Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2309.16089 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Relevant long-range interaction of the entanglement Hamiltonian emerges from a short-range gapped system

Chuhao Li, Rui-Zhen Huang, Yi-Ming Ding, Zi Yang Meng, Yan-Cheng Wang, Zheng Yan

Published May 31, 2024• 9 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Beyond the Li-Haldane-Poilblanc conjecture, we find the entanglement Hamiltonian (EH) is actually not closely similar to the original Hamiltonian on the virtual edge. Unexpectedly, the EH has some relevant long-range interacting terms which hugely affect the physics. Without loss of generality, we study a spin-1/2 Heisenberg bilayer to obtain the entanglement information between the two layers through our newly developed quantum Monte Carlo scheme, which can simulate large-scale EH. Although the entanglement spectrum carrying the Goldstone mode seems like a Heisenberg model on a single layer, which is consistent with Li-Haldane-Poilblanc conjecture, we demonstrate that there actually exists a finite-temperature phase transition of the EH. The results violate the Mermin-Wagner theorem, which means there should be relevant long-range terms in the EH. It reveals that the Li-Haldane-Poilblanc conjecture ignores necessary corrections for the EH which may lead totally different physics.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.109.195169

Related papers

Sudden change in entanglement Hamiltonian: Phase diagram of an Ising entanglement Hamiltonian

Wang, Zhe, Siyi Yang, Bin-Bin Mao +2 more

The form of the entanglement Hamiltonian varies with the parameters of the original system. Whether there is a singularity is the key problem for demonstrating/negating the universality of the relation between the entanglement spectrum and edge energy spectrum. We carefully study the phase diagram of a 1D Ising entanglement Hamiltonian as an example to clarify the long-standing controversy of the general relation between the entanglement Hamiltonian and original Hamiltonian. Interestingly, even if the singularities indeed exist, the Li-Haldane-Poilblanc conjecture, i.e., the general relation between the entanglement spectrum and edge energy spectrum, seemingly still holds.

arXiv:2410.10090•Oct 14, 2024•0 citations

Demonstrating the wormhole mechanism of the entanglement spectrum via a perturbed boundary

Zenan Liu, Rui-Zhen Huang, Zheng Yan +1 more

The Li-Haldane conjecture is one of the most famous conjectures in physics and opens a new research area in the quantum entanglement and topological phase. Although a lot of theoretical and numerical works have confirmed the conjecture in topological states with bulk-boundary correspondence, the cases with gapped boundary and the systems in high dimension are widely unknown. What is the valid scope of the Li-Haldane conjecture? Via the newly developed quantum Monte Carlo scheme, we are now able to extract the large-scale entanglement spectrum (ES) and study its relation with the edge energy spectrum generally. Taking the two-dimensional Affleck-Kennedy-Lieb-Tasaki model with a tunable boundary on the square-octagon lattice as an example, we find several counterexamples which cannot be explained by the Li-Haldane conjecture; e.g., the low-lying entanglement spectrum does not always show similar behaviors as the energy spectrum on the virtual boundary, and sometimes the ES resembles the energy spectrum of the edge even if it is gapped. Finally, we demonstrate that the newly proposed ``wormhole mechanism'' on the path integral of a reduced density matrix is the formation principle of the general ES. We find that the Li-Haldane conjecture is a particular case in some limit of the wormhole picture while all the examples of the conjecture we have studied can totally be explained within the wormhole mechanism framework. Our results provide important evidence for demonstrating that the wormhole mechanism is the fundamental principle to explain the ES.

arXiv:2303.00772•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Mar 12, 2024•13 citations

Unconventional entanglement scaling and quantum criticality in the long-range spin-one Heisenberg chain with single-ion anisotropy

Patrick Adelhardt, Sean R. Muleady, Kai P. Schmidt +1 more

Long-range interactions can fundamentally reshape the low-energy properties of low-dimensional quantum matter, altering both continuous symmetry breaking and topological phenomena. However, their impact on the quantum criticality separating these regimes remains poorly understood. We determine the ground-state phase diagram and critical properties of the spin-one Heisenberg chain with single-ion anisotropy and staggered antiferromagnetic power-law interactions, using matrix-product state (MPS) calculations complemented by high-order series expansions (pCUT+MC). Such long-range, non-frustrated interactions circumvent the Hohenberg-Mermin-Wagner theorem, thereby stabilizing continuous symmetry breaking (CSB) phases in direct competition with the Haldane phase. We map out the resulting phase diagram and analyze the entanglement entropy scaling behavior in the U(1) and SU(2) CSB phases, finding logarithmic corrections beyond the short-range, universal contributions expected from linearly dispersed Goldstone modes. We further characterize all critical boundaries through finite-size scaling of either the entanglement entropy or the staggered magnetization. In particular, the large-D-to-U(1)-CSB transition exhibits unconventional, continuously varying critical exponents as a function of the long-range decay exponent with a strong dependence on the imposed boundary conditions leading to distinct finite-size scalings for sufficiently long-range potentials. Remarkably, the Haldane-to-U(1)-CSB transition likewise displays unconventional quantum criticality with distinct continuously varying critical exponents. Our work positions this model as a target for near-term atomic platforms with tunable long-range couplings and exhibiting natural single-ion anisotropy, offering a minimal playground for exploring the interplay between long-range interactions, continuous symmetry breaking, and topology.

cond-mat.str-elCross-listedarXiv:2604.12754•Physical Review Research•Apr 15, 2026•0 citations

Unlocking the general relationship between energy and entanglement spectra via the wormhole effect

Zheng Yan, Zi Yang Meng

Based on the path integral formulation of the reduced density matrix, we develop a scheme to overcome the exponential growth of computational complexity in reliably extracting low-lying entanglement spectrum from quantum Monte Carlo simulations. We test the method on the Heisenberg spin ladder with long entangled boundary between two chains and the results support the Li and Haldane's conjecture on entanglement spectrum of topological phase. We then explain the conjecture via the wormhole effect in the path integral and show that it can be further generalized for systems beyond gapped topological phases. Our further simulation results on the bilayer antiferromagnetic Heisenberg model with 2D entangled boundary across the (2 + 1)D O(3) quantum phase transition clearly demonstrate the correctness of the wormhole picture. Finally, we state that since the wormhole effect amplifies the bulk energy gap by a factor of β, the relative strength of that with respect to the edge energy gap will determine the behavior of low-lying entanglement spectrum of the system.

arXiv:2112.05886•Nature Communications•Apr 24, 2023•30 citations

Quantum criticality and entanglement for two dimensional long-range Heisenberg bilayer

Menghan Song, Jiarui Zhao, Yang Qi +2 more

The study of quantum criticality and entanglement in systems with long-range (LR) interactions is still in its early stages, with many open questions remaining. In this work, we investigate critical exponents and scaling of entanglement entropies (EE) in the LR bilayer Heisenberg model using large-scale quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) simulations and the recently developed nonequilibrium increment algorithm for measuring EE. By applying modified (standard) finite-size scaling (FSS) above (below) the upper critical dimension and field theory analysis, we obtain precise critical exponents in three regimes: the LR Gaussian regime with a Gaussian fixed point, the short-range (SR) regime with Wilson-Fisher (WF) exponents, and a LR non-Gaussian regime where the critical exponents vary continuously from LR Gaussian to SR values. We compute the Rényi EE both along the critical line and in the Néel phase and observe that as the LR interaction is enhanced, the area-law contribution in EE gradually vanishes both at quantum critical points (QCPs) and in the Néel phase. The log-correction in EE arising from sharp corners at the QCPs also decays to zero as LR interaction grows, whereas the log-correction for Néel states, caused by the interplay of Goldstone modes and restoration of the symmetry in a finite system, is enhanced as LR interaction becomes stronger. We also discuss relevant experimental settings to detect these nontrivial properties in critical behavior and entanglement information for quantum many-body systems with LR interactions.

arXiv:2306.05465•Jun 8, 2023•0 citations

Worldline deconfinement and emergent long-range interaction in the entanglement Hamiltonian and in the entanglement spectrum

Zenan Liu, Zhe Wang, Dao‐Xin Yao +1 more

The entanglement spectrum (ES) is a powerful tool for probing topological phases. While its behavior in gapped systems is well understood, its properties in gapless regimes remain unclear. In this work, we employ a quantum Monte Carlo method to study the ES of a two-dimensional square-octagon lattice Heisenberg model at quantum criticality and in the Néel phase. We find that the ES exhibits an M-shape magnon mode with a distinct sublinear dispersion, deviating from the conventional linear magnon. This behavior, similar to that of a one-dimensional long-range Heisenberg chain, reveals the emergence of relevant long-range interactions in the entanglement Hamiltonian. We demonstrate that the mechanism underlying short- and long-range interactions in the entanglement Hamiltonian can be interpreted as the confinement/deconfinement of worldlines in the path integral formulation. Our results reveal that gapless modes can fundamentally change the entanglement Hamiltonian and its spectrum, thereby offering insight into this general phenomenon.

arXiv:2506.10078•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Mar 17, 2026•2 citations
Beyond the Li-Haldane-Poilblanc conjecture, we find the entanglement Hamiltonian (EH) is actually not closely similar to the original Hamiltonian on the virtual edge. Unexpectedly, the EH has some relevant long-range interacting terms which hugely affect the physics. Without loss of generality, we study a spin-1/2 Heisenberg bilayer to obtain the entanglement information between the two layers through our newly developed quantum Monte Carlo scheme, which can simulate large-scale EH. Although the entanglement spectrum carrying the Goldstone mode seems like a Heisenberg model on a single layer, which is consistent with Li-Haldane-Poilblanc conjecture, we demonstrate that there actually exists a finite-temperature phase transition of the EH. The results violate the Mermin-Wagner theorem, which means there should be relevant long-range terms in the EH. It reveals that the Li-Haldane-Poilblanc conjecture ignores necessary corrections for the EH which may lead totally different physics.
The form of the entanglement Hamiltonian varies with the parameters of the original system. Whether there is a singularity is the key problem for demonstrating/negating the universality of the relation between the entanglement spectrum and edge energy spectrum. We carefully study the phase diagram of a 1D Ising entanglement Hamiltonian as an example to clarify the long-standing controversy of the general relation between the entanglement Hamiltonian and original Hamiltonian. Interestingly, even if the singularities indeed exist, the Li-Haldane-Poilblanc conjecture, i.e., the general relation between the entanglement spectrum and edge energy spectrum, seemingly still holds.
The Li-Haldane conjecture is one of the most famous conjectures in physics and opens a new research area in the quantum entanglement and topological phase. Although a lot of theoretical and numerical works have confirmed the conjecture in topological states with bulk-boundary correspondence, the cases with gapped boundary and the systems in high dimension are widely unknown. What is the valid scope of the Li-Haldane conjecture? Via the newly developed quantum Monte Carlo scheme, we are now able to extract the large-scale entanglement spectrum (ES) and study its relation with the edge energy spectrum generally. Taking the two-dimensional Affleck-Kennedy-Lieb-Tasaki model with a tunable boundary on the square-octagon lattice as an example, we find several counterexamples which cannot be explained by the Li-Haldane conjecture; e.g., the low-lying entanglement spectrum does not always show similar behaviors as the energy spectrum on the virtual boundary, and sometimes the ES resembles the energy spectrum of the edge even if it is gapped. Finally, we demonstrate that the newly proposed ``wormhole mechanism'' on the path integral of a reduced density matrix is the formation principle of the general ES. We find that the Li-Haldane conjecture is a particular case in some limit of the wormhole picture while all the examples of the conjecture we have studied can totally be explained within the wormhole mechanism framework. Our results provide important evidence for demonstrating that the wormhole mechanism is the fundamental principle to explain the ES.
Long-range interactions can fundamentally reshape the low-energy properties of low-dimensional quantum matter, altering both continuous symmetry breaking and topological phenomena. However, their impact on the quantum criticality separating these regimes remains poorly understood. We determine the ground-state phase diagram and critical properties of the spin-one Heisenberg chain with single-ion anisotropy and staggered antiferromagnetic power-law interactions, using matrix-product state (MPS) calculations complemented by high-order series expansions (pCUT+MC). Such long-range, non-frustrated interactions circumvent the Hohenberg-Mermin-Wagner theorem, thereby stabilizing continuous symmetry breaking (CSB) phases in direct competition with the Haldane phase. We map out the resulting phase diagram and analyze the entanglement entropy scaling behavior in the U(1) and SU(2) CSB phases, finding logarithmic corrections beyond the short-range, universal contributions expected from linearly dispersed Goldstone modes. We further characterize all critical boundaries through finite-size scaling of either the entanglement entropy or the staggered magnetization. In particular, the large-D-to-U(1)-CSB transition exhibits unconventional, continuously varying critical exponents as a function of the long-range decay exponent with a strong dependence on the imposed boundary conditions leading to distinct finite-size scalings for sufficiently long-range potentials. Remarkably, the Haldane-to-U(1)-CSB transition likewise displays unconventional quantum criticality with distinct continuously varying critical exponents. Our work positions this model as a target for near-term atomic platforms with tunable long-range couplings and exhibiting natural single-ion anisotropy, offering a minimal playground for exploring the interplay between long-range interactions, continuous symmetry breaking, and topology.
Based on the path integral formulation of the reduced density matrix, we develop a scheme to overcome the exponential growth of computational complexity in reliably extracting low-lying entanglement spectrum from quantum Monte Carlo simulations. We test the method on the Heisenberg spin ladder with long entangled boundary between two chains and the results support the Li and Haldane's conjecture on entanglement spectrum of topological phase. We then explain the conjecture via the wormhole effect in the path integral and show that it can be further generalized for systems beyond gapped topological phases. Our further simulation results on the bilayer antiferromagnetic Heisenberg model with 2D entangled boundary across the (2 + 1)D O(3) quantum phase transition clearly demonstrate the correctness of the wormhole picture. Finally, we state that since the wormhole effect amplifies the bulk energy gap by a factor of β, the relative strength of that with respect to the edge energy gap will determine the behavior of low-lying entanglement spectrum of the system.
The study of quantum criticality and entanglement in systems with long-range (LR) interactions is still in its early stages, with many open questions remaining. In this work, we investigate critical exponents and scaling of entanglement entropies (EE) in the LR bilayer Heisenberg model using large-scale quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) simulations and the recently developed nonequilibrium increment algorithm for measuring EE. By applying modified (standard) finite-size scaling (FSS) above (below) the upper critical dimension and field theory analysis, we obtain precise critical exponents in three regimes: the LR Gaussian regime with a Gaussian fixed point, the short-range (SR) regime with Wilson-Fisher (WF) exponents, and a LR non-Gaussian regime where the critical exponents vary continuously from LR Gaussian to SR values. We compute the Rényi EE both along the critical line and in the Néel phase and observe that as the LR interaction is enhanced, the area-law contribution in EE gradually vanishes both at quantum critical points (QCPs) and in the Néel phase. The log-correction in EE arising from sharp corners at the QCPs also decays to zero as LR interaction grows, whereas the log-correction for Néel states, caused by the interplay of Goldstone modes and restoration of the symmetry in a finite system, is enhanced as LR interaction becomes stronger. We also discuss relevant experimental settings to detect these nontrivial properties in critical behavior and entanglement information for quantum many-body systems with LR interactions.
The entanglement spectrum (ES) is a powerful tool for probing topological phases. While its behavior in gapped systems is well understood, its properties in gapless regimes remain unclear. In this work, we employ a quantum Monte Carlo method to study the ES of a two-dimensional square-octagon lattice Heisenberg model at quantum criticality and in the Néel phase. We find that the ES exhibits an M-shape magnon mode with a distinct sublinear dispersion, deviating from the conventional linear magnon. This behavior, similar to that of a one-dimensional long-range Heisenberg chain, reveals the emergence of relevant long-range interactions in the entanglement Hamiltonian. We demonstrate that the mechanism underlying short- and long-range interactions in the entanglement Hamiltonian can be interpreted as the confinement/deconfinement of worldlines in the path integral formulation. Our results reveal that gapless modes can fundamentally change the entanglement Hamiltonian and its spectrum, thereby offering insight into this general phenomenon.