Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2308.01036 · Modern Physics Letters A

Performance analysis of satellite-based QKD protocols

Muskan, Ramniwas Meena, Subhashish Banerjee

Published Apr 6, 2026• 6 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Satellite-based free-space quantum key distribution (QKD) provides a practical framework for achieving secure global communication beyond the limitations of optical fibers. In this work, the quantum bit error rate (QBER) and secure key rate of four representative protocols-BB84, B92, BBM92, and E91 are investigated over low earth orbit (LEO) links in both uplink and downlink configurations. The optical link is modeled using a Gaussian beam formalism, incorporating the effects of diffraction, pointing errors, atmospheric turbulence, and background noise contributions. The protocols are examined under day and night-time operating conditions, and their dependence on the zenith angle is analyzed. The findings show that downlink links generally exhibit lower QBER and higher secure key rates than uplinks, and among prepare-and-measure schemes, BB84 consistently outperforms B92, while in entanglement-based approaches, BBM92 achieves higher key rates than E91.

DOI
10.1142/s0217732326501324

Related papers

Satellite-Based Quantum Communication: Performance Evaluation of Discrete-Variable Quantum Key Distribution Protocols

Muskan

Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) has emerged as a fundamentally secure approach to communication in the era of quantum computing, offering protection against threats posed to classical cryptographic schemes such as RSA and Diffie-Hellman. This thesis presents a comprehensive performance analysis of satellite-based QKD protocols, focusing on both prepare-and-measure and entanglement-based schemes under realistic atmospheric and operational conditions. The study begins by introducing the theoretical foundations of quantum communication, including qubits, entanglement, and quantum entropy, and motivates the need for satellite-based QKD to overcome the distance limitations of fiber-based systems. Subsequently, the thesis evaluates four prominent QKD protocols-BB84, B92, BBM92, and E91-using a circular beam propagation model that incorporates atmospheric effects such as diffraction, turbulence, attenuation, and pointing errors, along with environmental noise contributions for uplink and downlink. Comparative numerical simulations reveal that protocol performance is strongly influenced by channel asymmetries, beam propagation characteristics, and noise, providing guidance on optimal protocol selection for low Earth orbit (LEO) satellite links. The research further investigates high-dimensional (HD) QKD protocols, specifically HD-BB84 and HD-Extended B92, using the elliptic-beam approximation to account for turbulence-induced distortions for both uplink and downlink. Simulations under vary ing system dimensions, weather conditions, and zenith angles demonstrate that HD-BB84 achieves higher key rates, superior noise tolerance, and more favorable probability distributions of the key rate compared to HD-Extended B92, highlighting the advantages of high-dimensional encoding for robust satellite-based QKD.

quant-pharXiv:2606.09217•Jun 9, 2026•0 citations

Communication System Performance Analysis of Satellite-to-Ground BB84 Quantum Key Distribution over Gamma–Gamma Turbulence Channels with Pointing Errors.

Sahil Bhardwaj¹, Vikas Sidhu

Abstract Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) provides information-theoretic security for future communication networks by exploiting the fundamental principles of quantum mechanics. However, satellite-to-ground QKD links suffer significant performance degradation due to atmospheric turbulence, absorption, scattering, and satellite-induced pointing errors. This paper investigates the BB84 QKD protocol over a Free-Space Optical (FSO) channel modeled using the Gamma–Gamma distribution, which accurately captures both small-scale and large-scale atmospheric irradiance fluctuations. Closed-form and numerical results for outage probability and Quantum Bit Error Rate (QBER) are presented under weak, moderate, and strong turbulence regimes. The Secure Key Rate (SKR) is analyzed as a function of link distance under clear and foggy weather conditions. Additionally, the impact of satellite vibration is evaluated using a jitter-dependent pointing error model, demonstrating that misalignment significantly reduces link reliability. Simulation results show that strong turbulence conditions introduce more than 15 dB SNR penalty compared to clear-sky operation, while haze conditions limit QKD range to under 8–10 km. These findings provide practical performance benchmarks for Low-Earth Orbit (LEO) quantum downlinks in realistic atmospheric environments. The results provide practical insights for electronic receiver design and system implementation of satellite quantum communication links.

•Mar 5, 2026•0 citations

Performance evaluation of satellite-based quantum optical communication systems

Richard Etengu

This study aims at extending the concept of QKD to the optical free-space quantum communications domain. Moreover, the feasibility of a global satellite based quantum key distribution, in the low earth orbit (LEO) is investigated. Inline with this, three different link scenarios, including ground-to-ground, ground-to-satellite and satellite-to-satellite are considered. Moreover, system performance is analysed to show the sensitivity of the link to effect such as atmospheric attenuation, turbulence and detector noise. Generally, these factors are assumed to impair system performance by causing an overall increase in the systems quantum bit error rate (QBER), let alone limiting the communication bit rate and transmission distance of the link. The obtained results reveal the feasibility of satellite-based quantum key distribution in the LEO platform, a concept which could be potentially extended to geostationary earth orbit (GEO).

•Jul 1, 2009•0 citations

LEO small satellite QKD downlink performance: QuantSat-PT case study

Vladlen Galetsky, M. Niehus

In this work, we model and simulate the performance of a quantum key distribution (QKD) downlink from a low earth orbit (LEO) small satellite to an optical ground station (OGS), as integral part of the concept and preliminary design phase of the QuantSat-PT mission. By modelling and simulating in detail downlink transmission channel effects, with emphasis on turbulent and atmospheric losses for BB84 and E91 protocols, we find a consistent set of values for the performance envelope that resolves ambiguities of mission experimental data that had been reported previous to this work. We obtain for the 4-state BB84 protocol a sifted key rate and Quantum Bit Error Rate (QBER) of 32.1 kbit/s and $4\%$, respectively, for zenith at 750 km orbit. For the E91 protocol the Clauser, Horne, Shimony and Holt (CHSH) test was performed resulting in a correlation factor of $S \in[-2.63\pm0.02,-1.91\pm0.03]$ for the mission. The consistency of these results with the state of the art simulators and its relevance on experimental satellite based QKD is discussed.

arXiv:2209.10293•Sep 21, 2022•3 citations

Physical Limits of Entanglement-Based Quantum Key Distribution over Long-Distance Satellite Links

Mohammad Taghi Dabiri, Mazen O. Hasna, Saif M. Al-Kuwari +1 more

Entanglement-based quantum key distribution (QKD) protocols, such as E91 and BBM92, offer strong information-theoretic security and are naturally suited for satellite-to-satellite QKD (SatQKD) links. However, implementing these protocols over long-distance inter-satellite free-space optical (FSO) channels poses critical physical-layer challenges that are not addressed in the existing literature. In particular, photon losses due to beam divergence, pointing errors, and background noise can severely degrade the key generation rate and quantum bit error rate (QBER), especially under narrow receiver field-of-view (FoV) constraints. This paper presents a comprehensive performance analysis of entanglement-based inter-satellite QKD, focusing on photon-level modeling and the impact of practical impairments. We develop analytical expressions for signal detection probabilities, background photon influence, multi-pair emissions, and QBER, incorporating key parameters such as link distance, transmitter tracking jitter, receiver misalignment, and photon pair generation rate. Simulation results reveal the nonlinear sensitivity of system performance to tracking error and FoV limitations, and highlight optimal parameter regimes that jointly maximize secret key rate while maintaining QBER below acceptable thresholds. The proposed model provides actionable design insights for reliable and efficient deployment of entanglement-based SatQKD systems.

arXiv:2506.20798•Jun 25, 2025•1 citation

Performance Comparison of BB84 and B92 Satellite-Based Free Space Quantum Optical Communication Systems in the Presence of Channel Effects

Richard Etengu, F. M. Abbou, H. Y. Wong +3 more

Abstract The performance of single photon pulsed polarization based BB84 and B92 platforms against individual attacks for free space quantum optical communication links between a ground station and a satellite in the low earth orbit is compared. The comparison is attained by evaluating the quantum bit error rate and secure communication bit rate on secure optical link loss and the sensitivity of different parameters. Precisely, realistic experimental parameters are used and the obtained results are compared with those of other papers. Quantum bit error rates as low as 3.5% have been regularly obtained. Moreover, with repetition rate of 10MHz at the low earth orbit standard orbital altitude of 100 km and at zenith angle of 60 degrees, secure communication bit rates of ~ 280 kHz and ~ 70 kHz were received for the BB84 and B92, respectively. The obtained results show that the BB84 protocol exhibits better performance than B92 in the distribution of the secure communication key over long distance. Overall, these results reveal that it is possible to obtain secure key exchange in the low earth orbit, an idea which can be extended to other long distance laser links such as geostationary orbit.

Journal of Optical Communications•Apr 1, 2011•14 citations
Satellite-based free-space quantum key distribution (QKD) provides a practical framework for achieving secure global communication beyond the limitations of optical fibers. In this work, the quantum bit error rate (QBER) and secure key rate of four representative protocols-BB84, B92, BBM92, and E91 are investigated over low earth orbit (LEO) links in both uplink and downlink configurations. The optical link is modeled using a Gaussian beam formalism, incorporating the effects of diffraction, pointing errors, atmospheric turbulence, and background noise contributions. The protocols are examined under day and night-time operating conditions, and their dependence on the zenith angle is analyzed. The findings show that downlink links generally exhibit lower QBER and higher secure key rates than uplinks, and among prepare-and-measure schemes, BB84 consistently outperforms B92, while in entanglement-based approaches, BBM92 achieves higher key rates than E91.
Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) has emerged as a fundamentally secure approach to communication in the era of quantum computing, offering protection against threats posed to classical cryptographic schemes such as RSA and Diffie-Hellman. This thesis presents a comprehensive performance analysis of satellite-based QKD protocols, focusing on both prepare-and-measure and entanglement-based schemes under realistic atmospheric and operational conditions. The study begins by introducing the theoretical foundations of quantum communication, including qubits, entanglement, and quantum entropy, and motivates the need for satellite-based QKD to overcome the distance limitations of fiber-based systems. Subsequently, the thesis evaluates four prominent QKD protocols-BB84, B92, BBM92, and E91-using a circular beam propagation model that incorporates atmospheric effects such as diffraction, turbulence, attenuation, and pointing errors, along with environmental noise contributions for uplink and downlink. Comparative numerical simulations reveal that protocol performance is strongly influenced by channel asymmetries, beam propagation characteristics, and noise, providing guidance on optimal protocol selection for low Earth orbit (LEO) satellite links. The research further investigates high-dimensional (HD) QKD protocols, specifically HD-BB84 and HD-Extended B92, using the elliptic-beam approximation to account for turbulence-induced distortions for both uplink and downlink. Simulations under vary ing system dimensions, weather conditions, and zenith angles demonstrate that HD-BB84 achieves higher key rates, superior noise tolerance, and more favorable probability distributions of the key rate compared to HD-Extended B92, highlighting the advantages of high-dimensional encoding for robust satellite-based QKD.
Abstract Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) provides information-theoretic security for future communication networks by exploiting the fundamental principles of quantum mechanics. However, satellite-to-ground QKD links suffer significant performance degradation due to atmospheric turbulence, absorption, scattering, and satellite-induced pointing errors. This paper investigates the BB84 QKD protocol over a Free-Space Optical (FSO) channel modeled using the Gamma–Gamma distribution, which accurately captures both small-scale and large-scale atmospheric irradiance fluctuations. Closed-form and numerical results for outage probability and Quantum Bit Error Rate (QBER) are presented under weak, moderate, and strong turbulence regimes. The Secure Key Rate (SKR) is analyzed as a function of link distance under clear and foggy weather conditions. Additionally, the impact of satellite vibration is evaluated using a jitter-dependent pointing error model, demonstrating that misalignment significantly reduces link reliability. Simulation results show that strong turbulence conditions introduce more than 15 dB SNR penalty compared to clear-sky operation, while haze conditions limit QKD range to under 8–10 km. These findings provide practical performance benchmarks for Low-Earth Orbit (LEO) quantum downlinks in realistic atmospheric environments. The results provide practical insights for electronic receiver design and system implementation of satellite quantum communication links.
This study aims at extending the concept of QKD to the optical free-space quantum communications domain. Moreover, the feasibility of a global satellite based quantum key distribution, in the low earth orbit (LEO) is investigated. Inline with this, three different link scenarios, including ground-to-ground, ground-to-satellite and satellite-to-satellite are considered. Moreover, system performance is analysed to show the sensitivity of the link to effect such as atmospheric attenuation, turbulence and detector noise. Generally, these factors are assumed to impair system performance by causing an overall increase in the systems quantum bit error rate (QBER), let alone limiting the communication bit rate and transmission distance of the link. The obtained results reveal the feasibility of satellite-based quantum key distribution in the LEO platform, a concept which could be potentially extended to geostationary earth orbit (GEO).
In this work, we model and simulate the performance of a quantum key distribution (QKD) downlink from a low earth orbit (LEO) small satellite to an optical ground station (OGS), as integral part of the concept and preliminary design phase of the QuantSat-PT mission. By modelling and simulating in detail downlink transmission channel effects, with emphasis on turbulent and atmospheric losses for BB84 and E91 protocols, we find a consistent set of values for the performance envelope that resolves ambiguities of mission experimental data that had been reported previous to this work. We obtain for the 4-state BB84 protocol a sifted key rate and Quantum Bit Error Rate (QBER) of 32.1 kbit/s and 4%4\%4%, respectively, for zenith at 750 km orbit. For the E91 protocol the Clauser, Horne, Shimony and Holt (CHSH) test was performed resulting in a correlation factor of S∈[−2.63±0.02,−1.91±0.03]S \in[-2.63\pm0.02,-1.91\pm0.03]S∈[−2.63±0.02,−1.91±0.03] for the mission. The consistency of these results with the state of the art simulators and its relevance on experimental satellite based QKD is discussed.
Entanglement-based quantum key distribution (QKD) protocols, such as E91 and BBM92, offer strong information-theoretic security and are naturally suited for satellite-to-satellite QKD (SatQKD) links. However, implementing these protocols over long-distance inter-satellite free-space optical (FSO) channels poses critical physical-layer challenges that are not addressed in the existing literature. In particular, photon losses due to beam divergence, pointing errors, and background noise can severely degrade the key generation rate and quantum bit error rate (QBER), especially under narrow receiver field-of-view (FoV) constraints. This paper presents a comprehensive performance analysis of entanglement-based inter-satellite QKD, focusing on photon-level modeling and the impact of practical impairments. We develop analytical expressions for signal detection probabilities, background photon influence, multi-pair emissions, and QBER, incorporating key parameters such as link distance, transmitter tracking jitter, receiver misalignment, and photon pair generation rate. Simulation results reveal the nonlinear sensitivity of system performance to tracking error and FoV limitations, and highlight optimal parameter regimes that jointly maximize secret key rate while maintaining QBER below acceptable thresholds. The proposed model provides actionable design insights for reliable and efficient deployment of entanglement-based SatQKD systems.
Abstract The performance of single photon pulsed polarization based BB84 and B92 platforms against individual attacks for free space quantum optical communication links between a ground station and a satellite in the low earth orbit is compared. The comparison is attained by evaluating the quantum bit error rate and secure communication bit rate on secure optical link loss and the sensitivity of different parameters. Precisely, realistic experimental parameters are used and the obtained results are compared with those of other papers. Quantum bit error rates as low as 3.5% have been regularly obtained. Moreover, with repetition rate of 10MHz at the low earth orbit standard orbital altitude of 100 km and at zenith angle of 60 degrees, secure communication bit rates of ~ 280 kHz and ~ 70 kHz were received for the BB84 and B92, respectively. The obtained results show that the BB84 protocol exhibits better performance than B92 in the distribution of the secure communication key over long distance. Overall, these results reveal that it is possible to obtain secure key exchange in the low earth orbit, an idea which can be extended to other long distance laser links such as geostationary orbit.