Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2305.07028

2D Hamiltonians with exotic bipartite and topological entanglement

Balasubramanian, Shankar, Ethan Lake, Soonwon Choi

Published May 11, 2023• 6 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We present a class of exactly solvable 2D models whose ground states violate conventional beliefs about entanglement scaling in quantum matter. These beliefs are (i) that area law entanglement scaling originates from local correlations proximate to the boundary of the entanglement cut, and (ii) that ground state entanglement in 2D Hamiltonians cannot violate area law scaling by more than a multiplicative logarithmic factor. We explicitly present two classes of models defined by local, translation-invariant Hamiltonians, whose ground states can be exactly written as weighted superpositions of framed loop configurations. The first class of models exhibits area-law scaling, but of an intrinsically nonlocal origin so that the topological entanglement entropy scales with subsystem sizes. The second class of models has a rich ground state phase diagram that includes a phase exhibiting volume law entanglement.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2305.07028

Related papers

Explicit Hamiltonians inducing volume law for entanglement entropy in fermionic lattices

Giacomo Gori, Simone Paganelli, Auditya Sharma +2 more

We show how the area law for entanglement entropy may be violated by free fermions on a lattice, and we look for conditions leading to the emergence of a volume law. We give an explicit construction of the states with maximal entanglement entropy based on the fact that, once a bipartition of the lattice in two complementary sets $A$ and $\overline{A}$ is given, the states with maximal entanglement entropy (volume law) may be factored into Bell pairs (BPs) formed by two states with support on $A$ and $\overline{A}$. We then exhibit, for translational invariant fermionic systems on a lattice, a Hamiltonian whose ground state is such that it yields an exact volume law. As expected, the corresponding Fermi surface has a fractal topology. We also provide some examples of fermionic models for which the ground state may have an entanglement entropy ${S}_{A}$ between the area and the volume law, building an explicit example of a one-dimensional free fermion model where ${S}_{A}(L)\ensuremath{\propto}{L}^{\ensuremath{\beta}}$, with $\ensuremath{\beta}$ being intermediate between $\ensuremath{\beta}=0$ (area law) and $\ensuremath{\beta}=1$ (BP state inducing volume law). For this model, the dispersion relation has a ``zigzag'' structure leading to a fractal Fermi surface whose counting box dimension equals, for large lattices, $\ensuremath{\beta}$. Our analysis clearly relates the violation of the area law for the entanglement entropy of the ground state to the emergence of a nontrivial topology of the Fermi surface.

arXiv:1405.3616•Physical Review B•Jun 17, 2015•48 citations

Supercritical entanglement in local systems: Counterexample to the area law for quantum matter

Ramis Movassagh, Peter W. Shor

Quantum entanglement is the most surprising feature of quantum mechanics. Entanglement is simultaneously responsible for the difficulty of simulating quantum matter on a classical computer and the exponential speedups afforded by quantum computers. Ground states of quantum many-body systems typically satisfy an "area law": The amount of entanglement between a subsystem and the rest of the system is proportional to the area of the boundary. A system that obeys an area law has less entanglement and can be simulated more efficiently than a generic quantum state whose entanglement could be proportional to the total system's size. Moreover, an area law provides useful information about the low-energy physics of the system. It is widely believed that for physically reasonable quantum systems, the area law cannot be violated by more than a logarithmic factor in the system's size. We introduce a class of exactly solvable one-dimensional physical models which we can prove have exponentially more entanglement than suggested by the area law, and violate the area law by a square-root factor. This work suggests that simple quantum matter is richer and can provide much more quantum resources (i.e., entanglement) than expected. In addition to using recent advances in quantum information and condensed matter theory, we have drawn upon various branches of mathematics such as combinatorics of random walks, Brownian excursions, and fractional matching theory. We hope that the techniques developed herein may be useful for other problems in physics as well.

arXiv:1408.1657•Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences•Nov 7, 2016•126 citations

Scaling of entanglement entropy at 2D quantum Lifshitz fixed points and topological fluids

Eduardo Fradkin

The entanglement entropy of a pure quantum state of a bipartite system is defined as the von Neumann entropy of the reduced density matrix obtained by tracing over one of the two parts. Critical ground states of local Hamiltonians in one dimension have an entanglement entropy that diverges logarithmically in the subsystem size, with a universal coefficient that is is related to the central charge of the associated conformal field theory. Here I will discuss recent extensions of these ideas to a class of quantum critical points with dynamic critical exponent z = 2 in two space dimensions and to 2D systems in a topological phase. The application of these ideas to quantum dimer models and fractional quantum Hall states will be discussed.

arXiv:0906.1569•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Dec 2, 2009•45 citations

Area law for gapless states from local entanglement thermodynamics

Brian G. Swingle, John McGreevy

We demonstrate an area law bound on the ground state entanglement entropy of a wide class of gapless quantum states of matter using a strategy called local entanglement thermodynamics. The bound depends only on thermodynamic data, actually a single exponent, the hyperscaling violation exponent $\ensuremath{\theta}$. All systems in $d$ spatial dimensions obeying our scaling assumptions and with $\ensuremath{\theta}<d\ensuremath{-}1$ obey the area law, while systems with $\ensuremath{\theta}=d\ensuremath{-}1$ can violate the area law at most logarithmically. We also discuss the case of frustration-free Hamiltonians and show that to violate the area law more than logarithmically these systems must have an unusually large number of low energy states. Finally, we make contact with the recently proposed $s$-source framework and argue that $\ensuremath{\theta}$ and $s$ are related by $s={2}^{\ensuremath{\theta}}$.

arXiv:1505.07106•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•May 13, 2016•25 citations

Criticality, the Area Law, and the Computational Power of Projected Entangled Pair States

Frank Verstraete, M. M. Wolf, David Pérez-Garcı́a +1 more

The projected entangled pair state (PEPS) representation of quantum states on two-dimensional lattices induces an entanglement based hierarchy in state space. We show that the lowest levels of this hierarchy exhibit a very rich structure including states with critical and topological properties. We prove, in particular, that coherent versions of thermal states of any local 2D classical spin model correspond to such PEPS, which are in turn ground states of local 2D quantum Hamiltonians. This correspondence maps thermal onto quantum fluctuations, and it allows us to analytically construct critical quantum models exhibiting a strict area law scaling of the entanglement entropy in the face of power law decaying correlations. Moreover, it enables us to show that there exist PEPS which can serve as computational resources for the solution of NP-hard problems.

arXiv:quant-ph/0601075•Physical Review Letters•Jun 6, 2006•580 citations

Coupled Fredkin and Motzkin chains from quantum six- and nineteen-vertex models

Zhao Zhang, Israel Klich

We generalize the area-law violating models of Fredkin and Motzkin spin chains into two dimensions by building quantum six- and nineteen-vertex models with correlated interactions. The Hamiltonian is frustration free, and its projectors generate ergodic dynamics within the subspace of height configuration that are non negative. The ground state is a volume- and color-weighted superposition of classical bi-color vertex configurations with non-negative heights in the bulk and zero height on the boundary. The entanglement entropy between subsystems has a phase transition as the q q -deformation parameter is tuned, which is shown to be robust in the presence of an external field acting on the color degree of freedom. The ground state undergoes a quantum phase transition between area- and volume-law entanglement phases with a critical point where entanglement entropy scales as a function L\log L L log L of the linear system size L L . Intermediate power law scalings between L\log L L log L and L^2 L 2 can be achieved with an inhomogeneous deformation parameter that approaches 1 at different rates in the thermodynamic limit. For the q>1 q > 1 phase, we construct a variational wave function that establishes an upper bound on the spectral gap that scales as q^{-L^3/8} q − L 3 / 8 .

SciPost Physics•Aug 2, 2023•9 citations
We present a class of exactly solvable 2D models whose ground states violate conventional beliefs about entanglement scaling in quantum matter. These beliefs are (i) that area law entanglement scaling originates from local correlations proximate to the boundary of the entanglement cut, and (ii) that ground state entanglement in 2D Hamiltonians cannot violate area law scaling by more than a multiplicative logarithmic factor. We explicitly present two classes of models defined by local, translation-invariant Hamiltonians, whose ground states can be exactly written as weighted superpositions of framed loop configurations. The first class of models exhibits area-law scaling, but of an intrinsically nonlocal origin so that the topological entanglement entropy scales with subsystem sizes. The second class of models has a rich ground state phase diagram that includes a phase exhibiting volume law entanglement.
We show how the area law for entanglement entropy may be violated by free fermions on a lattice, and we look for conditions leading to the emergence of a volume law. We give an explicit construction of the states with maximal entanglement entropy based on the fact that, once a bipartition of the lattice in two complementary sets AAA and A‾\overline{A}A is given, the states with maximal entanglement entropy (volume law) may be factored into Bell pairs (BPs) formed by two states with support on AAA and A‾\overline{A}A. We then exhibit, for translational invariant fermionic systems on a lattice, a Hamiltonian whose ground state is such that it yields an exact volume law. As expected, the corresponding Fermi surface has a fractal topology. We also provide some examples of fermionic models for which the ground state may have an entanglement entropy SA{S}_{A}SA​ between the area and the volume law, building an explicit example of a one-dimensional free fermion model where ${S}_{A}(L)\ensuremath{\propto}{L}^{\ensuremath{\beta}}$, with $\ensuremath{\beta}$ being intermediate between $\ensuremath{\beta}=0$ (area law) and $\ensuremath{\beta}=1$ (BP state inducing volume law). For this model, the dispersion relation has a ``zigzag'' structure leading to a fractal Fermi surface whose counting box dimension equals, for large lattices, $\ensuremath{\beta}$. Our analysis clearly relates the violation of the area law for the entanglement entropy of the ground state to the emergence of a nontrivial topology of the Fermi surface.
Quantum entanglement is the most surprising feature of quantum mechanics. Entanglement is simultaneously responsible for the difficulty of simulating quantum matter on a classical computer and the exponential speedups afforded by quantum computers. Ground states of quantum many-body systems typically satisfy an "area law": The amount of entanglement between a subsystem and the rest of the system is proportional to the area of the boundary. A system that obeys an area law has less entanglement and can be simulated more efficiently than a generic quantum state whose entanglement could be proportional to the total system's size. Moreover, an area law provides useful information about the low-energy physics of the system. It is widely believed that for physically reasonable quantum systems, the area law cannot be violated by more than a logarithmic factor in the system's size. We introduce a class of exactly solvable one-dimensional physical models which we can prove have exponentially more entanglement than suggested by the area law, and violate the area law by a square-root factor. This work suggests that simple quantum matter is richer and can provide much more quantum resources (i.e., entanglement) than expected. In addition to using recent advances in quantum information and condensed matter theory, we have drawn upon various branches of mathematics such as combinatorics of random walks, Brownian excursions, and fractional matching theory. We hope that the techniques developed herein may be useful for other problems in physics as well.
The entanglement entropy of a pure quantum state of a bipartite system is defined as the von Neumann entropy of the reduced density matrix obtained by tracing over one of the two parts. Critical ground states of local Hamiltonians in one dimension have an entanglement entropy that diverges logarithmically in the subsystem size, with a universal coefficient that is is related to the central charge of the associated conformal field theory. Here I will discuss recent extensions of these ideas to a class of quantum critical points with dynamic critical exponent z = 2 in two space dimensions and to 2D systems in a topological phase. The application of these ideas to quantum dimer models and fractional quantum Hall states will be discussed.
We demonstrate an area law bound on the ground state entanglement entropy of a wide class of gapless quantum states of matter using a strategy called local entanglement thermodynamics. The bound depends only on thermodynamic data, actually a single exponent, the hyperscaling violation exponent $\ensuremath{\theta}$. All systems in ddd spatial dimensions obeying our scaling assumptions and with $\ensuremath{\theta}<d\ensuremath{-}1$ obey the area law, while systems with $\ensuremath{\theta}=d\ensuremath{-}1$ can violate the area law at most logarithmically. We also discuss the case of frustration-free Hamiltonians and show that to violate the area law more than logarithmically these systems must have an unusually large number of low energy states. Finally, we make contact with the recently proposed sss-source framework and argue that $\ensuremath{\theta}$ and sss are related by $s={2}^{\ensuremath{\theta}}$.
The projected entangled pair state (PEPS) representation of quantum states on two-dimensional lattices induces an entanglement based hierarchy in state space. We show that the lowest levels of this hierarchy exhibit a very rich structure including states with critical and topological properties. We prove, in particular, that coherent versions of thermal states of any local 2D classical spin model correspond to such PEPS, which are in turn ground states of local 2D quantum Hamiltonians. This correspondence maps thermal onto quantum fluctuations, and it allows us to analytically construct critical quantum models exhibiting a strict area law scaling of the entanglement entropy in the face of power law decaying correlations. Moreover, it enables us to show that there exist PEPS which can serve as computational resources for the solution of NP-hard problems.
We generalize the area-law violating models of Fredkin and Motzkin spin chains into two dimensions by building quantum six- and nineteen-vertex models with correlated interactions. The Hamiltonian is frustration free, and its projectors generate ergodic dynamics within the subspace of height configuration that are non negative. The ground state is a volume- and color-weighted superposition of classical bi-color vertex configurations with non-negative heights in the bulk and zero height on the boundary. The entanglement entropy between subsystems has a phase transition as the q q -deformation parameter is tuned, which is shown to be robust in the presence of an external field acting on the color degree of freedom. The ground state undergoes a quantum phase transition between area- and volume-law entanglement phases with a critical point where entanglement entropy scales as a function L\log L L log L of the linear system size L L . Intermediate power law scalings between L\log L L log L and L^2 L 2 can be achieved with an inhomogeneous deformation parameter that approaches 1 at different rates in the thermodynamic limit. For the q>1 q > 1 phase, we construct a variational wave function that establishes an upper bound on the spectral gap that scales as q^{-L^3/8} q − L 3 / 8 .