Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2305.08334 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Logarithmic light cone, slow entanglement growth, and quantum memory

Yu Zeng, Alioscia Hamma, Yu-Ran Zhang, Qiang Liu, Rengang Li, Heng Fan, Wu-Ming Liu

Published Aug 26, 2025• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Effective light cones, characterized by Lieb-Robinson bounds, emerge in nonrelativistic local quantum systems. Here, we present several analytical results derived from logarithmic light cones (LLCs). Possible origins of LLCs include the one-dimensional (1D) disordered XXZ model and a phenomenological model of many-body localization (MBL). In the LLC regime, we prove that, for arbitrary spatial dimensions and any initial pure state, entanglement growth is upper bounded by logarithmic time with an additional subleading double-logarithmic correction---arising from a real asymptotic solution of the Lambert W function---valid up to the asymptotic time limit. In the context of the 1D disordered XXZ model, this result resolves the ambiguity in distinguishing between logarithmic and power-law fits of entanglement growth in numerical studies; we also propose a falsifiable phenomenological functional form for the entanglement growth that agrees with existing numerical results. We show that information scrambling is logarithmically slow in the LLC regime. Furthermore, we demonstrate that the LLC supports long-lived quantum memories---quantum codes with macroscopic code distance and lifetimes that scale exponentially with system size---under unitary time evolution. Our analytical results provide benchmarks for future numerical studies of the MBL regime at large timescales.

DOI
10.1103/9jbn-nxwz

Related papers

Out-of-Time-Ordered Correlator in Many-Body Localized Systems

Yichen Huang, Yongliang Zhang, Xie Chen

In many-body localized systems, propagation of information forms a light cone that grows logarithmically with time. However, local changes in energy or other conserved quantities are expected to spread only within a finite distance. Is it possible to detect the logarithmic light cone using local observables, starting from thermal states or eigenstates? Here we show that this is indeed the case, but only in an out-of-time-ordered way. In particular, we numerically calculate various correlators in a prototypical model of many-body localization. While correlators of local operators $A(t=0)$ and $B(t>0)$ ordered in time sequence -- e.g., $A(t=0)B(t>0)$ -- are not sensitive to the unbounded information propagation, those with out-of-time order -- e.g., $A(t=0)B(t>0)A(t=0)B(t>0)$ -- can detect the logarithmic light cone. We demonstrate the connection between out-of-time-ordered correlators and the Lieb-Robinson bound in many-body localized systems, and explain how to saturate the latter by measuring the involved commutator on specially designed initial states. Moreover, out-of-time-ordered correlators also allow us to study the temperature dependence of the light cones and we observe an increase of propagation velocity with increasing temperature.

•Aug 3, 2016•10 citations

Slowest and fastest information scrambling in the strongly disordered XXZ model

Myeonghyeon Kim, DH Kim

We present a perturbation method to compute the out-of-time-ordered correlator in the strongly disordered Heisenberg XXZ model in the deep many-body localized regime. We characterize the discrete structure of the information propagation across the eigenstates, revealing a highly structured light cone confined by the strictly logarithmic upper and lower bounds representing the slowest and fastest scrambling available in this system. We explain these bounds by deriving the closed-form expression of the effective interaction for the slowest scrambling and by constructing the effective model of a half length for the fastest scrambling. We extend our lowest-order perturbation formulations to the higher dimensions, proposing that the logarithmic upper and lower light cones may persist in a finite two-dimensional system in the limit of strong disorder and weak hopping.

arXiv:2303.08801•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jun 22, 2023•3 citations

Dynamics of many-body localized systems: logarithmic lightcones and $\log \, t$-law of $α$-Rényi entropies

Daniele Toniolo, Sougato Bose

In the context of the Many-Body-Localization phenomenology we consider arbitrarily large one-dimensional local spin systems, the XXZ model with random magnetic field is a prototypical example. Without assuming the existence of exponentially localized integrals of motion (LIOM), but assuming instead that the system's dynamics gives rise to a Lieb-Robinson bound (L-R) with a logarithmic lightcone, we rigorously evaluate the dynamical generation, starting from a generic product state, of $ α$-Rényi entropies, with $ α$ close to one, obtaining a $\log \, t$-law, that denotes a slow spread of entanglement. This is in sharp contrast with Anderson localized phases that show no dynamically generated entanglement. To prove this result we apply a general theory recently developed by us in arXiv:2408.00743 that quantitatively relates the L-R bounds of a local Hamiltonian with the dynamical generation of entanglement. Assuming instead the existence of LIOM we provide new independent proofs of the known facts that the L-R bound of the system's dynamics has a logarithmic lightcone and show that the dynamical generation of the von Neumann entropy has for large times a $ \log \, t$-shape. L-R bounds, that quantify the dynamical spreading of local operators, may be easier to measure in experiments in comparison to global quantities such as entanglement.

arXiv:2408.02016•Aug 4, 2024•0 citations

Exponential bound on information spreading induced by quantum many-body dynamics with long-range interactions

Tomotaka Kuwahara

The dynamics of quantum systems strongly depends on the local structure of the Hamiltonian. For short-range interacting systems, the well-known Lieb–Robinson bound defines the effective light cone with an exponentially small error with respect to the spatial distance, whereas we can obtain only polynomially small errors for distance in long-range interacting systems. In this paper, we derive a qualitatively new bound for quantum dynamics by considering how many spins can correlate with each other after time evolution. Our bound characterizes the number of spins which support the many-body entanglement with exponentially small errors and is valid for a large class of Hamiltonians including long-range interacting systems. To demonstrate the advantage of our approach in quantum many-body systems, we apply our bound to prove several fundamental properties which have not been derived from the Lieb–Robinson bound.

arXiv:1509.00521•New Journal of Physics•May 26, 2016•17 citations

Nearly Linear Light Cones in Long-Range Interacting Quantum Systems

Michael Foss‐Feig, Zhexuan Gong, Charles W. Clark +1 more

In nonrelativistic quantum theories with short-range Hamiltonians, a velocity $v$ can be chosen such that the influence of any local perturbation is approximately confined to within a distance $r$ until a time $t\ensuremath{\sim}r/v$, thereby defining a linear light cone and giving rise to an emergent notion of locality. In systems with power-law ($1/{r}^{\ensuremath{\alpha}}$) interactions, when $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ exceeds the dimension $D$, an analogous bound confines influences to within a distance $r$ only until a time $t\ensuremath{\sim}(\ensuremath{\alpha}/v)\mathrm{log}r$, suggesting that the velocity, as calculated from the slope of the light cone, may grow exponentially in time. We rule out this possibility; light cones of power-law interacting systems are bounded by a polynomial for $\ensuremath{\alpha}>2D$ and become linear as $\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}$. Our results impose strong new constraints on the growth of correlations and the production of entangled states in a variety of rapidly emerging, long-range interacting atomic, molecular, and optical systems.

arXiv:1410.3466•Physical Review Letters•Apr 13, 2015•211 citations

Optimal Frobenius light cone in spin chains with power-law interactions

Chi-Fang Chen, Andrew Lucas

In many-body quantum systems with spatially local interactions, quantum information propagates with a finite velocity, reminiscent of the ``light cone'' of relativity. In systems with long-range interactions which decay with distance $r$ as $1/{r}^{\ensuremath{\alpha}}$, however, there are multiple light cones which control different information theoretic tasks. We show an optimal (up to logarithms) ``Frobenius light cone'' obeying $t\ensuremath{\sim}{r}^{min(\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{-}1,1)}$ for $\ensuremath{\alpha}>1$ in one-dimensional power-law interacting systems with finite local dimension: this controls, among other physical properties, the butterfly velocity characterizing many-body chaos and operator growth. We construct an explicit random Hamiltonian protocol that saturates the bound and settles the optimal Frobenius light cone in one dimension. We partially extend our constraints on the Frobenius light cone to a several operator $p$-norms, and show that Lieb-Robinson bounds can be saturated in at most an exponentially small ${e}^{\ensuremath{-}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}(r)}$ fraction of the many-body Hilbert space.

arXiv:2105.09960•Physical Review A•Dec 13, 2021•18 citations
Effective light cones, characterized by Lieb-Robinson bounds, emerge in nonrelativistic local quantum systems. Here, we present several analytical results derived from logarithmic light cones (LLCs). Possible origins of LLCs include the one-dimensional (1D) disordered XXZ model and a phenomenological model of many-body localization (MBL). In the LLC regime, we prove that, for arbitrary spatial dimensions and any initial pure state, entanglement growth is upper bounded by logarithmic time with an additional subleading double-logarithmic correction---arising from a real asymptotic solution of the Lambert W function---valid up to the asymptotic time limit. In the context of the 1D disordered XXZ model, this result resolves the ambiguity in distinguishing between logarithmic and power-law fits of entanglement growth in numerical studies; we also propose a falsifiable phenomenological functional form for the entanglement growth that agrees with existing numerical results. We show that information scrambling is logarithmically slow in the LLC regime. Furthermore, we demonstrate that the LLC supports long-lived quantum memories---quantum codes with macroscopic code distance and lifetimes that scale exponentially with system size---under unitary time evolution. Our analytical results provide benchmarks for future numerical studies of the MBL regime at large timescales.
In many-body localized systems, propagation of information forms a light cone that grows logarithmically with time. However, local changes in energy or other conserved quantities are expected to spread only within a finite distance. Is it possible to detect the logarithmic light cone using local observables, starting from thermal states or eigenstates? Here we show that this is indeed the case, but only in an out-of-time-ordered way. In particular, we numerically calculate various correlators in a prototypical model of many-body localization. While correlators of local operators A(t=0)A(t=0)A(t=0) and B(t>0)B(t>0)B(t>0) ordered in time sequence -- e.g., A(t=0)B(t>0)A(t=0)B(t>0)A(t=0)B(t>0) -- are not sensitive to the unbounded information propagation, those with out-of-time order -- e.g., A(t=0)B(t>0)A(t=0)B(t>0)A(t=0)B(t>0)A(t=0)B(t>0)A(t=0)B(t>0)A(t=0)B(t>0) -- can detect the logarithmic light cone. We demonstrate the connection between out-of-time-ordered correlators and the Lieb-Robinson bound in many-body localized systems, and explain how to saturate the latter by measuring the involved commutator on specially designed initial states. Moreover, out-of-time-ordered correlators also allow us to study the temperature dependence of the light cones and we observe an increase of propagation velocity with increasing temperature.
We present a perturbation method to compute the out-of-time-ordered correlator in the strongly disordered Heisenberg XXZ model in the deep many-body localized regime. We characterize the discrete structure of the information propagation across the eigenstates, revealing a highly structured light cone confined by the strictly logarithmic upper and lower bounds representing the slowest and fastest scrambling available in this system. We explain these bounds by deriving the closed-form expression of the effective interaction for the slowest scrambling and by constructing the effective model of a half length for the fastest scrambling. We extend our lowest-order perturbation formulations to the higher dimensions, proposing that the logarithmic upper and lower light cones may persist in a finite two-dimensional system in the limit of strong disorder and weak hopping.
Dynamics of many-body localized systems: logarithmic lightcones and log⁡ t\log \, tlogt-law of ααα-Rényi entropies
In the context of the Many-Body-Localization phenomenology we consider arbitrarily large one-dimensional local spin systems, the XXZ model with random magnetic field is a prototypical example. Without assuming the existence of exponentially localized integrals of motion (LIOM), but assuming instead that the system's dynamics gives rise to a Lieb-Robinson bound (L-R) with a logarithmic lightcone, we rigorously evaluate the dynamical generation, starting from a generic product state, of $ α$-Rényi entropies, with $ α$ close to one, obtaining a log⁡ t\log \, tlogt-law, that denotes a slow spread of entanglement. This is in sharp contrast with Anderson localized phases that show no dynamically generated entanglement. To prove this result we apply a general theory recently developed by us in arXiv:2408.00743 that quantitatively relates the L-R bounds of a local Hamiltonian with the dynamical generation of entanglement. Assuming instead the existence of LIOM we provide new independent proofs of the known facts that the L-R bound of the system's dynamics has a logarithmic lightcone and show that the dynamical generation of the von Neumann entropy has for large times a $ \log \, t$-shape. L-R bounds, that quantify the dynamical spreading of local operators, may be easier to measure in experiments in comparison to global quantities such as entanglement.
The dynamics of quantum systems strongly depends on the local structure of the Hamiltonian. For short-range interacting systems, the well-known Lieb–Robinson bound defines the effective light cone with an exponentially small error with respect to the spatial distance, whereas we can obtain only polynomially small errors for distance in long-range interacting systems. In this paper, we derive a qualitatively new bound for quantum dynamics by considering how many spins can correlate with each other after time evolution. Our bound characterizes the number of spins which support the many-body entanglement with exponentially small errors and is valid for a large class of Hamiltonians including long-range interacting systems. To demonstrate the advantage of our approach in quantum many-body systems, we apply our bound to prove several fundamental properties which have not been derived from the Lieb–Robinson bound.
In nonrelativistic quantum theories with short-range Hamiltonians, a velocity vvv can be chosen such that the influence of any local perturbation is approximately confined to within a distance rrr until a time $t\ensuremath{\sim}r/v$, thereby defining a linear light cone and giving rise to an emergent notion of locality. In systems with power-law ($1/{r}^{\ensuremath{\alpha}}$) interactions, when $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ exceeds the dimension DDD, an analogous bound confines influences to within a distance rrr only until a time $t\ensuremath{\sim}(\ensuremath{\alpha}/v)\mathrm{log}r$, suggesting that the velocity, as calculated from the slope of the light cone, may grow exponentially in time. We rule out this possibility; light cones of power-law interacting systems are bounded by a polynomial for $\ensuremath{\alpha}>2D$ and become linear as $\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}$. Our results impose strong new constraints on the growth of correlations and the production of entangled states in a variety of rapidly emerging, long-range interacting atomic, molecular, and optical systems.
In many-body quantum systems with spatially local interactions, quantum information propagates with a finite velocity, reminiscent of the ``light cone'' of relativity. In systems with long-range interactions which decay with distance rrr as $1/{r}^{\ensuremath{\alpha}}$, however, there are multiple light cones which control different information theoretic tasks. We show an optimal (up to logarithms) ``Frobenius light cone'' obeying $t\ensuremath{\sim}{r}^{min(\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{-}1,1)}$ for $\ensuremath{\alpha}>1$ in one-dimensional power-law interacting systems with finite local dimension: this controls, among other physical properties, the butterfly velocity characterizing many-body chaos and operator growth. We construct an explicit random Hamiltonian protocol that saturates the bound and settles the optimal Frobenius light cone in one dimension. We partially extend our constraints on the Frobenius light cone to a several operator ppp-norms, and show that Lieb-Robinson bounds can be saturated in at most an exponentially small ${e}^{\ensuremath{-}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}(r)}$ fraction of the many-body Hilbert space.