as which contains information about the interaction potential. At the unitary point however, since as diverges, all the properties of the system are described by a single length scale k −1
We theoretically investigate the superfluid properties of a two-band gas of 173Yb^{173}\mathrm{Yb}173Yb Fermi atoms with an orbital Feshbach resonance (OFR). To describe the BCS-BEC crossover region, we include superfluid fluctuations caused by interband and intraband pairing interactions associated with OFR by extending the strong-coupling theory developed by Nozi\`eres and Schmitt-Rink to the two-band case below the superfluid phase transition temperature; however, the effects of an experimentally inaccessible deep bound state are removed to model a real 173Yb^{173}\mathrm{Yb}173Yb Fermi gas near OFR. We show that the condensate fraction in the upper closed channel gradually becomes smaller than that in the lower open channel as one moves from the strong- to the weak-coupling regime, because the OFR-pairing mechanism tunes the interaction strengths by adjusting the energy difference between the two bands. However, even when the closed-channel band is much higher in energy than the open-channel band in the weak-coupling regime, the magnitude of the superfluid order parameter in the closed channel is found to be still comparable to that in the open channel. As the reason for this, we point out a pair-tunneling effect by the OFR-induced interband interaction. In addition to these superfluid quantities, we also examine collective modes, such as the Goldstone mode, the Schmid (Higgs) mode, and Leggett mode, to clarify how they appear in the spectral weights of pair-correlation functions in each band. Since the realization of a multiband superfluid Fermi gas is a crucial issue in cold Fermi gas physics, our results would contribute to the basic understanding of this type of Fermi superfluid in the BCS-BEC crossover region.
We study fermionic superfluidity in a boson-single-species-fermion cold-atom mixture. We argue that apart from the standard ppp-wave fermion pairing mediated by the phonon field of the boson gas, the system also exhibits sss-wave pairing with the anomalous correlator being an odd function of time or frequency. We show that such a superfluid phase can have a much higher transition temperature than the ppp-wave and may exist for sufficiently strong couplings between fermions and bosons. These conditions for odd-frequency pairing are favorable close to the value of the coupling at which the mixture phase separates. We evaluate the critical temperatures for this system and discuss the experimental realization of this superfluid in ultracold atomic gases.
We report results of quantum Monte Carlo calculations of the ground state of dilute Fermi gases with attractive short-range two-body interactions. The strength of the interaction is varied to study different pairing regimes which are characterized by the product of the sss-wave scattering length and the Fermi wave vector, akFa{k}_{F}akF​. We report results for the ground-state energy, the pairing gap $\ensuremath{\Delta}$, and the quasiparticle spectrum. In the weak-coupling regime, $1∕a{k}_{F}<\ensuremath{-}1$, we obtain Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer (BCS) superfluid and the energy gap $\ensuremath{\Delta}$ is much smaller than the Fermi gas energy EFG{E}_{\mathrm{FG}}EFG​. When a>0a>0a>0, the interaction is strong enough to form bound molecules with energy Emol{E}_{\mathrm{mol}}Emol​. For $1∕a{k}_{F}\ensuremath{\gtrsim}0.5$, we find that weakly interacting composite bosons are formed in the superfluid gas with $\ensuremath{\Delta}$ and gas energy per particle approaching $\ensuremath{\mid}{E}_{\mathrm{mol}}\ensuremath{\mid}∕2$. In this region, we seem to have Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC) of molecules. The behavior of the energy and the gap in the BCS-to-BEC transition region, $\ensuremath{-}0.5<1∕a{k}_{F}<0.5$, is discussed.
Various BCS-like pairing theories are still invariably used to describe the unusual superconducting/superfluid states and properties of condensed matters without clarifying the fermionic or bosonic nature of Cooper pairs and the relevant mechanisms of superconductivity and superfluidity. We show that the bosonization of Cooper pairs and the novel superconductivity and superfluidity resulting from the condensation of an attractive Bose gas of Cooper pairs into a superfluid state in high-Tc cuprates and other exotic systems occur under the condition εF≲2εA (where εF is the Fermi energy, εA is the energy of the effective attraction between fermions). We argue that the simple BCS criterion (i.e. formation of an energy gap on the Fermi surface) is insufficient for the occurrence of unconventional superconductivity (superfluidity) and the superconducting/superfluid transition in attractive Bose systems is more λ-like than the usual Bose–Einstein condensation. The new and specific criteria for unconventional superconductivity and superfluidity are formulated. Mean-field theory of the three- and two-dimensional superfluid Bose condensates of Cooper pairs describes reasonably well the novel superconducting states (i.e., two distinct superconducting phases below the bulk superconducting transition temperature Tc and a vortex-like state above Tc) and properties (such as λ-like transition at Tc, first-order phase transition and gapless bosonic excitations somewhat below Tc or even far below Tc) of high-Tc cuprates in full agreement with the experimental findings. The unusual superconducting/superfluid states and properties of heavy-fermion and organic compounds, Sr2RuO4, 3He, 4He and atomic Fermi gases are explained more clearly by this theory.