Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2308.06336

A bundle perspective on contextuality: Empirical models and simplicial distributions on bundle scenarios

Rui Soares Barbosa, Aziz Kharoof, Cihan Okay

Published Aug 11, 2023• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

This paper provides a bundle perspective to contextuality by introducing new categories of contextuality scenarios based on bundles of simplicial complexes and simplicial sets. The former approach generalizes earlier work on the sheaf-theoretic perspective on contextuality, and the latter extends simplicial distributions, a more recent approach to contextuality formulated in the language of simplicial sets. After constructing our bundle categories, we also construct functors that relate them and natural isomorphisms that allow us to compare the notions of contextuality formulated in two languages. We are motivated by applications to the resource theory of contextuality, captured by the morphisms in these categories. In this paper, we develop the main formalism and leave applications to future work.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2308.06336

Related papers

Simplicial methods in the resource theory of contextuality

Aziz Kharoof, Cihan Okay

We develop a resource theory of contextuality within the framework of symmetric monoidal categories, extending recent simplicial approaches to quantum contextuality. Building on the theory of simplicial distributions, which integrates homotopy-theoretic structures with probability, we introduce event scenarios as a functorial generalization of presheaf-theoretic measurement scenarios and prove their equivalence to bundle scenarios via the Grothendieck construction. We define symmetric monoidal structures on these categories and extend the distribution functor to a stochastic setting, yielding a resource theory that generalizes the presheaf-theoretic notion of simulations. Our main result characterizes convex maps between simplicial distributions in terms of non-contextual distributions on a corresponding mapping scenario, enhancing and extending prior results in categorical quantum foundations.

arXiv:2505.24010•May 29, 2025•0 citations

Categories of Empirical Models

Martti Karvonen

A notion of morphism that is suitable for the sheaf-theoretic approach to contextuality is developed, resulting in a resource theory for contextuality. The key features involve using an underlying relation rather than a function between measurement scenarios, and allowing for stochastic mappings of outcomes to outcomes. This formalizes an intuitive idea of using one empirical model to simulate another one with the help of pre-shared classical randomness. This allows one to reinterpret concepts and earlier results in terms of morphisms. Most notably: non-contextual models are precisely those allowing a morphism from the terminal object; contextual fraction is functorial; Graham-reductions induce morphisms, reinterpreting Vorob'evs theorem; contextual models cannot be cloned.

arXiv:1804.01514•Electronic Proceedings in Theoretical Computer Science•Jan 31, 2019•11 citations

Contextuality in the Bundle Approach, n-Contextuality, and the Role of Holonomy

Sidiney Bruno Montanhano

Contextuality can be understood as the impossibility to construct a globally consistent description of a model even if there is local agreement. In particular, quantum models present this property. We can describe contextuality with the bundle approach, where the scenario is represented as a simplicial complex, the fibers being the sets of outcomes, and contextuality as the non-existence of global section in the measure bundle. Using the generalization to non-finite outcome fibers, we built in details the concept of measure bundle, demonstrating the Fine-Abramsky-Brandenburger theorem for the bundle formalism. We introduce a hierarchy called n-contextuality to explore the dependence of contextual behavior of a model to the topology of the scenario, following the construction of it as a simplicial complex. With it we exemplify the dependence on higher homology groups and show that GHZ models, thus quantum theory, has all levels of the hierarchy. Also, we give an example of how non-trivial topology of the scenario result an increase of contextual behavior. For the first level of the hierarchy, we construct the concept of connection through Markov operators for the measure bundle. Taking the case of equal fibers we can identify the outcomes as the basis of a vector space, that transform according to a group extracted from the connection. We thus show that contextuality has a relationship with the non-triviality of the holonomy group in the respective frame bundle.

arXiv:2105.14132•May 28, 2021•2 citations

Simplicial quantum contextuality

Cihan Okay, Aziz Kharoof, Selman Ipek

We introduce a new framework for contextuality based on simplicial sets, combinatorial models of topological spaces that play a prominent role in modern homotopy theory. Our approach extends measurement scenarios to consist of spaces (rather than sets) of measurements and outcomes, and thereby generalizes nonsignaling distributions to simplicial distributions, which are distributions on spaces modeled by simplicial sets. Using this formalism we present a topologically inspired new proof of Fine's theorem for characterizing noncontextuality in Bell scenarios. Strong contextuality is generalized suitably for simplicial distributions, allowing us to define cohomological witnesses that extend the earlier topological constructions restricted to algebraic relations among quantum observables to the level of probability distributions. Foundational theorems of quantum theory such as the Gleason's theorem and Kochen--Specker theorem can be expressed naturally within this new language.

arXiv:2204.06648•Quantum•May 22, 2023•10 citations

Possibilistic collapse and extremality of simplicial distributions

Aziz Kharoof, Cihan Okay

Consistent families of locally defined probability distributions that do not admit a joint global distribution are known as contextual, with primary examples arising in quantum theory. In this paper, we study such families of distributions using the theory of simplicial distributions, and further develop the theory for possibilistic distributions defined over the Boolean semiring. We characterize possibilistic collapses of simplicial distributions geometrically using bundle scenarios. Using this characterization together with a new connectivity condition on the total space of a bundle scenario, we provide a criterion for detecting extremal simplicial distributions. In parallel, we develop an analogous theory for presheaves on simplicial complexes, describe possibilistic collapses of empirical models on them using event scenarios together with a categorical extremality condition, and relate the two frameworks via a comparison result. We provide examples of contextual simplicial distributions that arise from our criteria on scenarios of interest in quantum foundations, such as Bell scenarios and boundaries of standard simplices, the latter connecting to Vorob'ev's classical theorem on acyclic complexes.

math.CTCross-listedarXiv:2607.02754•Jul 6, 2026•0 citations

Simplicial distributions, convex categories, and contextuality

Aziz Kharoof, Cihan Okay

The data of a physical experiment can be represented as a presheaf of probability distributions.A striking feature of quantum theory is that those probability distributions obtained in quantum mechanical experiments do not always admit a joint probability distribution, a celebrated observation due to Bell.Such distributions are called contextual.Simplicial distributions are combinatorial models that extend presheaves of probability distributions by elevating sets of measurements and outcomes to spaces.Contextuality can be defined in this generalized setting.This paper introduces the notion of convex categories to study simplicial distributions from a categorical perspective.Simplicial distributions can be given the structure of a convex monoid, a convex category with a single object, when the outcome space has the structure of a group.We describe contextuality as a monoid-theoretic notion by introducing a weak version of invertibility for monoids.Our main result is that a simplicial distribution is noncontextual if and only if it is weakly invertible.Similarly, strong contextuality and contextual fraction can be characterized in terms of invertibility in monoids.Finally, we show that simplicial homotopy can be used to detect extremal simplicial distributions refining the earlier methods based on Čech cohomology and the cohomology of groups.The authors would like to thank the anonymous referee for useful comments that significantly improved the exposition of the paper, and Walker H. Stern and Redi Haderi for enlightening discussions.

arXiv:2211.00571•Theory and applications of categories•Jan 1, 2025•2 citations
This paper provides a bundle perspective to contextuality by introducing new categories of contextuality scenarios based on bundles of simplicial complexes and simplicial sets. The former approach generalizes earlier work on the sheaf-theoretic perspective on contextuality, and the latter extends simplicial distributions, a more recent approach to contextuality formulated in the language of simplicial sets. After constructing our bundle categories, we also construct functors that relate them and natural isomorphisms that allow us to compare the notions of contextuality formulated in two languages. We are motivated by applications to the resource theory of contextuality, captured by the morphisms in these categories. In this paper, we develop the main formalism and leave applications to future work.
We develop a resource theory of contextuality within the framework of symmetric monoidal categories, extending recent simplicial approaches to quantum contextuality. Building on the theory of simplicial distributions, which integrates homotopy-theoretic structures with probability, we introduce event scenarios as a functorial generalization of presheaf-theoretic measurement scenarios and prove their equivalence to bundle scenarios via the Grothendieck construction. We define symmetric monoidal structures on these categories and extend the distribution functor to a stochastic setting, yielding a resource theory that generalizes the presheaf-theoretic notion of simulations. Our main result characterizes convex maps between simplicial distributions in terms of non-contextual distributions on a corresponding mapping scenario, enhancing and extending prior results in categorical quantum foundations.
A notion of morphism that is suitable for the sheaf-theoretic approach to contextuality is developed, resulting in a resource theory for contextuality. The key features involve using an underlying relation rather than a function between measurement scenarios, and allowing for stochastic mappings of outcomes to outcomes. This formalizes an intuitive idea of using one empirical model to simulate another one with the help of pre-shared classical randomness. This allows one to reinterpret concepts and earlier results in terms of morphisms. Most notably: non-contextual models are precisely those allowing a morphism from the terminal object; contextual fraction is functorial; Graham-reductions induce morphisms, reinterpreting Vorob'evs theorem; contextual models cannot be cloned.
Contextuality can be understood as the impossibility to construct a globally consistent description of a model even if there is local agreement. In particular, quantum models present this property. We can describe contextuality with the bundle approach, where the scenario is represented as a simplicial complex, the fibers being the sets of outcomes, and contextuality as the non-existence of global section in the measure bundle. Using the generalization to non-finite outcome fibers, we built in details the concept of measure bundle, demonstrating the Fine-Abramsky-Brandenburger theorem for the bundle formalism. We introduce a hierarchy called n-contextuality to explore the dependence of contextual behavior of a model to the topology of the scenario, following the construction of it as a simplicial complex. With it we exemplify the dependence on higher homology groups and show that GHZ models, thus quantum theory, has all levels of the hierarchy. Also, we give an example of how non-trivial topology of the scenario result an increase of contextual behavior. For the first level of the hierarchy, we construct the concept of connection through Markov operators for the measure bundle. Taking the case of equal fibers we can identify the outcomes as the basis of a vector space, that transform according to a group extracted from the connection. We thus show that contextuality has a relationship with the non-triviality of the holonomy group in the respective frame bundle.
We introduce a new framework for contextuality based on simplicial sets, combinatorial models of topological spaces that play a prominent role in modern homotopy theory. Our approach extends measurement scenarios to consist of spaces (rather than sets) of measurements and outcomes, and thereby generalizes nonsignaling distributions to simplicial distributions, which are distributions on spaces modeled by simplicial sets. Using this formalism we present a topologically inspired new proof of Fine's theorem for characterizing noncontextuality in Bell scenarios. Strong contextuality is generalized suitably for simplicial distributions, allowing us to define cohomological witnesses that extend the earlier topological constructions restricted to algebraic relations among quantum observables to the level of probability distributions. Foundational theorems of quantum theory such as the Gleason's theorem and Kochen--Specker theorem can be expressed naturally within this new language.
Consistent families of locally defined probability distributions that do not admit a joint global distribution are known as contextual, with primary examples arising in quantum theory. In this paper, we study such families of distributions using the theory of simplicial distributions, and further develop the theory for possibilistic distributions defined over the Boolean semiring. We characterize possibilistic collapses of simplicial distributions geometrically using bundle scenarios. Using this characterization together with a new connectivity condition on the total space of a bundle scenario, we provide a criterion for detecting extremal simplicial distributions. In parallel, we develop an analogous theory for presheaves on simplicial complexes, describe possibilistic collapses of empirical models on them using event scenarios together with a categorical extremality condition, and relate the two frameworks via a comparison result. We provide examples of contextual simplicial distributions that arise from our criteria on scenarios of interest in quantum foundations, such as Bell scenarios and boundaries of standard simplices, the latter connecting to Vorob'ev's classical theorem on acyclic complexes.
The data of a physical experiment can be represented as a presheaf of probability distributions.A striking feature of quantum theory is that those probability distributions obtained in quantum mechanical experiments do not always admit a joint probability distribution, a celebrated observation due to Bell.Such distributions are called contextual.Simplicial distributions are combinatorial models that extend presheaves of probability distributions by elevating sets of measurements and outcomes to spaces.Contextuality can be defined in this generalized setting.This paper introduces the notion of convex categories to study simplicial distributions from a categorical perspective.Simplicial distributions can be given the structure of a convex monoid, a convex category with a single object, when the outcome space has the structure of a group.We describe contextuality as a monoid-theoretic notion by introducing a weak version of invertibility for monoids.Our main result is that a simplicial distribution is noncontextual if and only if it is weakly invertible.Similarly, strong contextuality and contextual fraction can be characterized in terms of invertibility in monoids.Finally, we show that simplicial homotopy can be used to detect extremal simplicial distributions refining the earlier methods based on Čech cohomology and the cohomology of groups.The authors would like to thank the anonymous referee for useful comments that significantly improved the exposition of the paper, and Walker H. Stern and Redi Haderi for enlightening discussions.