© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

Terms Privacy Legal Notice

arXiv:2306.12622 · Physical Review A

Optimized detector tomography for photon-number-resolving detectors with hundreds of pixels

D. Liu, Jia-Qi Wang, Chang‐Ling Zou, Xi‐Feng Ren, Guang‐Can Guo

Published Nov 20, 2023• 5 citations

Abstract

Photon-number-resolving detectors with hundreds of pixels are now readily available, while the characterization of these detectors using detector tomography is computationally intensive. Here, we present a modified detector tomography model that reduces the number of variables that need optimization. To evaluate the effectiveness and accuracy of our model, we reconstruct the photon number distribution of optical coherent and thermal states using the expectation-maximization-entropy algorithm. Our results indicate that the fidelity of the reconstructed states remains above 99%, and the second- and third-order correlations agree well with the theoretical values for a mean number of photons up to 100. We also investigate the computational resources required for detector tomography and find out that our approach reduces the solving time by around half compared to the standard detector tomography approach, and the required memory resources are the main obstacle for detector tomography of a large number of pixels. Our results suggest that detector tomography is viable on a supercomputer with 1 TB RAM for detectors with up to 340 pixels.

DOI: 10.1103/physreva.108.052611

Related papers

Quantum detector tomography applied to the human visual system: a feasibility study

Thomas H. A. van der Reep, Dylan Molenaar, W. Löffler +1 more

We show that quantum detector tomography can be applied to the human visual system to explore human perception of photon number states. In detector tomography, instead of using very hard-to-produce photon number states, the response of a detector to light pulses with known photon statistics of varying intensity is recorded, and a model is fitted to the experimental outcomes, thereby inferring the detector's photon number state response. Generally, light pulses containing a Poisson-distributed number of photons are utilized, which are very easy to produce in the lab. This technique has not been explored to study the human visual system before because it usually requires a very large number of repetitions not suitable for experiments on humans. Yet, in the present study we show that detector tomography is feasible for human experiments. Assuming a simple model for this accuracy, the results of our simulations show that detector tomography is able to reconstruct the model using Bayesian inference with as few as 5000 trials. We then optimize the experimental parameters in order to maximize the probability of showing that the single-photon accuracy is above chance. As such, our study opens the road to study human perception on the quantum level.

arXiv:2209.06693•Journal of the Optical Society of America A•Dec 16, 2022•2 citations

Quantum state measurements using multipixel photon detectors

I. Afek, Adi Natan, O. Ambar +1 more

The characterization and conditional preparation of multiphoton quantum states require the use of photon-number resolving detectors. We study the use of detectors based on multiple avalanche photodiode pixels in this context. We develop a general model that provides the positive operator value measures for these detectors. The model incorporates the effect of cross talk between pixels which is unique to these devices. We validate the model by measuring coherent-state photon-number distributions and reconstructing them with high precision. Finally, we evaluate the suitability of such detectors for quantum state tomography and entanglement-based quantum state preparation, highlighting the effects of dark counts and cross talk between pixels.

arXiv:0903.1415•Physical Review A•Apr 28, 2009•92 citations

Quantum Calibration of Photon-Number-Resolving Detectors Based on Multi-Pixel Photon Counters

Yujie Cai, Yu Chen, Xiuliang Chen +5 more

In this paper, we reconstructed the positive operator-valued measure (POVM) of a photon-number-resolving detector (PNRD) based on a multi-pixel photon counter (MPPC) by means of quantum detector tomography (QDT) at 791 nm and 523 nm, respectively. MPPC is a kind of spatial-multiplexing PNRD with a silicon avalanche photodiode (Si-APD) array as the photon receiver. Experimentally, the quantum characteristics of MPPC were calibrated at 2 MHz at two different wavelengths. The POVM elements were given by QDT. The fidelity of the reconstructed POVM elements is higher than 99.96%, which testifies that the QDT is reliable to calibrate MPPC at different wavelengths. With QDT and associated Wigner functions, the quantum properties of MPPC can be calibrated more directly and accurately in contrast with those conventional methods of modeling detectors.

Applied Sciences•Jun 29, 2019•9 citations

Tomography of Optical Quantum States with Imperfect Photon-Number-Resolving Detectors

I. A. Dmitriev, I. K. Golyshev, N. A. Bogdanova +2 more

Abstract A method for quantum state estimation using nonideal photon detection devices has been developed. Using the example of squeezed coherent states, we study the influence of detector efficiency and “dead time” on the fidelity of quantum-state reconstruction for photon-number-resolving (PNR) detectors.

Russian Microelectronics•Dec 1, 2025•0 citations

Superconducting Nanostrip Photon-Number-Resolving Detector for Photon Distribution Reconstruction

Pasquale Ercolano, A. Porzio, Mikkel Ejrnaes +9 more

Single photon detectors based on superconducting nanostrips demonstrated high performance at 1550 nm, combining high efficiency and low noise. Arranged in arrays, these devices can implement photon-number resolution, expanding the range of applicability of superconducting detectors. A detector of this kind was used in our recent work to implement the annihilation operator and the characterization of quantum states in terms of their photon number distribution. The reconstructed distributions were consistent with the theoretical predictions, exhibiting fidelities higher than 99.9%. In this work, this procedure was repeated with each pixel singularly to define a detector fidelity matrix, evaluating the fidelity among all the possible pixel combinations. In this way, we introduce an additional tool that quantifies not only the quality of the reconstructed photon number distribution when compared to the theoretical expectation, but also the mutual fidelity when different pixels are chosen as independent, and then the fabrication uniformity.

IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity•Mar 10, 2026•1 citation

Reconstruction of Photon Number Distribution without Relying on Photon Number-Resolving Detector

Akio Yoshizawa, Hidemi Tsuchida

The photon number distribution is reconstructed from the measured statistics of vacuum states in single-photon detection. Numerical results are presented for the coherent, thermal, number and squeezed-vacuum states. The quantum efficiency of single-photon detection should be high for the successful evaluation of the number state. The quantum efficiency provides the marginal influence for the evaluation of the coherent, thermal and squeezed-vacuum states. However, the accuracy of the reconstructed photon number distribution of the squeezed-vacuum state is low even though the quantum efficiency is unity. For a more accurate reconstruction, we must obtain a priori information on the photon number distribution of the squeezed-vacuum state.

Japanese Journal of Applied Physics•Nov 1, 2005•2 citations

Photon-number-resolving detectors with hundreds of pixels are now readily available, while the characterization of these detectors using detector tomography is computationally intensive. Here, we present a modified detector tomography model that reduces the number of variables that need optimization. To evaluate the effectiveness and accuracy of our model, we reconstruct the photon number distribution of optical coherent and thermal states using the expectation-maximization-entropy algorithm. Our results indicate that the fidelity of the reconstructed states remains above 99%, and the second- and third-order correlations agree well with the theoretical values for a mean number of photons up to 100. We also investigate the computational resources required for detector tomography and find out that our approach reduces the solving time by around half compared to the standard detector tomography approach, and the required memory resources are the main obstacle for detector tomography of a large number of pixels. Our results suggest that detector tomography is viable on a supercomputer with 1 TB RAM for detectors with up to 340 pixels.

We show that quantum detector tomography can be applied to the human visual system to explore human perception of photon number states. In detector tomography, instead of using very hard-to-produce photon number states, the response of a detector to light pulses with known photon statistics of varying intensity is recorded, and a model is fitted to the experimental outcomes, thereby inferring the detector's photon number state response. Generally, light pulses containing a Poisson-distributed number of photons are utilized, which are very easy to produce in the lab. This technique has not been explored to study the human visual system before because it usually requires a very large number of repetitions not suitable for experiments on humans. Yet, in the present study we show that detector tomography is feasible for human experiments. Assuming a simple model for this accuracy, the results of our simulations show that detector tomography is able to reconstruct the model using Bayesian inference with as few as 5000 trials. We then optimize the experimental parameters in order to maximize the probability of showing that the single-photon accuracy is above chance. As such, our study opens the road to study human perception on the quantum level.

The characterization and conditional preparation of multiphoton quantum states require the use of photon-number resolving detectors. We study the use of detectors based on multiple avalanche photodiode pixels in this context. We develop a general model that provides the positive operator value measures for these detectors. The model incorporates the effect of cross talk between pixels which is unique to these devices. We validate the model by measuring coherent-state photon-number distributions and reconstructing them with high precision. Finally, we evaluate the suitability of such detectors for quantum state tomography and entanglement-based quantum state preparation, highlighting the effects of dark counts and cross talk between pixels.

In this paper, we reconstructed the positive operator-valued measure (POVM) of a photon-number-resolving detector (PNRD) based on a multi-pixel photon counter (MPPC) by means of quantum detector tomography (QDT) at 791 nm and 523 nm, respectively. MPPC is a kind of spatial-multiplexing PNRD with a silicon avalanche photodiode (Si-APD) array as the photon receiver. Experimentally, the quantum characteristics of MPPC were calibrated at 2 MHz at two different wavelengths. The POVM elements were given by QDT. The fidelity of the reconstructed POVM elements is higher than 99.96%, which testifies that the QDT is reliable to calibrate MPPC at different wavelengths. With QDT and associated Wigner functions, the quantum properties of MPPC can be calibrated more directly and accurately in contrast with those conventional methods of modeling detectors.

Single photon detectors based on superconducting nanostrips demonstrated high performance at 1550 nm, combining high efficiency and low noise. Arranged in arrays, these devices can implement photon-number resolution, expanding the range of applicability of superconducting detectors. A detector of this kind was used in our recent work to implement the annihilation operator and the characterization of quantum states in terms of their photon number distribution. The reconstructed distributions were consistent with the theoretical predictions, exhibiting fidelities higher than 99.9%. In this work, this procedure was repeated with each pixel singularly to define a detector fidelity matrix, evaluating the fidelity among all the possible pixel combinations. In this way, we introduce an additional tool that quantifies not only the quality of the reconstructed photon number distribution when compared to the theoretical expectation, but also the mutual fidelity when different pixels are chosen as independent, and then the fabrication uniformity.

The photon number distribution is reconstructed from the measured statistics of vacuum states in single-photon detection. Numerical results are presented for the coherent, thermal, number and squeezed-vacuum states. The quantum efficiency of single-photon detection should be high for the successful evaluation of the number state. The quantum efficiency provides the marginal influence for the evaluation of the coherent, thermal and squeezed-vacuum states. However, the accuracy of the reconstructed photon number distribution of the squeezed-vacuum state is low even though the quantum efficiency is unity. For a more accurate reconstruction, we must obtain a priori information on the photon number distribution of the squeezed-vacuum state.