Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2311.04340 · Physical Review Letters

Hydrodynamics of Borromean Counterfluids

Egor S. Babaev, Boris V. Svistunov

Published Jul 9, 2024• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Counterflow superfluidity in a system with N≥3 components is distinctively different from the N=2 case. The key feature is the difference between the number (N) of elementary vortex excitations and the number (N-1) of independent branches of phonon modes, that is, the number of superfluid modes is larger than the number of ordered phase variables. We formulate a hydrodynamic theory of this state. We show how all the dynamical and statistical aspects of this ("Borromean") type of ordering are naturally described by effective N-component theory featuring compact-gauge invariance. We also discuss how off diagonal intercomponent couplings convert the Borromean supercounterfluid into a Borromean insulator, with an emphasis on the properties of a nontrivial state with broken time-reversal symmetry.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.133.026001

Related papers

Field theory of Borromean supercounterfluids

Anatoly B. Kuklov, Leo Radzihovsky, Boris V. Svistunov

We introduce a class of dynamical field theories for $N$-component "Borromean" ($N\geq 3$) super-counterfluid order, naturally formulated in terms of inter-species bosonic fields $ψ_{αβ}$. Their condensation breaks the normal-state [U(1)]$^N$ symmetry down to its diagonal U(1) subgroup, thereby encoding the arrest of the net superflow. This approach broadens our understanding of dynamical properties of super-counterfluids, at low energies capturing its universal properties, phase transition, counterflow vortices, and many of its other properties. Such super-counterfluid strikingly exhibits $N$ distinct flavors of energetically stable elementary vortex solutions, despite $\mathbb{Z}^{N-1}$ homotopy group of its $N\! -\! 1$ independent Goldstone modes, with $N\! -\! 1$ topologically distinct elementary vortex types, obeying modular arithmetic. The model leads to Borromean hydrodynamics as a low-energy theory, reveals counteflow AC Josephson effect, and generically predicts a first-order character of the phase transitions into Borromean super-counterfluid state in dimensions greater than two.

arXiv:2507.21766•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jan 14, 2026•1 citation

Borromean Criticality in Two Dimensions

Alexandru Golic, Igor Timoshuk, Albert Samoilenka +2 more

The characteristic feature of counterflow superfluids consisting of $N\geq 3$ components -- the so-called Borromean supercounterfluids (BSCF) -- is the presence of $N$ distinct elementary topological excitations (vortices) despite having only $N-1$ independent Goldstone modes. We show that this remarkable property clearly manifests itself at the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless-type transition from the BSCF to the normal state, under the conditions of slight to moderate deviations from the case of exact intercomponent symmetry. More generally, our analysis also applies to any multicomponent superfluid with intercomponent drag fine-tuned to the value when certain composite vortices compete energetically with elementary ones.

arXiv:2609.15259•Sep 14, 2026•0 citations

Borromean supercounterfluids at finite temperatures

Alexandru Golic, Igor Timoshuk, Egor S. Babaev +1 more

While the properties of standard (single-component) superfluids are well understood, principal differences arise in a special type of multicomponent systems—the so-called Borromean supercounterfluids—in which (i) supertransport is possible only in the counterflow regime and (ii) there are three or more counterflowing components. Borromean supercounterfluids's correlation and topological properties distinguish them from their single- and two-component counterparts. The component-symmetric case characterized by a distinctively different universality class of the supercounterfluid-to-normal phase transition is especially interesting. Using the recently introduced concept of compact-gauge invariance as the guiding principle, we develop the finite-temperature description of Borromean supercounterfluids in terms of an asymptotically exact long-wave effective action. We formulate and study Borromean X Y and loop statistical models, capturing the universal long-range properties and allowing us to perform efficient worm algorithm simulations. Numeric results demonstrate perfect agreement with analytic predictions. Particularly instructive is the two-dimensional case, where the Borromean nature of the system is strongly manifested while allowing for an asymptotically exact analytic description.

arXiv:2406.12833•Physical Review Research•Jan 15, 2025•2 citations

Borromean Supercounterfluidity

Emil Blomquist, Andrzej Syrwid, Egor S. Babaev

We demonstrate microscopically the existence of a new superfluid state of matter in a three-component Bose mixture trapped in an optical lattice. The superfluid transport involving coflow of all three components is arrested in that state, while counterflows between any pair of components are dissipationless. The presence of three components allows for three different types of counterflows with only two independent superfluid degrees of freedom.

arXiv:2108.11935•Physical Review Letters•Dec 15, 2021•15 citations

Hydrodynamics of a superfluid smectic

Johannes Hofmann, W. Zwerger

Abstract We determine the hydrodynamic modes of the superfluid analog of a smectic-A liquid crystal phase, i.e., a state in which both gauge invariance and translational invariance along a single direction are spontaneously broken. Such a superfluid smectic provides an idealized description of the incommensurate supersolid state realized in Bose–Einstein condensates with strong dipolar interactions as well as of the stripe phase in Bose gases with spin–orbit coupling. We show that the presence of a finite normal fluid density in the ground state of these systems gives rise to a well-defined second-sound type mode even at zero temperature. It replaces the diffusive permeation mode of a normal smectic phase and is directly connected with the classic description of supersolids by Andreev and Lifshitz in terms of a propagating defect mode. An analytic expression is derived for the two sound velocities that appear in the longitudinal excitation spectrum. It only depends on the low-energy parameters associated with the two independent broken symmetries, which are the effective layer compression modulus and the superfluid fraction.

arXiv:2012.06569•Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment•Mar 1, 2021•25 citations

Spontaneous symmetry breaking of vortex number in binary alternating current countersuperflow

Wei-Can Yang, Makoto Tsubota, Hua-Bi Zeng

In binary superfluid counterflow systems, vortex nucleation arises as a consequence of hydrodynamic instabilities when the coupling coefficient and counterflow velocity exceed the critical value. When dealing with two identical components, one might naturally anticipate that the number of vortices generated would remain equal. However, through the numerical experiments of the holographic model and the Gross-Pitaevskii equation, our investigation has unveiled a remarkable phenomenon: in alternating current counterflow systems, once the coupling coefficient and frequency exceed certain critical values, a surprising symmetry-breaking phenomenon occurs. This results in an asymmetry in the number of vortices in the two components. We establish that this phenomenon represents a continuous phase transition, which, as indicated by the phase diagram, is exclusively observable in alternating current counterflow. We provide an explanation for this intriguing phenomenon through soliton structures, thereby uncovering the complex and unique characteristics of quantum fluid instabilities and their rich phenomena.

arXiv:2311.03418•Physical Review A•Apr 3, 2024•1 citation
Counterflow superfluidity in a system with N≥3 components is distinctively different from the N=2 case. The key feature is the difference between the number (N) of elementary vortex excitations and the number (N-1) of independent branches of phonon modes, that is, the number of superfluid modes is larger than the number of ordered phase variables. We formulate a hydrodynamic theory of this state. We show how all the dynamical and statistical aspects of this ("Borromean") type of ordering are naturally described by effective N-component theory featuring compact-gauge invariance. We also discuss how off diagonal intercomponent couplings convert the Borromean supercounterfluid into a Borromean insulator, with an emphasis on the properties of a nontrivial state with broken time-reversal symmetry.
We introduce a class of dynamical field theories for NNN-component "Borromean" (N≥3N\geq 3N≥3) super-counterfluid order, naturally formulated in terms of inter-species bosonic fields ψαβψ_{αβ}ψαβ​. Their condensation breaks the normal-state [U(1)]N^NN symmetry down to its diagonal U(1) subgroup, thereby encoding the arrest of the net superflow. This approach broadens our understanding of dynamical properties of super-counterfluids, at low energies capturing its universal properties, phase transition, counterflow vortices, and many of its other properties. Such super-counterfluid strikingly exhibits NNN distinct flavors of energetically stable elementary vortex solutions, despite ZN−1\mathbb{Z}^{N-1}ZN−1 homotopy group of its N ⁣− ⁣1N\! -\! 1N−1 independent Goldstone modes, with N ⁣− ⁣1N\! -\! 1N−1 topologically distinct elementary vortex types, obeying modular arithmetic. The model leads to Borromean hydrodynamics as a low-energy theory, reveals counteflow AC Josephson effect, and generically predicts a first-order character of the phase transitions into Borromean super-counterfluid state in dimensions greater than two.
The characteristic feature of counterflow superfluids consisting of N≥3N\geq 3N≥3 components -- the so-called Borromean supercounterfluids (BSCF) -- is the presence of NNN distinct elementary topological excitations (vortices) despite having only N−1N-1N−1 independent Goldstone modes. We show that this remarkable property clearly manifests itself at the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless-type transition from the BSCF to the normal state, under the conditions of slight to moderate deviations from the case of exact intercomponent symmetry. More generally, our analysis also applies to any multicomponent superfluid with intercomponent drag fine-tuned to the value when certain composite vortices compete energetically with elementary ones.
While the properties of standard (single-component) superfluids are well understood, principal differences arise in a special type of multicomponent systems—the so-called Borromean supercounterfluids—in which (i) supertransport is possible only in the counterflow regime and (ii) there are three or more counterflowing components. Borromean supercounterfluids's correlation and topological properties distinguish them from their single- and two-component counterparts. The component-symmetric case characterized by a distinctively different universality class of the supercounterfluid-to-normal phase transition is especially interesting. Using the recently introduced concept of compact-gauge invariance as the guiding principle, we develop the finite-temperature description of Borromean supercounterfluids in terms of an asymptotically exact long-wave effective action. We formulate and study Borromean X Y and loop statistical models, capturing the universal long-range properties and allowing us to perform efficient worm algorithm simulations. Numeric results demonstrate perfect agreement with analytic predictions. Particularly instructive is the two-dimensional case, where the Borromean nature of the system is strongly manifested while allowing for an asymptotically exact analytic description.
Abstract We determine the hydrodynamic modes of the superfluid analog of a smectic-A liquid crystal phase, i.e., a state in which both gauge invariance and translational invariance along a single direction are spontaneously broken. Such a superfluid smectic provides an idealized description of the incommensurate supersolid state realized in Bose–Einstein condensates with strong dipolar interactions as well as of the stripe phase in Bose gases with spin–orbit coupling. We show that the presence of a finite normal fluid density in the ground state of these systems gives rise to a well-defined second-sound type mode even at zero temperature. It replaces the diffusive permeation mode of a normal smectic phase and is directly connected with the classic description of supersolids by Andreev and Lifshitz in terms of a propagating defect mode. An analytic expression is derived for the two sound velocities that appear in the longitudinal excitation spectrum. It only depends on the low-energy parameters associated with the two independent broken symmetries, which are the effective layer compression modulus and the superfluid fraction.
In binary superfluid counterflow systems, vortex nucleation arises as a consequence of hydrodynamic instabilities when the coupling coefficient and counterflow velocity exceed the critical value. When dealing with two identical components, one might naturally anticipate that the number of vortices generated would remain equal. However, through the numerical experiments of the holographic model and the Gross-Pitaevskii equation, our investigation has unveiled a remarkable phenomenon: in alternating current counterflow systems, once the coupling coefficient and frequency exceed certain critical values, a surprising symmetry-breaking phenomenon occurs. This results in an asymmetry in the number of vortices in the two components. We establish that this phenomenon represents a continuous phase transition, which, as indicated by the phase diagram, is exclusively observable in alternating current counterflow. We provide an explanation for this intriguing phenomenon through soliton structures, thereby uncovering the complex and unique characteristics of quantum fluid instabilities and their rich phenomena.