Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2311.03888 · Results in Physics

Impact of imperfect measurements on multi-party quantum key distribution

Yang Xiang

Published Oct 5, 2023• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The imperfection of measurements in real-world scenarios can compromise the performance of device-independent quantum key distribution (DIQKD) protocols. In this paper, we focus on a specific DIQKD protocol that relies on the violation of the Svetlichny’s inequality (SI), considering an eavesdropper utilizing the convex combination attack. Our analysis covers both the three-party DIQKD case and the general n-party scenario. Our main result is the relationship between the measurement accuracy and the extractable secret-key rate in all multi-party scenarios. The result demonstrates that as measurement accuracy improves, the extractable secret-key rate approaches 1, reaching its maximum value when the measurement accuracy is perfect. We reveal that achieving positive extractable secret-key rates requires a threshold measurement accuracy that is consistently higher than the critical measurement accuracy necessary to violate the SI. We depict these thresholds for n-party scenarios ranging from n=3 to n=10, demonstrating that as the number of parties (n) increases, both thresholds exhibit a rapid and monotonic convergence towards unity. Furthermore, we consider a scenario involving a non-maximally entangled state with imperfect measurements, where the emission of the initial GHZ state undergoes noise during transmission, resulting in a Werner state. The study further quantifies and demonstrates the relationship between the extractable secret-key rate, the visibility of the Werner state, and the measurement accuracy, specifically emphasizing the three-party scenario. This study aims to illuminate the influence of imperfect measurement accuracy on the security and performance of multi-party DIQKD protocols. The results emphasize the importance of high measurement accuracy in achieving positive secret-key rates and maintaining the violation of the SI.

DOI
10.1016/j.rinp.2023.107051

Related papers

Upper bounds on key rates in device-independent quantum key distribution based on convex-combination attacks

Karol Łukanowski, Maria Balanzó-Juandó, Máté Farkas +2 more

The device-independent framework constitutes the most pragmatic approach to quantum protocols that does not put any trust in their implementations. It requires all claims, about e.g. security, to be made at the level of the final classical data in hands of the end-users. This imposes a great challenge for determining attainable key rates in device-independent quantum key distribution (DIQKD), but also opens the door for consideration of eavesdropping attacks that stem from the possibility of a given data being just generated by a malicious third-party. In this work, we explore this path and present the convex-combination attack as an efficient, easy-to-use technique for upper-bounding DIQKD key rates. It allows verifying the accuracy of lower bounds on key rates for state-of-the-art protocols, whether involving one-way or two-way communication. In particular, we demonstrate with its help that the currently predicted constraints on the robustness of DIQKD protocols to experimental imperfections, such as the finite visibility or detection efficiency, are already very close to the ultimate tolerable thresholds.

arXiv:2206.06245•Quantum•Dec 6, 2023•9 citations

Effects of coherent and incoherent measurement imperfections on multipartite quantum nonlocality and quantum key distribution

Qiong Wang, Wen-Long Qiao, Qing Chen +1 more

Multipartite Bell nonlocality is a central resource for device-independent quantum information protocols, but its practical certification is inevitably affected by imperfect measurements. We analyze how coherent angular misalignment and incoherent outcome flipping affect Bell-value degradation and nonlocality thresholds in $n$-partite GHZ states based on the Mermin, Svetlichny, and Mermin--Ardehali--Belinskii--Klyshko (MABK) inequalities. Coherent misalignment produces periodic angular violation windows whose individual widths shrink with the number of parties. In contrast, incoherent outcome flipping yields a single critical outcome-flipping probability, which increases with $n$ for MABK and the odd-$n$ Mermin inequalities, but decreases with $n$ for the Svetlichny inequality. Connecting the degraded Bell values to asymptotic Devetak--Winter key-rate bounds under a convex-combination attack model shows that secret-key generation imposes stricter constraints on measurement imperfections than nonlocality certification. These results provide quantitative benchmarks for robust multipartite nonlocality certification and key-rate estimation under measurement imperfections.

quant-pharXiv:2607.13645•Jul 16, 2026•0 citations

Device-Independent Quantum Key Distribution beyond qubits

Javier Rivera-Dean, Anna Steffinlongo, Neil Parker-Sánchez +2 more

Device-Independent Quantum Key Distribution (DIQKD) aims to generate secret keys between two parties without relying on trust in their employed devices, imposing strict noise constraints for key generation. This study explores the resilience of high-dimensional quantum systems in DIQKD, focusing on a comparison between qubits and qutrits. Lower bounds on achievable key rates are investigated through numerical optimization, while upper bounds are evaluated using the Convex-Combination attack, which has been further extended to account for arbitrary dimensions. The observed difference between these bounds provides insights into noise thresholds and potential enhancements in DIQKD scenarios, prompting debate on the merit of increased dimensions given the associated experimental efforts required.

arXiv:2402.00161•Jan 31, 2024•1 citation

Device Independent Quantum Key Distribution in the Finite Key Regime

Kanvi Parekh

Relaxing the assumptions about the experimental setup in Quantum Key Distribution protocols lays the foundation for Device Independent Quantum Key Distribution (DIQKD). In the finite key regime of DIQKD, the protocols employ the use of only the CHSH inequality, so far. A natural question therefore arises whether are there other Bell inequalities that help achieve better results (in terms of higher rates, greater noise tolerance and lower number of minimum rounds required for positive rates) than those achieved using CHSH inequality? For the inequalities considered, we find that CHSH fares the best on account of noise tolerance. However, considering the other two parameters of interest we present two bipartite Bell-inequalities with three outcomes per party that perform better than CHSH for a certain range of noise involved.

•Jan 1, 2018•0 citations

Device-independent Quantum Key Distribution and the Role of Bell Nonlocality

Timo Holz

Quantum entanglement is a unique property of quantum particles. It can correlate them in such a way, that further correlations to an additional unwanted party is prevented. This renders quantum theory as the prime candidate to implement a secure distribution of an encryption key. Quantum key distribution (QKD) is dedicated to this task. A striking feature of correlations in a statistical experiment is, that they can, in principle, always be approximated. Even more so, correlations can be obtained without a detailed knowledge about the underlying physical process that generated the experimental data. This no-characterization approach is at the heart of the device-independent (DI) paradigm. Here, Bell inequalities are an imperative tool to detect nonlocal correlations, which are necessary for a DI secret key. One central subject of this thesis is multipartite DIQKD and the implications of Bell nonlocality in this context. Any DIQKD protocol involves test rounds in which the violation of a Bell inequality is checked. For multipartite DIQKD, however, not all Bell inequalities are suitable. We identify the crucial properties a Bell test requires to be a viable option. In this light, a published protocol for multipartite DIQKD is examined. We establish an incompatibility which is inherent to the proposed Bell test in combination with the required quantum states. This leads us to the conclusion, that the proposed protocol necessarily aborts. In a subsequent work, we develop a family of multipartite Bell inequalities, specifically tailored to the task of DI conference key agreement (CKA). Several features of this Bell inequality are analytically characterized. In addition, we prove its usefulness for the purposes of DICKA. To this end, semidefinite programming techniques are employed and extended to the multipartite scenario which allows us to quantify asymptotic DI conference key rates. In a second part, we explore the challenges of implementing (bipartite) long-distance DIQKD with quantum repeaters. For two repeater protocols, we describe how experimental parameters manifest themselves in DI secret-key rates. In doing so, we shed light on the fundamental differences between the usual and the DI scenario and we benchmark the threshold requirements of quantum devices to make profitable DI secret-key rates feasible. Finally, we develop a general method to describe in a non-DI setting the propagation of an important class of errors through quantum circuits in arbitrary dimensions. With this, we discuss the potential of error-corrected quantum repeaters to overcome fundamental point-to-point limitations.

•Jan 1, 2020•0 citations

Implementations for device-independent quantum key distribution

Alejandro Máttar, Antonio Acín

Abstract Device-independent quantum key distribution (DIQKD) generates a secret key among two parties in a provably secure way without making assumptions about the internal working of the devices used in the protocol. The main challenge for a DIQKD physical implementation is that the data observed among the two parties must violate a Bell inequality without fair-sampling, since otherwise the observed correlations can be faked with classical resources and security can no longer be guaranteed. In spite of the advances recently made to achieve higher detection efficiencies in Bell experiments, DIQKD remains experimentally difficult at long distances due to the exponential increase of loss in the channel separating the two parties. Here we describe and analyze plausible solutions to overcome the crucial problem of channel loss in the frame of DIQKD physical implementations.

arXiv:1603.02921•Physica Scripta•Mar 7, 2016•6 citations
The imperfection of measurements in real-world scenarios can compromise the performance of device-independent quantum key distribution (DIQKD) protocols. In this paper, we focus on a specific DIQKD protocol that relies on the violation of the Svetlichny’s inequality (SI), considering an eavesdropper utilizing the convex combination attack. Our analysis covers both the three-party DIQKD case and the general n-party scenario. Our main result is the relationship between the measurement accuracy and the extractable secret-key rate in all multi-party scenarios. The result demonstrates that as measurement accuracy improves, the extractable secret-key rate approaches 1, reaching its maximum value when the measurement accuracy is perfect. We reveal that achieving positive extractable secret-key rates requires a threshold measurement accuracy that is consistently higher than the critical measurement accuracy necessary to violate the SI. We depict these thresholds for n-party scenarios ranging from n=3 to n=10, demonstrating that as the number of parties (n) increases, both thresholds exhibit a rapid and monotonic convergence towards unity. Furthermore, we consider a scenario involving a non-maximally entangled state with imperfect measurements, where the emission of the initial GHZ state undergoes noise during transmission, resulting in a Werner state. The study further quantifies and demonstrates the relationship between the extractable secret-key rate, the visibility of the Werner state, and the measurement accuracy, specifically emphasizing the three-party scenario. This study aims to illuminate the influence of imperfect measurement accuracy on the security and performance of multi-party DIQKD protocols. The results emphasize the importance of high measurement accuracy in achieving positive secret-key rates and maintaining the violation of the SI.
The device-independent framework constitutes the most pragmatic approach to quantum protocols that does not put any trust in their implementations. It requires all claims, about e.g. security, to be made at the level of the final classical data in hands of the end-users. This imposes a great challenge for determining attainable key rates in device-independent quantum key distribution (DIQKD), but also opens the door for consideration of eavesdropping attacks that stem from the possibility of a given data being just generated by a malicious third-party. In this work, we explore this path and present the convex-combination attack as an efficient, easy-to-use technique for upper-bounding DIQKD key rates. It allows verifying the accuracy of lower bounds on key rates for state-of-the-art protocols, whether involving one-way or two-way communication. In particular, we demonstrate with its help that the currently predicted constraints on the robustness of DIQKD protocols to experimental imperfections, such as the finite visibility or detection efficiency, are already very close to the ultimate tolerable thresholds.
Multipartite Bell nonlocality is a central resource for device-independent quantum information protocols, but its practical certification is inevitably affected by imperfect measurements. We analyze how coherent angular misalignment and incoherent outcome flipping affect Bell-value degradation and nonlocality thresholds in nnn-partite GHZ states based on the Mermin, Svetlichny, and Mermin--Ardehali--Belinskii--Klyshko (MABK) inequalities. Coherent misalignment produces periodic angular violation windows whose individual widths shrink with the number of parties. In contrast, incoherent outcome flipping yields a single critical outcome-flipping probability, which increases with nnn for MABK and the odd-nnn Mermin inequalities, but decreases with nnn for the Svetlichny inequality. Connecting the degraded Bell values to asymptotic Devetak--Winter key-rate bounds under a convex-combination attack model shows that secret-key generation imposes stricter constraints on measurement imperfections than nonlocality certification. These results provide quantitative benchmarks for robust multipartite nonlocality certification and key-rate estimation under measurement imperfections.
Device-Independent Quantum Key Distribution (DIQKD) aims to generate secret keys between two parties without relying on trust in their employed devices, imposing strict noise constraints for key generation. This study explores the resilience of high-dimensional quantum systems in DIQKD, focusing on a comparison between qubits and qutrits. Lower bounds on achievable key rates are investigated through numerical optimization, while upper bounds are evaluated using the Convex-Combination attack, which has been further extended to account for arbitrary dimensions. The observed difference between these bounds provides insights into noise thresholds and potential enhancements in DIQKD scenarios, prompting debate on the merit of increased dimensions given the associated experimental efforts required.
Relaxing the assumptions about the experimental setup in Quantum Key Distribution protocols lays the foundation for Device Independent Quantum Key Distribution (DIQKD). In the finite key regime of DIQKD, the protocols employ the use of only the CHSH inequality, so far. A natural question therefore arises whether are there other Bell inequalities that help achieve better results (in terms of higher rates, greater noise tolerance and lower number of minimum rounds required for positive rates) than those achieved using CHSH inequality? For the inequalities considered, we find that CHSH fares the best on account of noise tolerance. However, considering the other two parameters of interest we present two bipartite Bell-inequalities with three outcomes per party that perform better than CHSH for a certain range of noise involved.
Quantum entanglement is a unique property of quantum particles. It can correlate them in such a way, that further correlations to an additional unwanted party is prevented. This renders quantum theory as the prime candidate to implement a secure distribution of an encryption key. Quantum key distribution (QKD) is dedicated to this task. A striking feature of correlations in a statistical experiment is, that they can, in principle, always be approximated. Even more so, correlations can be obtained without a detailed knowledge about the underlying physical process that generated the experimental data. This no-characterization approach is at the heart of the device-independent (DI) paradigm. Here, Bell inequalities are an imperative tool to detect nonlocal correlations, which are necessary for a DI secret key. One central subject of this thesis is multipartite DIQKD and the implications of Bell nonlocality in this context. Any DIQKD protocol involves test rounds in which the violation of a Bell inequality is checked. For multipartite DIQKD, however, not all Bell inequalities are suitable. We identify the crucial properties a Bell test requires to be a viable option. In this light, a published protocol for multipartite DIQKD is examined. We establish an incompatibility which is inherent to the proposed Bell test in combination with the required quantum states. This leads us to the conclusion, that the proposed protocol necessarily aborts. In a subsequent work, we develop a family of multipartite Bell inequalities, specifically tailored to the task of DI conference key agreement (CKA). Several features of this Bell inequality are analytically characterized. In addition, we prove its usefulness for the purposes of DICKA. To this end, semidefinite programming techniques are employed and extended to the multipartite scenario which allows us to quantify asymptotic DI conference key rates. In a second part, we explore the challenges of implementing (bipartite) long-distance DIQKD with quantum repeaters. For two repeater protocols, we describe how experimental parameters manifest themselves in DI secret-key rates. In doing so, we shed light on the fundamental differences between the usual and the DI scenario and we benchmark the threshold requirements of quantum devices to make profitable DI secret-key rates feasible. Finally, we develop a general method to describe in a non-DI setting the propagation of an important class of errors through quantum circuits in arbitrary dimensions. With this, we discuss the potential of error-corrected quantum repeaters to overcome fundamental point-to-point limitations.
Abstract Device-independent quantum key distribution (DIQKD) generates a secret key among two parties in a provably secure way without making assumptions about the internal working of the devices used in the protocol. The main challenge for a DIQKD physical implementation is that the data observed among the two parties must violate a Bell inequality without fair-sampling, since otherwise the observed correlations can be faked with classical resources and security can no longer be guaranteed. In spite of the advances recently made to achieve higher detection efficiencies in Bell experiments, DIQKD remains experimentally difficult at long distances due to the exponential increase of loss in the channel separating the two parties. Here we describe and analyze plausible solutions to overcome the crucial problem of channel loss in the frame of DIQKD physical implementations.