© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

Terms Privacy Legal Notice

arXiv:2307.03085 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Ergodicity-breaking phase diagram and fractal dimensions in long-range models with generically correlated disorder

Shilpi Roy, Saurabh Basu, Ivan M. Khaymovich

Published Mar 7, 2025• 1 citation

Abstract

Models with correlated disorder are rather common in physics. In some of them, like the Aubry-André (AA) model, the localization phase diagram can be found from the (self)duality with respect to the Fourier transform. In others, like the all-to-all translation-invariant Rosenzweig-Porter (TI RP) ensemble or the many-body localization (MBL), one needs to develop more sophisticated and usually phenomenological methods to obtain the localization transition. In addition, such models contain not only localization, but also the ergodicity-breaking transition in the Hilbert-space eigenstate structure, giving way to the nonergodic (i.e., MBL) phase of states with nontrivial fractal dimensions D q > 0 . In this work, we suggest a method to calculate both the above transitions and a lower bound to the fractal dimensions D 2 and D ∞ , relevant for the physical observables. To verify this method, we apply it to the class of long-range (self-)dual models, interpolating between a tight-binding ballistic model and TI RP via both power-law dependencies of the hopping terms and the on-site disorder correlations, and, thus, being out of the validity range of the previously developed methods. We show that the interplay of the correlated disorder and the power-law decaying hopping terms leads to the emergence of the two types of nonergodic phases in the entire range of parameters, even without having any quasiperiodicity of the AA potential. The analytical results of the above method are in full agreement with the extensive numerical calculations.

DOI: 10.1103/physrevb.111.104203

Related papers

One-Dimensional Quasicrystals with Power-Law Hopping

Xiaolong Deng, Sayak Ray, Subhasis Sinha +2 more

One-dimensional quasiperiodic systems with power-law hopping, 1/r^{a}, differ from both the standard Aubry-André (AA) model and from power-law systems with uncorrelated disorder. Whereas in the AA model all single-particle states undergo a transition from ergodic to localized at a critical quasidisorder strength, short-range power-law hops with a>1 can result in mobility edges. We find that there is no localization for long-range hops with a≤1, in contrast to the case of uncorrelated disorder. Systems with long-range hops rather present ergodic-to-multifractal edges and a phase transition from ergodic to multifractal (extended but nonergodic) states. Both mobility and ergodic-to-multifractal edges may be clearly revealed in experiments on expansion dynamics.

arXiv:1808.03585•Physical Review Letters•Jul 10, 2019•217 citations

Tuning the phase diagram of a Rosenzweig-Porter model with fractal disorder

Madhumita Sarkar, Roopayan Ghosh, Ivan M. Khaymovich

The Rosenzweig-Porter (RP) model has garnered much attention in the last decade, as it is a simple analytically tractable model showing both ergodic-nonergodic extended and Anderson localization transitions. Thus, it is a good toy model to understand the Hilbert-space structure of many-body localization phenomenon. In our Letter, we present analytical evidence, supported by exact numerics, that demonstrates the controllable tuning of the phase diagram in the RP model by employing on-site potentials with a nontrivial fractal dimension instead of the conventional random disorder. We demonstrate that such disorder extends the fractal phase and creates an unusual dependence of fractal dimensions of the eigenfunctions. Furthermore, we study the fate of level statistics in such a system to understand how these changes are reflected in the eigenvalue statistics.

arXiv:2305.13370•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Aug 29, 2023•20 citations

Fragile extended phases in the log-normal Rosenzweig-Porter model

Ivan M. Khaymovich, V. E. Kravtsov, B. L. Altshuler +1 more

In this paper, we suggest an extension of the Rosenzweig-Porter (RP) model, the LN-RP model, in which the off-diagonal matrix elements have a wide, log-normal distribution.We argue that this model is more suitable to describe a generic many-body localization problem.In contrast to RP model, in LN-RP model, a fragile weakly ergodic phase appears that is characterized by broken basis-rotation symmetry which the fully ergodic phase, also present in this model, strictly respects in the thermodynamic limit.Therefore, in addition to the localization and ergodic transitions in LN-RP model, there exists also the transition between the two ergodic phases (FWE transition).We suggest new criteria of stability of the nonergodic phases that give the points of localization and ergodic transitions and prove that the Anderson localization transition in LN-RP model involves a jump in the fractal dimension of the egenfunction support set.We also formulate the criterion of FWE transition and obtain the full phase diagram of the model.We show that truncation of the log-normal tail shrinks the region of weakly ergodic phase and restores the multifractal and the fully ergodic phases.

arXiv:2006.04827•Physical Review Research•Dec 9, 2020•107 citations

Lévy-Rosenzweig-Porter random matrix ensemble

Giulio Biroli, Marco Tarzia

In this paper, we consider an extension of the Rosenzweig-Porter model, the L\'evy-RP (L-RP) model, in which the off-diagonal matrix elements are broadly distributed, providing a more realistic benchmark to develop an effective description of nonergodic extended (NEE) states in interacting many-body disordered systems. We put forward a simple, general, and intuitive argument that allows one to unveil the multifractal structure of the minibands in the local spectrum when hybridization is due to anomalously large transition amplitudes in the tails of the distribution. The idea is that the energy spreading of the minibands can be determined self-consistently by requiring that the maximal hybridization rate ${\mathcal{H}}_{ij}$ between a site $i$ and the other ${N}^{{D}_{1}}$ sites of the support set is of the same order of the Thouless energy itself ${N}^{{D}_{1}\ensuremath{-}1}$. This argument yields the fractal dimensions that characterize the statistics of the multifractal wave functions in the NEE phase, as well as the whole phase diagram of the L-RP ensemble. Its predictions are confirmed both analytically, by a thorough investigation of the self-consistent equation for the local density of states obtained using the cavity approach, and numerically, via extensive exact diagonalizations.

arXiv:2012.12841•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Mar 25, 2021•66 citations

Nonergodic extended states in the β ensemble

Adway Kumar Das, Anandamohan Ghosh

Matrix models showing a chaotic-integrable transition in the spectral statistics are important for understanding many-body localization (MBL) in physical systems. One such example is the $\ensuremath{\beta}$ ensemble, known for its structural simplicity. However, eigenvector properties of the $\ensuremath{\beta}$ ensemble remain largely unexplored, despite energy level correlations being thoroughly studied. In this work we numerically study the eigenvector properties of the $\ensuremath{\beta}$ ensemble and find that the Anderson transition occurs at $\ensuremath{\gamma}=1$ and ergodicity breaks down at $\ensuremath{\gamma}=0$ if we express the repulsion parameter as $\ensuremath{\beta}={N}^{\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\gamma}}$. Thus other than the Rosenzweig-Porter ensemble (RPE), the $\ensuremath{\beta}$ ensemble is another example where nonergodic extended (NEE) states are observed over a finite interval of parameter values $(0<\ensuremath{\gamma}<1)$. We find that the chaotic-integrable transition coincides with the breaking of ergodicity in the $\ensuremath{\beta}$ ensemble but with the localization transition in the RPE or the 1D disordered spin-1/2 Heisenberg model. As a result, the dynamical timescales in the NEE regime of the $\ensuremath{\beta}$ ensemble behave differently than the latter models.

arXiv:2112.11910•Physical review. E•May 12, 2022•31 citations

Characterizing the many-body localization transition through correlations

Benjamin Villalonga, Bryan K. Clark

Closed, interacting, quantum systems have the potential to transition to a many-body localized (MBL) phase under the presence of sufficiently strong disorder, hence breaking ergodicity and failing to thermalize. In this work we study the distribution of correlations throughout the ergodic-MBL phase diagram. We find the typical correlations in the MBL phase decay as a stretched exponential with range $r$ eventually crossing over to an exponential decay deep in the MBL phase. At the transition, the stretched exponential goes as $e^{-A\sqrt{r}}$, a decay that is reminiscent of the random singlet phase. While the standard deviation of the $\log(QMI)$ has a range dependence, the $\log(QMI)$ converges to a range-invariant distribution on all other moments (i.e., the skewness and higher) at the transition. The universal nature of these distributions provides distinct phenomenology of the transition different from both the ergodic and MBL phenomenologies. In addition to the typical correlations, we study the extreme correlations in the system, finding that the probability of strong long-range correlations is maximal at the transition, suggesting the proliferation of resonances there. Finally, we analyze the probability that a single bit of information is shared across two halves of a system, finding that this probability is non-zero deep in the MBL phase but vanishes at moderate disorder well above the transition.

arXiv:2007.06586•Bulletin of the American Physical Society•Jul 13, 2020•6 citations

Models with correlated disorder are rather common in physics. In some of them, like the Aubry-André (AA) model, the localization phase diagram can be found from the (self)duality with respect to the Fourier transform. In others, like the all-to-all translation-invariant Rosenzweig-Porter (TI RP) ensemble or the many-body localization (MBL), one needs to develop more sophisticated and usually phenomenological methods to obtain the localization transition. In addition, such models contain not only localization, but also the ergodicity-breaking transition in the Hilbert-space eigenstate structure, giving way to the nonergodic (i.e., MBL) phase of states with nontrivial fractal dimensions D q > 0 . In this work, we suggest a method to calculate both the above transitions and a lower bound to the fractal dimensions D 2 and D ∞ , relevant for the physical observables. To verify this method, we apply it to the class of long-range (self-)dual models, interpolating between a tight-binding ballistic model and TI RP via both power-law dependencies of the hopping terms and the on-site disorder correlations, and, thus, being out of the validity range of the previously developed methods. We show that the interplay of the correlated disorder and the power-law decaying hopping terms leads to the emergence of the two types of nonergodic phases in the entire range of parameters, even without having any quasiperiodicity of the AA potential. The analytical results of the above method are in full agreement with the extensive numerical calculations.

One-dimensional quasiperiodic systems with power-law hopping, 1/r^{a}, differ from both the standard Aubry-André (AA) model and from power-law systems with uncorrelated disorder. Whereas in the AA model all single-particle states undergo a transition from ergodic to localized at a critical quasidisorder strength, short-range power-law hops with a>1 can result in mobility edges. We find that there is no localization for long-range hops with a≤1, in contrast to the case of uncorrelated disorder. Systems with long-range hops rather present ergodic-to-multifractal edges and a phase transition from ergodic to multifractal (extended but nonergodic) states. Both mobility and ergodic-to-multifractal edges may be clearly revealed in experiments on expansion dynamics.

The Rosenzweig-Porter (RP) model has garnered much attention in the last decade, as it is a simple analytically tractable model showing both ergodic-nonergodic extended and Anderson localization transitions. Thus, it is a good toy model to understand the Hilbert-space structure of many-body localization phenomenon. In our Letter, we present analytical evidence, supported by exact numerics, that demonstrates the controllable tuning of the phase diagram in the RP model by employing on-site potentials with a nontrivial fractal dimension instead of the conventional random disorder. We demonstrate that such disorder extends the fractal phase and creates an unusual dependence of fractal dimensions of the eigenfunctions. Furthermore, we study the fate of level statistics in such a system to understand how these changes are reflected in the eigenvalue statistics.

In this paper, we suggest an extension of the Rosenzweig-Porter (RP) model, the LN-RP model, in which the off-diagonal matrix elements have a wide, log-normal distribution.We argue that this model is more suitable to describe a generic many-body localization problem.In contrast to RP model, in LN-RP model, a fragile weakly ergodic phase appears that is characterized by broken basis-rotation symmetry which the fully ergodic phase, also present in this model, strictly respects in the thermodynamic limit.Therefore, in addition to the localization and ergodic transitions in LN-RP model, there exists also the transition between the two ergodic phases (FWE transition).We suggest new criteria of stability of the nonergodic phases that give the points of localization and ergodic transitions and prove that the Anderson localization transition in LN-RP model involves a jump in the fractal dimension of the egenfunction support set.We also formulate the criterion of FWE transition and obtain the full phase diagram of the model.We show that truncation of the log-normal tail shrinks the region of weakly ergodic phase and restores the multifractal and the fully ergodic phases.

In this paper, we consider an extension of the Rosenzweig-Porter model, the L\'evy-RP (L-RP) model, in which the off-diagonal matrix elements are broadly distributed, providing a more realistic benchmark to develop an effective description of nonergodic extended (NEE) states in interacting many-body disordered systems. We put forward a simple, general, and intuitive argument that allows one to unveil the multifractal structure of the minibands in the local spectrum when hybridization is due to anomalously large transition amplitudes in the tails of the distribution. The idea is that the energy spreading of the minibands can be determined self-consistently by requiring that the maximal hybridization rate

{\mathcal{H}}_{ij}

between a site

i

and the other

{N}^{{D}_{1}}

sites of the support set is of the same order of the Thouless energy itself ${N}^{{D}_{1}\ensuremath{-}1}$. This argument yields the fractal dimensions that characterize the statistics of the multifractal wave functions in the NEE phase, as well as the whole phase diagram of the L-RP ensemble. Its predictions are confirmed both analytically, by a thorough investigation of the self-consistent equation for the local density of states obtained using the cavity approach, and numerically, via extensive exact diagonalizations.

Matrix models showing a chaotic-integrable transition in the spectral statistics are important for understanding many-body localization (MBL) in physical systems. One such example is the $\ensuremath{\beta}$ ensemble, known for its structural simplicity. However, eigenvector properties of the $\ensuremath{\beta}$ ensemble remain largely unexplored, despite energy level correlations being thoroughly studied. In this work we numerically study the eigenvector properties of the $\ensuremath{\beta}$ ensemble and find that the Anderson transition occurs at $\ensuremath{\gamma}=1$ and ergodicity breaks down at $\ensuremath{\gamma}=0$ if we express the repulsion parameter as $\ensuremath{\beta}={N}^{\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\gamma}}$. Thus other than the Rosenzweig-Porter ensemble (RPE), the $\ensuremath{\beta}$ ensemble is another example where nonergodic extended (NEE) states are observed over a finite interval of parameter values $(0<\ensuremath{\gamma}<1)$. We find that the chaotic-integrable transition coincides with the breaking of ergodicity in the $\ensuremath{\beta}$ ensemble but with the localization transition in the RPE or the 1D disordered spin-1/2 Heisenberg model. As a result, the dynamical timescales in the NEE regime of the $\ensuremath{\beta}$ ensemble behave differently than the latter models.

Closed, interacting, quantum systems have the potential to transition to a many-body localized (MBL) phase under the presence of sufficiently strong disorder, hence breaking ergodicity and failing to thermalize. In this work we study the distribution of correlations throughout the ergodic-MBL phase diagram. We find the typical correlations in the MBL phase decay as a stretched exponential with range

r

eventually crossing over to an exponential decay deep in the MBL phase. At the transition, the stretched exponential goes as

e^{-A\sqrt{r}}

, a decay that is reminiscent of the random singlet phase. While the standard deviation of the

\log(QMI)

has a range dependence, the

\log(QMI)

converges to a range-invariant distribution on all other moments (i.e., the skewness and higher) at the transition. The universal nature of these distributions provides distinct phenomenology of the transition different from both the ergodic and MBL phenomenologies. In addition to the typical correlations, we study the extreme correlations in the system, finding that the probability of strong long-range correlations is maximal at the transition, suggesting the proliferation of resonances there. Finally, we analyze the probability that a single bit of information is shared across two halves of a system, finding that this probability is non-zero deep in the MBL phase but vanishes at moderate disorder well above the transition.