Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2304.08764 · Journal of the Physical Society of Japan

How Infrared Singularities Affect Nambu–Goldstone Bosons at Finite Temperatures

Takafumi Kita

Published Apr 18, 2023• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Ordered phases realized through broken continuous symmetries embrace long-range order-parameter fluctuations as manifest in the power-law decays of both the transverse and longitudinal correlations, which are similar to those at the second-order transition point. We calculate the transverse one-loop correction to the dispersion relation of nonrelativistic Nambu-Goldstone (NG) bosons at finite temperatures, assuming that they have well-defined dispersion relations with some integer exponents. It is found that the transverse correlations make the lifetime of the NG bosons vanish right on the assumed dispersion curve below three dimensions at finite temperatures. Combined with the vanishing of the longitudinal "mass", the result indicates that the correlations generally bring both an intrinsic lifetime to the excitations and a qualitative change in the dispersion relation at long wavelengths below three dimensions at finite temperatures, unless it is protected by some conservation law. A more detailed calculation performed specifically on a single-component Bose-Einstein condensate reveals that the gapless Bogoliubov mode predicted by the perturbative treatment is modified substantially after incorporating the correlations to have (i) an intrinsic lifetime and (ii) a peak shift at long wavelengths from the linear dispersion relation. Thus, the NG bosons may be fluctuating intrinsically into and out of the ordered "vacuum" to maintain the order temporally.

DOI
10.7566/jpsj.92.054004

Related papers

Properties of Nambu–Goldstone Bosons in a Single-Component Bose–Einstein Condensate

Takafumi Kita

We theoretically study the properties of Nambu-Goldstone bosons in an interacting single-component Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC). We first point out that the proofs of Goldstone's theorem by Goldstone, et al. [Phys. Rev. {\bf 127} (1962) 965] may be relevant to distinct massless modes of the BEC: whereas the first proof deals with the poles of the single-particle Green's function $\hat{G}$, the second one concerns those of the two-particle Green's function. Thus, there may be multiple Nambu-Goldstone bosons even in the single-component BEC with broken U(1) symmetry. The second mode turns out to have an infinite lifetime in the long-wavelength limit in agreement with the conventional viewpoint. In contrast, the first mode from $\hat{G}$, i.e., the Bogoliubov mode in the weak-coupling regime, is shown to be a "bubbling" mode fluctuating temporally out of and back into the condensate. The substantial lifetime originates from an "improper" structure of the self-energy inherent in the BEC, which has been overlooked so far and will be elucidated here, and removes various infrared divergences pointed out previously.

arXiv:1108.2324•Journal of the Physical Society of Japan•Aug 15, 2011•12 citations

Infrared behavior in systems with a broken continuous symmetry: Classical O( N ) model versus interacting bosons

N. Dupuis

In systems with a spontaneously broken continuous symmetry, the perturbative loop expansion is plagued by infrared divergences due to the coupling between transverse and longitudinal fluctuations. As a result, the longitudinal susceptibility diverges and the self-energy becomes singular at low energy. We study the crossover from the high-energy Gaussian regime, where perturbation theory remains valid, to the low-energy Goldstone regime characterized by a diverging longitudinal susceptibility. We consider both the classical linear O (N) model and interacting bosons at zero temperature, using a variety of techniques: perturbation theory, hydrodynamic approach (i.e., for bosons, Popov's theory), large-N limit, and nonperturbative renormalization group. We emphasize the essential role of the Ginzburg momentum scale p{G}, below which the perturbative approach breaks down. Even though the action of (nonrelativistic) bosons includes a first-order time derivative term, we find remarkable similarities in the weak-coupling limit between the classical O(N) model and interacting bosons at zero temperature.

arXiv:1011.3324•Physical Review E•Mar 18, 2011•49 citations

Magnetic long-range order at finite temperature in two-dimensional hyperbolic lattices

Alexander Hickey, Joseph Maciejko

Infrared singularities of gapless Goldstone modes preclude magnetic long-range order at finite temperature in conventional two-dimensional systems. By studying the spin-$S$ Heisenberg model on regular tilings of the hyperbolic plane, we show that this obstruction is absent in negatively curved space. Using spin-wave theory, we find that the zero-energy collective modes required by symmetry carry vanishing local spectral weight and are separated from the thermodynamic bulk magnon continuum by a finite gap in the bulk local spectral density. As a result, local transverse correlations remain short ranged, with a finite correlation length, despite the presence of Goldstone modes associated with the broken SO(3) spin-rotation symmetry. Stronger negative curvature is found to suppress quantum fluctuations in bulk thermodynamic quantities, pushing the ordered state toward "mean-field-like" behavior. We further estimate the ordering temperature from the thermal spin-wave correction to the ordered moment. These results establish hyperbolic geometry as a route to finite-temperature magnetic order that circumvents the Mermin-Wagner obstruction without breaking or modifying the continuous symmetry.

cond-mat.str-elCross-listedarXiv:2606.27422•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jun 29, 2026•0 citations

Renormalization-group approach to the infrared behavior of a zero-temperature Bose system

F. Pistolesi, Claudio Castellani, C. Di Castro +1 more

We exploit the renormalization-group approach to establish the exact infrared behavior of an interacting Bose system at zero temperature. The local-gauge symmetry in the broken-symmetry phase is implemented through the associated Ward identities, which reduce the number of independent running couplings to a single one. For this coupling the \ensuremath{\epsilon} expansion can be controlled to all orders in \ensuremath{\epsilon} $(=3\ensuremath{-}d).$ For spatial dimensions $1<d<~3$ the Bogoliubov fixed point is unstable towards a different fixed point characterized by the divergence of the longitudinal correlation function. The Bogoliubov linear spectrum, however, is found to be independent of the critical behavior of this correlation function, being exactly constrained by Ward identities. The new fixed point properly gives a finite value of the coupling among transverse fluctuations, but due to virtual intermediate longitudinal fluctuations, the effective coupling affecting the transverse correlation function flows to zero. As a result, no transverse anomalous dimension is present. This treatment allows us to recover known results for the quantum Bose gas in the context of a unifying framework and also to reveal the nontrivial skeleton structure of its perturbation theory.

arXiv:cond-mat/0310306•Physical Review B•Jan 16, 2004•67 citations

Effects of Quantum Coordinates on Condensate Density in a Trapped Bose-Einstein Condensate

Masahiko Okumura, Y. Yamanaka

The effects of quantum coordinates associated with the Nambu-Goldstone mode in a trapped Bose-Einstein condensate are investigated at zero and finite temperatures. We develop a loop expansion and perform numerical calculations over a wide range of temperature, i.e., between zero and the critical temperatures. Our results are compared with those obtained in cases without the Nambu-Goldstone mode (the Bogoliubov approximation) and with the Nambu-Goldstone mode as a zero-energy particle mode.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Feb 1, 2004•5 citations

Infrared behavior and spectral function of a Bose superfluid at zero temperature

N. Dupuis

In a Bose superfluid, the coupling between transverse (phase) and longitudinal fluctuations leads to a divergence of the longitudinal correlation function, which is responsible for the occurrence of infrared divergences in the perturbation theory and the breakdown of the Bogoliubov approximation. We report a nonperturbative renormalization-group calculation of the one-particle Green's function of an interacting boson system at zero temperature. We find two regimes separated by a characteristic momentum scale ${k}_{G}$ (``Ginzburg'' scale). While the Bogoliubov approximation is valid at large momenta and energies, $|\mathbf{p}|,\text{ }|\ensuremath{\omega}|/c⪢{k}_{G}$ (with $c$ as the velocity of the Bogoliubov sound mode), in the infrared (hydrodynamic) regime, $|\mathbf{p}|,\text{ }|\ensuremath{\omega}|/c⪡{k}_{G}$, the normal and anomalous self-energies exhibit singularities reflecting the divergence of the longitudinal correlation function. In particular, we find that the anomalous self-energy agrees with the Bogoliubov result ${\ensuremath{\Sigma}}_{\text{an}}(\mathbf{p},\ensuremath{\omega})\ensuremath{\simeq}\text{const}$ at high energies and behaves as ${\ensuremath{\Sigma}}_{\text{an}}(\mathbf{p},\ensuremath{\omega})\ensuremath{\sim}{({c}^{2}{\mathbf{p}}^{2}\ensuremath{-}{\ensuremath{\omega}}^{2})}^{(d\ensuremath{-}3)/2}$ in the infrared regime (with $d$ as the space dimension), in agreement with the Nepomnyashchii identity ${\ensuremath{\Sigma}}_{\text{an}}(0,0)=0$ and the predictions of Popov's hydrodynamic theory. We argue that the hydrodynamic limit of the one-particle Green's function is fully determined by the knowledge of the exponent $3\ensuremath{-}d$ characterizing the divergence of the longitudinal susceptibility and the Ward identities associated to gauge and Galilean invariances. The infrared singularity of ${\ensuremath{\Sigma}}_{\text{an}}(\mathbf{p},\ensuremath{\omega})$ leads to a continuum of excitations (coexisting with the sound mode) which shows up in the one-particle spectral function.

arXiv:0907.2779•Physical Review A•Oct 28, 2009•49 citations
Ordered phases realized through broken continuous symmetries embrace long-range order-parameter fluctuations as manifest in the power-law decays of both the transverse and longitudinal correlations, which are similar to those at the second-order transition point. We calculate the transverse one-loop correction to the dispersion relation of nonrelativistic Nambu-Goldstone (NG) bosons at finite temperatures, assuming that they have well-defined dispersion relations with some integer exponents. It is found that the transverse correlations make the lifetime of the NG bosons vanish right on the assumed dispersion curve below three dimensions at finite temperatures. Combined with the vanishing of the longitudinal "mass", the result indicates that the correlations generally bring both an intrinsic lifetime to the excitations and a qualitative change in the dispersion relation at long wavelengths below three dimensions at finite temperatures, unless it is protected by some conservation law. A more detailed calculation performed specifically on a single-component Bose-Einstein condensate reveals that the gapless Bogoliubov mode predicted by the perturbative treatment is modified substantially after incorporating the correlations to have (i) an intrinsic lifetime and (ii) a peak shift at long wavelengths from the linear dispersion relation. Thus, the NG bosons may be fluctuating intrinsically into and out of the ordered "vacuum" to maintain the order temporally.
We theoretically study the properties of Nambu-Goldstone bosons in an interacting single-component Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC). We first point out that the proofs of Goldstone's theorem by Goldstone, et al. [Phys. Rev. {\bf 127} (1962) 965] may be relevant to distinct massless modes of the BEC: whereas the first proof deals with the poles of the single-particle Green's function G^\hat{G}G^, the second one concerns those of the two-particle Green's function. Thus, there may be multiple Nambu-Goldstone bosons even in the single-component BEC with broken U(1) symmetry. The second mode turns out to have an infinite lifetime in the long-wavelength limit in agreement with the conventional viewpoint. In contrast, the first mode from G^\hat{G}G^, i.e., the Bogoliubov mode in the weak-coupling regime, is shown to be a "bubbling" mode fluctuating temporally out of and back into the condensate. The substantial lifetime originates from an "improper" structure of the self-energy inherent in the BEC, which has been overlooked so far and will be elucidated here, and removes various infrared divergences pointed out previously.
In systems with a spontaneously broken continuous symmetry, the perturbative loop expansion is plagued by infrared divergences due to the coupling between transverse and longitudinal fluctuations. As a result, the longitudinal susceptibility diverges and the self-energy becomes singular at low energy. We study the crossover from the high-energy Gaussian regime, where perturbation theory remains valid, to the low-energy Goldstone regime characterized by a diverging longitudinal susceptibility. We consider both the classical linear O (N) model and interacting bosons at zero temperature, using a variety of techniques: perturbation theory, hydrodynamic approach (i.e., for bosons, Popov's theory), large-N limit, and nonperturbative renormalization group. We emphasize the essential role of the Ginzburg momentum scale p{G}, below which the perturbative approach breaks down. Even though the action of (nonrelativistic) bosons includes a first-order time derivative term, we find remarkable similarities in the weak-coupling limit between the classical O(N) model and interacting bosons at zero temperature.
Infrared singularities of gapless Goldstone modes preclude magnetic long-range order at finite temperature in conventional two-dimensional systems. By studying the spin-SSS Heisenberg model on regular tilings of the hyperbolic plane, we show that this obstruction is absent in negatively curved space. Using spin-wave theory, we find that the zero-energy collective modes required by symmetry carry vanishing local spectral weight and are separated from the thermodynamic bulk magnon continuum by a finite gap in the bulk local spectral density. As a result, local transverse correlations remain short ranged, with a finite correlation length, despite the presence of Goldstone modes associated with the broken SO(3) spin-rotation symmetry. Stronger negative curvature is found to suppress quantum fluctuations in bulk thermodynamic quantities, pushing the ordered state toward "mean-field-like" behavior. We further estimate the ordering temperature from the thermal spin-wave correction to the ordered moment. These results establish hyperbolic geometry as a route to finite-temperature magnetic order that circumvents the Mermin-Wagner obstruction without breaking or modifying the continuous symmetry.
We exploit the renormalization-group approach to establish the exact infrared behavior of an interacting Bose system at zero temperature. The local-gauge symmetry in the broken-symmetry phase is implemented through the associated Ward identities, which reduce the number of independent running couplings to a single one. For this coupling the \ensuremath{\epsilon} expansion can be controlled to all orders in \ensuremath{\epsilon} $(=3\ensuremath{-}d).$ For spatial dimensions 1<d< 31<d<~31<d< 3 the Bogoliubov fixed point is unstable towards a different fixed point characterized by the divergence of the longitudinal correlation function. The Bogoliubov linear spectrum, however, is found to be independent of the critical behavior of this correlation function, being exactly constrained by Ward identities. The new fixed point properly gives a finite value of the coupling among transverse fluctuations, but due to virtual intermediate longitudinal fluctuations, the effective coupling affecting the transverse correlation function flows to zero. As a result, no transverse anomalous dimension is present. This treatment allows us to recover known results for the quantum Bose gas in the context of a unifying framework and also to reveal the nontrivial skeleton structure of its perturbation theory.
In a Bose superfluid, the coupling between transverse (phase) and longitudinal fluctuations leads to a divergence of the longitudinal correlation function, which is responsible for the occurrence of infrared divergences in the perturbation theory and the breakdown of the Bogoliubov approximation. We report a nonperturbative renormalization-group calculation of the one-particle Green's function of an interacting boson system at zero temperature. We find two regimes separated by a characteristic momentum scale kG{k}_{G}kG​ (``Ginzburg'' scale). While the Bogoliubov approximation is valid at large momenta and energies, $|\mathbf{p}|,\text{ }|\ensuremath{\omega}|/c⪢{k}_{G}$ (with ccc as the velocity of the Bogoliubov sound mode), in the infrared (hydrodynamic) regime, $|\mathbf{p}|,\text{ }|\ensuremath{\omega}|/c⪡{k}_{G}$, the normal and anomalous self-energies exhibit singularities reflecting the divergence of the longitudinal correlation function. In particular, we find that the anomalous self-energy agrees with the Bogoliubov result ${\ensuremath{\Sigma}}_{\text{an}}(\mathbf{p},\ensuremath{\omega})\ensuremath{\simeq}\text{const}$ at high energies and behaves as ${\ensuremath{\Sigma}}_{\text{an}}(\mathbf{p},\ensuremath{\omega})\ensuremath{\sim}{({c}^{2}{\mathbf{p}}^{2}\ensuremath{-}{\ensuremath{\omega}}^{2})}^{(d\ensuremath{-}3)/2}$ in the infrared regime (with ddd as the space dimension), in agreement with the Nepomnyashchii identity ${\ensuremath{\Sigma}}_{\text{an}}(0,0)=0$ and the predictions of Popov's hydrodynamic theory. We argue that the hydrodynamic limit of the one-particle Green's function is fully determined by the knowledge of the exponent $3\ensuremath{-}d$ characterizing the divergence of the longitudinal susceptibility and the Ward identities associated to gauge and Galilean invariances. The infrared singularity of ${\ensuremath{\Sigma}}_{\text{an}}(\mathbf{p},\ensuremath{\omega})$ leads to a continuum of excitations (coexisting with the sound mode) which shows up in the one-particle spectral function.