arXiv:2307.15116

The debate over QKD: A rebuttal to the NSA's objections

Renato Renner, Ramona Wolf

Published Jul 27, 2023• 4 citations

Abstract

A recent publication by the NSA assessing the usability of quantum cryptography has generated significant attention, concluding that this technology is not recommended for use. Here, we reply to this criticism and argue that some of the points raised are unjustified, whereas others are problematic now but can be expected to be resolved in the foreseeable future.

DOI: 10.48550/arxiv.2307.15116

Related papers

Reply to recent scepticism about the foundations of quantum cryptography

Renato Renner

In a series of recent papers, Hirota and Yuen claim to have identified a fundamental flaw in the theory underlying quantum cryptography, which would invalidate existing security proofs. In this short note, we sketch their argument and show that their conclusion is unjustified --- it originates from a confusion between necessary and sufficient criteria for secrecy.

arXiv:1209.2423Sep 11, 201216 citations

Applicability of QKD: TerraQuantum view on the NSA's scepticism

Сыч Денис Васильевич, Aleksei Kodukhov, Valeria A. Pastushenko +3 more

Quantum communication offers unique features that have no classical analog, in particular, it enables provably secure quantum key distribution (QKD). Despite the benefits of quantum communication are well understood within the scientific community, the practical implementations sometimes meet with scepticism or even resistance. In a recent publication [1], NSA claims that QKD is inferior to "quantum-resistant" cryptography and does not recommend it for use. Here we show that such a sceptical approach to evaluation of quantum security is not well justified. We hope that our arguments will be helpful to clarify the issue.

arXiv:2308.07082Aug 14, 20230 citations

Quantum Cryptography – The Future of Secure Communication Using Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) Protocols

B. Sriman, S. Arjunsiva, G. Aswath +3 more

Communications in computer and information scienceJan 1, 20240 citations

How secure is quantum cryptography

Mario Stipčević

International Convention on Information and Communication Technology, Electronics and MicroelectronicsJan 1, 20120 citations

Quantum Technologies in Transition: Bridging Infrastructure, Policy, and Practice

Asep Irvan Irvani, Rizki Ilmianih, Nurul Kami Sani

Quantum technologies have emerged as critical enablers of next-generation communication, computation, and sensing systems. This review aims to assess the current state of Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) and related quantum technologies by examining recent empirical findings, methodological innovations, and systemic challenges. A structured literature search was conducted across Scopus, PubMed, and Google Scholar using Boolean keyword combinations targeting QKD, quantum sensing, and communication applications. The review focused on peer-reviewed articles from the last five years and included experimental studies, simulations, and applied case analyses. Findings show that QKD has demonstrated remarkable reliability in both controlled laboratory and real-world settings. Studies on multicore fiber networks highlight the potential for high-dimensional communication security, while comparative analyses reveal disparities between implementation strategies across different regions. However, systemic challenges such as inadequate infrastructure, inconsistent regulation, and insufficient public understanding hinder wide-scale adoption. The discussion identifies critical factors contributing to these challenges and proposes actionable policy recommendations, including increased investment in infrastructure, standardized regulations, and targeted education programs. This review concludes that achieving the full potential of quantum technologies will require integrative strategies addressing technical, institutional, and social dimensions. Future research should emphasize longitudinal evaluation and interdisciplinary collaboration to enhance scalability and impact. The insights offered here provide a foundational framework for policymakers, researchers, and industry leaders to advance the adoption of secure, scalable quantum systems.

Jurnal Fisika Terapan dan Inovasi IndonesiaNov 12, 20250 citations

Quantum key distribution and cryptography: a survey

Romain Alléaume, Norbert Lütkenhaus, Renato Renner +21 more

I will try to partially answer, based on a review on recent work, the following question: Can QKD and more generally quantum information be useful to cover some practical security requirements in current (and future) IT infrastructures ? I will in particular cover the following topics - practical performances of QKD - QKD network deployment - SECOQC project - Capabilities of QKD as a cryptographic primitive - comparative advantage with other solution, in order to cover practical security requirements - Quantum information and Side-channels - QKD security assurance - Thoughts about "real" Post-Quantum Cryptography

Dagstuhl Seminar ProceedingsJan 1, 20105 citations