Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2306.13747

Deterministic and Bayesian Characterization of Quantum Computing Devices

Zhichao Peng, Daniel Appelö, N. Anders Petersson, Mohammad Motamed, Fortino Garcia, Yujin Cho

Published Jun 23, 2023• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Motivated by the noisy and fluctuating behavior of current quantum computing devices, this paper presents a data-driven characterization approach for estimating transition frequencies and decay times in a Lindbladian dynamical model of a superconducting quantum device. The data includes parity events in the transition frequency between the first and second excited states. A simple but effective mathematical model, based upon averaging solutions of two Lindbladian models, is demonstrated to accurately capture the experimental observations. A deterministic point estimate of the device parameters is first performed to minimize the misfit between data and Lindbladian simulations. These estimates are used to make an informed choice of prior distributions for the subsequent Bayesian inference. An additive Gaussian noise model is developed for the likelihood function, which includes two hyper-parameters to capture the noise structure of the data. The outcome of the Bayesian inference are posterior probability distributions of the transition frequencies, which for example can be utilized to design risk neutral optimal control pulses. The applicability of our approach is demonstrated on experimental data from the Quantum Device and Integration Testbed (QuDIT) at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, using a tantalum-based superconducting transmon device.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2306.13747

Related papers

Identifiability and characterization of transmon qutrits through Bayesian experimental design

Sohail R. Reddy

Robust control of a quantum system is essential to utilize the current noisy quantum hardware to its full potential, such as quantum algorithms. To achieve such a goal, a systematic search for an optimal control for any given experiment is essential. The design of optimal control pulses requires accurate numerical models and, therefore, accurate characterization of the system parameters. We present an online Bayesian approach for quantum characterization of qutrit systems, which automatically and systematically identifies optimal experiments that provide maximum information on the system parameters, thereby greatly reducing the number of experiments that need to be performed on the quantum testbed. Unlike most characterization protocols that provide point-estimates of the parameters, the proposed approach is able to estimate their probability distribution. The applicability of the Bayesian experimental design technique was demonstrated on test problems, where each experiment was defined by a parameterized control pulse. In addition to this, we also present an approach for iterative pulse extension, which is robust under uncertainties in transition frequencies and coherence times, and shot noise, despite being initialized with wide uninformative priors. Furthermore, we provide a mathematical proof of the theoretical identifiability of the model parameters and present conditions on the quantum state under which the parameters are identifiable. The proof and conditions for identifiability are presented for both closed and open quantum systems using the Schrödinger equation and the Lindblad master equation, respectively.

arXiv:2312.10233•Journal of Applied Physics•Jun 14, 2024•0 citations

Data-driven characterization of latent dynamics on quantum testbeds

Sohail R. Reddy, Stefanie Günther, Yujin Cho

This paper presents a data-driven approach to learn latent dynamics in superconducting quantum computing hardware. To this end, we augment the dynamical equation of quantum systems described by the Lindblad master equation with a parameterized source term that is trained from experimental data to capture unknown system dynamics, such as environmental interactions and system noise. We consider a structure preserving augmentation that learns and distinguishes unitary from dissipative latent dynamics parameterized by a basis of linear operators, as well as an augmentation given by a nonlinear feed-forward neural network. Numerical results are presented using data from two different quantum processing units (QPUs) at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory's Quantum Device and Integration Testbed. We demonstrate that our interpretable, structure preserving, and nonlinear models are able to improve the prediction accuracy of the Lindblad master equation and accurately model the latent dynamics of the QPUs.

arXiv:2401.09822•AVS Quantum Science•Jul 18, 2024•0 citations

Data-efficient quantum noise modeling via machine learning

Yanjun Ji, Marco Roth, David A. Kreplin +2 more

Maximizing the computational utility of near-term quantum processors requires predictive noise models that inform robust, noise-aware compilation and error mitigation. Conventional models often fail to capture the complex error dynamics of real hardware or require prohibitive characterization overhead. We introduce a data-efficient framework that first constructs a physically motivated, parameterized noise model, and subsequently employs machine-learning-driven Bayesian optimization to identify its parameters. Our approach circumvents costly characterization protocols by estimating algorithm- and hardware-specific error parameters directly from readily available experimental data derived from existing application and benchmark circuit executions. The generality and robustness of the framework are demonstrated across diverse algorithms and superconducting devices, yielding high-fidelity predictions by estimating an independent parameter set tailored to each specific algorithm-hardware context. Crucially, we show that a model calibrated exclusively on small-scale circuits accurately predicts the behavior of larger validation circuits. Our data-efficient approach achieves up to a 65% improvement in model fidelity quantified by the Hellinger distance between predicted and experimental circuit output distributions, compared to standard noise models derived from device properties. This work establishes a practical paradigm for application-aware noise characterization, enabling compilation and error-mitigation strategies tailored to the specific interplay between quantum algorithms and device-specific noise dynamics.

arXiv:2509.12933•Physical Review Applied•Feb 11, 2026•0 citations

Probabilistic Graybox Characterization of Quantum Devices With Bayesian Neural Networks

Poramet Pathumsoot, Michal Hajdušek, Rodney Van Meter

While the Graybox characterization method allows for implicit noise models and is platform-agnostic, the method lacks uncertainty quantification. Characterization of quantum devices is a crucial process that enables researchers to gain insight from experimental settings. Graybox characterization combines known system dynamics with unknown transformations, where the latter is modeled using machine learning. Prediction uncertainty helps researchers make informed decisions. It allows valuable insights from the devices without overconfidence. We therefore develop a probabilistic Graybox characterization model using probabilistic machine learning, specifically Bayesian Neural Networks, and utilize binary measurement outcomes directly for inference. With stochastic noise in a quantum device, we analyze statistical properties of the measurement data. Our results show that the model's prediction performance solely depends on its ability to capture the expected value of the true expectation value. Our proposed probabilistic Graybox model outperforms the original model by up to 1.9 times in capturing the distribution of observed data. We expect that our results will serve as an additional tool for characterizing quantum devices with uncertainty estimation, as they provide a flexible choice that can be utilized even without extensive prior knowledge of the noise model of the devices.

arXiv:2509.24232•IEEE Transactions on Quantum Engineering•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Mathematical approaches for characterization, control, calibration and validation of a quantum computing device

Zhichao Peng, Daniel Appelö, N. Anders Petersson +2 more

Quantum computing has received significant amounts of interest from many different research communities over the last few years. Although there are many introductory texts that focus on the algorithmic parts of quantum computing, there is a dearth of publications that describe the modeling, calibration and operation of current quantum computing devices. One aim of this report is to fill that void by providing a case study that walks through the entire procedure from the characterization and optimal control of a qudit device at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory (LLNL) to the validation of the results. A goal of the report is to provide an introduction for students and researchers, especially computational mathematicians, who are interested in but new to quantum computing. Both experimental and mathematical aspects of this procedure are discussed. We present a description of the LLNL QuDIT testbed, the mathematical models that are used to describe it, and the numerical methods that are used to to design optimal controls. We also present experimental and computational methods that can be used to characterize a quantum device. Finally, an experimental validation of an optimized control pulse is presented, which relies on the accuracy of the characterization and the optimal control methodologies.

arXiv:2301.10712•Jan 25, 2023•0 citations

A Bayesian Approach for Characterizing and Mitigating Gate and Measurement Errors

Muqing Zheng, Ang Li, Tamás Terlaky B +1 more

Various noise models have been developed in quantum computing study to describe the propagation and effect of the noise that is caused by imperfect implementation of hardware. Identifying parameters such as gate and readout error rates is critical to these models. We use a Bayesian inference approach to identify posterior distributions of these parameters such that they can be characterized more elaborately. By characterizing the device errors in this way, we can further improve the accuracy of quantum error mitigation. Experiments conducted on IBM’s quantum computing devices suggest that our approach provides better error mitigation performance than existing techniques used by the vendor. Also, our approach outperforms the standard Bayesian inference method in some scenarios.

arXiv:2010.09188•ACM Transactions on Quantum Computing•Sep 15, 2022•15 citations
Motivated by the noisy and fluctuating behavior of current quantum computing devices, this paper presents a data-driven characterization approach for estimating transition frequencies and decay times in a Lindbladian dynamical model of a superconducting quantum device. The data includes parity events in the transition frequency between the first and second excited states. A simple but effective mathematical model, based upon averaging solutions of two Lindbladian models, is demonstrated to accurately capture the experimental observations. A deterministic point estimate of the device parameters is first performed to minimize the misfit between data and Lindbladian simulations. These estimates are used to make an informed choice of prior distributions for the subsequent Bayesian inference. An additive Gaussian noise model is developed for the likelihood function, which includes two hyper-parameters to capture the noise structure of the data. The outcome of the Bayesian inference are posterior probability distributions of the transition frequencies, which for example can be utilized to design risk neutral optimal control pulses. The applicability of our approach is demonstrated on experimental data from the Quantum Device and Integration Testbed (QuDIT) at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, using a tantalum-based superconducting transmon device.
Robust control of a quantum system is essential to utilize the current noisy quantum hardware to its full potential, such as quantum algorithms. To achieve such a goal, a systematic search for an optimal control for any given experiment is essential. The design of optimal control pulses requires accurate numerical models and, therefore, accurate characterization of the system parameters. We present an online Bayesian approach for quantum characterization of qutrit systems, which automatically and systematically identifies optimal experiments that provide maximum information on the system parameters, thereby greatly reducing the number of experiments that need to be performed on the quantum testbed. Unlike most characterization protocols that provide point-estimates of the parameters, the proposed approach is able to estimate their probability distribution. The applicability of the Bayesian experimental design technique was demonstrated on test problems, where each experiment was defined by a parameterized control pulse. In addition to this, we also present an approach for iterative pulse extension, which is robust under uncertainties in transition frequencies and coherence times, and shot noise, despite being initialized with wide uninformative priors. Furthermore, we provide a mathematical proof of the theoretical identifiability of the model parameters and present conditions on the quantum state under which the parameters are identifiable. The proof and conditions for identifiability are presented for both closed and open quantum systems using the Schrödinger equation and the Lindblad master equation, respectively.
This paper presents a data-driven approach to learn latent dynamics in superconducting quantum computing hardware. To this end, we augment the dynamical equation of quantum systems described by the Lindblad master equation with a parameterized source term that is trained from experimental data to capture unknown system dynamics, such as environmental interactions and system noise. We consider a structure preserving augmentation that learns and distinguishes unitary from dissipative latent dynamics parameterized by a basis of linear operators, as well as an augmentation given by a nonlinear feed-forward neural network. Numerical results are presented using data from two different quantum processing units (QPUs) at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory's Quantum Device and Integration Testbed. We demonstrate that our interpretable, structure preserving, and nonlinear models are able to improve the prediction accuracy of the Lindblad master equation and accurately model the latent dynamics of the QPUs.
Maximizing the computational utility of near-term quantum processors requires predictive noise models that inform robust, noise-aware compilation and error mitigation. Conventional models often fail to capture the complex error dynamics of real hardware or require prohibitive characterization overhead. We introduce a data-efficient framework that first constructs a physically motivated, parameterized noise model, and subsequently employs machine-learning-driven Bayesian optimization to identify its parameters. Our approach circumvents costly characterization protocols by estimating algorithm- and hardware-specific error parameters directly from readily available experimental data derived from existing application and benchmark circuit executions. The generality and robustness of the framework are demonstrated across diverse algorithms and superconducting devices, yielding high-fidelity predictions by estimating an independent parameter set tailored to each specific algorithm-hardware context. Crucially, we show that a model calibrated exclusively on small-scale circuits accurately predicts the behavior of larger validation circuits. Our data-efficient approach achieves up to a 65% improvement in model fidelity quantified by the Hellinger distance between predicted and experimental circuit output distributions, compared to standard noise models derived from device properties. This work establishes a practical paradigm for application-aware noise characterization, enabling compilation and error-mitigation strategies tailored to the specific interplay between quantum algorithms and device-specific noise dynamics.
While the Graybox characterization method allows for implicit noise models and is platform-agnostic, the method lacks uncertainty quantification. Characterization of quantum devices is a crucial process that enables researchers to gain insight from experimental settings. Graybox characterization combines known system dynamics with unknown transformations, where the latter is modeled using machine learning. Prediction uncertainty helps researchers make informed decisions. It allows valuable insights from the devices without overconfidence. We therefore develop a probabilistic Graybox characterization model using probabilistic machine learning, specifically Bayesian Neural Networks, and utilize binary measurement outcomes directly for inference. With stochastic noise in a quantum device, we analyze statistical properties of the measurement data. Our results show that the model's prediction performance solely depends on its ability to capture the expected value of the true expectation value. Our proposed probabilistic Graybox model outperforms the original model by up to 1.9 times in capturing the distribution of observed data. We expect that our results will serve as an additional tool for characterizing quantum devices with uncertainty estimation, as they provide a flexible choice that can be utilized even without extensive prior knowledge of the noise model of the devices.
Quantum computing has received significant amounts of interest from many different research communities over the last few years. Although there are many introductory texts that focus on the algorithmic parts of quantum computing, there is a dearth of publications that describe the modeling, calibration and operation of current quantum computing devices. One aim of this report is to fill that void by providing a case study that walks through the entire procedure from the characterization and optimal control of a qudit device at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory (LLNL) to the validation of the results. A goal of the report is to provide an introduction for students and researchers, especially computational mathematicians, who are interested in but new to quantum computing. Both experimental and mathematical aspects of this procedure are discussed. We present a description of the LLNL QuDIT testbed, the mathematical models that are used to describe it, and the numerical methods that are used to to design optimal controls. We also present experimental and computational methods that can be used to characterize a quantum device. Finally, an experimental validation of an optimized control pulse is presented, which relies on the accuracy of the characterization and the optimal control methodologies.
Various noise models have been developed in quantum computing study to describe the propagation and effect of the noise that is caused by imperfect implementation of hardware. Identifying parameters such as gate and readout error rates is critical to these models. We use a Bayesian inference approach to identify posterior distributions of these parameters such that they can be characterized more elaborately. By characterizing the device errors in this way, we can further improve the accuracy of quantum error mitigation. Experiments conducted on IBM’s quantum computing devices suggest that our approach provides better error mitigation performance than existing techniques used by the vendor. Also, our approach outperforms the standard Bayesian inference method in some scenarios.