Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2308.13607 · PRX Quantum

Quantum-Informed Recursive Optimization Algorithms

Jernej Rudi Finžgar, Aron Kerschbaumer, Martin J. A. Schuetz, Christian B. Mendl, Helmut G. Katzgraber

Published May 3, 2024• 39 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We propose and implement a family of quantum-informed recursive optimization (QIRO) algorithms for combinatorial optimization problems. Our approach leverages quantum resources to obtain information that is used in problem-specific classical reduction steps that recursively simplify the problem. These reduction steps address the limitations of the quantum component (e.g., locality) and ensure solution feasibility in constrained optimization problems. Additionally, we use backtracking techniques to further improve the performance of the algorithm without increasing the requirements on the quantum hardware. We showcase the capabilities of our approach by informing QIRO with correlations from classical simulations of shallow circuits of the quantum approximate optimization algorithm, solving instances of maximum independent set and maximum satisfiability problems with hundreds of variables. We also demonstrate how QIRO can be deployed on a neutral atom quantum processor to find large independent sets of graphs. In summary, our scheme achieves results comparable to classical heuristics even with relatively weak quantum resources. Furthermore, enhancing the quality of these quantum resources improves the performance of the algorithms. Notably, the modular nature of QIRO offers various avenues for modifications, positioning our work as a template for a broader class of hybrid quantum-classical algorithms for combinatorial optimization. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

DOI
10.1103/prxquantum.5.020327

Related papers

Iterative quantum algorithms for maximum independent set

Lucas T. Brady, Stuart Hadfield

Quantum algorithms have been widely studied in the context of combinatorial optimization problems. While this endeavor can often analytically and practically achieve quadratic speedups, theoretical and numeric studies remain limited, especially compared to the study of classical algorithms. We propose and study an alternative class of hybrid approaches to quantum optimization, termed iterative quantum algorithms, which in particular generalizes the recursive quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA). This paradigm can incorporate hard problem constraints, which we demonstrate by considering the maximum independent set (MIS) problem. We show that, for QAOA with $p=1$ circuit layers, this algorithm performs exactly the same operations and selections as the classical greedy algorithm for MIS. We then turn to deeper $p>1$ circuits and other ways to modify the quantum algorithm that can no longer be easily mimicked by classical algorithms, and empirically confirm improved performance. Our work demonstrates the practical importance of incorporating proven classical techniques into more effective hybrid quantum-classical algorithms.

Physical Review A•Nov 25, 2024•12 citations

Iterative Quantum Algorithms for Maximum Independent Set: A Tale of Low-Depth Quantum Algorithms

Lucas T. Brady, Stuart Hadfield

Quantum algorithms have been widely studied in the context of combinatorial optimization problems. While this endeavor can often analytically and practically achieve quadratic speedups, theoretical and numeric studies remain limited, especially compared to the study of classical algorithms. We propose and study a new class of hybrid approaches to quantum optimization, termed Iterative Quantum Algorithms, which in particular generalizes the Recursive Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm. This paradigm can incorporate hard problem constraints, which we demonstrate by considering the Maximum Independent Set (MIS) problem. We show that, for QAOA with depth $p=1$, this algorithm performs exactly the same operations and selections as the classical greedy algorithm for MIS. We then turn to deeper $p>1$ circuits and other ways to modify the quantum algorithm that can no longer be easily mimicked by classical algorithms, and empirically confirm improved performance. Our work demonstrates the practical importance of incorporating proven classical techniques into more effective hybrid quantum-classical algorithms.

arXiv:2309.13110•Sep 22, 2023•4 citations

On the Use of the Quantum Alternating Operator Ansatz in Quantum-Informed Recursive Optimization: A Case Study on the Minimum Vertex Cover

Pablo Ramos-Ruiz, Antonio Miguel Fuentes-Jiménez, José E. Ramos-Ruíz +1 more

In recent years, several quantum algorithms have been proposed for addressing combinatorial optimization problems. Among them, the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) has become a widely used approach. However, reported limitations of QAOA have motivated the development of multiple algorithmic variants, including recursive hybrid methods such as the Recursive Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (RQAOA), as well as the Quantum-Informed Recursive Optimization (QIRO) framework. In this work, we integrate the Quantum Alternating Operator Ansatz within the QIRO framework in order to improve its quantum inference stage. Both the original and the enhanced versions of QIRO are applied to the Minimum Vertex Cover problem, an NP-complete problem of practical relevance. Performance is evaluated on a benchmark of Erdös-Rényi graph instances with varying sizes, densities, and random seeds. The results show that the proposed modification leads to a higher number of successfully solved instances across the considered benchmark, indicating that refinements of the variational layer can improve the effectiveness of the QIRO framework.

AppliedMath•Feb 6, 2026•0 citations

Solving Nonnative Combinatorial Optimization Problems Using Hybrid Quantum–Classical Algorithms

Jonathan Wurtz, Stefan H. Sack, Sheng-Tao Wang

Combinatorial optimization is a challenging problem applicable in a wide range of fields from logistics to finance. Recently, quantum computing has been used to attempt to solve these problems using a range of algorithms, including parameterized quantum circuits, adiabatic protocols, and quantum annealing. These solutions typically have several challenges: 1) there is little to no performance gain over classical methods; 2) not all constraints and objectives may be efficiently encoded in the quantum ansatz; and 3) the solution domain of the objective function may not be the same as the bit strings of measurement outcomes. This work presents “nonnative hybrid algorithms”: a framework to overcome these challenges by integrating quantum and classical resources with a hybrid approach. By designing nonnative quantum variational anosatzes that inherit some but not all problem structure, measurement outcomes from the quantum computer can act as a resource to be used by classical routines to indirectly compute optimal solutions, partially overcoming the challenges of contemporary quantum optimization approaches. These methods are demonstrated using a publicly available neutral-atom quantum computer on two simple problems of Max$k$-Cut and maximum independent set. We find improvements in solution quality when comparing the hybrid algorithm to its “no quantum” version, a demonstration of a “comparative advantage.”

arXiv:2403.03153•IEEE Transactions on Quantum Engineering•Jan 1, 2024•16 citations

Quantum and classical correlations in shrinking algorithms for optimization

Victor Araujo Figueredo Fischer, Maximilian Passek, Friedrich Wagner +3 more

Understanding the benefits of quantum computing for solving combinatorial optimization problems (COPs) remains an open research question. In this work, we extend and analyze algorithms that solve COPs by recursively shrinking them. The algorithms leverage correlations between variables extracted from quantum or classical subroutines to recursively simplify the problem. We compare the performance of the algorithms equipped with correlations from the quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA) as well as the classical linear programming (LP) and semi-definite programming (SDP) relaxations. This allows us to benchmark the utility of QAOA correlations against established classical relaxation algorithms. We apply the recursive algorithm to MaxCut problem instances with up to a hundred vertices at different graph densities. Our results indicate that LP outperforms all other approaches for low-density instances, while SDP excels for high-density problems. Moreover, the shrinking algorithm proves to be a viable alternative to established methods of rounding LP and SDP relaxations. In addition, the recursive shrinking algorithm outperforms its bare counterparts for all three types of correlations, i.e., LP with spanning tree rounding, the Goemans-Williamson algorithm, and conventional QAOA. While the lowest depth QAOA consistently yields worse results than the SDP, our tensor network experiments show that the performance increases significantly for deeper QAOA circuits.

arXiv:2404.17242•Apr 26, 2024•0 citations

A scalable quantum-enhanced greedy algorithm for maximum independent set problems

Elisabeth Wybo, Jami Rönkkö, Olli Hirviniemi +2 more

We investigate a hybrid quantum-classical algorithm for solving the Maximum Independent Set (MIS) problem on regular graphs, combining the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) with a minimal degree classical greedy algorithm. The method leverages pre-computed QAOA angles, derived from depth-$p$ QAOA circuits on regular trees, to compute local expectation values and inform sequential greedy decisions that progressively build an independent set. This hybrid approach maintains shallow quantum circuit and avoids instance-specific parameter training, making it well-suited for implementation on current quantum hardware: we have implemented the algorithm on a 20 qubit IQM superconducting device to find independent sets in graphs with thousands of nodes. We perform tensor network simulations to evaluate the performance of the algorithm beyond the reach of current quantum hardware and compare to established classical heuristics. Our results show that even at low depth ($p=4$), the quantum-enhanced greedy method significantly outperforms purely classical greedy baselines as well as more sophisticated approximation algorithms. The modular structure of the algorithm and relatively low quantum resource requirements make it a compelling candidate for scalable, hybrid optimization in the NISQ era and beyond.

quant-pharXiv:2601.21923•Jan 30, 2026•0 citations
We propose and implement a family of quantum-informed recursive optimization (QIRO) algorithms for combinatorial optimization problems. Our approach leverages quantum resources to obtain information that is used in problem-specific classical reduction steps that recursively simplify the problem. These reduction steps address the limitations of the quantum component (e.g., locality) and ensure solution feasibility in constrained optimization problems. Additionally, we use backtracking techniques to further improve the performance of the algorithm without increasing the requirements on the quantum hardware. We showcase the capabilities of our approach by informing QIRO with correlations from classical simulations of shallow circuits of the quantum approximate optimization algorithm, solving instances of maximum independent set and maximum satisfiability problems with hundreds of variables. We also demonstrate how QIRO can be deployed on a neutral atom quantum processor to find large independent sets of graphs. In summary, our scheme achieves results comparable to classical heuristics even with relatively weak quantum resources. Furthermore, enhancing the quality of these quantum resources improves the performance of the algorithms. Notably, the modular nature of QIRO offers various avenues for modifications, positioning our work as a template for a broader class of hybrid quantum-classical algorithms for combinatorial optimization. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
Quantum algorithms have been widely studied in the context of combinatorial optimization problems. While this endeavor can often analytically and practically achieve quadratic speedups, theoretical and numeric studies remain limited, especially compared to the study of classical algorithms. We propose and study an alternative class of hybrid approaches to quantum optimization, termed iterative quantum algorithms, which in particular generalizes the recursive quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA). This paradigm can incorporate hard problem constraints, which we demonstrate by considering the maximum independent set (MIS) problem. We show that, for QAOA with p=1p=1p=1 circuit layers, this algorithm performs exactly the same operations and selections as the classical greedy algorithm for MIS. We then turn to deeper p>1p>1p>1 circuits and other ways to modify the quantum algorithm that can no longer be easily mimicked by classical algorithms, and empirically confirm improved performance. Our work demonstrates the practical importance of incorporating proven classical techniques into more effective hybrid quantum-classical algorithms.
Quantum algorithms have been widely studied in the context of combinatorial optimization problems. While this endeavor can often analytically and practically achieve quadratic speedups, theoretical and numeric studies remain limited, especially compared to the study of classical algorithms. We propose and study a new class of hybrid approaches to quantum optimization, termed Iterative Quantum Algorithms, which in particular generalizes the Recursive Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm. This paradigm can incorporate hard problem constraints, which we demonstrate by considering the Maximum Independent Set (MIS) problem. We show that, for QAOA with depth p=1p=1p=1, this algorithm performs exactly the same operations and selections as the classical greedy algorithm for MIS. We then turn to deeper p>1p>1p>1 circuits and other ways to modify the quantum algorithm that can no longer be easily mimicked by classical algorithms, and empirically confirm improved performance. Our work demonstrates the practical importance of incorporating proven classical techniques into more effective hybrid quantum-classical algorithms.
In recent years, several quantum algorithms have been proposed for addressing combinatorial optimization problems. Among them, the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) has become a widely used approach. However, reported limitations of QAOA have motivated the development of multiple algorithmic variants, including recursive hybrid methods such as the Recursive Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (RQAOA), as well as the Quantum-Informed Recursive Optimization (QIRO) framework. In this work, we integrate the Quantum Alternating Operator Ansatz within the QIRO framework in order to improve its quantum inference stage. Both the original and the enhanced versions of QIRO are applied to the Minimum Vertex Cover problem, an NP-complete problem of practical relevance. Performance is evaluated on a benchmark of Erdös-Rényi graph instances with varying sizes, densities, and random seeds. The results show that the proposed modification leads to a higher number of successfully solved instances across the considered benchmark, indicating that refinements of the variational layer can improve the effectiveness of the QIRO framework.
Combinatorial optimization is a challenging problem applicable in a wide range of fields from logistics to finance. Recently, quantum computing has been used to attempt to solve these problems using a range of algorithms, including parameterized quantum circuits, adiabatic protocols, and quantum annealing. These solutions typically have several challenges: 1) there is little to no performance gain over classical methods; 2) not all constraints and objectives may be efficiently encoded in the quantum ansatz; and 3) the solution domain of the objective function may not be the same as the bit strings of measurement outcomes. This work presents “nonnative hybrid algorithms”: a framework to overcome these challenges by integrating quantum and classical resources with a hybrid approach. By designing nonnative quantum variational anosatzes that inherit some but not all problem structure, measurement outcomes from the quantum computer can act as a resource to be used by classical routines to indirectly compute optimal solutions, partially overcoming the challenges of contemporary quantum optimization approaches. These methods are demonstrated using a publicly available neutral-atom quantum computer on two simple problems of Maxkkk-Cut and maximum independent set. We find improvements in solution quality when comparing the hybrid algorithm to its “no quantum” version, a demonstration of a “comparative advantage.”
Understanding the benefits of quantum computing for solving combinatorial optimization problems (COPs) remains an open research question. In this work, we extend and analyze algorithms that solve COPs by recursively shrinking them. The algorithms leverage correlations between variables extracted from quantum or classical subroutines to recursively simplify the problem. We compare the performance of the algorithms equipped with correlations from the quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA) as well as the classical linear programming (LP) and semi-definite programming (SDP) relaxations. This allows us to benchmark the utility of QAOA correlations against established classical relaxation algorithms. We apply the recursive algorithm to MaxCut problem instances with up to a hundred vertices at different graph densities. Our results indicate that LP outperforms all other approaches for low-density instances, while SDP excels for high-density problems. Moreover, the shrinking algorithm proves to be a viable alternative to established methods of rounding LP and SDP relaxations. In addition, the recursive shrinking algorithm outperforms its bare counterparts for all three types of correlations, i.e., LP with spanning tree rounding, the Goemans-Williamson algorithm, and conventional QAOA. While the lowest depth QAOA consistently yields worse results than the SDP, our tensor network experiments show that the performance increases significantly for deeper QAOA circuits.
We investigate a hybrid quantum-classical algorithm for solving the Maximum Independent Set (MIS) problem on regular graphs, combining the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) with a minimal degree classical greedy algorithm. The method leverages pre-computed QAOA angles, derived from depth-ppp QAOA circuits on regular trees, to compute local expectation values and inform sequential greedy decisions that progressively build an independent set. This hybrid approach maintains shallow quantum circuit and avoids instance-specific parameter training, making it well-suited for implementation on current quantum hardware: we have implemented the algorithm on a 20 qubit IQM superconducting device to find independent sets in graphs with thousands of nodes. We perform tensor network simulations to evaluate the performance of the algorithm beyond the reach of current quantum hardware and compare to established classical heuristics. Our results show that even at low depth (p=4p=4p=4), the quantum-enhanced greedy method significantly outperforms purely classical greedy baselines as well as more sophisticated approximation algorithms. The modular structure of the algorithm and relatively low quantum resource requirements make it a compelling candidate for scalable, hybrid optimization in the NISQ era and beyond.