Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2308.14151 · Entropy

Broken Arrows: Hardy–Unruh Chains and Quantum Contextuality

Michael Janas, Michel Janssen B

Published Nov 21, 2023• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Hardy and Unruh constructed a family of non-maximally entangled states of pairs of particles giving rise to correlations that cannot be accounted for with a local hidden-variable theory. Rather than pointing to violations of some Bell inequality, however, they pointed to apparent clashes with the basic rules of logic. Specifically, they constructed these states and the associated measurement settings in such a way that the outcomes satisfy some conditionals but not an additional one entailed by them. Quantum mechanics avoids the broken ‘if …then …’ arrows in such Hardy–Unruh chains, as we call them, because it cannot simultaneously assign truth values to all conditionals involved. Measurements to determine the truth value of some preclude measurements to determine the truth value of others. Hardy–Unruh chains thus nicely illustrate quantum contextuality: which variables do and do not obtain definite values depends on what measurements we decide to perform. Using a framework inspired by Bub and Pitowsky and developed in our book Understanding Quantum Raffles (co-authored with Michael E. Cuffaro), we construct and analyze Hardy–Unruh chains in terms of fictitious bananas mimicking the behavior of spin-12 particles.

DOI
10.3390/e25121568

Related papers

Hardy's Paradox and the Fano Associator: A Geometric Diagnosis of Quantum Contextuality

Ian Richard C Buckley

Hardy's paradox is an all-versus-nothing logical contradiction for bipartite quantum systems: three jointly satisfiable conditions on measurement probabilities each force a fourth probability to zero by classical logic, yet quantum mechanics permits that fourth probability to be strictly positive. Unlike Bell inequalities, no statistical averaging is required — the contradiction is exact and logical. This paper presents a five-part numerical study connecting Hardy's paradox to the non-associative geometry of the Fano plane $PG(2,2)$ and the octonion associator $\mathcal{A}(e_i, e_j, e_k) = (e_i e_j)e_k - e_i(e_j e_k)$. Part 1 finds the Hardy state by constrained optimisation (Nelder-Mead, 100 initialisations), confirming all three zero-conditions to within $10^{-6}$ and the impossible event $P(Z^+, Z^+) = 0.10 > 0$ with residual $\sim 10^{-36}$. Part 2 shows that the Fano-SYK ground state restricted to the measurement node pair ${0,1}$ is entangled, with von Neumann entropy $S = 0.8762$ ebits, connecting the Fano dynamical structure to the Hardy contextual structure. Part 3 sweeps a one-parameter entangled state family and demonstrates that the Hardy impossible-event probability and the CHSH witness are correlated (Pearson $r = 0.982$), both vanishing at the separable limit. Part 4 verifies the full octonion associator table: $|\mathcal{A}(e_i,e_j,e_k)| = 0$ for all 7 Fano lines (associative triples) and $|\mathcal{A}| = 2$ for all 28 non-Fano triples, exact to $< 10^{-14}$. Part 5 maps the Hardy measurement settings $Z, X$ to octonion directions $e_0, e_1$, which lie on the unique Fano line ${0,1,3}$, and argues that entanglement forces the bipartite system to sample non-Fano directions in $\mathbb{R}^7 \otimes \mathbb{R}^7$ where no consistent classical truth-value assignment exists. The central claim — stated as the Fano-Contextuality Conjecture — is that a measurement triple admits a consistent joint classical value assignment if and only if the corresponding octonion directions lie on a Fano line ($|\mathcal{A}| = 0$). Hardy contextuality is diagnosed as the consequence of entanglement distributing quantum weight into the non-associative region of measurement space. A formal proof connecting this partition to the Kochen-Specker theorem is identified as the primary open problem. This is the first paper in the ASA Quantum Foundations series (Portfolio F), accompanied by the Spacelike Associator Paradox (doi:10.5281/zenodo.20058013) and the Fano Monogamy Paradox (doi:10.5281/zenodo.20058092). Working paper in the Adelic Simplicial Architecture (ASA) series.

•May 6, 2026•0 citations

Underpinning quantum theory by a non-local hidden variable theory: the contextuality loophole?

Bryan J. Dalton

Abstract Quantum theory has accounted for a wide range of physical effects in systems ranging from microscopic to macroscopic. However, it is associated with various paradoxes—such as the well-known EPR example. Einstein’s suggestion that the theory was incomplete has led to numerous attempts to underpin quantum theory by a hidden variable theory, including the Bell approach. This approach was originally based on certain assumptions: (i) realism (ii) locality and (iii) non-contextuality. In its developed form, the theory involved only probabilities for outcome values of system observables. For systems involving two sub-systems, the hidden variable theory predicted that correlations between measurement outcomes of observable pairs of from different sub-systems would satisfy certain—such as the CHSH Bell inequality. The inequality was inconsistent with quantum theory predictions and with experiment. Hence, the question arose: Which of the three assumptions was invalid? A widely held view is that a non-local theory is needed—another is that hidden variable theory should be contextual. In this article, derivations of the CHSH Bell inequality based on various combinations of locality/non-locality and non-contextuality/contextuality assumptions are outlined, leading to the conclusion that for a hidden variable theory to underpin quantum theory, it must be both non-local and contextual. Non-locality or contextuality alone is insufficient. However, it is also concluded that the realism assumption is questionable. At present an alternative approach of augmenting quantum theory by adding additional features—such as the deterministic trajectories of Bohmian mechanics (also a non-local theory) may be a better route for completeness.

The European Physical Journal Special Topics•Jul 4, 2025•1 citation

Quantum perfect correlations and Hardy's nonlocality theorem

Jose Luis Cereceda

In this paper the failure of Hardy's nonlocality proof for the class of maximally entangled states is considered. A detailed analysis shows that the incompatibility of the Hardy equations for this class of states physically originates from the fact that the existence of quantum perfect correlations for the three pairs of two-valued observables (D_11,D_21), (D_11,D_22) and (D_12,D_21) [in the sense of having with certainty equal (different) readings for a joint measurement of any one of the pairs (D_11,D_21), (D_11,D_22), and (D_12,D_21)], necessarily entails perfect correlation for the pair of observables (D_12,D_22) [in the sense of having with certainty equal (different) readings for a joint measurement of the pair (D_12,D_22)]. Indeed, the set of these four perfect correlations is found to satisfy the CHSH inequality, and then no violations of local realism will arise for the maximally entangled state as far as the four observables D_ij, i,j = 1,2, are concerned. The connection between this fact and the impossibility for the quantum mechanical predictions to give the maximum possible theoretical violation of the CHSH inequality is pointed out. Moreover, it is generally proved that the fulfillment of all the Hardy nonlocality conditions necessarily entails a violation of the resulting CHSH inequality. The largest violation of this latter inequality is determined.

arXiv:quant-ph/9908039•Aug 12, 1999•2 citations

Chain of Hardy-type local reality constraints for n qubits

Sibasish Ghosh A, Shasanka Mohan Roy

Nonlocality without inequality is an elegant argument introduced by Hardy for two qubit systems, and later generalised to n qubits, to establish contradiction of quantum theory with local realism. Interestingly, for n = 2 this argument is actually a corollary of Bell-type inequalities, viz., the CH–Hardy inequality involving Bell correlations, but for n greater than two it involves n-particle probabilities more general than Bell-correlations. In this paper, we first derive a chain of completely new local realistic inequalities involving joint probabilities for n qubits and then associated with each such inequality, we provide a new Hardy-type local reality constraint without inequalities. Quantum mechanical maximal violations of the chain of inequalities and of the associated constraints are also studied by deriving appropriate Cirel'son-type theorems. These results involving joint probabilities more general than Bell correlations are expected to provide a new systematic tool to investigate entanglement.

arXiv:1007.4649•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Dec 1, 2010•4 citations

Hardy’s non-locality in four-qubit state

Urjjarani Patel, K. V. S. Shiv Chaitanya

Hardy’s non-locality provides a proof of the incompatibility between quantum mechanics and local realism without using Bell inequalities. While this argument has been extensively studied for two- and three-qubit systems, a detailed analysis of the four-qubit case is still lacking. In this work, we investigate Hardy’s non-locality for a four-qubit system within the standard two-setting framework. We explicitly construct the entangled state satisfying the Hardy conditions and determine the measurement settings that maximize the success probability. • We present an explicit analytical construction of a four-qubit Hardy state together with the corresponding projective measurement settings. • The maximum Hardy success probability for four qubits is found to be 0.143, exceeding the values obtained in the two- and three-qubit cases. • The resulting state is non-maximally entangled and exhibits genuine multipartite quantum correlations.

Results in Physics•Feb 3, 2026•1 citation

Stronger Hardy-like proof of quantum contextuality

Wen-Rong Qi, Jie Zhou, Ling‐Jun Kong +9 more

A Hardy-like proof of quantum contextuality is a compelling way to see the conflict between quantum theory and noncontextual hidden variables (NCHVs), as the latter predict that a particular probability must be zero, while quantum theory predicts a nonzero value. For the existing Hardy-like proofs, the success probability tends to 1/2 when the number of measurement settings n goes to infinity. It means the conflict between the existing Hardy-like proof and NCHV theory is weak, which is not conducive to experimental observation. Here we advance the study of a stronger Hardy-like proof of quantum contextuality, whose success probability is always higher than the previous ones generated from a certain n -cycle graph. Furthermore, the success probability tends to 1 when n goes to infinity. We perform the experimental test of the Hardy-like proof in the simplest case of n = 7 by using a four-dimensional quantum system encoded in the polarization and orbital angular momentum of single photons. The experimental result agrees with the theoretical prediction within experimental errors. In addition, by starting from our Hardy-like proof, one can establish the stronger noncontextuality inequality, for which the quantum-classical ratio is higher with the same n , which provides a new method to construct some optimal noncontextuality inequalities. Our results offer a way for optimizing and enriching exclusivity graphs, helping to explore more abundant quantum properties.

Photonics Research•May 9, 2022•3 citations
Hardy and Unruh constructed a family of non-maximally entangled states of pairs of particles giving rise to correlations that cannot be accounted for with a local hidden-variable theory. Rather than pointing to violations of some Bell inequality, however, they pointed to apparent clashes with the basic rules of logic. Specifically, they constructed these states and the associated measurement settings in such a way that the outcomes satisfy some conditionals but not an additional one entailed by them. Quantum mechanics avoids the broken ‘if …then …’ arrows in such Hardy–Unruh chains, as we call them, because it cannot simultaneously assign truth values to all conditionals involved. Measurements to determine the truth value of some preclude measurements to determine the truth value of others. Hardy–Unruh chains thus nicely illustrate quantum contextuality: which variables do and do not obtain definite values depends on what measurements we decide to perform. Using a framework inspired by Bub and Pitowsky and developed in our book Understanding Quantum Raffles (co-authored with Michael E. Cuffaro), we construct and analyze Hardy–Unruh chains in terms of fictitious bananas mimicking the behavior of spin-12 particles.
Hardy's paradox is an all-versus-nothing logical contradiction for bipartite quantum systems: three jointly satisfiable conditions on measurement probabilities each force a fourth probability to zero by classical logic, yet quantum mechanics permits that fourth probability to be strictly positive. Unlike Bell inequalities, no statistical averaging is required — the contradiction is exact and logical. This paper presents a five-part numerical study connecting Hardy's paradox to the non-associative geometry of the Fano plane PG(2,2)PG(2,2)PG(2,2) and the octonion associator A(ei,ej,ek)=(eiej)ek−ei(ejek)\mathcal{A}(e_i, e_j, e_k) = (e_i e_j)e_k - e_i(e_j e_k)A(ei​,ej​,ek​)=(ei​ej​)ek​−ei​(ej​ek​). Part 1 finds the Hardy state by constrained optimisation (Nelder-Mead, 100 initialisations), confirming all three zero-conditions to within 10−610^{-6}10−6 and the impossible event P(Z+,Z+)=0.10>0P(Z^+, Z^+) = 0.10 > 0P(Z+,Z+)=0.10>0 with residual ∼10−36\sim 10^{-36}∼10−36. Part 2 shows that the Fano-SYK ground state restricted to the measurement node pair 0,1{0,1}0,1 is entangled, with von Neumann entropy S=0.8762S = 0.8762S=0.8762 ebits, connecting the Fano dynamical structure to the Hardy contextual structure. Part 3 sweeps a one-parameter entangled state family and demonstrates that the Hardy impossible-event probability and the CHSH witness are correlated (Pearson r=0.982r = 0.982r=0.982), both vanishing at the separable limit. Part 4 verifies the full octonion associator table: ∣A(ei,ej,ek)∣=0|\mathcal{A}(e_i,e_j,e_k)| = 0∣A(ei​,ej​,ek​)∣=0 for all 7 Fano lines (associative triples) and ∣A∣=2|\mathcal{A}| = 2∣A∣=2 for all 28 non-Fano triples, exact to <10−14< 10^{-14}<10−14. Part 5 maps the Hardy measurement settings Z,XZ, XZ,X to octonion directions e0,e1e_0, e_1e0​,e1​, which lie on the unique Fano line 0,1,3{0,1,3}0,1,3, and argues that entanglement forces the bipartite system to sample non-Fano directions in R7⊗R7\mathbb{R}^7 \otimes \mathbb{R}^7R7⊗R7 where no consistent classical truth-value assignment exists. The central claim — stated as the Fano-Contextuality Conjecture — is that a measurement triple admits a consistent joint classical value assignment if and only if the corresponding octonion directions lie on a Fano line (∣A∣=0|\mathcal{A}| = 0∣A∣=0). Hardy contextuality is diagnosed as the consequence of entanglement distributing quantum weight into the non-associative region of measurement space. A formal proof connecting this partition to the Kochen-Specker theorem is identified as the primary open problem. This is the first paper in the ASA Quantum Foundations series (Portfolio F), accompanied by the Spacelike Associator Paradox (doi:10.5281/zenodo.20058013) and the Fano Monogamy Paradox (doi:10.5281/zenodo.20058092). Working paper in the Adelic Simplicial Architecture (ASA) series.
Abstract Quantum theory has accounted for a wide range of physical effects in systems ranging from microscopic to macroscopic. However, it is associated with various paradoxes—such as the well-known EPR example. Einstein’s suggestion that the theory was incomplete has led to numerous attempts to underpin quantum theory by a hidden variable theory, including the Bell approach. This approach was originally based on certain assumptions: (i) realism (ii) locality and (iii) non-contextuality. In its developed form, the theory involved only probabilities for outcome values of system observables. For systems involving two sub-systems, the hidden variable theory predicted that correlations between measurement outcomes of observable pairs of from different sub-systems would satisfy certain—such as the CHSH Bell inequality. The inequality was inconsistent with quantum theory predictions and with experiment. Hence, the question arose: Which of the three assumptions was invalid? A widely held view is that a non-local theory is needed—another is that hidden variable theory should be contextual. In this article, derivations of the CHSH Bell inequality based on various combinations of locality/non-locality and non-contextuality/contextuality assumptions are outlined, leading to the conclusion that for a hidden variable theory to underpin quantum theory, it must be both non-local and contextual. Non-locality or contextuality alone is insufficient. However, it is also concluded that the realism assumption is questionable. At present an alternative approach of augmenting quantum theory by adding additional features—such as the deterministic trajectories of Bohmian mechanics (also a non-local theory) may be a better route for completeness.
In this paper the failure of Hardy's nonlocality proof for the class of maximally entangled states is considered. A detailed analysis shows that the incompatibility of the Hardy equations for this class of states physically originates from the fact that the existence of quantum perfect correlations for the three pairs of two-valued observables (D_11,D_21), (D_11,D_22) and (D_12,D_21) [in the sense of having with certainty equal (different) readings for a joint measurement of any one of the pairs (D_11,D_21), (D_11,D_22), and (D_12,D_21)], necessarily entails perfect correlation for the pair of observables (D_12,D_22) [in the sense of having with certainty equal (different) readings for a joint measurement of the pair (D_12,D_22)]. Indeed, the set of these four perfect correlations is found to satisfy the CHSH inequality, and then no violations of local realism will arise for the maximally entangled state as far as the four observables D_ij, i,j = 1,2, are concerned. The connection between this fact and the impossibility for the quantum mechanical predictions to give the maximum possible theoretical violation of the CHSH inequality is pointed out. Moreover, it is generally proved that the fulfillment of all the Hardy nonlocality conditions necessarily entails a violation of the resulting CHSH inequality. The largest violation of this latter inequality is determined.
Nonlocality without inequality is an elegant argument introduced by Hardy for two qubit systems, and later generalised to n qubits, to establish contradiction of quantum theory with local realism. Interestingly, for n = 2 this argument is actually a corollary of Bell-type inequalities, viz., the CH–Hardy inequality involving Bell correlations, but for n greater than two it involves n-particle probabilities more general than Bell-correlations. In this paper, we first derive a chain of completely new local realistic inequalities involving joint probabilities for n qubits and then associated with each such inequality, we provide a new Hardy-type local reality constraint without inequalities. Quantum mechanical maximal violations of the chain of inequalities and of the associated constraints are also studied by deriving appropriate Cirel'son-type theorems. These results involving joint probabilities more general than Bell correlations are expected to provide a new systematic tool to investigate entanglement.
Hardy’s non-locality provides a proof of the incompatibility between quantum mechanics and local realism without using Bell inequalities. While this argument has been extensively studied for two- and three-qubit systems, a detailed analysis of the four-qubit case is still lacking. In this work, we investigate Hardy’s non-locality for a four-qubit system within the standard two-setting framework. We explicitly construct the entangled state satisfying the Hardy conditions and determine the measurement settings that maximize the success probability. • We present an explicit analytical construction of a four-qubit Hardy state together with the corresponding projective measurement settings. • The maximum Hardy success probability for four qubits is found to be 0.143, exceeding the values obtained in the two- and three-qubit cases. • The resulting state is non-maximally entangled and exhibits genuine multipartite quantum correlations.
A Hardy-like proof of quantum contextuality is a compelling way to see the conflict between quantum theory and noncontextual hidden variables (NCHVs), as the latter predict that a particular probability must be zero, while quantum theory predicts a nonzero value. For the existing Hardy-like proofs, the success probability tends to 1/2 when the number of measurement settings n goes to infinity. It means the conflict between the existing Hardy-like proof and NCHV theory is weak, which is not conducive to experimental observation. Here we advance the study of a stronger Hardy-like proof of quantum contextuality, whose success probability is always higher than the previous ones generated from a certain n -cycle graph. Furthermore, the success probability tends to 1 when n goes to infinity. We perform the experimental test of the Hardy-like proof in the simplest case of n = 7 by using a four-dimensional quantum system encoded in the polarization and orbital angular momentum of single photons. The experimental result agrees with the theoretical prediction within experimental errors. In addition, by starting from our Hardy-like proof, one can establish the stronger noncontextuality inequality, for which the quantum-classical ratio is higher with the same n , which provides a new method to construct some optimal noncontextuality inequalities. Our results offer a way for optimizing and enriching exclusivity graphs, helping to explore more abundant quantum properties.