Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2312.06151 · New Journal of Physics

Measurement-device-independent detection of beyond-quantum state

Baichu Yu, Masahito Hayashi

Published Sep 9, 2024• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract In quantum theory, a quantum state on a composite system of two parties realizes a non-negative probability with any measurement element with a tensor product form. However, there also exist non-quantum states which satisfy the above condition. Such states are called beyond-quantum states, and cannot be detected by standard Bell tests. To distinguish a beyond-quantum state from quantum states, we propose a measurement-device-independent (MDI) test for beyond-quantum state detection, which is composed of quantum input states on respective parties and quantum measurements across the input system and the target system on respective parties. The performance of our protocol is independent of the forms of the tested states and the measurement operators, which provides an advantage in practical scenarios. We also discuss the importance of tomographic completeness of the input sets to the detection.

DOI
10.1088/1367-2630/ad787c

Related papers

Detection of Beyond-Quantum Non-locality based on Standard Local Quantum Observables

Hayato Arai, Yu, Baichu, Hayashi, Masahito

Device independent detections of quantum non-locality like Bell-CHSH inequality are important methods to detect quantum non-locality because the whole protocol can be implemented by uncertified local observables. However, this detection is not sufficient for the justification of standard quantum theory, because there are theoretically many types of beyond-quantum non-local states in General Probabilistic Theories. One important class is Entanglement Structures (ESs), which contain beyond-quantum non-local states even though their local systems are completely equivalent to standard quantum systems. This paper shows that any device independent detection cannot distinguish beyond-quantum non-local states from standard quantum states. To overcome this problem, this paper gives a device dependent detection based on local observables to distinguish any beyond-quantum non-local state from all standard quantum states. Especially, we give a way to detect any beyond-quantum non-local state in two-qubit ESs by observing only spin observables on local systems.

arXiv:2301.04196•Jan 10, 2023•1 citation

Experimental Measurement-Device-Independent Entanglement Detection

Mohamed Nawareg, Sadiq Muhammad, Elias Amselem +1 more

Entanglement is one of the most puzzling features of quantum theory and of great importance for the new field of quantum information. The determination whether a given state is entangled or not is one of the most challenging open problems of the field. Here we report on the experimental demonstration of measurement-device-independent (MDI) entanglement detection using witness method for general two qubits photon polarization systems. In the MDI settings, there is no requirement to assume perfect implementations or neither to trust the measurement devices. This experimental demonstration can be generalized for the investigation of properties of quantum systems and for the realization of cryptography and communication protocols.

Scientific Reports•Feb 4, 2015•27 citations

Detection and quantification of entanglement with measurement-device-independent and universal entanglement witness*

Zhi‐Jin Ke, Yi‐Tao Wang, Shang Yu +10 more

Entanglement is the key resource in quantum information processing, and an entanglement witness (EW) is designed to detect whether a quantum system has any entanglement. However, prior knowledge of the target states should be known first to design a suitable EW, which weakens this method. Nevertheless, a recent theory shows that it is possible to design a universal entanglement witness (UEW) to detect negative-partial-transpose (NPT) entanglement in unknown bipartite states with measurement-device-independent (MDI) characteristic. The outcome of a UEW can also be upgraded to be an entanglement measure. In this study, we experimentally design and realize an MDI UEW for two-qubit entangled states. All of the tested states are well-detected without any prior knowledge. We also show that it is able to quantify entanglement by comparing it with concurrence estimated through state tomography. The relation between them is also revealed. The entire experimental framework ensures that the UEW is MDI.

Chinese Physics B•May 13, 2020•8 citations

Efficient device-independent entanglement detection for multipartite systems

Baccari, Flavio, Daniel Cavalcanti, Wittek, Peter +1 more

Entanglement is one of the most studied properties of quantum mechanics for its application in quantum information protocols. Nevertheless, detecting the presence of entanglement in large multipartite sates keeps being a great challenge both from the theoretical and the experimental point of view. Most of the known methods either have computational costs that scale inefficiently with the number of parties or require more information on the state than what is attainable in every-day experiments. We introduce a new technique for entanglement detection that provides several important advantages in these respects. First, its scales efficiently with the number of parties, thus allowing for application to systems composed by up to few tens of parties. Second, it needs only the knowledge of a subset of all possible measurements on the state, therefore being apt for experimental implementation. Moreover, since it is based on the detection of nonlocality, our method is device-independent. We report several examples of its implementation for well-known multipartite states, showing that the introduced technique has a promising range of applications.

•Jan 1, 2016•46 citations

Sequential measurement-device-independent entanglement detection by multiple observers

Chirag Srivastava, Shiladitya Mal, Aditi Sen +1 more

Violation of a Bell inequality certifies that the underlying state must be entangled in a device-independent way, although there exist some entangled states which do not violate such an inequality. However, for every entangled state, it is possible to find a Hermitian operator called an entanglement witness that can detect entanglement through some local measurements in a device-dependent method, but implementation of wrong measurements may lead to fake detection of entanglement. To avoid such difficulties, measurement-device-independent entanglement witness (MDI-EW) based on a semiquantum nonlocal game was proposed, which is not only robust against wrong measurements but also against a specific kind of lossy detectors. We employ here a measurement-device-independent entanglement witness to detect entanglement in a scenario where half of an entangled pair is possessed by a single observer while the other half is with multiple observers performing unsharp measurements, sequentially, independently, and preserving entanglement as much as possible. Interestingly, we find that the numbers of successful observers who can detect entanglement, measurement-device-independently, both with equal and unequal sharpness parameters of the noisy measurements, are greater than that obtained with standard and Bell-inequality-based entanglement detection methods, reflecting its robustness. The entanglement contents of the sequentially shared states are also analyzed. Unlike other scenarios, our investigations also reveal that in this measurement-device-independent situation, states having entanglement in proximity to maximal remain entangled until there are two sequential observers, even if they measure sharply.

arXiv:1911.02908•Physical Review A•Mar 10, 2021•30 citations

Closing loopholes of measurement-device-independent nonlinear entanglement witnesses

Kornikar Sen, Chirag Srivastava, Ujjwal Sen

The concept of entanglement witnesses forms a useful technique to detect entanglement in realistic quantum devices. Measurement-device-independent nonlinear entanglement witnesses (MDI-NEWs) are a kind of entanglement witness that eliminates dependence on the correct alignments of measurement devices for guaranteeing the existence of entanglement and also detects more entangled states than its linear counterparts. While this method guarantees entanglement independent of measurement alignments, it is still prone to serving wrong results due to other loopholes. Here, we study the response of MDI-NEWs to two categories of faults occurring in experiments. In the first category, the detection loophole, characterized by lost and additional events of outcomes of measurements, is investigated, and bounds which guarantee entanglement are obtained in terms of the efficiency of measurement being performed. In the second category, we study noise associated with the sets of additional quantum inputs required in MDI-NEW scenarios. In this case, a type of noise is identified which still allows the MDI-NEWs to guarantee entanglement. We also show that MDI-NEWs are less or equally robust in comparison to their linear counterparts under the same noise in additional quantum inputs, although the former group detects a larger volume of entangled states in the noiseless scenario than their linear cousins.

arXiv:2203.07192•Physical Review A•Nov 27, 2023•0 citations
Abstract In quantum theory, a quantum state on a composite system of two parties realizes a non-negative probability with any measurement element with a tensor product form. However, there also exist non-quantum states which satisfy the above condition. Such states are called beyond-quantum states, and cannot be detected by standard Bell tests. To distinguish a beyond-quantum state from quantum states, we propose a measurement-device-independent (MDI) test for beyond-quantum state detection, which is composed of quantum input states on respective parties and quantum measurements across the input system and the target system on respective parties. The performance of our protocol is independent of the forms of the tested states and the measurement operators, which provides an advantage in practical scenarios. We also discuss the importance of tomographic completeness of the input sets to the detection.
Device independent detections of quantum non-locality like Bell-CHSH inequality are important methods to detect quantum non-locality because the whole protocol can be implemented by uncertified local observables. However, this detection is not sufficient for the justification of standard quantum theory, because there are theoretically many types of beyond-quantum non-local states in General Probabilistic Theories. One important class is Entanglement Structures (ESs), which contain beyond-quantum non-local states even though their local systems are completely equivalent to standard quantum systems. This paper shows that any device independent detection cannot distinguish beyond-quantum non-local states from standard quantum states. To overcome this problem, this paper gives a device dependent detection based on local observables to distinguish any beyond-quantum non-local state from all standard quantum states. Especially, we give a way to detect any beyond-quantum non-local state in two-qubit ESs by observing only spin observables on local systems.
Entanglement is one of the most puzzling features of quantum theory and of great importance for the new field of quantum information. The determination whether a given state is entangled or not is one of the most challenging open problems of the field. Here we report on the experimental demonstration of measurement-device-independent (MDI) entanglement detection using witness method for general two qubits photon polarization systems. In the MDI settings, there is no requirement to assume perfect implementations or neither to trust the measurement devices. This experimental demonstration can be generalized for the investigation of properties of quantum systems and for the realization of cryptography and communication protocols.
Entanglement is the key resource in quantum information processing, and an entanglement witness (EW) is designed to detect whether a quantum system has any entanglement. However, prior knowledge of the target states should be known first to design a suitable EW, which weakens this method. Nevertheless, a recent theory shows that it is possible to design a universal entanglement witness (UEW) to detect negative-partial-transpose (NPT) entanglement in unknown bipartite states with measurement-device-independent (MDI) characteristic. The outcome of a UEW can also be upgraded to be an entanglement measure. In this study, we experimentally design and realize an MDI UEW for two-qubit entangled states. All of the tested states are well-detected without any prior knowledge. We also show that it is able to quantify entanglement by comparing it with concurrence estimated through state tomography. The relation between them is also revealed. The entire experimental framework ensures that the UEW is MDI.
Entanglement is one of the most studied properties of quantum mechanics for its application in quantum information protocols. Nevertheless, detecting the presence of entanglement in large multipartite sates keeps being a great challenge both from the theoretical and the experimental point of view. Most of the known methods either have computational costs that scale inefficiently with the number of parties or require more information on the state than what is attainable in every-day experiments. We introduce a new technique for entanglement detection that provides several important advantages in these respects. First, its scales efficiently with the number of parties, thus allowing for application to systems composed by up to few tens of parties. Second, it needs only the knowledge of a subset of all possible measurements on the state, therefore being apt for experimental implementation. Moreover, since it is based on the detection of nonlocality, our method is device-independent. We report several examples of its implementation for well-known multipartite states, showing that the introduced technique has a promising range of applications.
Violation of a Bell inequality certifies that the underlying state must be entangled in a device-independent way, although there exist some entangled states which do not violate such an inequality. However, for every entangled state, it is possible to find a Hermitian operator called an entanglement witness that can detect entanglement through some local measurements in a device-dependent method, but implementation of wrong measurements may lead to fake detection of entanglement. To avoid such difficulties, measurement-device-independent entanglement witness (MDI-EW) based on a semiquantum nonlocal game was proposed, which is not only robust against wrong measurements but also against a specific kind of lossy detectors. We employ here a measurement-device-independent entanglement witness to detect entanglement in a scenario where half of an entangled pair is possessed by a single observer while the other half is with multiple observers performing unsharp measurements, sequentially, independently, and preserving entanglement as much as possible. Interestingly, we find that the numbers of successful observers who can detect entanglement, measurement-device-independently, both with equal and unequal sharpness parameters of the noisy measurements, are greater than that obtained with standard and Bell-inequality-based entanglement detection methods, reflecting its robustness. The entanglement contents of the sequentially shared states are also analyzed. Unlike other scenarios, our investigations also reveal that in this measurement-device-independent situation, states having entanglement in proximity to maximal remain entangled until there are two sequential observers, even if they measure sharply.
The concept of entanglement witnesses forms a useful technique to detect entanglement in realistic quantum devices. Measurement-device-independent nonlinear entanglement witnesses (MDI-NEWs) are a kind of entanglement witness that eliminates dependence on the correct alignments of measurement devices for guaranteeing the existence of entanglement and also detects more entangled states than its linear counterparts. While this method guarantees entanglement independent of measurement alignments, it is still prone to serving wrong results due to other loopholes. Here, we study the response of MDI-NEWs to two categories of faults occurring in experiments. In the first category, the detection loophole, characterized by lost and additional events of outcomes of measurements, is investigated, and bounds which guarantee entanglement are obtained in terms of the efficiency of measurement being performed. In the second category, we study noise associated with the sets of additional quantum inputs required in MDI-NEW scenarios. In this case, a type of noise is identified which still allows the MDI-NEWs to guarantee entanglement. We also show that MDI-NEWs are less or equally robust in comparison to their linear counterparts under the same noise in additional quantum inputs, although the former group detects a larger volume of entangled states in the noiseless scenario than their linear cousins.