Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2308.05594 · Open Research Europe

Threshold studies for a hot beam superradiant laser including an atomic guiding potential

Martin Fasser, Christoph Hotter, David Plankensteiner, Helmut Ritsch

Published Jan 8, 2024• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Motivated by the outstanding short time stability and reliable continuous operation properties of microwave clock masers, intense worldwide efforts target the first implementation of their optical analogues based on narrow optical clock transitions and using laser cooled dilute atomic gases. While as a central line of research large efforts are devoted to create a suitably dense continuous ultracold and optically inverted atom beam source, recent theoretical predictions hint at an alternative implementation using a filtered thermal beam at much higher density. Corresponding numerical studies give encouraging results but the required very high densities are sensitive to beam collimation errors and inhomogeneous shifts. Here we present extensive numerical studies of threshold conditions and the predicted output power of such a superradiant laser involving realistic particle numbers and velocities along the cavity axis. Detailed studies target the threshold scaling as a function of temperature as well as the influence of eliminating the hottest part of the atomic distribution via velocity filtering and the benefits of additional atomic beam guiding. Using a cumulant expansion approach allows us to quantify the significance of atom-atom and atom-field correlations in such configurations. We predict necessary conditions to achieve a certain threshold photon number depending on the atomic temperature and density. In particular, we show that the temperature threshold can be significantly increased by using more atoms. Interestingly, a velocity filter removing very fast atoms has only almost negligible influence despite their phase perturbing properties. On the positive side an additional conservative optical guiding towards cavity mode antinodes leads to significantly lower threshold and higher average photon number. Interestingly we see that higher order atom-field and direct atom-atom quantum correlations play only a minor role in the laser dynamics, which is a bit surprising in the superradiant regime.

DOI
10.12688/openreseurope.16506.1

Related papers

A superradiant two-level laser with intrinsic light force generated gain

Anna A. Bychek, Helmut Ritsch

Abstract The implementation of a superradiant laser as an active frequency standard is predicted to provide better short-term stability and robustness to thermal and mechanical fluctuations when compared to standard passive optical clocks. However, despite significant recent progress, the experimental realization of continuous wave superradiant lasing still remains an open challenge as it requires continuous loading, cooling, and pumping of active atoms within an optical resonator. Here we propose a new scenario for creating continuous gain by using optical forces acting on the states of a two-level atom via bichromatic coherent pumping of a cold atomic gas trapped inside a single-mode cavity. Analogous to atomic maser setups, tailored state-dependent forces are used to gather and concentrate excited-state atoms in regions of strong atom-cavity coupling while ground-state atoms are repelled. To facilitate numerical simulations of a sufficiently large atomic ensemble, we rely on a second-order cumulant expansion and describe the atomic motion in a semi-classical point-particle approximation subject to position-dependent light shifts which induce optical gradient forces along the cavity axis. We study minimal conditions on pump laser intensities and detunings required for collective superradiant emission. Balancing Doppler cooling and gain-induced heating we identify a parameter regime of a continuous narrow-band laser operation close to the bare atomic frequency.

arXiv:2304.13190•New Journal of Physics•Oct 26, 2023•2 citations

Superradiant lasing in inhomogeneously broadened ensembles with spatially varying coupling

Anna A. Bychek, Christoph Hotter, David Plankensteiner +1 more

Background: Theoretical studies of superradiant lasing on optical clock transitions predict a superb frequency accuracy and precision closely tied to the bare atomic linewidth. Such a superradiant laser is also robust against cavity fluctuations when the spectral width of the lasing mode is much larger than that of the atomic medium. Recent predictions suggest that this unique feature persists even for a hot and thus strongly broadened ensemble, provided the effective atom number is large enough. Methods: Here we use a second-order cumulant expansion approach to study the power, linewidth and lineshifts of such a superradiant laser as a function of the inhomogeneous width of the ensemble including variations of the spatial atom-field coupling within the resonator. Results: We present conditions on the atom numbers, the pump and coupling strengths required to reach the buildup of collective atomic coherence as well as scaling and limitations for the achievable laser linewidth. Conclusions: We show how sufficiently large numbers of atoms subject to strong optical pumping can induce synchronization of the atomic dipoles over a large bandwidth. This generates collective stimulated emission of light into the cavity mode leading to narrow-band laser emission at the average of the atomic frequency distribution. The linewidth is orders of magnitudes smaller than that of the cavity as well as the inhomogeneous gain broadening and exhibits reduced sensitivity to cavity frequency noise.

arXiv:2105.11023•Open Research Europe•Jun 25, 2021•18 citations

Prospects of a superradiant laser based on a thermal or guided beam of Sr 88

Mikkel Tang, Stefan Alaric Schäffer, Jörg Helge Müller

The prospects of superradiant lasing on the 7.5-kHz-wide $^{1}S_{0}\text{\ensuremath{-}}^{3}P_{1}$ transition in $^{88}\mathrm{Sr}$ is explored by using numerical simulations of two systems based on realistic experimental numbers. One system uses the idea of demonstrating continuous superradiance in a simple, hot atom beam with high flux, and the other system is based on using ultracold atoms in a dipole guide. For the hot-beam system we consider a range of atom beam parameters as well as the impact of a scheme to discard fast atoms along the cavity axis. We find that the system achieves lasing above a flux of $2.5\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{12}$ atoms/s and that it is capable of outputting hundreds of nanowatts and suppressing cavity noise by a factor of 20--30. The relativistic transverse Doppler shifts cause a shift in the lasing frequency on the order of 500 Hz. For the cold-atom beam we account for decoherence and thermal effects when using a repumping scheme for atoms confined in a dipole guide. This is done by treating recoils and state-dependent forces acting on atoms in the dipole guide within the framework of the stochastic master equation. We find that the output power is on the order of hundreds of picowatts; however, transverse Doppler shifts can be neglected, and cavity noise can be suppressed on the order of a factor of 50--100. Additionally, we show that both systems exhibit local insensitivity to fluctuations in atomic flux.

arXiv:2112.15420•Physical Review A•Dec 9, 2022•11 citations

Superradiant cooling, trapping, and lasing of dipole-interacting clock atoms

Christoph Hotter, David Plankensteiner, Laurin Ostermann +1 more

A cold atomic gas with an inverted population on a transition coupled to a field mode of an optical resonator constitutes a generic model of a laser. For quasi-continuous operation, external pumping, trapping and cooling of the atoms is required to confine them in order to achieve enough gain inside the resonator. As inverted atoms are high-field seekers in blue detuned light fields, tuning the cavity mode to the blue side of the atomic gain transition allows for combining lasing with stimulated cavity cooling and dipole trapping of the atoms at the antinodes of the laser field. We study such a configuration using a semiclassical description of particle motion along the cavity axis. In extension of earlier work we include free space atomic and cavity decay as well as atomic dipole-dipole interactions and their corresponding forces. We show that for a proper choice of parameters even in the bad cavity limit the atoms can create a sufficiently strong field inside the resonator such that they are trapped and cooled via the superradiant lasing action with less than one photon on average inside the cavity.

arXiv:1906.01945•Optics Express•Oct 14, 2019•22 citations

Superradiant Cooling, Trapping and Lasing of Dipole-Interacting Clock Atoms

Christoph Hotter

A cold atomic gas with an inverted population on a transition coupled to a field mode of an optical resonator constitutes a generic model of a laser. For quasi-continuous operation, external pumping, trapping and cooling of the atoms is required to confine them in order to achieve enough gain inside the resonator. As inverted atoms are high-field seekers in blue detuned light fields, tuning the cavity mode to the blue side of the atomic gain transition allows for combining lasing with stimulated cavity cooling and dipole trapping of the atoms at the antinodes of the laser field. We study such a configuration using a semiclassical description of particle motion along the cavity axis. In extension of earlier work we include free space atomic and cavity decay as well as atomic dipole-dipole interactions and their corresponding forces. We show that for a proper choice of parameters even in the bad cavity limit the atoms can create a sufficiently strong field inside the resonator such that they are trapped and cooled via the superradiant lasing action with less than one photon on average inside the cavity.

•Jan 1, 2018•18 citations

Instabilities of the continuous superradiant laser

Bruno Laburthe-Tolra, Martin Robert-de-Saint-Vincent, Benjamin Pasquiou

We investigate the intensity stability of the superradiant laser. Our study focuses on the architecture where a continuous beam of atoms in an electronically excited state crosses the mode of a high-finesse Fabry-Perot cavity, which has been proposed as a new architecture of an active optical clock. We show that such superradiant laser can become unstable and develop chaotic behavior. We derive an analytical criterion for this instability and find that it may only occur when the lifetime of photons in the cavity is significantly shorter than the lifetime of atoms. This criterion allows for refining the necessary parameters to run a superradiant laser as a frequency reference in the optical domain. In particular, we point-out the consequences of the instability on intensity fluctuations and laser linewidth. On the other hand, we also point out that the superradiant laser, when in the unstable regime, can become an interesting playground for studying chaos. At the mean-field level, there is a direct mapping to the Bénard instability associated with fluid turbulence; however quantum fluctuations associated with photon out-coupling and atom re-filling substantially modify the expected behaviors. Finally, we point-out the existence of a regular self-pulsing regime at large atom numbers.

quant-pharXiv:2606.21675•Jun 23, 2026•0 citations
Motivated by the outstanding short time stability and reliable continuous operation properties of microwave clock masers, intense worldwide efforts target the first implementation of their optical analogues based on narrow optical clock transitions and using laser cooled dilute atomic gases. While as a central line of research large efforts are devoted to create a suitably dense continuous ultracold and optically inverted atom beam source, recent theoretical predictions hint at an alternative implementation using a filtered thermal beam at much higher density. Corresponding numerical studies give encouraging results but the required very high densities are sensitive to beam collimation errors and inhomogeneous shifts. Here we present extensive numerical studies of threshold conditions and the predicted output power of such a superradiant laser involving realistic particle numbers and velocities along the cavity axis. Detailed studies target the threshold scaling as a function of temperature as well as the influence of eliminating the hottest part of the atomic distribution via velocity filtering and the benefits of additional atomic beam guiding. Using a cumulant expansion approach allows us to quantify the significance of atom-atom and atom-field correlations in such configurations. We predict necessary conditions to achieve a certain threshold photon number depending on the atomic temperature and density. In particular, we show that the temperature threshold can be significantly increased by using more atoms. Interestingly, a velocity filter removing very fast atoms has only almost negligible influence despite their phase perturbing properties. On the positive side an additional conservative optical guiding towards cavity mode antinodes leads to significantly lower threshold and higher average photon number. Interestingly we see that higher order atom-field and direct atom-atom quantum correlations play only a minor role in the laser dynamics, which is a bit surprising in the superradiant regime.
Abstract The implementation of a superradiant laser as an active frequency standard is predicted to provide better short-term stability and robustness to thermal and mechanical fluctuations when compared to standard passive optical clocks. However, despite significant recent progress, the experimental realization of continuous wave superradiant lasing still remains an open challenge as it requires continuous loading, cooling, and pumping of active atoms within an optical resonator. Here we propose a new scenario for creating continuous gain by using optical forces acting on the states of a two-level atom via bichromatic coherent pumping of a cold atomic gas trapped inside a single-mode cavity. Analogous to atomic maser setups, tailored state-dependent forces are used to gather and concentrate excited-state atoms in regions of strong atom-cavity coupling while ground-state atoms are repelled. To facilitate numerical simulations of a sufficiently large atomic ensemble, we rely on a second-order cumulant expansion and describe the atomic motion in a semi-classical point-particle approximation subject to position-dependent light shifts which induce optical gradient forces along the cavity axis. We study minimal conditions on pump laser intensities and detunings required for collective superradiant emission. Balancing Doppler cooling and gain-induced heating we identify a parameter regime of a continuous narrow-band laser operation close to the bare atomic frequency.
Background: Theoretical studies of superradiant lasing on optical clock transitions predict a superb frequency accuracy and precision closely tied to the bare atomic linewidth. Such a superradiant laser is also robust against cavity fluctuations when the spectral width of the lasing mode is much larger than that of the atomic medium. Recent predictions suggest that this unique feature persists even for a hot and thus strongly broadened ensemble, provided the effective atom number is large enough. Methods: Here we use a second-order cumulant expansion approach to study the power, linewidth and lineshifts of such a superradiant laser as a function of the inhomogeneous width of the ensemble including variations of the spatial atom-field coupling within the resonator. Results: We present conditions on the atom numbers, the pump and coupling strengths required to reach the buildup of collective atomic coherence as well as scaling and limitations for the achievable laser linewidth. Conclusions: We show how sufficiently large numbers of atoms subject to strong optical pumping can induce synchronization of the atomic dipoles over a large bandwidth. This generates collective stimulated emission of light into the cavity mode leading to narrow-band laser emission at the average of the atomic frequency distribution. The linewidth is orders of magnitudes smaller than that of the cavity as well as the inhomogeneous gain broadening and exhibits reduced sensitivity to cavity frequency noise.
The prospects of superradiant lasing on the 7.5-kHz-wide $^{1}S_{0}\text{\ensuremath{-}}^{3}P_{1}$ transition in 88Sr^{88}\mathrm{Sr}88Sr is explored by using numerical simulations of two systems based on realistic experimental numbers. One system uses the idea of demonstrating continuous superradiance in a simple, hot atom beam with high flux, and the other system is based on using ultracold atoms in a dipole guide. For the hot-beam system we consider a range of atom beam parameters as well as the impact of a scheme to discard fast atoms along the cavity axis. We find that the system achieves lasing above a flux of $2.5\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{12}$ atoms/s and that it is capable of outputting hundreds of nanowatts and suppressing cavity noise by a factor of 20--30. The relativistic transverse Doppler shifts cause a shift in the lasing frequency on the order of 500 Hz. For the cold-atom beam we account for decoherence and thermal effects when using a repumping scheme for atoms confined in a dipole guide. This is done by treating recoils and state-dependent forces acting on atoms in the dipole guide within the framework of the stochastic master equation. We find that the output power is on the order of hundreds of picowatts; however, transverse Doppler shifts can be neglected, and cavity noise can be suppressed on the order of a factor of 50--100. Additionally, we show that both systems exhibit local insensitivity to fluctuations in atomic flux.
A cold atomic gas with an inverted population on a transition coupled to a field mode of an optical resonator constitutes a generic model of a laser. For quasi-continuous operation, external pumping, trapping and cooling of the atoms is required to confine them in order to achieve enough gain inside the resonator. As inverted atoms are high-field seekers in blue detuned light fields, tuning the cavity mode to the blue side of the atomic gain transition allows for combining lasing with stimulated cavity cooling and dipole trapping of the atoms at the antinodes of the laser field. We study such a configuration using a semiclassical description of particle motion along the cavity axis. In extension of earlier work we include free space atomic and cavity decay as well as atomic dipole-dipole interactions and their corresponding forces. We show that for a proper choice of parameters even in the bad cavity limit the atoms can create a sufficiently strong field inside the resonator such that they are trapped and cooled via the superradiant lasing action with less than one photon on average inside the cavity.
A cold atomic gas with an inverted population on a transition coupled to a field mode of an optical resonator constitutes a generic model of a laser. For quasi-continuous operation, external pumping, trapping and cooling of the atoms is required to confine them in order to achieve enough gain inside the resonator. As inverted atoms are high-field seekers in blue detuned light fields, tuning the cavity mode to the blue side of the atomic gain transition allows for combining lasing with stimulated cavity cooling and dipole trapping of the atoms at the antinodes of the laser field. We study such a configuration using a semiclassical description of particle motion along the cavity axis. In extension of earlier work we include free space atomic and cavity decay as well as atomic dipole-dipole interactions and their corresponding forces. We show that for a proper choice of parameters even in the bad cavity limit the atoms can create a sufficiently strong field inside the resonator such that they are trapped and cooled via the superradiant lasing action with less than one photon on average inside the cavity.
We investigate the intensity stability of the superradiant laser. Our study focuses on the architecture where a continuous beam of atoms in an electronically excited state crosses the mode of a high-finesse Fabry-Perot cavity, which has been proposed as a new architecture of an active optical clock. We show that such superradiant laser can become unstable and develop chaotic behavior. We derive an analytical criterion for this instability and find that it may only occur when the lifetime of photons in the cavity is significantly shorter than the lifetime of atoms. This criterion allows for refining the necessary parameters to run a superradiant laser as a frequency reference in the optical domain. In particular, we point-out the consequences of the instability on intensity fluctuations and laser linewidth. On the other hand, we also point out that the superradiant laser, when in the unstable regime, can become an interesting playground for studying chaos. At the mean-field level, there is a direct mapping to the Bénard instability associated with fluid turbulence; however quantum fluctuations associated with photon out-coupling and atom re-filling substantially modify the expected behaviors. Finally, we point-out the existence of a regular self-pulsing regime at large atom numbers.